Saturday, January 31, 2009

I feel like I'm losing my mother

I almost titled this "My mother is considering weight loss surgery", but while the latter is factual, what I have up there gets to the meaning of the post.

I need to preface this by saying that I was raised, to the best of my mother's ability and against my father's wishes, with the basic idea, if not the exact words, of Health At Every Size. I have never deliberately dieted in my life. I have lost significant amounts of weight twice, once in high school because I was accidentally starving myself (if I didn't eat breakfast, I found I only needed a Mt Dew and maybe a pastry at school, had to eat a meal at 5pm when I got home from play rehearsal, then wouldn't be really hungry for dinner at 6:30. I do not recommend this), and again after I got off Depakote, which had royally fucked up my body and my appetite and caused me to gain in the vicinity of 100lbs over two or three years, most of which I lost after getting the hell off it; neither of these times were health-promoting for me. I do not want to hear about your diet. I will bitchslap you (or at least fantasize about it) if you moan about getting fat in my presence, and you weigh less than 150% of what you did two months ago. I do not want to hear about your diet. I have recently fallen hard for Harding et al at Shapely Prose. I do not want to hear about your diet.

And this is how my good mama raised me. She was fucked over by the patriarchy and fatphobia and an asshole dad who thought "not starving" = "fat" (and yet insisted that no food be wasted at the table and all plates must be cleaned), and my asshole dad who thought fat = bad and ugly, and a diet industry that told her swallowing sponges = good. She promised to do better with me, her showing-every-sign-of-being-fat daughter, and though I wish she'd gotten a clue in time to save my seven-years-older brother (who once got in a yelling match with my dad about how fat I was WHEN I WAS FUCKING FIVE), I am beyond grateful that she did it more or less right with me. She wasn't perfect (who is?), and I do not have a perfect relationship with food (who does?), but once I was talking with her (at her, really, with her nose buried in a magazine, she occasionally emitting an appropriate-sounding "uh huh") and casually said "Mom, would it be OK if I dye it?" talking about my hair, and her head snapped up with the exclamation "you certainly may not diet!" Bless her a thousand times for that one, and for the subscription to Radiance, and then to Hues (both now defunct, unfortunately but unsurprisingly), and for putting herself between my dad's fatphobic vitriol and me, and for the thousand other things she did to try to avoid fucking me up as badly as she had been.

Bless her also, while I'm on the topic, for plonking $1000 at a trip at boutique clothing stores that sold clothes at which I was a size 1 as soon as I hit adolescence (the $1000 was only once, and bought abundant [pun intended] clothes for both of us; but the general gist of go shopping, spend lots, make shopkeepers grin and stay open late for us continued). Bless her for giving me a wardrobe that looked fucking fabulous on me, whatever size I was at the time, for making shopping a joy and a treat and a way to surround myself with older women who also Got It, and told me how amazing I looked (because I did!) and offered to pay me to model for them. Bless her.

Thus, difficulties that many fat acceptance converts struggle with, I largely avoided. I grew up knowing dieting was stupid and unhealthy and didn't work (knowing indeed that dieting was responsible for turning my 160lb mom into my 400ishlb mom), even if I did also watch her try PhenFen and every other "it's medicine and scientific so it must be healthy" prescription diet drug that came out. I did not usually know my weight or consider it an important indicator of health, even as she had discussions with her doctors about hers. Bless her for that as well.

And now... weight loss surgery. Stomach stapling. Bariatric bypass.

Maybe.

If I still had all the old Radiance issues I could pull out all the articles that talk about what a Dumb, Self-Hating Idea it is, but she'd dismiss them because "the surgeries are really different now, and I know a lot of women for whom it really was good". And she may be right. The surgeries are safer now (it would have been hard for them to get less safe!), and there are women for whom it was a godsend. And with her other health issues (notably her mobility issues, which are aggravated though not caused by her weight), maybe it would be good for her, too. We've had several discussions on the topic, each trying to listen to the other, each trying to be heard. I am open to the possibility that it might be the right decision for her.

But I still feel like I'm losing her. Not because, if she went through with it, her beautiful body would melt away (seriously, my mother is the most beautiful person in the world to me, with the only sometimes exception of my child, and it's not that she has "such a pretty face", though she does, nor in spite of her size, nor even really because of it, but simply because she is so. damn. beautiful, just as she is). Nor because she'd be making a choice I disagreed with (she's an allopathic drug dealing MD, I'm a crunchy woowoo acupuncture-loving fish-oil-swilling neo-hippie; we're used to disagreeing and still loving and respecting each other). Not even because, no matter how safe it is, the surgery still might kill her.

No, it's because I find an article like this one that I so want to email to her because she'd Get It... and I don't. It's because I used to always talk to her about my own weight and health and body acceptance issues... and now I feel I can't.

I'm losing her. My rock -- no, my squishy safe bed with the softest pillows and the monster-repelling covers -- my loving mother, my protectress, my goddess, the one person who would stand up for me and my right to love my body just the way it is thank you all very fucking much... isn't anymore. I can't send her those articles because she'd think I was trying to make a point with her and whether to do the surgery, when I just want to share my joy. I can't talk to her about my stuff, because it'll sound like it's about hers. It sometimes makes me miss my mother so much I start to cry.

Which is so much self-indulgent angst and a slap in the face to everyone who actually has lost a mother in the real dead-and-gone sense (my own beloved lifemate included), but they're my feelings, and I'm sticking to them... the way my mama taught me.



(Any comments in favor of her doing the surgery because weight loss always = good, saying I don't want her to because then I'll be the fattest, supporting the dangerous myth that fat = unhealthy, promoting your own diet, talking about the weight you "need" to lose, or in any other way displaying willful fatphobia or thin privilege will be deleted. Consider that fair warning.)

Thursday, January 29, 2009

Why I'm not blogging

I actually have a draft sitting in the hopper that I typed out at midnight yesterday when I couldn't sleep, which I was really hoping to get up today, but which (because I typed it out at midnight when I really should have been sleeping) really needs a thorough clean up and sprucing before it's ready for your edification and education. I also have notes on three more posts that have been floating around in my head for the past week that desperately want to get out of mine and in to yours.

I am, however, not posting any of that, because of various factors including mold, pervasive bleach smell to clean said mold both resulting in massive headaches, visit to courthouse and handing over of large sums of money to prevent license from being suspended, Random Winter Cold (tm) in all human members of our family, a sort-of-expected visit from Aging Hippie Aunt, and A&P test for which I was completely unprepared (owing mainly to the above factors). And I need sleep. Yes, more even than I need to exercise (or exorcise) my blogging muscles.

But there's no need for pity. It's not been bad, exactly, there's just been... a lot.

So, I hope to get at least one post with actual content up in the next day, but if my luck holds, I will not.

Still, sometime, perhaps just when you need it, perhaps long after you've forgotten me in the fickle environment that is the blogosphere, New Content Will Arrive. I promise.

Monday, January 26, 2009

Closer to understanding the domestic goddess

Those who have been paying attention know that The Man and I are attempting a 1-month no-spend challenge, the largest change for us being not eating out at all (excepting Chipotle once a weekend because hey, it's hungry work shopping for a whole week, and it's Chipotle). In attempting this, I have gone from cooking less than, on average, 15% of our meals (The Man cooked most of the other 85%, at least of dinners), to cooking rather more than 50%, simply because I'm the one home during the day.

In doing so, I believe I have discovered at least part of why the domestic goddess phenomenon is so popular. (Just to reiterate, I'm all in favor of upping the status of the domestic, and I do stay at home during the day, but there's a phenomenon I'm not a part of in which staying home and raising the kids and keeping the house is the entirety of what one [a woman, generally] does and takes pride in. I've long been confused by it, having been raised by a mostly second-wave feminist WOHM, for all that I travel in the same social spheres as many who embrace the title, and have much in common with them.)

