Monday, August 10, 2009

The misogyny of denying milk-making moms mental-health medication

OK, I hadn't meant to get so behind in updating this site. I'm not going to do this much longer, so:

Update your feeds and bookmarks! New site at www.RaisingMyBoychick.com!

Really, it's way better.


In honor of World Breastfeeding Week (even if it is almost over), I offer a post about breastfeeding, blame-the-kyriarchy style.

Perhaps you've been lucky enough to have missed this scenario, but I, at the intersection of those with lactating breasts and those with mental illness, have seen it far too often: a woman goes to her psychiatrist, generalist, family doctor, nurse practitioner, or psych nurse, for help with, oh, depression (postpartum or otherwise), or anxiety, or mood disorder, or sleep problem. Being a careful parent and a conscientious patient, she discloses that she is breastfeeding her child, so that she and her health care practitioner can find the healthiest, most appropriate medications for her (should they mutually decide medications are necessary).

This is when, in a sane society, her physician or nurse would nod, draw on hir vast knowledge of and experience with medications appropriate for breastfeeding, and say "No problem, that only rules out a very few classes of drugs, there are lots of things we can try still." Or, barring that, would reach for the copy of Hale's zie keeps handy in hir office, or would call one of the many breastfeeding-knowledgeable pharmacists zie keeps on file as references. The woman and the health care provider she employs would then work together to pick a medication most appropriate for her particular situation.

That is not what usually happens. Too often (ever would be too often), the physician, upon hearing said disclosure, automatically replies "I don't want to give you anything until you wean/terminate breastfeeding/stop doing that."

There is so much wrong with this situation, I hardly know where to start.

Do I start with the ignorance? How so very rarely is weaning actually necessary, in any situation, and even less often to treat most mental health issues? How the ignorance of a basic facet of women's health is inherently misogynistic: how women are not a "special group", lactation is not a "special case", and we shouldn't have to go to "specialists" to find a physician knowledgeable of the basics of care when we are engaged in a normal human biological function? To be ignorant of these things is inexcusable, and reflective of both systemic and individual misogyny, whether recognized or not.

Or do I start with the authoritarianism? With the assumption that the physician knows better -- knows what they're talking about for that matter! --, that what they "want" matters one whit in the face of a client coming to them for treatment of a specific issue, that they have the right to place ultimatums on the conditions under which their clients receive treatment? Paternalistic authoritarianism, whether coming from a man or a woman, dictating or denying the course of a woman's treatment and what she can/'t do with her body, is always misogynistic.

Or do I simply rail against how *&^%ed up, how immoral and wrong-headed it is? How in fact damaging to a woman's mental well-being it is to be denied her normal biological entwinement with her young, to be told she must chose between her own health and the health of her child? Do I describe the panic that ensues, the flight-or-fight reaction as her body is flooded with adrenaline, as she realizes the person across from her is not her ally but her enemy, her judge, the antagonistic gatekeeper blocking her from that which might make her well? Do I justifiably liken it to throwing gasoline on an already smoldering -- or raging -- firestorm of imbalanced brain chemicals?

I do think that we ought be cautious in what we expose our young to, especially when it has the potential to affect brain development, and I am the first in line to question the pervasive use of psychotropics, the first to encourage that other avenues of health and stability and sanity be pursued first, or at least simultaneously. I am the first in line to criticize the culture of "problem? pop a pill!", the first to point out the downsides of many mental health medications -- my own experiences with mood stabilizers and anti-depressants are far from flawless, and what finally made me sane was not the prescription I was handed first.

And I am jumping the line to be the first and loudest to proclaim how so many postpartum and parental mental health problems are the kyriarchy's damn fault in the first place: how the isolation, the lack of tangible support, the dearth of family-friendly work options, the pitiful state of parental leave (in the USA at least), the antagonism toward breastfeeding in public, the burden of parenting placed solely on the "nuclear family" -- and too often primarily if not exclusively on the woman within that unnatural unit --, all combine to create situations in which NOT experiencing postpartum mental health problems is more surprising than having them.

But this? This "I don't want to give you anything until you wean"? That's not a careful critique of the pharmacological industry, that's not an intersectionalist examination of the role kyriarchy plays in the creation of women's mental health issues, and it's not a sober weighing of the balance of "greatest goods" when faced with exposing a child to an ill mother or minute quantities of probably-safe substances. No, that's nothing more than an ignorant, authoritarian, fucked up, misogynistic ultimatum.

Breastfeeding is a feminist issue. This post isn't about telling women what they should/n't do, it isn't about being a "breastfeeding zealot", and it isn't even a defense of medication during lactation (there are benefits and risks, and each woman -- in consultation with knowledgeable health care providers -- must weigh them for herself). It's about saying that the way we talk about breastfeeding, drugs, and mental health needs to change. It's about saying that this kind of comment is downright dangerous, because it discourages women from breastfeeding, it discourages women from getting help for their illnesses, and it supports the kyriarchy through misogyny -- and thus damages all women, lactating or not.

I am lucky that I haven't needed to go on medication during pregnancy, or while the Boychick is nursing. I have done many things, worked very hard, to achieve this, but I also know that I am, at the end, simply lucky. Maybe you were too. Or maybe you were another kind of lucky, and got a health care worker who helped you rather than hindered you. But too many women are slapped with this, too many women are lied too, too many women don't have the knowledge or the spoons to counter this misogyny. And as long as any woman encounters this attitude, we all have a need -- and a duty -- to counter it.

Friday, August 7, 2009

WFPP Guest Post: The Lessons of Mothering

So, you'd have had this post 36 hours ago if you updated your feed, and if you head over to Raising My Boychick now you can comment on this AND read the newest post! What are you waiting for?

This entry for the Womanist/Feminist Parenting Primer comes from Rachel of Rachel's Ramblings, one of my earliest regular commenters and frequent source of inspiration for me.

In this piece, she starts with an anecdote of rethinking one of the patriarchy's lies, catching it just before it escapes her mouth into the innocent ears of her children. She then discusses the lessons she learns from her children, and the lessons she hopes to pass on -- and ultimately realizes that that which she wants her children to know is already in them, and the key is to stop the kyriarchy from replacing those joyful truths with its restrictive falsehoods.

The Lessons of Mothering


My children are usually asleep when I get ready for work, but sometimes their cheerful morning selves welcome the sunshine and they join me. One morning my three-year old son was watching me put on makeup and asked, "What's that?"

"Eyeliner."

"What's it do?"

I heard the answer in my head: "It makes me beautiful."

But I said aloud after stumbling around, "It outlines my beautiful eyes so people can see them. Aren't I beautiful?"

Who knew that mothering would open the doors of self development? I thought I was raising children, but I continually find that I am growing too. I become wiser and more mature as I realize and process the internal beliefs I have about myself, about boys, about girls and about marriage. I enter this growth opportunity willingly because I want to pass only the best to my children.

Who wants their child to feel limited and discouraged?
Who wants their child to discriminate, hate or limit others?
Who wants their child to set aside their gifts and do only what their culture or society demands?
Who wants their child to believe that something outside themselves will make them beautiful, smart, sexy and strong?
Who wants their child to feel ugly, stupid or worthless?

