Showing posts with label fathers. Show all posts
Showing posts with label fathers. Show all posts

Saturday, July 11, 2009

A feminist parenting primer: share your stories through guest blogging

I'm considering running a series of posts on how we live womanist/feminist parenting; a sort of kaleidoscope primer on the day-to-day living of those of us who fight, oppose, undermine, and dismantle the kyriarchy (or at least try to!) that can help answer the questions "Sure, this all sounds good, but how do you DO this?" or "How can the ideals of feminism and anti-kyriarchy really work in real life?"

This may have some overlap with bluemilk's What does a feminist mother look like?/10 feminist mother questions meme, and the Carnival of Feminist Parenting, but I'm looking for something a little different: an image of your day, or a snapshot of a particular moment, or the tale of a decision you made, or your "feminist family mission statement" and how you try to follow it. Something practical that shows how we really put our ideals into practice. Here are a few of my posts that sort of show what I mean, but I'm really looking for your stories, and your ways of storytelling.

I'm not looking for perfection: sometimes the best opportunities for learning or teaching come when we mess up. And don't worry about it being "good enough" in either feminist content or writing quality -- I'm not going to judge the former, and I can help with the latter. I'm just looking for a picture, big or little, of some way you try to enact womanism/feminism in your life as a parent, and raise the next generation more aware of and less enslaved by kyriarchy/patriarchy.

I'd especially like to get the perspective of parents ("regular", step, adoptive, birth, and to-be or hoping-to-be) who are not male-partnered, white, able-bodied, middle-class, American women -- though even if you are all those things don't let that stop you from submitting.

So what do you think? Sound like a good idea?

Anyone interested, whether you know what to write or not, contact me at raisingmyboychick at gmail dot com.

Please and thank you!


ETA A couple of questions have come up. One, I don't require anyone to identify as a "feminist parent" to participate in this, nor even especially as a "womanist" or "feminist". Identity is up to you. What I am interested in is stories about trying to parent in line with womanist/feminist values, whether identified that way or not: striving for equal coparenting; raising children without limiting gender roles; opposing instances of sexism or racism or other facets of the kyriarchy in your children's lives. Whether you use the words "womanist" or "feminist" or kyriarchy/patriarchy is sort of irrelevant to me (although if you don't, I must admit I'm a little mystified why you'd be reading here!).

The other is that I do want to hear from those who are not-yet-parents: many of us have been opposing the kyriarchy in the parenting realm since we first started whispering the possibility that children might be on the horizon; or even earlier, if we have particularly obnoxious relations. I'd love to hear those stories. And all of us have been children, and had parents or parent stand-ins: perhaps you have a story about being raised by womanists/feminists, or who would never have identified as such but who nevertheless managed to ignite some important proto-feminist spark in you; or, perhaps your parents were Exhibit A in how not to raise children free of kyriarchy -- those could be instructive stories as well.

And if you really just don't have anything to share right now, sit back and enjoy the reading; but I intend for this to be an ever-evolving primer, so don't be surprised if one day you realize there's a story tapping on your shoulder, waiting to be shared. I'll be here.

Friday, July 10, 2009

Go read Daddy Dialectic

How had I not discovered Daddy Dialectic before? You all must go read it. Now. Especially, especially Jeremy Adam Smith's answers to his own modified version of bluemilk's What does a feminist mother look like? questions. I think I'm in love. Platonically, of course.
At the end of the day, your main task is to survive and support your family and raise happy children; how you respond to the things you can’t control reveals a great deal about your character, some of it good and some of it bad. You might discover (have you noticed my retreat to the safety of the second person?) a capacity for sacrifice and care that you never knew was there.

On the flip side, the dark one, you might also find yourself erupting with petty rage and misdirected resentment, eruptions that frighten you, your child, and your partner. In those scary moments, when our worst emotions take over and drive our ideals and aspirations over a cliff, it is easiest of all for both fathers and mothers to fall back on traditional patterns of dominance and submission.

What does that have to do with feminism? Everything, and nothing.