The Man and I have long maintained that in an ideal world, we would both be parenting the Boychick 50/50, even if I did all the milk-giving. Given that we do not live in an ideal world, his job 40 hours a week is to go earn money so we as a family can stay fed and housed, and my job during those 40 hours a week is to keep the Boychick and myself alive and (preferably) sane. Anything on top of that is non-obligatory and not expected. Everything else -- the cooking, the cleaning, the house maintenance, the shopping, the getting the fuck out of the house-- is stuff we try to do together, or at least split fairly (and him doing most of the cooking and washing the dishes is SO fair, because... it just is!). This has long worked for us.

But here I am, cooking during the day so we eat at home come evening. Chicken makhani with curried veggies, beef stew with garlic croutons, spaghetti with garlic bread, apple chicken with quinoa, no-knead bread with everything, stuffed squash, beans and rice, roast chicken, and more scones and cookies and muffins and bars than one should have in an entire year, all made at home, from scratch (even the croutons), mostly by me. And you know what? My days are kinda easier. I have, for the love of God/dess, something to do.

And I think that's it. That's why, when women are handed the vast burden of the childrearing by a society that says children and work can't mix and men don't matter in the early years, so many of us turn to being a Good Housewife, or better yet a Domestic Goddess (the good housewife for the new millennium). It gives her something to do other than stare at her (unbelievably beautiful and talented and adorable) child(ren), a purpose -- keeping the hearth, 21st century-style -- and a standard by which she can measure her success in real-time, not just wait around until her kids are 20, 40, 80, and declare, if they turned out right (whatever the hell that means), that she was a Good Mother, and It Was All Worth It.

Because really, am I doing my kid any favors spending half the day trying not to lose my temper with him, not because he's bad or is doing anything wrong, but just because I can't take it any more? I don't know. I believe so, I believe that fostering attachment and providing milk and giving him the freedom to just run and play and cuddle and be free of time pressures and peer pressures and grow-up pressures is good for him, but I don't know. What I do know is that in the last month I've made food that has sustained and been enjoyed by my family, helped us meet our budget, helped us pay off debt so home and working-car ownership is a possibility somewhere just over the horizon. I know I've made something, done something substantial and important, even if it is now nothing more than a memory and a sewage smear somewhere; and it feels pretty darn good.

It's an awfully seductive proposition, turning that sensation in to a vocation, and I think I have more understanding now for why so many do it.

Sunday, January 25, 2009

Are you a good parent? quiz memes, or, the always-good-for-a-chuckle double standards in parenting

I ran across this meme today, which is both funny and incredibly sad and telling about our society (spelling as in original, author unknown):

With all the conflicting parenting advice out there, it’s difficult to know whether you’re a good parent or a bad parent. Take this handy quiz to find out once and for all.
Keep track of your answers on a post-it and total your score at the end. Won’t it be a relief to know whether or not you’re a bad mom?

1. How many hours per week does your child spend in daycare?
A. None. I’m a stay-at-home mom.
B. 40 or more. I work full-time.
C. About 20. I work half-time.

2. Where does your baby sleep
A. In a crib.
B. In my bed.
C. In a co-sleeper.

3. Do you allow your child to watch television?
A. Yes.
B. No.

4. Has your child been vaccinated?
A. Yes.
B. No.

5. How many scheduled activities (storytimes, lessons, classes or playgroups) does your child attend each week?
A. None
B. One or more.




ANSWERS:
1. Day Care.
A: Stay at home mom. You are a bad mom. Your child will be poorly socialized, will lack verbal skills, and will become horribly ill during kindergarten because he or she has never been exposed to germs.
B: Full-time working mom. You are a bad mom. Your child will have an attachment disorder. You are missing the best years of his or her life.
C: Part-time working mom. You are the worst mom. Your child will suffer attachment issues, be poorly socialized, lack verbal skills and will be sick as a dog forever.

2. Sleeping arrangements.
A: Baby sleeps in a crib. You are a bad mom. How could you put your child in a cage to sleep? What’s wrong with you?
B: Baby sleeps in your bed. You are a bad mom. How could you risk rolling onto your child and killing her? What’s wrong with you?
C: Baby sleeps in a co-sleeper. You are a bad mom. How could you waste so much money on that ridiculous co-sleeper? Is it because you read about it in Dr. Sears? You won’t be able to afford to send your child to college.

3. Television
Yes. You are a bad mom. Your child will be violent, mouthy, and unpleasant. He or she will whine for every candy and toy they see the next time you go to the store.
No. You are a bad mom. Your child will lack reading skills and will have nothing to talk with other children about. You are raising a freak.

4. Vaccinations.
A: Yes. You are a bad mom. How could you do that to a helpless baby who cannot consent to being experimented on by the public health system?
B: No. You are a bad mom. How could you do that to a helpless baby whose immune system can’t fight off all those germs?

5. Activities.
A: None. You are a bad mom. Your child will fall behind his or her peers and never catch up if you don’t head over to the children’s theatre production of “Apocalypse Now” this weekend.
B: One or more. You are a bad mom. Your child is overscheduled and will suffer a breakdown due to the stress you’re putting on him or her. You’re probably doing Suzuki, aren’t you?

Brought to you by the folks at Parenting, Mothering, Time, Newsweek, The Today Show, Babycenter.com, Wonder Time, What to Expect When You’re Expecting, Your Pregnancy Week by Week, your pediatrician, your obstetrition, your mother, your mother-in-law, and that awful psycho in the elevator who knows better than you how you should be raising your kids.
(Note that Mothering, the magazine I volunteer for, got a shout out. Note also that when they said "find out if you're a good parent", they meant good mom.)



I was then inspired to write a complementary quiz for fathers:

The good dad/bad dad quiz:

1. How much time per week do you spend in the same room with your child(ren)?
A) 0 -- I work 100 hours per week and travel more than 50%
B) 3-5
C) 24/7 -- I am a stay at home dad

2. Where does your baby sleep?
A) In his own room in a crib
B) In bed with the wife
C) In bed with both of us

3. How many diapers have you changed in your child's life?
A) 0-1, but I made sure the little woman always did it within 4 hours of the kid dropping a load
B) 50-100
C) About once a day when I was home

4. If divorced, do you pay child support?
A) Yes, the minimum amount
B) Yes, when I can afford it after the widescreen tv payments
C) No, I got out of it and use the money to pay for my new, blond, wife and our two new children

5. What do you know about your children?
A) Their names, their friends, their friends' parents, the number for their school or daycare, their dietary likes and dislikes, their vaccine schedule (or all the reasons why they are not vaccinated), the date of their next dentist, pediatrician, and music lesson appointments, and what they really want for their birthday
B) Their names, a couple of their friends' names, the type of instrument they play, and what they want for their birthday
C) Their names... usually


Tally up your answers:

Time with kids:
A) None--you are a good dad, because you work so hard to provide for them.
B) 3-5 hrs/week--you are a good dad, because that's more than your father spent with you
C) SAH--you are a Super Dad!

Sleep arrangements
A) In a crib in their own room--you are a good dad for putting your foot down and insisting the little woman separate from the leech
B) In bed with the wife--you are a good dad for sacrificing your own needs to meet your baby's
C) In bed with both of you--you are a Super Dad!

Diaper changing
A) 0-1--you are a good dad for making sure the little woman does it
B) 50-100--you are a good dad for occasionally giving the little woman a hand
C) Once a day--you are a Super Dad!

Child Support
A) Yes--you are a Super Dad!
B) Yes, sometimes--you are a good dad for pitching in when you can
C) No, due to new family--you are a good dad to the new kids for saving your money for them, and a good dad to the old kids for providing them with siblings!

Kid trivia
A) Know it all--you're lying
B) Know some--you're a good dad, because you know the important stuff
C) Know their names--you're a good dad, because at least you stuck around long enough to hear their names

Brought to you by the patriarchy and every exclamatory comment over how fabulous it is when a dad actually does some small thing to parent his kids.

The Man said too much of it was true, and it was all too frustrating, to be funny.

For the record, I answered bad mom, bad mom, bad mom, bad mom, and bad mom. He answered good dad, Super Dad, Super Dad, n/a, and he's lying.

And there you have it. The double standards for parenting neatly summed up in a pair of moderately funny and entirely depressing memes.

Friday, January 23, 2009

The ways I make my child cry

I drive away to class while he's begging for me to take him in my arms and stay with him.