I don't.

So when I'm at my best (who am I fooling, I'm not perfect), I try to reinforce messages such as:

  • We are beautiful because we are people. All of us.

  • Everyone can play with HotWheels, even sisters. Same goes for stuffed animals and babies, even brothers.

  • Healthy food is good for us. Sugar should be eaten in small quantities.

  • Explore the world!

  • We wear what's comfortable and what we want. Some events do require a costume and then we dress accordingly, like weddings, funerals and corporate workplaces. At church, God likes jeans and ballcaps cuz he's not into fakers.

  • We don't hit.

  • We can dance ANYWHERE!

  • Our bodies are strong.

  • Everyone in a family nurtures in their own way.


What’s interesting about these messages is that if you look closely, children already know many of them. They’re born knowing they are strong, healthy and beautiful. My 16-month old daughter trusts her body and instincts. I’m not teaching new lessons, just reminding all of us what we already know.

Rachel writes about the parenting journey at Rachel's Ramblings. At seven, she wore pajamas with a "Women's Lib" patch and couldn't figure out why women needed to be liberated. Now, with a corporate job and two young children, Rachel is learning the value of shared parenting and equal opportunity.

Wednesday, August 5, 2009

"How else would you have us say it?"

What are you doing reading this here? You could have read it 18 hours earlier if you were updated to the new feed! Remember, if you want to post a comment, it needs to be over at www.raisingmyboychick.com; I'll keep updating you here for a while longer, but you really should switch now!

*************************************************

Reader Gayle left a fabulously intelligent question on the post The personal and the political:

I have seen debates on the subjects you mention where one side mentions that what the other side has said hurts them/shames them/makes them feel inadequate. To which the other side replies, “How else would you have us say it?” What are you thoughts on that power shifting? Or is some hurt inevitable, even if it is unintended, especially in these subjects which are so emotionally charged to begin with?

I was so inspired my response comment turned into a post all its own:

I think you put your finger on it with the phrase "power shifting". When that question is asked by a group with power (privilege) to a group without/with lesser power (privilege), I think it's extremely problematical. I see that dynamic a whole lot more in discussions on race, sexuality, and so on: less often, I think, in parenting, where we are ALL very low on the power structure (in the eyes of kyriarchy; it'll put us on a pedestal, sure, when it's not trampling all over us, but let us have real power? no way!).

The reason it is problematical within certain power dynamics (say if I, as a white cis woman, were to say that to Monica Roberts, a black trans woman, should she have reason to call me on my language) is because it shifts the responsibility -- the work, the onus -- from the oppressors to the oppressed. It says "I don't need to do any learning, I'm going to make you figure this out, I'm going to make you teach me, I'm going to make you justify your pain, make you be responsible for avoiding your own hurt." It also ignores that odds are excellent there already is an abundance of answers to that very question from the oppressed group, and asking it betrays that one is unwilling to do even a cursory examination of the existing thoughts on the topic; that is, that one is ignorant of and unwilling to do the (incredibly simple!) work of finding and listening to the voices of those without power.

That, obviously, is not good. That power shifting, in fact, is one of the prime ways that kyriarchy -- acting through those with privilege against those without -- protects itself.

However, in the context of parenting, and the in-fighting of "the mommy wars" and discussions about parenting practices, the power dynamic is, generally, quite different. While someone who uses formula has huge, moneyed, powerful, corporate, industrial aspects of the kyriarchy backing up hir "choice", on an individual level a formula feeder and a breastfeeder are both on the same bottom rung of the kyriarchy (all else being equal; which, granted, they rarely are). So in that context, asking "how would you have us say it?" can be an act of compassionate bridge-making; but, it requires both being willing to humble oneself and really, truly being willing to listen to and hear the answer.

To further complicate things, there is a significant corporate/kyriarchal interest in many of these topics: there is huge money in undermining breastfeeding, in selling plastic parent-substitutes, in medicalizing birth, et cetera and so on, in addition to the less financial but no less real and powerful kyriarchal forces wishing to convince us that our bodies are broken, that interdependence is wrong, that we are incapable of knowing how to raise our children without the advice of patronizing, patriarchal "experts". So when I say "formula is inferior" -- because it is, because human milk is the biological norm, the standard, and formula simply fails to measure up -- I am simultaneously speaking truth to power, and potentially hurting my sister oppressed mothers who for whatever reason use(d) formula. So, if I change my language, soften it, sacrifice strength and accuracy for kindness and palatability, am I being compassionate to my beloved sisters? Or am I acceding to the pressures of the powerful, greedy, immoral formula industry?

Unfortunately, I think the answer is "yes". We are left facing a choice; compassion for our sisters? Or effecting change by standing up to the kyriarchy? I don't think there is any single right answer, but the best path at any given time is going to depend on the specific circumstances.

When speaking with a woman who could not or did not breastfeed, perhaps that is not the best time for using our most powerful lactivist language; instead then we might talk about how fortunate we are that formula is adequate to sustain life now, or perhaps even bemoan the lack of support women have for establishing and sustaining breastfeeding, or discuss the local milk bank or milk share program we're working to get started. But when writing material directed at formula companies, at women who are facing the "choice" of feeding method, when we are discussing as lactivists the best way to get our message across, when we, as I try to do on this blog, are discussing the larger culture and the kyriarchal influences on our individual lives: then, I think that language is appropriate and valuable.

What about those individuals who encounter it, even in those contexts, and are still hurt? At some point, I think there is a level of individual responsibility that must be taken (remembering that we are discussing a situation among those with roughly equal power and privilege -- or lack thereof); at some point, one has to be able to step back and avoid taking, as well as giving, offense unnecessarily.

Sometimes language makes us uncomfortable; sometimes critiques of kyriarchy make us squirm. My responsibility as a woman both with and without privilege is to make sure I'm keeping my side of the street clean: is my language accurate? Is it chosen wisely? Is this the right time and place to say it? Is there a way to say this that will still speak truth while hurting my sister mothers less? Am I speaking from a place grounded in justice? Am I directing my anger at institutions, not individuals? If I am sure my side is clean, as it were, I am free to offer compassion to those who are wounded by my words, without choosing to change them. I am responsible for me, including, yes, how and when I present my thoughts, but I cannot be responsible for what another does with them when she receives them.

Is hurt inevitable? Probably. We live in a society that attacks us women who parent at every turn, when it is not shoving us up on inhuman pedestals and demanding inhuman feats of perfection. We live in a society that is constantly hurting us, telling us we are wrong, telling us we are bad, telling us we are broken, and which is remarkably good at making us tell each other and ourselves that. We are highly sensitive to any perceived criticism, and not without good reason. Of course we are likely to encounter a factual statement like "formula is inferior" or "crying-it-out is not good" and internalize it as "I am a bad mother, I am hurting my child". And of course we're likely to lash out when we do.