Pledging allegiance to feminist ideals doesn’t make you a good person or a good parent or a good partner, but it might remind you of the power you have—we always have power, if only over ourselves—and the need to restrain that power or share it with other people. It can also remind fathers of something that I think is crucial: There are alternatives; you do have choices, and your choices matter. You don’t have to be the man your father was; you don't have to be the idiots we see on TV; you can be a new kind of man, and you can help your sons become that kind of man.

That's ten kinds of inspiring, right there. Plus, he knows how to use both colons AND semicolons! What's not to love?

Sunday, July 5, 2009

The problem with "the problem with men"

This is how feminists get a reputation for being humorless: we fail to laugh at jokes or quips that serve the kyriarchy. Like the one I heard yesterday, from D, an otherwise dear friend, spouse of my sister-in-all-but-genetics-and-law.

He and The Man were outside with the Boychick and his cousin, watching them run through the sprinklers (well, encouraging them to, anyway: the Boychick was standing at the edges saying it was "too cold!", while his cousin happily ran around getting soaked). D came in, and my sister asked if they had towels out there for them. D's reply was "Of course not: we're men, we don't think that far ahead!"

He didn't understand why I raised an eyebrow and rolled my eyes, and nor did anyone else in the room.

The Man would have gotten it.

The problem with "the problem with men" type "jokes" is that they serve to support the patriarchy-assigned sexist gender-roles. Although directed at men, and not women, and supposedly OK and "not sexist" by being at the expense of men, and not women, by supporting the limiting and dehumanizing gender roles of the patriarchy, they ultimately hurt women. Not to mention being incredibly insulting to men who have worked hard to get past said limiting stereotypes.

These jokes are especially problematical when about the incompetence of men in the domestic sphere, for by casting men as bumbling idiots in the home, it falls on women to pick up the slack there, keeping us tethered to the domestic sphere, leaving the public sphere, with its associated privilege and power, exclusively the domain of men.

So call me a humorless feminist all you like, but I fail to see why I should laugh at tired old sexist tropes that dehumanize and underestimate the capabilities of my best beloveds, many of whom are male, while ultimately reinforcing my own oppression.

It's not that I don't have a sense of humor, it's that I'd much rather laugh at the patriarchy rather than with it, and that requires thinking for yourself instead of regurgitating the partriarchy's old standbys.

You can do it. I believe in you.

Sunday, June 21, 2009

The Adventures of The Family Lactational, and a Fathers' Day postscript

Okeedoke, I was trying to write an entire actual, y'know, post to go with these comics, but... nah. Later, maybe.

For now, a quick explanation: several years ago, long before the Boychick's conception much less birth or extrauterine life (which is to say, way before I had any first-hand experience with any of this), I came up with the idea for a comic-based handbook for new fathers/non-lactating coparents. It would address the concerns non-lactating parents often express about how to be "involved" when their mamababy is a breastfeeding dyad. I liked the idea so much, I drew up half a dozen examples, starring the superheroes Nursing Mom, Supportive Partner (originally conceived as Super Dad, the rejection of which title and my ambivalence toward SP meriting a post to itself), and Amazing Babe.

They sucked.

But that's OK, because I liked them.

I redrew them, from lined paper (bad for photocopying) to beautiful textured journal paper (er, also bad for photocopying, in hindsight)... and then forgot them.

Well, not exactly forgot: I'd pull them out and look at them and go "hey, this was a neat idea!" every once in a while, and then I'd carefully put the originals back in to the journal with the newer sketches, and put the journal back on the shelf, and not do anything with them.

Consider this a slightly more public, virtual rendition of that tradition.

For your titillation (sorry, I had to), may I present the partial adventures of

The Family Lactational




[Image: Mom in rocker nursing baby, partner bringing plate with drink and apple. Text: Supportive Partner helps keep Nursing Mom hydrated and healthy!]


[Image: Partner wearing baby in sling, on a walk holding hands with mom. Text: Supportive Partner spends lots of time with Nursing Mom and Amazing Babe!]


[Image: Mom nursing babe in sling, partner blocking talking head pointing and "blah blah blah"ing. Text: Supportive Partner guards Nursing Mom from Interfering Ignorami!]