I hold him down while he screams so someone can torture him with medical adhesive or blood drawing syringes.

I place out of his reach really interesting toys like sharp knives and broken glass.

I make him put away the cart after he's run with it around in the store for 10 minutes after I'm done shopping.

I fail to make the water fountain not be turned off for winter.

I tell him he cannot have a third green banana.

I don't make the world soft and bouncy and have rounded corners, and I allow him to get hurt, and sometimes it leaves scars.

I yell at him for no reason other than I am having a hard day.

There is no real point to this post, just a catalogue of some of the ways I fail in my child's eyes. No matter how consensually we try to live, I cannot and will not let him have his way every time. Sometimes he gets hurt, and I can't instantly make it better. Sometimes I am just cruel because I cannot cope any longer. It breaks my heart -- a phrase I did not truly understand until having him -- every time and yet I would not deny him all hurts even if I could. It would deny him the ability to empathize, deny him the ability to sympathize, deny him any chance to grow, deny him the experience of life. I will never willingly inflict pain on him for no purpose other than to suffer, but I cannot entirely regret that he will, sometimes outside of my control and sometimes with my collusion, know suffering.

Wednesday, January 21, 2009

Can we stop saying patriarchy is good for men?

If the patriarchy is good for men, then feminism, which opposes and seeks to dismantle the patriarchy, must be bad for men, and men become feminist's enemies, the pawns and bishop and knights of the patriarchy, if you will. We need to recruit allies, not create enemies which the "us v. them" rhetoric does quite well.

And patriarchy really isn't good for men, except in comparison to how truly horrible it is for women.

What the patriarchy does is create a hierarchy with (straight white rich thin ablebodied nuerotypical cisgendered) men at top, and (queer black poor fat disabled neurodivergent trans) women at bottom. It piles every privilege on men; values their work and their bodies as the standard; instills in them surety of their superiority; tells them they are closest to God (made in His image!); and gives them free reign to express their anger and hatred with any violence they please to use, at least as long as it's against a woman.

Sound great? Compared to getting pissed on and shat on and beat on and hated on and enslaved and raped and killed at the bottom of the patriarchal ladder, of course it does. Of course it is. It's a hundred thousand million times better and easier to live at the top as a straight white rich thin ablebodied nuerotypical cisgendered man than at the bottom as a queer poor fat disabled neurodivergent trans woman of color, and any man who tries to play the "you think you've got it hard??" game with a woman deserves, well, any violent expression of anger and hatred she pleases to use.

But simply rearranging that fucked up hierarchy, moving around the pieces so different types get piled on and get to sit on top, isn't what feminism is about. Feminism (and anti-racism and neurodiversity and other power-protesting movements) is about dismantling the whole unholy ladder entirely. It's about saying that the circumstances of your birth -- your gender, your race, your sexuality, your able-ity -- don't give you more value than anyone else. Men don't deserve bowing and scraping and every blessing of capitalism; no one does. Power corrupts, and privilege is ugly, and having power and privilege above others is bad for the soul of anyone.

The thing about the patriarchy is that while it gives men more freedom than anyone else by a factor of a thousand, it is not a perfect freedom. Men are allowed to show anger, but not fear or gentleness or vulnerability. Their work is valued, unless they want to do what is considered feminine. Their bodies are valued, as long as their bodies are manly enough. They are like God, but lose the chance to know Goddess as an equal. They are placed above all, and their humanity and humility corroded thereby.

What feminism offers men is a removal of those restrictions. No longer will men be pampered by the service of women, but rather they will be presented with strong, proud partners they can work with. Men won't be privileged above all others, but all the others will rise up and will join together to the benefit of all. Only the brainwashing of the patriarchy tells us that superiority is better than equality.

In the patriarchy, it is women who get the short end of the stick, to be sure, but I look at my Boychick, as beautiful and vulnerable and perfect as all babies are but "privileged" to be at the top of a stinking ugly inhumane heap of humanity, and I just want to get rid of the damned stick altogether. From here on out, the patriarchy is only going to hurt him, damage him, make him uglier, even as it makes him hurt those below him a million times more. How can that be "good" for him?

Monday, January 19, 2009

A day late and a Boo Yaa short

In frank and open theft of Womanist Musings's idea, I am hereby announcing to the blogger world that I started my period yesterday. I am menstruating, getting a visit from Aunt Flo (oh how I hate that one), riding the red tide, heading to the red tent, and suffering Eve's curse (mmm, more misogyny). I am, indeed, bleeding nigh unto death from my vagina -- or maybe it just feels like it. Either way, I am on the rag; which is actually an accurate colloquialism in this case, since I use cloth pads I made myself.

Why do you want to know this? Ok, you probably don't. But why not? Is our cultural avoidance of discussing menstruation simply out of respect for privacy? Part of our overall avoidance of discussing things involving fluid and the body? (Although apparently the state of one's cervix nine months after one fails to menstruate is fair game for everyone from your brother in law to the grocery clerk.) Or is it part of our misogynistic disgust with the female form, hatred rooted in envy of our power of procreation?

Or maybe no one wants to risk pissing off the already pissy chick with the bleeding pussy?

Regardless, I dislike the silence, the taboo. And so I'm breaking it.

This is my ninth menstruation since the 14 months of lactational amenorrhea the child and chance and round the clock nursing blessed me with. It is the first full cycle we have tried charting for pregnancy avoidance. (I say tried because it doesn't work so well when the child steals the basal body thermometer and loses it inside the house... somewhere... and eventually a new one is purchased, generic because that's all they had under $60 and who the hell spends $60 on a damn thermometer?, that works like absolute shite -- I am not sticking that piece of plastic in my mouth for FIVE MINUTES; if I wanted to do that I'd just buy a freaking glass one -- and the old one finally found, only to have discovered that somewhere in that week of wonky or no charting, you appear to have ovulated. Probably. Which is not the certainty I for one am looking for in my pregnancy avoidance method.) We've been meaning to for, well, all of the postpartum cycles, but just didn't get around to it. Needless to say, this cycle didn't exactly meet all the requirements for successful, safe condom-free nookie.

But that's OK, since the Boychick has also decided this month to fall asleep most nights by talking to himself. For an hour. Or two. I really wasn't worried about not getting my period this month, for the same reason a virgin generally isn't.

But still. Isn't it nice to know it's here?

Sunday, January 18, 2009

Something I said in my last post has been bugging me

I said:
This is why it matters when our kids' books have only white, able-bodied, neurotypical, cisgendered, gender-stereotyped characters. This is why it matters that we talk with our toddlers and our preschoolers about diversity and gender and sexuality and race and privilege, to the best of our ability, in ways they can understand. They may not know exactly what they are inside yet, they may not know exactly what race means yet or exactly what sex is yet, so it might seem to "not matter", but so, so soon they will.
I've been thinking a lot recently about race, and racism, and white privilege, and the intersection of feminism and anti-racism (and the intersections of feminism and racism), and I think that was part of why I was trying to do the ultra-liberal thing of conflating all -isms together in one big homogeneous lump and treating them all with "these suck, don't do them" stick.

It doesn't work that way, of course.

The very fact that I can think and say that my child may not know what race is at not-quite-two is because I am white, and my child is white, and The Man is white, and I swim, eat, breathe white privilege. Of course my child doesn't have to "deal with" race yet, or understand that the color of his skin speaks of so much more than how much melanin he produces; not because he is two, but because he is white. We have the option of talking with him about racism, or not. We have the option of talking with him about privilege, or not. That is one small aspect of this giant napsack of white privilege: the option to ignore it exists.

And being white; having this privilege I did not ask for and do not want; having been raised knowing racism was bad but never talking about race; having been taught that to be "color blind" was the goal so if we all (by which of course we mean white people) just squeezed our eyes shut real tight and held on and wished hard, it would go away (it being race and racism and privilege and difficult conversations and horrific pasts and horrific presents)... it's hard to talk about.

I have to anyway. Even if I don't always know what to say. Even if I get it wrong sometimes (which I did, and which I will again). Because I have to, else the Boychick will become just another damn clueless white guy, and I can't let that happen.