But I do not believe this is a reason to give up our ideals or our goals or our activism. We can only watch our own words, take responsibility for what is ours to control, and offer compassion and understanding to those who are hurting. To avoid speaking truth to avoid ever causing any pain would be allowing the kyriarchy to control us even more. The world is better served when we can work to change the institutions belittling and constricting and attacking us -- including by using words that may be challenging, no matter how carefully they are chosen.


******************************

Hey, you're missing the conversation that's happening over at the new site! Update your feed, subscribe by email, or head over there now.

Sunday, August 2, 2009

Pardon the dust!

What are you doing reading this over here? Go check out the new site! Soon I'll stop updating this site altogether, so switch your feed now!

What on earth possessed me to believe I could get this all done in one weekend? Although The Man has been a huge help, both with working on the non-content parts of setting up the new digs, and with distracting The Boychick (lots!) so I could get work done, there was simply no way we could get everything done in such a short period of time. So, there's lots of dust, lots still left to do, lots of little things to fix (and a couple big things)...

But! Here we are. Sure, it's got some some police tape around the edges, there's a fine sheen of dust you're really hoping is lead-free covering everything, and a few of the doors are mysteriously stuck shut, but still: a new home. I hope you all enjoy it as much as I.

Let's go on a brief tour, shall we?

To your left, we have new categories (with a collapsing menu! you don't want to hear how hard that was to get to work), and to your right, a spiffy (giant!) tag cloud, and a popular post feature that appears to be on the fritz. If you'll look straight up, you'll see some of the most exciting features of these new digs: pages! Blog is here, the plain ol' blog homepage; About RMB is self explanatory, I think, as is the Comment Policy (please be aware that the links on the About page still redirect to the old site, and you will have to come back here to find the post to comment; this should be remedied soon. also please note that the comment policy should really be called more of an alpha than a beta; it most definitely should still be considered under construction, although I think you can see the outline of its final shape at the moment).

Ahem. Moving along.

Also up there in the pretty new pages menu, you can see the new home of the Womanist/Feminist Parenting Primer! Along with an easy way to find the Primer posts, you can also find out more about it, as well as guidelines and solicitations for sumissions.

Finally, and perhaps most excitingly, I am with this move now the proud owner of a Glossary! The Glossary, like the Primer and the blog itself, should definitely be considered an ongoing work in progress; there are several terms already defined, and place holders for several coming soon (really!). The glossary itself is still in need of some work to make its navigation optimally convenient; however, I have collected here for your reading pleasure the terms that already have entries (look, content!):

Entries range from fairly short and straightforward to full length treatises on the topic. Please do read the disclaimer and the glossary comment policy as well.

So there you have it; tour complete. Take a look around, poke at the appliances, test the windows, and let me know what you think.

(Be sure to update your feed readers! You also have the option now of subscribing by email, or subscribing to comments. Neato!)

Thursday, July 30, 2009

Ignore the woman behind the curtain!

I really thought I would be able to get more content up before the site switch, but I've been so taken up by working on the new blog design that I haven't had time to, y'know, blog.

So here's how it's going to happen: some time in the next couple days, I'm going to shut down comments on this site. Sometime after that -- and we'll try for the same day but it might be a day or two later -- the new site will be revealed (it's currently locked as we tinker), and all comment traffic will be directed there: I'll post here to let y'all know when that happens, and to remind you to switch feeds!

For those who procrastinate (like, um, yours truly), I'll keep posting new blog content here as well (with comments closed!), but I'll keep nagging you to switch to the new site, where all the action will be happening. (Glossary! All new About WFPP! And more!) After a few weeks of that, I'll cease posting to this site at all, and it will wither and fade in the shadow of the new, brighter, better than ever www.RaisingMyBoychick.com

Sound good?

Good, me too.

For now, in lieu of content, I offer you links, teasers, and a request. First, links:
Second, teasers:
  • A reader and Twitter follower asked me to write a post on my thoughts and experiences with Elimination Communication, so I've been thinking about how to write such a piece as a parent who is out the other end (pun not intended!), and has no desire to proselytize or piss diapering parents off, but who really, truly thinks EC rocks. Can I manage it?

  • New reader Maria wants to know when and how I knew I was ready to have kids, in terms of my mental illness. I don't think I've written much about that story here, and I'll give it a try.

  • I have what I thought was three posts but realized is one even better post brewing on the topic of needs: in women (especially in labor), in babies, and in my own life. What is a need, anyway? I don't know if I can answer that question, but I have some interesting thoughts on it at least.

  • Finally, I really will write that post on babies and big boys I've been thinking about for a while, as the Boychick races from toddlerhood to what lays beyond, becoming ever more both capable and needy.
Any of that wet your metaphorical whistle?

Last, I come back to the new blog: I'm creating a glossary (the ability to do which is one of the big reasons I decided switching would be worth the hassle!), and have the prime suspects of cis, kyriarchy, and PIV, but I want to know: what words and terms and phrases do I use that have made you go "huh?" What do you want to see defined, as clearly and concisely as I am (not) able to?

And are there any other questions you'd like to take this opportunity to ask me? Anything you think I should address in an About Me or About Raising My Boychick that you haven't seen answered yet? What would you want answered in a FAQ about this blog?

You can leave your thoughts in the comments, or email me at arwyn at raisingmyboychick dot com (new address! old one still works, but look! new! sparkly!).

Wednesday, July 29, 2009

WFPP Guest Post: Talking to Strangers

This entry to the Womanist/Feminist Parenting Primer comes from Amber Strocel, who blogs about parenting, life with kids, and maternity leave at Strocel.com.

As the title implies, this post is about Amber's struggle with first encouraging and then finding herself afraid of her daughter "talking to strangers". She discusses her own socialization to both fear and avoid offending strangers, and neatly elucidates both how and why teaching "stranger danger" is not only ineffective but potentially dangerous.

Although she doesn't explicitly relate her desire for "my daughter to feel confident, to be able to trust herself instead of being nice at all costs" to feminism, her reasonings and decisions are emphatically founded in womanist/feminist ideology. The patriarchy would have us -- all of us, but especially women, children, and most especially girls -- give up our own autonomy and healthy interdependence in favor of unfounded fear and a frightening disregard for our own feelings. Raising a child
, then, to trust herself, and to trust those she feels comfortable with, is revolutionary.

Talking to Strangers

My 4-year-old Hannah is very friendly. At the park she strolls right up to people she's never met and announces, "My name is Hannah!" She tells me, "I say my name and people want to be my friend." It makes no difference to her if they're children or adults, if they respond to her advances or even if they speak English. She will chatter away as long as someone occasionally smiles and nods.

Until about a year ago Hannah was too shy to approach strangers. She didn't have the necessary social or verbal skills to pull off an introduction. I could see her watching kids play and I could tell she wanted to join in but didn't know how. Sometimes I would help her, and sometimes she preferred to just observe. I really wanted for her to find a way to bridge the social gap, since she seemed to really want to.

When Hannah became confident enough to approach people on her own I was happy for her. Most people were happy to listen to my boisterous preschooler chatter away incessantly. And she really chattered, spewing forth all sorts of information in rapid fire fashion. Where she lives. How I let her eat dry cereal off the floor. The names of all her friends at school. That time she accidentally called 9-1-1 and I was mad. It occurs to me I might not always be portrayed in the most flattering light in these little expositions, on closer examination.