[Image: Partner and Mom in family bed, superhero capes hung up for the night, babe asleep in between them, cat at foot of bed. Text: Supportive Partner spends the night with Nursing Mom and Amazing Babe!]


But what I wanted to say with this, what I really wanted to say and have been having trouble finding the words for, is:

Beloved, when I drew these, I had no idea how far you would blow them out of the water with your fathering, your parenting, your love for our Boychick, your thoughtfulness for me. I had no idea how insulting these caricatures would be to the reality of your deep, rounded, complete parenthood. You had no need for such a guide, and could write your own handbook on how to be a parent (full-stop, not a coparent, not a helping parent, not a mom's-assistant father) as a feminist male in a patriarchal society -- and you should, because the world could and should learn from you: you do nothing miraculous, you never expect accolades for what you do, you expect more from yourself than any one, you just simply, and beautifully, parent our child. It should be nothing out of the ordinary, but it is, and it irritates you that it is, and for that alone, even if I didn't have the hundred thousand other reasons I have, I would love you.

Thank you. Happy Fathers' Day.

Saturday, May 23, 2009

If I Twittered, this would be a Tweet

The Man with no ponytail is hardly The Man at all.

And also: It takes a lot longer than you'd think to cut through a braid. We were surprised, anyway.

(I could go on a feminist rant about how ridiculous it is that women can have almost any length hair -- as long as it's pornulated styled "right", of course -- whereas men, if they want to get employed, simply can't, and that yes, this is sexist in a way that still manages to oppress women, but I'm still too shell-shocked. Thus the tweet-that's-not-a-tweet.)

Friday, March 6, 2009

I'm so happy the Boychick didn't nap

Normally, I hate no-nap days. And I really, really wasn't expecting today to be one, after the 2 mile hike at a local state park (two hours of running around a forest with five other 2-5 year olds), tiring out enough to want up in the sling (! and I almost didn't bother bringing it, it's been so long since he's wanted it) at the very end, then a nice looooong drive home. He didn't quite tucker out in the car as we'd hoped, but came home nicely worn out. And then he voluntarily climbed in to bed and yelled at me to come nap with him. Sweet! I thought. Alas, not so much. The Man comes home at 4:30pm, not calling even though he's home early, because he was sure the Boychick would be asleep. Hah! No such luck.

So why am I so happy? Because right now, the cat and I have the house to ourselves, while The Man and the Boychick and the dog take a walk -- with the Boychick happily riding on his father's back.

Twice in one day! Since the time about four months ago he discovered he could walk in stores, and started insisting on walking everywhere "my own self!", babywearing tanked from something we did 1-12 times a day to something measured in times per month. As in maybe twice a month.

I haven't really written about the cessation of babywearing, although it's something I think about a lot. I smile in melancholy remembrance when I see a sleeping toddler on a back in the library, an alert infant on a hip in a pouch, a tell-tale bump of baby under a stretchy wrap. It actually hurts to think about not having that anymore.

I sometimes put off the hurt by joking "Didn't he get the memo that babywearing leads to over dependence?" I mean, really. Worn every single day for the first 1.5+ years of life, napped exclusively in a lap or carrier or in bed with us (ok, sometimes in the carseat, though only in the car!) until well over a year, never bothered with or needed a stroller or pram, still breastfeeding at 2 with no end in sight... He should be the poster child for all the "ONOZ, AP=clingy spoiled brat that'll never let you put hir down!!" types, right?

I wish. No, really, I do; at least, a part of me does. I miss wearing him, miss that physical closeness, the snuggles, the weight and feel and smell of him. So, maybe my back doesn't miss it, but it was always worth it.

And I miss seeing him and The Man together. Although they still have so many sweet, caring moments together, so many hugs and kisses and snuggles, I miss the pure joy of watching my two favorite people together like that, enjoying the sight of the at once utterly mundane and sublime expression of love that babywearing is.

So even though a late nap (for they returned, the Boychick's eyes oh so heavily lidded, and he nursed to sleep at last in my arms) means a hard night, and a hard tomorrow, it was worth it; the hard night, the closet full of carriers kept just in case, the emergency carrier stashed in the car, the chiropractor visits for wearing 30 squirming pounds: it's all worth it, just to have him close, to see that joy, to be able to say "yes, even though you walk everywhere your own self now, we will still be here to carry you whenever you wish, as long as you need". That, as they say, is priceless.