This is why it matters

Hellen G commented on my post "there's my rabbit Bob..." that:
many trans people know from a very early age that they have a gender identity issue, even if we don't necessarily have the words to describe it - I was about 5 when I knew that 'something wasn't right' about my body...
Another person I was talking with in the last week said that she knew she was attracted only to other girls by five, as much as a five year old can be (theirs may be an immature sexuality, but it is real nonetheless).

The only reason at age five I didn't know my own sexuality was because I had no word for it, no admittance in my culture that it even existed. By the time I was five, I knew I was attracted to boys and girls (and genderqueers and androgynes and other variations, as much as they showed up in suburban kindergarten land), but it wasn't until a decade later that I had a word for it. I knew most girls liked boys, and some girls liked just girls, but no one liked both. I thought there was something wrong with me, because there were no words for what I was, no bisexuals in my story books, no bi parents, no bi pride marches.

There were straights, and I wasn't that, and there were gays, and I wasn't that either, and there were sluts, of course, but that definitely wasn't me. I didn't even kiss anyone (except for my best friend when she and I were 5, hidden under my parents' waterbed) until The Man. I had no one at all in my culture to connect to, so I wasn't bisexual or pansexual or plain ol' happy queer, I was just a confused mess, wondering why I dreamed both about Wesley Crusher and Xena, Warrior Princess.

And I grew up in a fairly gay-friendly progressive household, and I knew that I wouldn't be kicked out if I came out as queer. I found out years after I came out (with reactions from my friends ranging from "uh huh" to "duh" -- I wasn't exactly good at hiding my queerness in the first place) that my own mother was bisexual, but as a monogamous married woman with kids didn't think it was "worth it" to be out, it "didn't matter".

I still sometimes feel like screaming at her "of course it fucking mattered! I could have saved myself a decade of pain and confusion if you were out!" I needed someone, anyone, to say to me "these people exist. this sexuality, this gender, these intrinsic inclinations are normal." And I was ready to hear that by age five. Helen was ready to hear that by age five.

This is why it matters when our kids' books have only white, able-bodied, neurotypical, cisgendered, gender-stereotyped characters. This is why it matters that we talk with our toddlers and our preschoolers about diversity and gender and sexuality and race and privilege, to the best of our ability, in ways they can understand. They may not know exactly what they are inside yet, they may not know exactly what race means yet or exactly what sex is yet, so it might seem to "not matter", but so, so soon they will. And their friends will. And we need to give them the words to explain it, and the room to celebrate it.

Friday, January 16, 2009

Toddler friendships (or, bath and cheese-eating pictures!)

I have a very dear friend, who happens to have a child about 10 months older than the Boychick. To our relief (for we would get together regularly for our own sanity anyway), they are as close as toddlers can get to Best Friends. They light up when they see each other (if it is almost always followed by screams of possessiveness), they push each other in carts, they walk around holding hands, they play at crawling together, they feed each other food they "cook" in their kitchens, they even on occasion hug, or kiss each other's boo-boos better. They sometimes bathe together, pouring water over each other and splashing and laughing hysterically. It melts our hearts.

They also, of course, yell at and hit each other, and scream whenever the other gets something the first doesn't, and snatch things from each other, and insist on always doing what the other is even if only one can at a time, and generally give us a big ol' headache. But hey, they're toddlers.

The only "unusual" part of all this is that the Best Friend is (as far as one can tell before puberty) of the female persuasion.

You would not believe (or perhaps that should be "I in my optimism can hardly believe") the amount of labeling this gets them from the generally-sexist general population. If they are not siblings ("sisters", usually, because the Boychick does not wear clothing with trucks and "Mommy's little monster" plastered all over it, and therefore must be female), then they are "boyfriend and girlfriend": they "flirt"; they "smooch"; he is "a little ladykiller" (can there be a more misogynistic phrase?), she "quite the catch". Because, of course, a boy and a girl, no matter how young, cannot be pals, or buddies, or just plain friends. Theirs must be a romantic relationship, if not a sibling one, for there cannot be any other roles for a male and a female of the same age.

This attitude, of course, makes my head explode. They don't know what romance is. They barely yet know what "boy" and "girl" are (he less than she, it seems so far). All they know is they like each other, like to spend time together, like to play with each other -- and occasionally despise the other with an agony representable only by supersonic screams of rage (if you've ever had a toddler, you know of what I speak).

But even if they knew. Even if they were teens, and had the potential to be romantically interesting in anything, and definitely were aware of the physical differences between the sexes, so what? Must every non-gay male and female be a romantic possibility? Can there be no relating to a person without evaluation of their sexual potential? Must every one of the Boychick's future female acquaintances be labeled by idiotic onlookers as a "maybe girlfriend"? My blood pressure skyrockets at the vision.

Before you accuse me of getting worked up over nothing, this is not just innocent fun that adults have with the relationship between their children, with no harm to the little ones. The assigning of toddler friendships with the "romantic" or "boyfriend/girlfriend" label is nothing more or less than a part of the ploy of the patriarchy to make women sexual objects and men sexual predators. If one is programmed to look at someone of the "opposite" gender and think "sex", even if in just some small part of one's mind, regardless of whether one is actually attracted to the other, then one cannot relate to the other as a person. And the patriarchy would surely fall apart if we all did that.

Wednesday, January 14, 2009

"...there's my rabbit, Bob, and his bunny wife Bob"

There was a time I naively assumed that I wouldn't have to worry about sexism in my child's books until at least story books, maybe not even until chapter books. Surely board books, written to start reading to infants so young they only understand the rhythm and rhyme of the words, would be immune!

That naivete lasted until maybe five minutes after the Boychick got his first book.

The truth is even board books, even modern board books, are rife with sexism, heterosexism, racism, and of course, what's a good word, cisgenderism? (One can't even call it transphobia, for it's more the complete lack of acknowledgment that gender isn't always obvious, simple, and binary. Transphobia might be a step up.)

The title for this post came from the usually innocuous Sandra Boynton, in her book titled Fifteen Animals, a recent gift from beloved relatives and fellow Boynton fans. That line alone would be enough to make my head explode (the male bob is referred to as a rabbit, the female with the diminutive bunny; she is of course a "wife", not an independent woman rabbit nor even an interdependent but nonsexist "spouse"; and he possesses her as his wife), but it's only one of the offensive examples on the Boychick's library -- which itself has been chosen largely by us to be as nonsexist as possible.

A recent disappointment was Papa, Papa. I had heard good things about Mama, Mama from the AP community (mentions of nursing and cosleeping, also things lacking in children's books in general) -- and apart from one weird and one schmaltzy page it isn't too bad -- and since I try never to buy a mother-centric book without getting a corresponding father-centric book, we ordered Papa, Papa as well, with moderately high hopes.

Papa Papa, it turns out, is basically one long exploration of fathering stereotypes. Father as home builder, wise and worshiped, leader, teacher of howling (in a patriarchal context, this can stand for teacher of how to be outspoken, assertive, and possessive; how to trumpet aggression), and promoter of (and proud of) independence are some of the highlights. The "best" pages are the first and last, where Papa teaches little ones to sing, and where the narrator feels "warm and safe" with Papa (in the context of playing "peekaboo"), but nowhere is there an image of father-as-nurturer, or father-as-caretaker (as in Mama, Mama, which features Mama cleaning and feeding the narrator). The Man's take on it is the Mama, Mama book is about the mother/child as a unit, with mother as safe base, and exploring the world around WITH each other, whereas in Papa, Papa, there is separation between the father and child, with the father teaching and giving TO the narrator.

Another example is Sam Loves Kisses (bought for the Boychick by well-meaning friends because of the lovely last page featuring a snuggly family bed), in which the "mommy" gets "a sweet kiss" and is depicted (in a dress, though devoid of feminine curves) as busy in the kitchen, and the "daddy" (bepantsed, of course) gets "an airplane kiss", and plays with Sam to distract him so the mother can cook -- because, of course, the man couldn't take a turn cooking, nor could he distract the child with nurturing or cuddles. We'll not even get in to the cars covering Sam's bedspread.