And still more climbing

Listening to Hannah talk and talk and talk some part of my brain screamed Danger! After all, kids aren't supposed to talk to strangers. Especially not adult strangers. I certainly wasn't supposed to when I was a kid, anyway. When I was young we were warned about stranger danger and admonished not to accept rides or candy from people we didn't know. As I watched my daughter chat people up on the playground or at the grocery store I wondered if I should let her do this.

The thing is I don't believe admonitions about avoiding strangers are all that effective. Anyone who's ever watched a newsmagazine has seen 7-year-olds get into some guy's van to help him find a lost puppy. Their mothers swore up and down that their kids would know better, and yet they didn't. I remember having a preconceived notion of what a 'stranger' looked like as a kid myself - in my mind a stranger looked sort of like the Hamburglar. I don't think that most kids think that someone who seems nice can be a stranger.

Plus the whole message is really very contradictory. I talk to strangers all the time. My kids see me talk to strangers. At the grocery store or the library or sometimes even the sidewalk I will share words with people I've never seen before and will probably never see again. I even gave birth in front of people I didn't know because my daughter was premature and there was a whole team on hand. I suspect that a lot of talk about stranger danger is confusing and pointless.

Hannah drawing chalk art at the playground

On the other hand I don't want to send my daughter out into the world unequipped. The unfortunate truth is that not everyone has good intentions. While stranger abduction is rare, the statistics about sexual abuse are alarming. According to my local abuse prevention authority 35% of girls in grades 7-12 have experienced sexual abuse. I feel I need to arm my daughter in some way so that she's not a sitting duck.

But how? I thought about my own childhood and what worked (or mostly didn't) for me. Like most girls I was raised to be 'nice'. I wasn't supposed to talk to strangers, but I also wasn't supposed to be rude to them under any circumstances. At no point were my own feelings or instincts considered. I have found myself sitting beside people who made me feel uncomfortable, responding as they engaged me in conversation. As much as I wanted to get up and move I didn't, I ignored the voice in my head because it might have offended someone.

When Hannah talks to strangers she is using her own instincts. As a 4-year-old girl she naturally gravitates towards other children of around the same age. She also likes to talk to other parents, especially if they are playing with their own children. Out in public she talks to the people she sees me talking to - the cashier at the grocery store or the librarian. Although she doesn't verbalize it, she has an idea of who she is comfortable with and who she isn't.

Hannah and the hens

In fact, Hannah is doing exactly what she should do. She is seeking out certain people. She is honing her social skills by interacting with them. She is learning who she can trust and who she can't trust. And she studiously avoids people that she isn't comfortable with. Since she is only 4 of course I am always nearby, in eyeshot and earshot, ready to assist her if she needs it. But so far she really hasn't.

I want my daughter to feel confident, to be able to trust herself instead of being nice at all costs. I want her to learn how to seek out the help of others as required, in a way that makes her feel safe. I don't want her to sit passively beside someone who makes her uncomfortable because she doesn't trust her own intuition. And I want her to engage with others in positive and meaningful ways. I believe that allowing her to talk to strangers on her own terms is critical to that process. Not forcing her, not coercing her, not dictating that she hug someone she doesn't want to hug. But also not intervening or preventing if there's no immediate danger.

The world isn't always a safe or welcoming place. For better or worse, though, our children will live in it. They need to know how to navigate it. And I have come to believe that talking to strangers is one of the best ways to learn.


Amber Strocel blogs about parenting, life with kids and maternity leave at Strocel.com. She is 33 years old and is still afraid to talk to strangers but thanks to her daughter she's finally learning how.

Monday, July 27, 2009

Presumably straight, presumably male even... but definitely white

I first wrote this four months ago; I'm not really sure why I didn't publish it then. I looked at it again recently, thinking it was much more draft-y and much less coherent than it turned out to be, discovered it wasn't that bad, dusted it off, and here it is.

First, let me say that I've been praying that I can write out these thoughts in a coherent way without tripping up on my privilege and unrecognized prejudices too damned bad. Second, let me say that I know I'm just not gonna get it all right, and I apologize in advance, and request gentle corrections so that I can learn and do better next time.

After my post about why I call the Boychick "presumably-straight", I started thinking, again, about why it is we have transgender and transsexual persons, but not transracial (the questionable case of Michael Jackson, may he finally be at peace, aside). What is it about race and gender that makes being trans one but not trans the other make sense? The most bigoted of "radfems" and the ignorant masses notwithstanding, it is not possible to be rational and be exposed to the stories and lives of trans persons and still claim that they are "really" the gender into which they were assigned at birth. Any rational society would recognize that, would allow for graceful transitions, would legally protect these (and all) persons against discrimination, would provide what medical services they require, would allow appropriate and easy alteration of legal documents, would laugh the "trans-panic defense" out of the court, etc., etc. (And any not-totally-jacked society would get the damn pronouns right!)

And yet, the idea of someone like the Boychick being "transracial", that is, born into one race ("white") and deciding/discovering that he's "really" another race (say, "black") is ridiculous. It's nonsensical. And more than that, it simply doesn't happen. The closest to it is people trying to pass to access the privilege denied to them by racist societies. We are not a rational society when it comes to race, so we cannot claim that it is the fair and equitable way race is dealt with (hah!) that prevents "pressure" from "creating" "transracial" persons; therefore, neither can we say that the real pressures present in a patriarchy are "creating" transgender/transsexual persons -- surely if it were just self-hatred caused by living under a kyriarchy that devalues the body one lives in, we would see far more people of color clamouring for such an identity.

So what makes the difference? Gender is based on sex, which has been a part of our genetics since probably the first multicellular organism. From way, way, way back in our evolutionary history, we instinctively know that there are more or less two types of individuals, and we generally expect to identify as one or the other. Because we are complicated animals, and because of the power of our social memes, gender is an amazingly complex construction, based in genetics and environment and biology and society and psychology and who knows what else -- but there is, inherent in us, some expectation of being gendered, whether that's male or female or something more complex. There is nothing in us that pops us out of the womb wanting pink or blue, nail polish or RC trucks; this is the societal construction of the expression and performance of gender. But if the Boychick lived in a society that gendered yellow teeth female, he might be one of those born with penises who grow up dreaming of dental dye; not because desire for yellow teeth is inborn (which is no more ridiculous an idea than a desire for pink toenails being inborn), but because their internal gender draws them to those things their society genders female, regardless of their external sex.

Race, however, is an entirely social construction, an entirely modern -- in the evolutionary scale -- idea. There is nothing in us that expects to be "race-ed"; genes dictate that the Boychick's skin is less pigmented than others, his eyes have more creases, his nose is more pointed, but there is no gene, or chromosome combination, for defining him as "racially White", or any one else as "Black" or "Asian" or "Aboriginal". What there are, instead, are memes; for this is not to try to argue a colorblind (aka racist, however well intended) ideology: race is entirely real, because we believe it to be so, based only on minute skin tone and facial differences, and we are creatures with amazingly powerful intellects and social memes. (Case in point: there may be no culture that escapes from the ills of racism, but by no means is racial identity universal; what we call "Black" in the US may be "morena or mulata" in Brazil.)