Friday, February 27, 2009

Say WHAT now?!

In the car, The Man had NPR on to entertain the Boychick whilst waiting for me to bring the pizza (drool) out. We drive off, too busy munching and avoiding downtown traffic to turn off the radio. There's some interview going on about a "lunch lady" (yes, the reporter actually called her a "lunch lady", which should have been my first clue) who took the job just to have something to do while her kids were at work, ended up staying to pay the bills, still here 15 years later, etc, yadda yadda. And then, says the announcer, it's time for the part of her job where she calls up the moms that haven't paid their children's lunch bills*.

The moms.

The moms.

The fucking MOMS.

Excuse me? Excuse fucking me? Is this "lunch lady" living in the district of exclusively single mother (or two mother) households? Do not a one of their students have a father or two hanging around? (Being raised by grandparents or other relatives, perhaps?) No? So what the fuck is with calling the MOMS?

Oh I'm sorry, I seem to have temporarily forgotten that dads' responsibility ends at ejaculation. Wait, no, we need them to pay the bills. Oh this was a bill? Oh right, we just need them to earn the money, but it's up to the mothers to actually make sure the chil'ens are actually fed, because we can't can't expect dads to keep track of little things like the survival of their kids.

Did you perchance notice my ire on this topic? Why, you ask? It's one word. Just one word. What's the big deal?

It's one word that carries with it the world of burden that sexist assumptions about parenting brings. It's one word that says sure there may or may not be men in the picture, but it's certainly not their job to keep track of lunch bills and permission slips and PTA meetings. It's one word that tells women fine, you can get a job if you need to, but heaven forbid you ever share the responsibility of childrearing; no, unto you falls all the hassles of work AND keeping track of everything about your children; only men are allowed off work after 5, you just shift jobs. It's one word that perfectly sums up the double standard of parenting, and it's one word that makes radfem instructions to avoid procreation to avoid perpetuating patriarchy seem to make sense. It's one word that if changed could change the world; it's one word that will probably only be changed when the whole world changes first.

I didn't hear the rest of the piece; my blood was boiling too loudly, and I snapped off the radio in self protection. The story actually had nothing to do with the calls to moms; that was just an aside, a fun little half-second bit to prop up the patriarchy and keep the wimmins in their place. Nothing, really. Just the dimminuization and essentialization of my entire self as woman with child. Just the erasure of my coparent's existence and responsibility. The story moved on, even if I could not, stuck and struck as I was by how much misogyny just one little word could convey.

But hey, the pizza was good.


* For an excellent piece this reminded the tiny part of my brain that hadn't just imploded at the word "moms" of, see Womanist Musings on If you're poor in New Mexico.

Wednesday, February 25, 2009

It's all about the lunches

I have determined that my sanity as a parent and our ability to do the paid-work/care-for-kid split without the usual resulting disconect and resentment is due to lunches. Specifically, that The Man comes home for lunch every day, with rare, difficult exceptions (like today). He also has been known to go in late (er, sometimes really late), take long lunches, and views 5pm as his deadline for leaving the office; staying late means not getting out until 5:15, and happens maybe once a month.

But mostly, it's the lunches. It's the fact that I never have to face 8 or 9 uninterrupted hours by myself with the Boychick. It's the fact that thanks to sleep schedules and naps, the Boychick is usually without his dad around for no more than half his waking day, often less. It's the fact that if dinner needs prep work, we usually do it together at lunch. It's that I do get a lunch break, during which I don't have to deal with another's feces, I can eliminate mine in peace, I can shower with the child on the other side of the door, and I get hugs and adult conversation and a sympathetic ear. It's that sometimes, even, I can have lunch out without having sole responsibility for an always-potentially-cranky toddler. Lunches together make all the difference in the world, which is never so clear as when I find myself alone for lunch with no alternate plans and a roast to start and a loaf to shape and a toddler to save ffrom himself, such as today.