I could go on: there's City Babies, in which there are mother animals but no fathers (I will allow that the non-human animal kingdom is factually sex-biased in parenting, but the authors could have used examples from the avian world -- there were three bird pages in there already); in Daddy Cuddles, an otherwise excellent book, the human father "cuddles" his baby on his back, demonstrating once again that men can be playful (piggy back) but not nurturing (in arms); of the several books that depict one parent and a child, only one has a father instead of a mother (the hippopotamus of Sandra Boynton's The Bellybutton Book).

So we are confronted with what to do. We have already chosen "the best of the bunch", at least of what we can find in stores around here, and if we wanted more books with fewer -isms and more diversity, we'd have to special order all of them (I actually tried to order And Tango Makes Three for the Boychick for Yule, but was informed it was unavailable in board book at this time), and I wouldn't even know where to look. We don't wish to censor books, but neither do we want to immerse him at so young an age (or ever!) in a sexist, heterosexist mindset, when his opinion on the world is just being formed.

For many of our books, we have settled on alternate readings that offend us less (we switch who gets which type of kisses and who is in the kitchen in Sam Loves Kisses, and say "...there's my rabbit, Bob, and her bunny partner Bob"). But when others come to read to him, they read it the "straight" (pun intended, of course) way. Will he look at others funny (or correct them!) when they read it "wrong? ...and would that be "bad"? If we don't read exactly what is on the page, will we damage or delay his reading, if he's still using these books in a few years when he's at that stage? If we cross out the irritating bits and write in our versions, are we teaching him censorship and book defacement are OK? Or would we be merely recording and commemorating our family's unique stories? How do we navigate these waters?

How do you?

Tuesday, January 13, 2009

We're not done yet

There's a note taped to the wall above the light switch in the women's bathroom at my school that reads:
Due to safety concerns, the women's bathroom light must stay on during open hours.
Feminism can never be an irrelevant philosophy while signs like this are still needed.

Monday, January 12, 2009

Tomorrow I go back to school (or, hello self-indulgent introspection and academic angst)

OK, so I went to school last quarter, too, but this still feels like a Really Big Deal to me.

Last September, I finally enrolled in massage school. I've been studying homebirth midwifery off and on for years, and considered ramping that up and looking for a school or an apprenticeship, but with the Boychick still so young, and potentially another chick somewhere down the road, I decided I couldn't pursue midwifery right now.

But goddess knows I needed something to do. Don't get me wrong, I do enjoy (and dread and everything in between, though on whole it's a joy and well worth it) spending my days with the Boychick, but without something to focus on, the possibility to focus just on him, to the detriment of our relationship and my sanity and my identity, is too great.

So the idea of massage school, always tickling the back of my mind, came to the fore and started knocking my mental door. Again.

Why massage? Why not, say, university and feminist studies? I can certainly name several reasons why not enter a profession that is primarily and traditionally female, that trades on the touch and caring servitude of a woman (and that feminist studies degree is also something I dream of -- I think if I had my way I'd be in school for the next century), but the plain and simple truth is, I like it. I've been giving massages since I can remember, and I'm pretty darn good at it. It's a flexible career that doesn't demand I be in an office 40 hours a week (something I am constitutionally not good at, not that I think it's good for the rest of humanity either). Plus I can attend to pregnant and postpartum women, and infiltrate their barriers with subtle messages of feminism and attachment shared-parenting ("your work said what to you?? here, let me give you a number to call about discrimination in the workplace", "have your partner walk around with the baby in the sling for an hour so s/he doesn't need to cry during our session").

But back to going back to school.

I felt such anxiety at the start of last quarter, when I took just one class, one day a week, for three hours in the evening -- partly due to concerns about my rocky history with school repeating itself, but largely due to concerns about leaving the Boychick. I'd never been apart from him that long before -- by my own desire. And the separation wasn't always good for either of us (think of The Man running around for three hours trying to distract a toddler who was used to always nursing when he woke up from his nap, me lying very uncomfortably on the massage table with overfull breasts), but I think it was also good for both of us. He learns that not just dadas go to work, but mamas do too. I get to recharge and improve myself (and get a massage, if a practice one!), and have a focus and a goal for the rest of the week. And eventually, I'll be able to earn a decent wage doing something I enjoy, so we can start paying off the outrageous career loan, that is, both earn income.

This quarter I'm going for two classes, putting me out of the house twice a week, for a total of 8 hours or so. Which is nothing, right? Women-with-children everywhere manage that every day. (Meanwhile the patriarchal outpost in my head is screaming at me alternatingly "you should do that too!" and "other women manage to NEVER leave their precious babies!"; it'll say anything to break me down and make me hate on myself.) So anxiety over that meager a separation is just self-indulgent whiney angst, right?

But still... for us, for me, for now, a big deal.


(Next post, a return to the fierce, feminist ranter you've come to love, or at least read, as I discuss sexism in children's books!)

Sunday, January 11, 2009

A minor talent

I have some talent musically. I studied piano for twelve years, and tutored it for a summer after high school. I played the sax in band, first the alto then the bari. I can play an octave on a dozen instruments, and pick out the three-note melody for Mary Had a Little Lamb on almost anything. I sang in choir, and when in condition had an alto range that could serviceably manage a tenor through a soprano.

I also have some talent with the written word. I wrote poetry unceasingly from middle through high school. I got in to honors English in high school on the strength of an impromptu essay. I won a partial but significant scholarship to college based on a collection of my essays and poems. I was chosen for a very small honors colloquium at the college I ended up choosing. I flatter myself that I am skilled enough to write a blog worth reading.

And yet...

One of my best friends is a musical genius, an easy natural with near-perfect pitch. She picks up instruments like others pick up... well, nothing. Socks, perhaps. I sat in first row in my instrument in high school; she sat first chair in hers. The guitar is one of the instruments that has so far eluded me; yesterday I was at her house, and listened to her play a professional sounding accompaniment to several children's songs... that she had "just picked out".

My other best friend is a twice-published novelist, whose lyrical, honest narrative wins critical acclaim internationally. I won a partial scholarship to a liberal arts college with my writing; she won a larger scholarship to a fine arts university with hers. I'm watching her craft a third novel, as she takes a plot which could be sappy or heavy-handed (as indeed all plots could) and uses it to tell truth and beauty in alternating heart-stopping and humorous ways, choosing language and imagery I could never in a hundred years think of.

As I stand with my minor talent in the shadow of these greats, I struggle to avoid the cultural conditioning which says I must be in competition with other women, which says if I cannot be the best, why bother. It is a struggle, to be sure, and sometimes I think I do turn green with envy -- not a flattering color for my ivory-pink complexion, nor an appreciative enough treatment of my goddess-granted and mother-descended gifts. I struggle to avoid the comparisons which are the root of competition, to stand proud with what I do have, when every part of the patriarchy tells me I could never be good enough, even if I were the best. I struggle to deny the messages that say I must either hate or worship those more blessed than I: those with more musical talent, those with more writing talent, and those of the "right", more privileged gender. Rejecting that culturally-dictated hatred -- hatred of the better, or hatred of the self -- may seem like a minor feat, but it is one of the most radical acts I can imagine.

Saturday, January 10, 2009

Man as babywearer (or, this site needs pictures)

All blogs need photos. It seems we are such a visual animal that a blog without photos is like cocoa without sugar and cream: what's the point? And, I've been meaning to write about babywearing, and how attachment parenting really can be feminist, especially with a babywearing father. So here they are, my (presumably) straight white males, defying the stereotypes and snuggling close (and yes, he does all the wrapping himself, and indeed, taught me how).










Of course, one of the great things about men babywearing is it models nurturing behavior for the next generation. (That's BunBun on the Boychick's back, in a much-too-large Sutemi Pack wrapped around him two or three times.)








When attachment parenting is not just attachment mothering, everyone benefits: the mother gets to share the parenting in a way still meeting the child's needs (though I did all of the feeding of the Boychick for the first 7 months, The Man did all the babywearing while he was on paternity leave, and almost all of it when he was home after that, making a point to wear him especially in the evenings to give me "me" time, and himself baby time), the father or partner gets the joys of having a baby snuggled in close (and it is a joy!), and the child gets to build loving relationships with all parents. Add to that the nurturing of male children, who are traditionally held apart and told to suck it up, and I can only see how attachment parenting, and especially babywearing, is helping us raise the next generation nonsexistly.