The irony, then, if that is the right word, is that the reason he is only presumably male is because masculinity, male-ness, is something at least partially inborn; the reason he can never be anything but white is because whiteness is entirely socially constructed. The one that is more "real" is the one that an individual may "change"; the one that is more "artificial" is immutable by the individual.

So this is the Boychick I am raising: presumably straight, presumably male, but definitely white.

Saturday, July 25, 2009

Changes they are a-comin' Part Deux!

Even more changes are a-comin' in the life of those of us raising the Boychick: the very day after I completed my five-week afternoon course, The Man got a job offer. Not just any job, but a practically perfect job, downtown (which means pretty close, and accessible via bus), for significantly higher pay.

[Pauses for celebratory exclamations]

Only thing is, he needs (low-level) security clearance, so if you know us, and strange scary official looking folk from the gov'ment come to the door asking about him, pretend remember we're really good people with nothing to hide, OK?

So! He doesn't have a start date yet, and because of the security stuff and other bureaucracy it'll likely be at least a couple weeks. Which is good, because I'm now facing the loss of my coparent to full time out of the house employment, and it's enough to make me collapse in a quivering crying lump. In the last 2.5 months, the Boychick has gotten used to having his dad around, we've gotten quite used to sharing parenting throughout the day, and the Boychick is now 2.5 months even more energetic. I'm really not sure how I'm going to manage; we'll likely all go through a grieving period, and somehow, I doubt even the lack of worries over paying the bills will make up for it. Still, once again, all will be well.

This does give us a deadline and more incentive to get the new blog website all set up: our plan now is to make the switch a week from today. Eek! When we do get it all switched over, I'll close comments on this site: I will, however, keep posting new threads here (along with a reminder to switch feeds!) for a while, say, a month? And by then, dear readers, I hope you'll all have joined me at our new, prettier, more functional home, home on the web, where The Man and the Boychickie play!

Thursday, July 23, 2009

WFPP Guest Post: Running as Feminist Pursuit

Today's entry to the Womanist/Feminist Parenting Primer comes from a dear friend and occasional reader (if not regular commenter, *ahem*), Courtney Wilder, PhD.

This is a long entry, but well worth it. In it, Courtney first explores the ways that running serves to reify patriarchal gender norms. She then places it in an historically misogynistic context in which women were actively discouraged and often outright barred from and drummed out of athletics and physical pursuits. She ultimately reveals how it is an "ultra-feminist" activity and helps teach her children progressive, feminist values, by showing that women can be strong, by modeling bodily autonomy, and by demonstrating that physical activity is well worth pursuing regardless of whether one meets the patriarchy's sexist standards.

Running as Feminist Pursuit

A couple of years ago, I took up running. It did not feel, at the time, like an activity with particular feminist (or un-feminist) overtones; it did not feel subversive, or especially important to my parenting. It felt like a way to get out of the house, like a way to do something other than slowly go nuts writing the last few chapters of my doctoral dissertation, like a way to breathe some fresh air while my kids were in preschool and first grade, respectively. It was cheaper than the gym, more soothing than using an exercise bike in front of the TV, and I got to know the streets of my neighborhood from a perspective that was different from the ones afforded me by car or bicycle transportation.

Of course, nothing – especially nothing involving women and their bodies – can remain neutral for very long. And nothing, I found, that a mother chooses to engage in can fail to impact her children in some way. I started to run more, and I started to read about running, and I entered longer and longer road races (aiming for a marathon this fall!), and slowly I found my perspective shifting. Running is subversive, it can be ultra-feminist, and my running teaches my children a wealth of things about women, and bodies, and how to be healthy, and what so-called limits they might transcend rather easily.

First, the aspects of running that seem to reify sexist gender stereotypes: I have a range of running clothes now, mostly in shades you’d find in a box of Necco Wafers. I have pink and blue and white tech shirts, and lavender and pink and black running bras, and shorts and running skirts that range from black (with a pink waistband) to blue to gray (with a pink stripe). When I run, I look super, super girly. Sweaty, but girly. Despite the skepticism with which seasoned athletes regard running skirts, I wear them almost exclusively – they’re comfy, they often provide more coverage of leg and ass than running shorts, and I like them. Moreover, I finally found an activity where it’s very likely that you can solve your problems with a new pair of shoes, and since this has long been my practice – to soothe my ego or perk myself up or provide a carrot for myself as the reward for some grueling or dull task – I enjoy having a real reason to choose new shoes.

A more serious overlap between running and traditional, repressive, sexist strictures for women involves the size and shape of my body. As I started to run more, I started to weigh less. I went from a perfectly nice size 8 to 10 body (this, after having given birth twice and breastfed continuously for – drum roll please! – more than seven consecutive years) to a size 4. My parents describe me as “lean,” my husband is somewhat taken aback, the most overtly feminine of my female coworkers talk to me frequently in approving tones about my waist and hips. My sister-in-law, a few months post-partum, sized me up when I came to visit and observed simply, “You’re really thin.” I am. I am really thin. But when I look at my daughter, I can see that she’s also lean; I eat well (and frequently, and in good quantities), and I’m inclined to think this is just what my body looks like when I take care of myself. I am really thin, which pings my feminist anxieties in all kinds of ways, but I am also really damned strong. I am in better shape than I ever was as a teenager, or a college student, or a mother of very young children (mine are now eight and five.)

So: while dressing in a cute pink and gray skirt and dashing along the local running trails in my size four body seems very much in keeping with the sexist stereotypes I deplore as a feminist, I’m convinced that running is actually something very different. While some women no doubt run only to govern their bodies into more socially acceptable forms, this practice pales in comparison to those women who fought for the right to engage in physical activity alongside their brothers and male classmates. Although when I began running, I knew vaguely about Title IX, the 1972 law [in the USA] prohibiting discrimination on the basis of sex in educational settings, I had no idea – none – about how hard aspiring female athletes fought for the simple right to compete in organized events. Early female entrants to marathons disguised their gender on their entry forms, were sometimes chased during the race by angry men, were denied official record of their accomplishments. Although in the United States alone, working class women and farm or pioneer women, not to mention enslaved women, engaged in significant physical labor all their lives, somehow twentieth century women who wanted to engage in athletics were seen as too delicate. With the exception of the 1928 Olympics, where there was a women’s 800 meter event, no woman’s footrace was longer than 200 meters until 1960. Women couldn’t officially run the Boston Marathon until 1972. It was a shock to me that women’s bodies were so tightly, so successfully, controlled in this sphere; I had thought of women’s choices regarding their bodies to be largely a matter of reproductive care – access to birth control and abortion. It had never occurred to me that there was public discourse (in the United States, within the last sixty years) about whether women were biologically fit to run distances further than a mile and a half.