It is part luck that allows us this, and a heap of privilege as well to be sure, but it was also something worked for, chosen, deliberately and determinedly pursued. He guards his lunch jealously, and his evenings rigidly, and refuses travel that by rights his work could demand of him or release him for; and it costs him in networking and advancement and annual review points, but it gains him so much: his family, his lover's sanity, his child's delight. This, far far more than any earning potentially lost, is his responsibility and his right as a father. This is how men can work and sacrifice for the good of their family. Not 80 hour workweeks, but 5 hours of lunches. Just by coming home. Just lunch.

Sunday, January 25, 2009

Are you a good parent? quiz memes, or, the always-good-for-a-chuckle double standards in parenting

I ran across this meme today, which is both funny and incredibly sad and telling about our society (spelling as in original, author unknown):

With all the conflicting parenting advice out there, it’s difficult to know whether you’re a good parent or a bad parent. Take this handy quiz to find out once and for all.
Keep track of your answers on a post-it and total your score at the end. Won’t it be a relief to know whether or not you’re a bad mom?

1. How many hours per week does your child spend in daycare?
A. None. I’m a stay-at-home mom.
B. 40 or more. I work full-time.
C. About 20. I work half-time.

2. Where does your baby sleep
A. In a crib.
B. In my bed.
C. In a co-sleeper.

3. Do you allow your child to watch television?
A. Yes.
B. No.

4. Has your child been vaccinated?
A. Yes.
B. No.

5. How many scheduled activities (storytimes, lessons, classes or playgroups) does your child attend each week?
A. None
B. One or more.




ANSWERS:
1. Day Care.
A: Stay at home mom. You are a bad mom. Your child will be poorly socialized, will lack verbal skills, and will become horribly ill during kindergarten because he or she has never been exposed to germs.
B: Full-time working mom. You are a bad mom. Your child will have an attachment disorder. You are missing the best years of his or her life.
C: Part-time working mom. You are the worst mom. Your child will suffer attachment issues, be poorly socialized, lack verbal skills and will be sick as a dog forever.

2. Sleeping arrangements.
A: Baby sleeps in a crib. You are a bad mom. How could you put your child in a cage to sleep? What’s wrong with you?
B: Baby sleeps in your bed. You are a bad mom. How could you risk rolling onto your child and killing her? What’s wrong with you?
C: Baby sleeps in a co-sleeper. You are a bad mom. How could you waste so much money on that ridiculous co-sleeper? Is it because you read about it in Dr. Sears? You won’t be able to afford to send your child to college.

3. Television
Yes. You are a bad mom. Your child will be violent, mouthy, and unpleasant. He or she will whine for every candy and toy they see the next time you go to the store.
No. You are a bad mom. Your child will lack reading skills and will have nothing to talk with other children about. You are raising a freak.

4. Vaccinations.
A: Yes. You are a bad mom. How could you do that to a helpless baby who cannot consent to being experimented on by the public health system?
B: No. You are a bad mom. How could you do that to a helpless baby whose immune system can’t fight off all those germs?

5. Activities.
A: None. You are a bad mom. Your child will fall behind his or her peers and never catch up if you don’t head over to the children’s theatre production of “Apocalypse Now” this weekend.
B: One or more. You are a bad mom. Your child is overscheduled and will suffer a breakdown due to the stress you’re putting on him or her. You’re probably doing Suzuki, aren’t you?

Brought to you by the folks at Parenting, Mothering, Time, Newsweek, The Today Show, Babycenter.com, Wonder Time, What to Expect When You’re Expecting, Your Pregnancy Week by Week, your pediatrician, your obstetrition, your mother, your mother-in-law, and that awful psycho in the elevator who knows better than you how you should be raising your kids.
(Note that Mothering, the magazine I volunteer for, got a shout out. Note also that when they said "find out if you're a good parent", they meant good mom.)