(I apologize for the poor quality photos: I can only beg forgiveness as a nonskilled photographer, with the added excuse that our camera was dying when these pictures were taken; it has since gone on to silicon heaven, and we miss it dearly.)

Friday, January 9, 2009

What does a feminist mother look like?

I've been on the hunt for other feminist parent blogs, and I found the motherlode at blue milk. I imagine I will be filling up my RSS reader with the plethora of amazing feminist parent blogs linked to from there. Finding this abundance, when I started this blog largely because I hadn't heard this voice before, both intimidated and inspired me; it makes me want to close up shop with a redirect to blue milk and a "what she said" note, and gives me hope of finding an audience and has me thinking of a hundred new blog posts of my own.

One of them (this one) you could call a cheat, or a meme, but I, like blue milk, call it:

What does a feminist mother look like?


1. How would you describe your feminism in one sentence? When did you become a feminist? Was it before or after you became a mother?
I could crib, and use the ever-popular "feminism is the radical notion that women are people", and it would be true, if annoyingly vague. Feminism for me is a path to the end of gender-based discrimination, to gender equality, to a world where women are not systematically oppressed and men systematically elevated. I believe I was raised a feminist; whether or not the word was used, and regardless of my parents' not-exactly-equal marriage, the idea that "women are people", and that the system is set up against us, was there from the beginning, reinforced at many turns. In fact, I was frankly shocked when, in adolescence, I discovered that not all women (smart, strong women at that!) identify as feminist. Didn't they believe women were people? Didn't they disagree with policies oppressing women? So why didn't they identify as feminist? I still haven't figured out an answer to that that satisfies me (though I blame the patriarchy).

2. What has surprised you most about motherhood?
I was fortunate to join a mothering community and make mother-friends (both online and in face-to-face) before even deciding to have children, and I read voraciously, so little about this parenting journey has surprised me, other than the specifics that our path have taken (I was not expecting congenital hypothyroidism, for instance, nor that a child of not-skinny The Man and I would be long and lean). The one thing I often run up against that surprises me, though it shouldn't, is the way mothering, motherhood, and mothers are perceived, and conversely the way fathers and fathering is perceived. Would that I had a dollar for every sexist "dads can't do this/mothers are this way/babies never like dads" comment I've heard!

3. How has your feminism changed over time? What is the impact of motherhood on your feminism?
I think I have become more radical over time, and possibly more cynical or jaded -- I have discovered that feminism isn't as ubiquitous as it should be, that there is more sexism still in the world than I believed possible, that even the advancements we have achieved either have backslid or had undesirable consequences, that gender-neutrality and gender-equality even as goals are again being rejected and reviled. I have become more critical of the only-women-must-change philosophy of the ever-popular "choice feminism". In motherhood, I have become more aware of how much the system needs a radical overhaul, how little progress has been made toward sane and family-friendly policies that would support equally shared parenting, and how really, truly damaged by sexism little boys are as well as little girls. I have also become more nuanced in my thoughts on women, motherhood, and work, having become more aware of the importance of attachment and breastmilk in the early years; but even this goes back to becoming more radical, and believing we truly need a major, systemic, patriarchy- and corporatocracy-toppling revolution.


4. What makes your mothering feminist? How does your approach differ from a non-feminist mother’s? How does feminism impact upon your parenting?
A look at the clothes and toys the Boychick has displays a large part of the differences between us as feminist parents and American popular non-feminist parents (a post about toys and clothes is forthcoming) -- and the way I answered just now, with us not I, is one of the ways that my parenting is different, because The Man and I see these choices as ours, whereas in a non-feminist family, the choices of what young child wears and plays with is more exclusively the domain of the mother (with the father having veto rights over anything pink and girly for his sons). My mothering is feminist because I expect my partner's fathering to be equally invested in our child. The Man wore our baby every day of his life until he was over a year and a half; he is an overt and outspoken breastfeeding supporter; he took charge of non-nursing nighttime parenting; he learned about and equally practiced elimination communication, and changed diapers when we missed, and did the diaper laundry. I as a feminist mother assumed and allowed (did not interfere with) him to establish his own, unique relationship with our baby. I encourage the Boychick to be nurtured, and nurturing, to be attached and dependent, and independent, and interdependent. I do not assume I know who as an adult he will be or who he will love or what he will do, simply because I know the genitals between his legs. We chose his name while knowing him in my womb, without knowing his sex. Feminism informs every part of my parenting, even if some parts look "traditional" and therefore patriarchal.


5. Do you ever feel compromised as a feminist mother? Do you ever feel you’ve failed as a feminist mother?
I think that very question is telling: it is on the woman to "succeed" or "fail" at feminism. I reject that notion, and say instead that society often fails us, requiring compromises to feminist values that, if universally accepted and accounted for, would create an entirely new kind of life.

There have been times when I have looked around at my traditional-appearing life and thought "what the hell am I doing?" But I do not believe that reflects a belief that I have failed, rather that I have temporarily bought in to the (entirely false) idea that I must change, and take part in the inherently patriarchal, capitalistic, stuff-based rat-race if I am to be a "real feminist" or a "fulfilled woman", once again placing the traditionally-male higher in value than the traditionally-female. I feel angry often that The Man and I are not able to lead quite the life we would like to, thanks to patriarchal, anti-feminist institutions and cultural expectations, but no, I do not believe this means I have failed.

6. Has identifying as a feminist mother ever been difficult? Why?
I exist at an interesting crossroads, being both a feminist and a "crunchy", attachment-minded parent. The natural birth/breastfeeding/attachment community draws such a diverse group, from radical submissive proud housewives to radical equality-seeking queer feminists, and everything in between. In that context, it is sometimes difficult, in that I am often lumped in to categories and stereotypes that are entirely counter to my feminism; or, conversely, I may be accused of rejecting attachment values if I proclaim my feminist ones. Convincing people one can be both at the same time is not always easy.

7. Motherhood involves sacrifice, how do you reconcile that with being a feminist?
This is such a strange question to me, although I recognize where it comes from (the idea of the sacrificial mother). Any relationship or endeavor involves sacrifice: having a pet, having a partner, having a job, going to school... The things we want in life are worth sacrifice, compromise, giving up one thing to get another. I don't believe in sacrificial motherhood (the mother as martyr), so I don't feel I sacrifice more as a mother than I do as a partner, as a student, as a person with companion animals. It's definitely more involved, and if someone is used to living only for the self, that can be a shock, but for someone with an awareness and appreciation of interdependence before having children, it's not much of a change of type, just a change of scale.

8. If you have a partner, how does your partner feel about your feminist motherhood? What is the impact of your feminism on your partner?
We are feminist parents, whether or not The Man identifies as "a feminist" (this has changed over time, with him becoming more comfortable with it as we have talked more about it; the cultural shaming of identifying as feminist is even stronger for men than for women). It seems to me that one cannot act fully as a feminist mother with a non-feminist partner (see answer to question 4); in order to be a feminist mother in a partnered relationship, the partner MUST take up equal childrearing duties without regard to "traditional" gender roles. I think The Man has a much better, closer relationship with the Boychick due to our views on equality parenting (which is to say, due to feminism).

9. If you’re an attachment parenting mother, what challenges if any does this pose for your feminism and how have you resolved them?
I don't think attachment parenting is in any way contradictory with feminism; attachment mothering is. Attachment parenting means both (all) parents build attachment with their child: this means we both wear him, both sleep with him, both offer gentle guidance, both play with him, both bring him in to our lives and help him see us work (to the best of our ability). The only apparent contradictions are breastfeeding and the home/work split; breastfeeding is not a challenge to feminism at all, but a facet of it (more on that later), and I've previously discussed the compromises that have led to me staying with the child during the day while The Man works in an office. Both have meant that in other ways, The Man takes on a proportionally larger role than I: when the Boychick was exclusively breastfed, The Man did almost all of the babywearing when we were together; when he comes home at lunch or after work or on weekends, he does more of the pottying and dressing and playing. Since rarely do I leave them both (I am a homebody by nature), I do spend more time with the Boychick than The Man does, but I don't think I spend much, if any, more "on" time. The mother-child relationship in a breastfeeding, attached family may be closer in the younger years than the partner/father-child relationship, but with equally shared as well as attachment parenting, this isn't a "problem" for me as a feminist mother.