Trust me, my children will never take that discussion seriously. My daughter will never, ever have reason to think she can’t be athletic because of her gender; it will, I hope, never even occur to my son to regard girls and women as fragile little things. My kids have grown used to seeing me head out the door in my running clothes, or slog back in, sweaty and disheveled. They’ll happily make conversation at church potlucks about my latest half-marathon; they ask about how my runs go. Occasionally my daughter will come with me on her bike, although she’s a little fast for me. This is the other interesting wrinkle about running for me, and one reason it has such an impact on my kids. Like my grandfather, my dad, and both of my children, I have asthma. While the kids seem to be growing out of it, I have not. So when I run, I run pretty slowly. I can do comfortable 9:30 miles for a long time, but in the running world, that’s slow.

There are a slew of articles – mostly, I’ve noticed, by men – about how disgraceful the current state of things is in the running world, how the marathon is now just open to any fool with shoes, how slow runners should just get some other hobby. I know my kids will encounter this attitude – possibly about their very bodies, possibly about people in general – and I remain hopeful, and confident, that I have provided them with a counter-example to that argument. Because I run, despite the asthma, despite the fraught history of women and their bodies, because I’m confident and strong even in the absence of innate talent or great physical skill – I’m a great feminist role model for my kids. They’ve stopped asking me after races whether I’ve won – the answer will always be no – but they remain proud of my effort. Even in the face of utterly objective measure that tells me I am bad at this, I am slow, I lack talent – I am happily persisting. I hope this is what they learn, my daughter and my son: your body is your body, and you can make it strong, and healthy. No one can tell you what to do with your own body, or that you’re not good enough to do what you enjoy. Your body, however imperfect it might seem by the wildly unattainable standards of our culture, is yours, and it is good.


Courtney Wilder did finish that dissertation, earning a Ph.D. in theology from the University of Chicago, and now teaches in the Religion and Philosophy Department at Midland Lutheran College. She runs and, with her spouse, raises her kids in Omaha, Nebraska.

Wednesday, July 22, 2009

(Not exactly) Wordless Wednesday

I only hope he learns better babywearing etiquette before I have grandkids. But hey, the baby IS in a carseat!... sort of.





[Image: Boychick asleep in carseat with baby doll in sling.]

Tuesday, July 21, 2009

Changes they are a-comin'!

While I could go on about regretting that I didn't do this months ago, I'm instead just going to celebrate it now: I am the proud owner of RaisingMyBoychick.com! (Don't bother going, there's nothing really there at the moment.) I'm in the process of switching the blog over to WordPress at the new URL: everything except the content (which I'll transfer over wholesale) will be brand sparkly new. This means, alas, that all your RSS feeds are going to have to be updated.

Now, no reason to panic: when I say "I'm in the process", I mean "I am so overwhelmed by all of this I hardly know where to begin and am thinking of running away and hiding under the covers until it fixes itself", so, y'know, it'll be a little while.

I'll keep you all updated: for most of you, reading in RSS, this won't affect anything, except for being irritating in that you have to switch feeds (but not yet!). I hope, however, it will make navigating the blog much easier (I'll be able to display the Womanist/Feminist Parenting Primer properly!), and will definitely make things less frustrating for me doing the blogging (after, y'know, I learn my way around WordPress), which, in the long run, will be good for you, the reader, as I'll have even more incentive and ability to actually post the Grade A Quality Feminist Content y'all are here for!

...I hope.

So stick around: it'll be worth it. I have another (excellent!) WFPP post to go up later this week, and several topics brewing in my brain. I also have three midterms this week, but, assuming I survive, it shouldn't impact you too much.

Wish me luck!

Monday, July 20, 2009

Sula and sleep: on raising a white child and reading "the n word"

The Man and I have a years-long tradition of reading to each other in bed to help us sleep. Although the arrival of the Boychick changed the purpose of this nightly ritual from decompression- and snuggle-time to help-Arwyn-survive-breastfeeding-baby-to-sleep time, it didn't really change the books we chose. We've always read books with “adult content”, and we don't see why we should limit our selections to exclusively “children's books” just because we have a child now. Still, as he's grown, we've gotten just a little pickier about the content, trying to balance the desire to expose him to enjoyable, mind-expanding literature with not wanting to expose him to too much in the way of inappropriate language or ideas. It's sometimes hard finding books we enjoy, that work well read aloud, and that have a low enough objectionable-to-laudable scene ratio in them; but mostly, we pick books that will interest and engage us: he's just along for the ride.

The other night, having decided that The Canterbury Tales was too difficult to follow while half asleep and too misogynistic for any time of day, I brought to bed Sula by Toni Morrison. I had picked up the novel on sale years ago, knowing that I admired Morrison's work but not having read this one before. It languished in our library, unopened and unread, as Half Price Books and under-treated bipolar disorder left me at the time with more books acquired than actually appreciated. But this night I was looking for something new, something thinner in size if not in scope than our recent hefty choices, and I spotted it, and thought, why not?

The possible answer to "why not?" came in the form of "the n word" appearing half a dozen times in the first five pages. After the third or fourth iteration, The Man abruptly stopped reading, and asked -- more like demanded, desperate for an answer -- "should I be reading that word aloud?" I said the only thing I could: "I don't know."

I don't know. I know I want to teach the Boychick about the evils some people (people who look a lot like him) have done and still do against other people (people who look slightly less like him but are still fundamentally the same as him). I know I want to be able to have calm and rational conversations with him about the N word and why it is a word he is not ever allowed to use, even if he one day has friends who use it for themselves. I know I want to expose him to the profound and beautiful literature this hateful language -- and the even more hateful actions it represents -- have inspired in those who have endured and survived it, expose him to stories of lives he will never have to live, stories I hope he will help to make unnecessary for the next generation to write.

But he's two years old. He is a linguistic sponge, surprises everyone with his vocabulary and complex sentence structure and clarity of speech and thought -- and he will repeat the words he hears, even if he doesn't know what they mean, even if he can't understand why he mustn't use them. Even if we agree he's old enough to be exposed to the ugliness of life (more on that in a moment), I'm not sure he's yet cognitively able to hear and discuss and understand the explanations about the uses and implications of racial slurs, and until he is, I'm not sure we should expose him to the words and thus risk him exposing others -- who would understand, who could be hurt unnecessarily but understandably -- to them when he repeats them.

It is, of course, entirely due to white privilege that we have the choice whether to expose him to those slurs: he is white, we are white, most of our friends are white, and we travel primarily in a social sphere where racism is institutionalized, not explicated, subtle, not overt. A parent of color, or a parent of a child of color, all too often has the choice taken away from them, as these words are forced on them, flung at them like filth. It is entirely privilege unearned that allows me to sit comfortably in my sub/urban house, in a residential neighbourhood overwhelmingly white, in a city blindingly white, in a country still controlled by whiteness for all it is headed by a half black (but entirely Black) man, and indulge in angst over whether to allow my child to hear an ugly word that will never, ever be used against him.

But I think it is also white responsibility, stemming from that white privilege, to think about that language, to examine the role I play in perpetuating it, to act to counter it. I have a responsibility to teach my child about the word, about the larger evils it represents, yes: but I also have a responsibility to ensure my child does not hurt those around him by repeating it before he knows better, do I not?