I was then inspired to write a complementary quiz for fathers:

The good dad/bad dad quiz:

1. How much time per week do you spend in the same room with your child(ren)?
A) 0 -- I work 100 hours per week and travel more than 50%
B) 3-5
C) 24/7 -- I am a stay at home dad

2. Where does your baby sleep?
A) In his own room in a crib
B) In bed with the wife
C) In bed with both of us

3. How many diapers have you changed in your child's life?
A) 0-1, but I made sure the little woman always did it within 4 hours of the kid dropping a load
B) 50-100
C) About once a day when I was home

4. If divorced, do you pay child support?
A) Yes, the minimum amount
B) Yes, when I can afford it after the widescreen tv payments
C) No, I got out of it and use the money to pay for my new, blond, wife and our two new children

5. What do you know about your children?
A) Their names, their friends, their friends' parents, the number for their school or daycare, their dietary likes and dislikes, their vaccine schedule (or all the reasons why they are not vaccinated), the date of their next dentist, pediatrician, and music lesson appointments, and what they really want for their birthday
B) Their names, a couple of their friends' names, the type of instrument they play, and what they want for their birthday
C) Their names... usually


Tally up your answers:

Time with kids:
A) None--you are a good dad, because you work so hard to provide for them.
B) 3-5 hrs/week--you are a good dad, because that's more than your father spent with you
C) SAH--you are a Super Dad!

Sleep arrangements
A) In a crib in their own room--you are a good dad for putting your foot down and insisting the little woman separate from the leech
B) In bed with the wife--you are a good dad for sacrificing your own needs to meet your baby's
C) In bed with both of you--you are a Super Dad!

Diaper changing
A) 0-1--you are a good dad for making sure the little woman does it
B) 50-100--you are a good dad for occasionally giving the little woman a hand
C) Once a day--you are a Super Dad!

Child Support
A) Yes--you are a Super Dad!
B) Yes, sometimes--you are a good dad for pitching in when you can
C) No, due to new family--you are a good dad to the new kids for saving your money for them, and a good dad to the old kids for providing them with siblings!

Kid trivia
A) Know it all--you're lying
B) Know some--you're a good dad, because you know the important stuff
C) Know their names--you're a good dad, because at least you stuck around long enough to hear their names

Brought to you by the patriarchy and every exclamatory comment over how fabulous it is when a dad actually does some small thing to parent his kids.

The Man said too much of it was true, and it was all too frustrating, to be funny.

For the record, I answered bad mom, bad mom, bad mom, bad mom, and bad mom. He answered good dad, Super Dad, Super Dad, n/a, and he's lying.

And there you have it. The double standards for parenting neatly summed up in a pair of moderately funny and entirely depressing memes.

Wednesday, January 14, 2009

"...there's my rabbit, Bob, and his bunny wife Bob"

There was a time I naively assumed that I wouldn't have to worry about sexism in my child's books until at least story books, maybe not even until chapter books. Surely board books, written to start reading to infants so young they only understand the rhythm and rhyme of the words, would be immune!

That naivete lasted until maybe five minutes after the Boychick got his first book.

The truth is even board books, even modern board books, are rife with sexism, heterosexism, racism, and of course, what's a good word, cisgenderism? (One can't even call it transphobia, for it's more the complete lack of acknowledgment that gender isn't always obvious, simple, and binary. Transphobia might be a step up.)

The title for this post came from the usually innocuous Sandra Boynton, in her book titled Fifteen Animals, a recent gift from beloved relatives and fellow Boynton fans. That line alone would be enough to make my head explode (the male bob is referred to as a rabbit, the female with the diminutive bunny; she is of course a "wife", not an independent woman rabbit nor even an interdependent but nonsexist "spouse"; and he possesses her as his wife), but it's only one of the offensive examples on the Boychick's library -- which itself has been chosen largely by us to be as nonsexist as possible.

A recent disappointment was Papa, Papa. I had heard good things about Mama, Mama from the AP community (mentions of nursing and cosleeping, also things lacking in children's books in general) -- and apart from one weird and one schmaltzy page it isn't too bad -- and since I try never to buy a mother-centric book without getting a corresponding father-centric book, we ordered Papa, Papa as well, with moderately high hopes.