10. Do you feel feminism has failed mothers and if so how? Personally, what do you think feminism has given mothers?
I think the patriarchy fails mothers, and that feminism isn't done yet. I think some branches of feminism were (inadvertently, I like to believe) hurtful to mothers, but that isn't a failure of feminism, but a win of the patriarchy: whenever we fight with each other, it is the patriarchy that wins.

Feminism has given us so much in tangible contributions that so many non-feminist-identified women take for granted these days (if I do not remind myself, I can forget it too), from being seen as legally persons instead of property of a man, to the right to vote, the right to divorce, the right to contraception, the right to make decisions for our children, the right to own property, the right to work, the right to terminate a pregnancy, to the ability to have a child out of wedlock without being shunned, the ability to be pregnant in public without being shunned, the ability to have family at our births, the ability to birth without the humiliation of enemas or pubic shaving (though the patriarchy still asserts itself in other ways), the ability to chose our last name and the last name of our child, the ability to speak up and not be laughed at in the public sphere. These (and more) are all direct results of feminist activists, of feminism changing the way we as a culture think. We have so much more to do, but we must not forget how far feminism has brought us already.

Wednesday, January 7, 2009

Pro-choice, sure, but pro choice-feminism?

Choice feminism, in a nutshell and as I understand it, is a reaction to the "throw down your aprons and your razors and go get a job!" feminism of the 70s. Its position is that any act is feminist as long as the woman acting chooses it. "It's all about choice" is the slogan, and is usually hurled by those who are choosing that which traditional feminists declare to be oppressing them (shave, wear make up, stay at home, etc).

It's a compelling argument, to be sure. After all, I as a feminist am pro choice, right? I choose to stay home, certainly. Women's liberation was just a reaction to being forced to stay home, and it's totally different if she chooses it. Right?

Well, yes. But also no. We need to be free to choose the trajectories of our own lives, to be sure, and emancipation and liberation are not as simple as "go out and get a real job." But the rallying cry of choice feminism ("It's all about choice!") is missing the point as well, and is arguably proping up the patriarchy.

The thing is, we don't live in a vacuum, nor in a post patriarchy. Like it or not, acknowledge it or not, our choices -- my choices -- are influenced by the society we live in, a society that sends often conflicting, but always constricting, messages to women (and men) about what they should and shouldn't and must and mustn't do. Whenever our "totally free and independent choices" coincide perfectly with one of the dominant messages sent by the patriarchy, and indeed are the acts required to allow the patriarchy to continue to exist, we must examine where those choices, and the situation and preferences behind them, come from. It may be "my choice" to stay at home and care for the Boychick while my male partner works in a corporate office environment 40 hours a week, but what are the factors influencing that decision? What are my other choices? And why don't I have a full range of real, child- and family-friendly choices?

Ultimately, choice feminism succeeds in being popular and fails at challenging or changing the patriarchy because of its insistence on individual responsibility and freedom without placing any burden on society as a whole. It pretends that we have achieved full liberation already, and thus denies that patriarchal institutions limit what choices we have available to select from, and thus is allowed (and encouraged, in as much as it displaces other flavors of feminism) to continue by a deeply misogynistic and sexist society, while feminism that would challenge the dominant structure, by calling for broad social changes, is dismissed as either overly idealistic or overly prescriptive, a victimhood "everybody hates me" philosophy, the domain of man- and child-hating ugly bepantsed women who would deny other women the joys of home and family.

So no, I am not a choice feminist. These are not the choices I would make in a post-patriarchal world. We can choose acts which perpetuate patriarchy, and they are not magically made feminist by the act of our choosing them. Don't get me wrong; I don't particularly want an office job, and though I in fact don't shave or wear makeup I don't thing everyone else should stop. I do believe we must have choices, and each woman must choose for herself, not just what happens in her uterus but what happens in her larger life.

Rather, my point is twofold: not that we should always avoid choices that support patriarchy (else I wouldn't be at home, I wouldn't have had the Boychick, and I arguably wouldn't be with a man at all), but that we shouldn't blind ourselves to the effects our choices have; and that by placing all the burden of "choice" on women, and none on society to offer a broader array of choices to both men and women, choice feminism is at its root misogynistic. It is once again saying that it's all up to women, that society is just fine and isn't going to change at all, and women can just deal with it. That's not a position I can get behind at all.

Tuesday, January 6, 2009

Is domesticity anti-feminist?

In an effort to get our eating out and Starbucks bills under control, The Man and I are participating on a no spend challenge this month. I've also been experimenting with traditional foods, especially soaking grains. We even created a meal plan for the week, and I have no knead bread rising as I type. Add to that that the Boychick has actually let me pick up the knitting needles again (good thing, too, for The Man left his previous wool hat on the bus in the middle of a blizzard), and that I'm in the middle of a month long break from classes, and it's all combined to make me feel a little... domestic.

Did you hear that whisper? The slightly horrified tone? Domestic is a dirty word, no doubt about it.

But why? Where did that repugnance come from? Well, Betty Friedan, but other than that. Why the revilement of the place we spend most of our lives? I am surely not immune to it, for the realization that I had made all three of our meals (a rare event in our household only for me: The Man, the main cook here, does it most weekends) plus our dessert and had already started on tomorrow's dinner made me feel decidedly odd. I had an urge to throw down the spatula and run away to an all-women university. I felt I was betraying my mother (a physician from the generation where the female med students still had to share the nurse's locker room), my grandmother (who really did wear army boots), and all my feminist forebears.

But I also felt betrayed. I was raised on meals from a can, a box, or a fast food "restaurant", and didn't even know what real food was, much less how important it is. I was taught that cleaning was for the maids (all women, interestingly), for it was beneath an educated, enlightened woman, and so it took me (and my partner, whose full-time on the night shift mother gave up sleep to clean and care for him) years to learn how to avoid squalor, and we still haven't fully controlled the clutter. Homes must be kept, if we are to live somewhere. Children must be reared, if we are to have them. Why must these tasks be reviled?

Oh, but I am so not suggesting women meekly head home and don their aprons like good little housewives. That truly would be a betrayal, and I would rightly be roundly shot down by my fellow feminists. I maintain that there must be, and is, a position neither women oppressing nor home neglecting.

The problem as I see it is that domesticity is reviled because it was women's work, and the way proposed to raise women's status up was to leave the domestic sphere and join the men. Which is great, as far as it goes. But it means no one's home. And those who are (either literally by being stay at home parents, or figuratively by excelling at domestic tasks such as cooking or knitting) are belittled -- the men by the gender traditionalists, the women by feminist traditionalists.

The solution then, as I see it, is neither to raise women out of the domestic sphere nor to lower them back in to it, but to raise the status of the sphere itself. Only when domesticity and home-keeping are valued by all will men as a whole take up their share, and only then that women will be free to enter or leave it as they please, and be respected either way. Only then will our domestic ancestresses receive the honor and acclaim they deserve for keeping the home fires burning, and our ancestors the shame of not participating fully.

One could accuse me merely of wanting status for falling in to a role my mothers worked so hard to run away from, and maybe that's part of it. But I can't see what we would lose by celebrating domesticity a little, and I see so much we could gain, from gender equality to really great bread. That seems worth the effort, doesn't it?

Monday, January 5, 2009

Blast from the past

I've been writing about feminism for a while it seems. This is a post from my previous (now-defunct) attempt at a blog, from three years ago, pre-Boychick (pre-pregnancy, for that matter). I don't think this is what I would write on this topic now, but I think it still fundamentally reflects a part of my truth.

(Yup, this is a post about a post about a post on a message board, 'cause I'm slick like that.)