So do we read the word aloud and hope he is able to understand our explanations? Substitute it with a euphemism more palatable but ultimately no less kyriarchal? Mumble it and hope he doesn't ask for clarification? Put the book away until he's "old enough", whenever that is? If we do that last, are we whitewashing his world, perpetuating racism-through-exclusion? Or would we be ensuring that in his formative years he only is exposed to positive images of people of color, friendly interactions between people of different races? I come around to the answer I gave that night: I don't know.

I don't have all the answers; some days, it feels I don't have any. I only hope that seeing me struggle to seek them will serve the Boychick well, because he's going to be white -- in a world that privileges whiteness above all others -- for the rest of his life. As I hold him close to me at night, thinking of another mother clutching her child after being exposed to the word in a way she couldn't control, would never have chosen, I whisper a prayer to whatever god/desses are listening: please, please let him do better. Let him work to oppose that privilege. Let the answers come easier to him. Let his generation grow beyond this ugliness. Let that word become meaningless, powerless, within his lifetime. Let him know how lucky he is; how no more worthy than any others, only luckier. Let him be white without perpetuating whiteness. Please.


****************

What do you do? Those who have had the choice taken away from you, or who chose to take the plunge and read it aloud, what did you say to your children? Were they able to understand the explanations? If you haven't addressed this issue, why not, and how have you worked to counter the privilege inherent in that choice?

Friday, July 17, 2009

Have I ever thought of a book?

A reader, bless her beautiful heart, recently asked if I had "ever thought of a book." This comment, while breathtakingly sweet and a balm to my self-scathing soul, betrays a fairly fundamental lack of understanding of what it means to me to have bipolar disorder.

Have I ever thought about writing a book? Being bipolar means I have to expend a significant amount of mental energy on not thinking about writing a book, not thinking about a book deal that will make me rich, not thinking about getting published and getting famous, not thinking about my appearance on The Daily Show (the quips we'd trade, the bloggers with less privilege I'd promote, the laughs I'd get, the thoughts I'd provoke, the flats I'd wear to not loom too tall over him), not thinking about getting invited to the White House to discuss the immensely important issues my book would address with depth and nuance (Josh Lyman would be there, of course), not thinking about the revolution that will finally overthrow the kyriarchy for good sparked in no small part by said immensely important and deeply nuanced book. Because if I think of doing a book, I cannot help but thinking of all those things in turn: there are no half measures in this mentally ill mind o'mine.

Reality of course can never live up to such fantasies, and dreaming them both takes away from time I could, and would rather, spend actually writing, and paralyzes me, because the flip side of such grandiosity -- only ever a hair's breadth away -- is being convinced I am and only ever will be a waste of oxygen, hydrogen, carbon, and space. (A friend asked me the other day why, if I didn't think my writing was any good, were people coming to the site in such numbers. My reply was "To point and laugh?" Yes, I might be a wee bit crazy.)

The only way I've found to avoid this type of thinking (what Anne Lamott cleverly and concisely calls "mind fucking") is to not think. If I allowed myself to think about how big my blog could get, what I'd do if it became really popular, the articles I'd be asked to write for Bitch and Salon and Mothering and The New Yorker... I would never actually be able to blog at all. So I don't. I think about this post, the post I have planned for tomorrow, the way I'll respond to the comments I've actually gotten. Better still, I just write, and don't think about it in a meta way at all.

So have I ever thought about a book? Um, yes. But I try not to.

Thursday, July 16, 2009

WFPP Guest Post: FCUKing the Patriarchy

Welcome to the first official entry to the Womanist/Feminist Parenting Primer! Today's guest post comes from a reader who wishes to be known as "Mama of the Family from the Fringes".

The Family from the Fringes Mama is a former academic and editor with a degree in political science and women's studies who now works as a pregnancy, birth and postpartum servant and is training to become a breastfeeding counsellor. She is also a full-time mother to one homeborn, cloth bummed, co-sleeping, babyworn, breastfed, unschooled child who she (and her male partner) are hoping to raise feminist.


To understand the context of this post, which MotFftF places as a PS, it's important to know that fcuk, and slogans playing on fcuk, come from a clothing company, ostensibly as an acronym for French Connection United Kingdom. A series of shirts with lines such as "fcuk fashion" and "hot as fcuk" were released. In this context, the message on the shirt in question goes from an inexplicably misspelled anti-patriarchalism to a fairly clever subversion of a patriarchal clothing line.

Regardless of whether you think placing almost-swear words on an illiterate child is appropriate, or something you yourself would do, this piece is a welcome start to the Primer as the story of the way one feminist family deals with the fallout of raising a child overtly and explicitly anti-patriarchy.

FCUKing The Patriarchy

When Harri was born she received a t-shirt from one of her Aunts, which was bought for Harriet with her mother and father's sense of humour and political leanings in mind. It doesn't get worn out much since a woman in her 60s verbally abused Harriet's Mama in a room full of people, saying "do you want people to think of fucking when they think of your baby girl? Because that's what they will think! You shouldn't be allowed to use your child to promote your political message."

Mama packed the shirt away for a few months, shaken by her public shaming (though it should be noted that before and after the shaming the other women who were present in that room had come to Harriet's Mum to tell her how much they loved and appreciated the shirt). When asked what she thought about the shirt a dear family friend, who we shall call Grace, said "FCUK that woman and her opinion. It's just her opinion! And it is MY opinion that every man, woman and child should have a shirt like that and wear it everywhere!"

Mama stumbled across a slogan today that inspired her to put the shirt back on Harri. It said "Children. Have them. Love them. Radicalize them!" Damn straight. Honestly, in a culture where little boys have "chick magnet" and "lock up your daughters" on their tees and little girls are dressed to look like slutty adults, with toddlers able to get g-strings and bikinis in their size, a little fcuking of the patriarchy can only be a good thing!

We understand the objection to pushing political opinions onto our children that are not their own. But ultimately we see little difference between dressing Harriet in a shirt that promotes bringing an end to male dominance and a shirt that promotes breastfeeding; they both espouse positive ideas that are good for the health of all people (they're just not popular in a capitalist patriarchy).

As Harri grows and forms her own opinions about these issues it will be entirely her choice whether or not she wants to wear clothing with politically motivated messages on them and we have always been honest with her about meanings (from the myth of Santa to the importance of breastfeeding and the problems with patriarchy - which she already experiences first hand as a woman-in-training in this society). For now she seems fine with it:



PS I also love that this shirt is a spoof of the FCUK fashion brand (French Connection United Kingdom) because fashion plays such an important part in upholding patriarchy.

Wednesday, July 15, 2009

...now what does that mean in the real world?

This is a follow up to my post The personal and the political, and a response to this question from reader Rachel on Two things I do believe and several things I don't:
...she said she and her husband chose to do [crying it out], he is involved in bedtime and it was a decision they both made.

They don't fit what you've described.