Papa Papa, it turns out, is basically one long exploration of fathering stereotypes. Father as home builder, wise and worshiped, leader, teacher of howling (in a patriarchal context, this can stand for teacher of how to be outspoken, assertive, and possessive; how to trumpet aggression), and promoter of (and proud of) independence are some of the highlights. The "best" pages are the first and last, where Papa teaches little ones to sing, and where the narrator feels "warm and safe" with Papa (in the context of playing "peekaboo"), but nowhere is there an image of father-as-nurturer, or father-as-caretaker (as in Mama, Mama, which features Mama cleaning and feeding the narrator). The Man's take on it is the Mama, Mama book is about the mother/child as a unit, with mother as safe base, and exploring the world around WITH each other, whereas in Papa, Papa, there is separation between the father and child, with the father teaching and giving TO the narrator.

Another example is Sam Loves Kisses (bought for the Boychick by well-meaning friends because of the lovely last page featuring a snuggly family bed), in which the "mommy" gets "a sweet kiss" and is depicted (in a dress, though devoid of feminine curves) as busy in the kitchen, and the "daddy" (bepantsed, of course) gets "an airplane kiss", and plays with Sam to distract him so the mother can cook -- because, of course, the man couldn't take a turn cooking, nor could he distract the child with nurturing or cuddles. We'll not even get in to the cars covering Sam's bedspread.

I could go on: there's City Babies, in which there are mother animals but no fathers (I will allow that the non-human animal kingdom is factually sex-biased in parenting, but the authors could have used examples from the avian world -- there were three bird pages in there already); in Daddy Cuddles, an otherwise excellent book, the human father "cuddles" his baby on his back, demonstrating once again that men can be playful (piggy back) but not nurturing (in arms); of the several books that depict one parent and a child, only one has a father instead of a mother (the hippopotamus of Sandra Boynton's The Bellybutton Book).

So we are confronted with what to do. We have already chosen "the best of the bunch", at least of what we can find in stores around here, and if we wanted more books with fewer -isms and more diversity, we'd have to special order all of them (I actually tried to order And Tango Makes Three for the Boychick for Yule, but was informed it was unavailable in board book at this time), and I wouldn't even know where to look. We don't wish to censor books, but neither do we want to immerse him at so young an age (or ever!) in a sexist, heterosexist mindset, when his opinion on the world is just being formed.

For many of our books, we have settled on alternate readings that offend us less (we switch who gets which type of kisses and who is in the kitchen in Sam Loves Kisses, and say "...there's my rabbit, Bob, and her bunny partner Bob"). But when others come to read to him, they read it the "straight" (pun intended, of course) way. Will he look at others funny (or correct them!) when they read it "wrong? ...and would that be "bad"? If we don't read exactly what is on the page, will we damage or delay his reading, if he's still using these books in a few years when he's at that stage? If we cross out the irritating bits and write in our versions, are we teaching him censorship and book defacement are OK? Or would we be merely recording and commemorating our family's unique stories? How do we navigate these waters?

How do you?

Saturday, January 10, 2009

Man as babywearer (or, this site needs pictures)

All blogs need photos. It seems we are such a visual animal that a blog without photos is like cocoa without sugar and cream: what's the point? And, I've been meaning to write about babywearing, and how attachment parenting really can be feminist, especially with a babywearing father. So here they are, my (presumably) straight white males, defying the stereotypes and snuggling close (and yes, he does all the wrapping himself, and indeed, taught me how).










Of course, one of the great things about men babywearing is it models nurturing behavior for the next generation. (That's BunBun on the Boychick's back, in a much-too-large Sutemi Pack wrapped around him two or three times.)








When attachment parenting is not just attachment mothering, everyone benefits: the mother gets to share the parenting in a way still meeting the child's needs (though I did all of the feeding of the Boychick for the first 7 months, The Man did all the babywearing while he was on paternity leave, and almost all of it when he was home after that, making a point to wear him especially in the evenings to give me "me" time, and himself baby time), the father or partner gets the joys of having a baby snuggled in close (and it is a joy!), and the child gets to build loving relationships with all parents. Add to that the nurturing of male children, who are traditionally held apart and told to suck it up, and I can only see how attachment parenting, and especially babywearing, is helping us raise the next generation nonsexistly.



(I apologize for the poor quality photos: I can only beg forgiveness as a nonskilled photographer, with the added excuse that our camera was dying when these pictures were taken; it has since gone on to silicon heaven, and we miss it dearly.)