I was in a discussion on mothering and feminism with a woman who calls herself a "liberal individualist" who rejects "the idea of feminism" and is insulted by the suggestion that, although each woman may have freedom of choice (which is the entirety of her view), they are also heavily influenced by social pressures into conforming with a patriarchal, still misogynistic society. Feminism is insulting to women, she said, because it denies that they are choosing to conform to society and therefore are powerful because they have made a choice, and have not been "forced" by "social pressures" (although there apparently exists no such thing as "social pressure"). This was my response.

-----------------------------------

Everyone has full freedom and personal choice and free will, all the time, and no one is coerced into anything (ever - there is always a choice, even if the choice is to die rather than do what their oppressors want). That is completely true.

It is also true that everything everyone does and every choice anyone ever makes is influenced and often restricted profoundly by the society they live in and the assumptions and beliefs (often contradictory) of that society, and that what each person does and the "choices" each person makes is almost always predictable by knowing the social and psychological forces they live with.

Both are true.

I'm not trying to be annoyingly zen here or anything - both are completely true. To acknowledge one of the above statements and think the other is wrong is to deny something fundamental about what it is to be human and alive in this world. We have full freedom of choice in each moment, and we live our lives in largely predictable ways based on the pressures of the society we live in.

One of the strong points of feminism, although (as with every strength) it is sometimes made a weakness by going too far, is the acknowledgment and exploration of the second idea. I am heavily influenced here by my familial history with Al-Alon and buddhist-influenced psychotherapy, and their belief that power and personal autonomy exist only when one admits one's powerlessness in the face of disease/social pressure. I come from a background where admitting and acknowledging one's powerlessness is the only path to power. So no, I don't think it's insulting to women to say that every choice a woman makes (and a man - I don't exempt them, so I guess I'm insulting them and calling them weak also?) is influenced, and often restricted, by the society she lives in - I think it's empowering.

By acknowledging that every choice I make is being influenced and often restricted by the world I live in, I can examine those influences and restrictions and assumptions and choose to accept them or reject them. I am made more powerful, and my choices are made more free, by that knowledge. That, in my view, is the power and the gift of feminism - it helps me to be on the look out for, to see, to acknowledge, to deconstruct, and finally to accept or reject the patriarchal and misogynistic influences that surround me, and I am freer for it.

Sunday, January 4, 2009

The USA is misogynist and anti-family, or, I am not a SAHM

I am not one of those feminists who think women must be engaged in paid employment to be fulfilled.

I am not one of those feminists who thinks a woman's highest calling and only pursuit necessary for fulfillment is mothering.

I do not believe in gender essentialism; I do not believe formula freed women.

I am not a SAHM; I just spend the day taking care of my kid.

This might sound like another one of my contradictions, but -- oh wait, it is, because they're not contradictory at all, just nuanced. Here's the thing: I believe in attachment theory (in about the same the way as I believe in the theory of gravity). I believe breastmilk is a birthright of every child, barring rare and unfortunate circumstances. I believe daycares are not bad, but villages are better. And given all this, I believe the US of A is a really crappy place to raise a kid.

It's not that I think having a parent at home full time is the best for children: I don't. I really don't, actually, and this is one of the biggest reasons why I am not comfortable with that label. But I think the ideal parenting situations -- where children are welcome in the real world, where work and life are not strictly segregated, where there are lots of loving family and friends close-by long-term, where the motherbaby unit is acknowledged as one, where the importance of attachment is recognized -- don't exist in my life. Or anyone's life that I know of. So we have to make compromises; for me, for our family, this is the best compromise for the time being. The Boychick needs to be close to his parent(s), he needs access to the breast, he needs to be a part of someone's life, observing and learning from the world, and me being with him during the day is the way we try to best meet the majority of those needs.

But it's not our ideal.

For all the lip-service (and there is much!) that the USA gives to "family" and "motherhood", we offer an amazing dearth of real, practical support. There is no guarantee of health care for parents or child; no, not even for pregnant women, for all that we supposedly are so against pregnancy termination because it's a crime against the unborn. The parental leave, when one has access to any, is laughable (if I didn't laugh, I'd start crying -- as I did when the Boychick's father went back to work at three weeks postpartum, before I'd even stopped bleeding). Only a tiny minority of companies have any kind of on-site daycare available, and disturbingly few are supportive of pumping at work, much less bringing in a sleepy sling baby to nurse while working.

So given the dearth of options available, along with my partner's high earning potential and my current lack of any, I take care of the child while my partner works. In a sane society, one that didn't demand everything of women without offering anything to help, I would have more options for paid employment or meaningful pursuits, either in or near my house or where I could bring my child along. In a sane society, perhaps I would be at home still, but perhaps so would my partner; or, it would be understood that this was a short part of my child's life, and in 3-5 years I would be engaged in other activities. In a sane society, I would not be defined by my family's choices in my child's infancy. In a sane society, I would be a person first, a woman second, and a mother third. In a sane society, my work as a volunteer moderator and my studies as a student would be recognized and honored, instead of ignored because they are unpaid and take place outside of 8-5.

But this is an insane society. So I am home (or out and about, but otherwise unemployed) during the day with my child. But I'm still not a SAHM.

Thursday, January 1, 2009

Penises, vulvas, and other interesting things

The Boychick is 21 months old. His vocabulary is not even trackable, it is so large and growing so quickly. Two of his favorite words are penis ("peenee", which amuses me no end) and vulva. He knows mama wipes her vulva and her butt, and he knows he wipes his penis and his butt. He also likes to say he's wiping his vulva, which near as I can figure means his perineum, that is, the bottom of his scrotum and the space between it and his anus. He really doesn't believe us that he doesn't have a vulva, that neither does his father, and that only mothers and women and girls have vulvas. He doesn't yet understand the categories "male" and "female" as far as we can tell, though he knows there are differences between his mother and his father (his father's breasts don't have milk, for one!).

Interestingly, the idea of me having a penis has not come up. To my child, the default is having a vulva; penises are interesting extras, of course, but everyone has a vulva.

And here is an opening for one of my favorite rants: I loathe, loathe, LOATHE the saying "boys have penises, girls have vaginas". Vagina isn't a dirty word: it's a great one (if we ignore its ignoble origins as a word meaning "sheath"). And barring infection, the organ isn't dirty either, just amazingly useful (I conceived and birthed my child through mine! how cool is that?). But the analogue to the penis it ain't, except in reference to PIV (penis in vagina) intercourse, where only the man's orgasm matters.

Anatomically, the closest female analogue to penis is the clitoris. Say it with me, because it is just that beautiful a word: clitoris. It is the primary female sexual organ, not the vagina. Our vaginas are fabulously interesting passages, to be sure, but I know of less than a handful of women who can (or care to) orgasm exclusively through vaginal stimulation.

But perhaps I'm focusing too much on sex, with my championship of the clitoris (I am an American, after all, if a female one -- and you will also note that I am speaking exclusively of female-born females, and ignoring female persons born with male-appearing bodies, and vice versa, and other gender variations; I beg you will forgive me my simplicity at this time, with the excuse that my little one is less than two years old).

Let's take another tack: the vagina is an organ notable for its internality, invisible in all but sexual or gynecological situations. Boys must take it for granted that their mothers' and sisters' vaginas exist at all, much less know what they look like. We might as well say girls have uteri, for they're about as visible to the average boy, and even more essential to anatomical female-ness. To say that boys have penises and girls have vaginas is to ignore all the beautiful external genitalia girls do have. Perhaps not the nestled-away clitoris, but the vulva as a whole, the external labia and pubic mons, are visible in casual situations, such as when on the toilet. So an argument could be made for the use of vulva, as the female external genital analogue to the penis, and indeed, that is what we use with the Boychick.

So, boys have penises and girls have clitorises. Or, boys have penises and girls have vulvas. But please, although factually true that boys have penises and girls have vaginas, it makes about as much sense as saying girls have clitorises and boys have prostates. So stop. Vagina is a beautiful word, one that we must not be afraid to use, but so is clitoris. So is vulva. And in this context, they make more sense. The use of vagina as the penis's "opposite" is inherently male-focused, and ignores the hub (or nub!) of what it is to be female.