So how would you respond in a similar situation?
Much like Rachel, I both wouldn't want to criticize their choice, but also would feel quite uncomfortable tacitly supporting a practice I feel to be unnecessary and unkind, at best, and borderline abusive, at worst. In truth, I, like her, would be unlikely to say anything.

In fact, I've been in situations similar. My brother and sister-in-law did the "graduated extinction" form of CIO with both of their children: once I was on the phone with my brother, hearing my niece cry in the background and my SIL periodically go in to "reassure" her. At that time, I did try to say something, along the lines of "Sometimes babies just need help getting to sleep." He took this to mean an endorsement of the practice I was trying to gently speak against. I got off the phone shortly after that, and we haven't talked about parenting and children's sleep since then.

Why didn't I say anything more? In part because he's my brother, and I love him, and I want to be able to continue to have him in my life for decades to come. But also because I think advocacy of parenting practices works on the individual level before the other party has made a decision, or when they are unsatisfied with the decision, or are reflecting on a past decision when looking forward to a new one. They must, in some way, be open to and interested in new information, or a new perspective, about the topic. I don't find it useful to try to get someone to regret a decision that is over and done with, about which there is nothing can be done to change it, or that is currently being done and about which they are likely to be highly defensive.

I think we also must recognize that no matter what information we share with someone, some people are going to make decisions we disagree with. This is hard to deal with when it is a subject we are passionate about, and especially when it affects the health and well-being of children as crying it, unnecessary formula use, and so on do. Here, I find it helpful to remember a few things:
  • Human beings are remarkably resilient creatures. We can endure, even in infancy, a profound array of actually abusive practices, and still, often, grow up in to reasonably sane, worthwhile, beautiful persons. While not good for us, we can usually survive and even thrive under sub-standard conditions of the sort lactivists and attachment parenting types speak against: most babies are not going to be killed by unnecessary formula; most babies are not going to fail to thrive or develop attachment pathologies from being abandoned to cry. Odds are, they're still going to be fine. "My parents did X, and I turned out alright" is a lousy excuse for not doing better, but it's a good mantra to save my sanity, and reducing my stress and anxiety is good for my own child.

  • I cannot single-handedly counter the kyriarchy. Every parent receives a thousand messages a day from their society, usually messages overtly or covertly promoting kyriarchal values, including messages saying biology is inferior to science, women's bodies are broken or dangerous, healthy interdependence is pathological dependence, and so on. While I can influence, I might only be a drop the proverbial bucket of information that a parent receives about breastfeeding and infant sleep, and the rest are likely lies and fallacies promoted by the kyriarchy. There is only so much I can do, and while what I do is important and necessary and valuable, it is not up to me alone to change the world or change another's mind.

  • When an individual does manage to defy her cultural expectations -- by breastfeeding full term, by meeting her children's nighttime needs without leaving them to cry, by raising her child to be anti-sexist and anti-racist -- by all means I should give her the credit, but when she does not, I find it far more useful to give the culture the blame. I say this both because women and parents exist within the kyriarchy, and have their choices influenced and constricted thereby, and because I don't have any desire to add the stress of blaming her to my own life and to our relationship. In other words, I take the long view because it makes my life easier.
So in all, my philosophy doesn't make me look much different in action (in this situation) than any other parent. I get extremely uncomfortable, I try to avoid conflict, and I expend far too much mental energy worrying it over after the fact. I try to speak against the practices I believe harmful when I can -- when I believe it to be potentially helpful, and not dangerous to my person or my sanity -- and I try to let it go when I can't.

Other women, other parents, are not my enemy, no matter how much I may disagree with them. Whether or not it's true, as long as we continue to live under kyriarchy, I am going to continue to believe that parents would not be abandoning their children to cry at night in a sane society, with proper social support and accurate information. I am going to continue to believe that all women capable of it would choose to exclusively breastfeed, and to nurse full-term, in a society that welcomed and promoted it. I will always continue to speak truth as I see it on subjects such as CIO, whether it's well-received or not, and I will always do my best to be a positive influence in individuals' lives, but I refuse to do the kyriarchy's work of attacking them when they do "wrong".



The first guest post to the Womanist/Feminist Parenting Primer goes up tomorrow! Be sure to submit your own stories for future posts in the series.

Tuesday, July 14, 2009

Neither monsters nor martyrs be: lessons on motherhood from my menstrual cycle

Thanks to the science of charting, I knew enough to pull on my red undies this morning, and toss a couple pads in my bag before heading out for a day on the town. Sure enough, my flow showed as predicted, and I was pleased to be prepared, even if for once I was hoping to be wrong.

Mostly, I'm fine with cycling and menstruating. The way my genitals change over the course of the month -- dormant, dry, raised and closed, through wet, open, swollen and fertile and back again -- never ceases to fascinate me. I like my cloth pads, enjoy making them and using them. I'm in no way ashamed of menstruation, or the cyclical nature of my hormones and their affect on my mood and being; I believe I carry none of the patriarchal conceptions of menstrual or cervical fluids as dirty or disgusting.

But sometimes, I just get tired of it. Especially with 9-10 day luteal phases (standard being 12-16), meaning even fewer opportunities for deliciously natural PIV sex (that being, let me be frank, my prime motivator for charting), and 26-28 day cycles of which 6-7 days are spent bleeding, even menstruation-enthusiast me gets weary of the more-than-monthly bleed, and the associated irritations, discomforts, and duties. It doesn't matter how much we love something, everything complex has its downsides, its annoyances, its downright drags: menstruation, breastfeeding, baby-care, school, blogging; everything.

I was thinking of this just this afternoon, bloody pad between my legs and crying toddler in my arms. We had been in downtown Portland most of the day, chasing him around Powell's City of Books between making sure he didn't kill himself in his enthusiasm for the MAX trains. He was ready for a nap, and I was beyond ready for him to nap, and could have used a quiet lie down myself. When he woke up when we tried to transfer him from the car to the bed, after three minutes' nap, he was cranky and I was crankier.

I love my child with all my heart. I love spending time with him. Although finally getting to the point where I'd jump at the chance to have an evening away with my beloved, and having been in school for nearly a year because I started needing outside pursuits again, I'm perfectly happy spending nearly his every waking moment together. But I need some down time now and then.

That's not exactly a revolutionary confession; at the moment, it seems, there's a whole industry based on the "bad mom" who revels in revealing all the sordid sides of parenting. This is in direct reaction to the previous "good mom", who never admitted anything was less than perfect.

I've never been happy with or identified with either of these stereotypes, because both of these are false constructs of the patriarchy, both serve its goals: the "perfect mom" by raising women who parent up on unreachable pedestals, inhuman, with all us mere mortals able to be treated as rubbish when we inevitably fail to achieve those heights; the "bad mom" by disregarding the blissful moments of parenting, and reducing its rewarding toil to fodder for fecal jokes, deriding those of us who would take seriously this stage of our and our children's lives.

The "perfect mom" would have me write off, suppress, any frustrations around being always on call. The "bad mom" would have me mix a martini and let him squawl, or book a cruise to the Caribbean and abandon him with relatives. Problem is, I don't hit the bottle, my momma taught me not to bottle it up, and if I'm going to a tropical beach I can't imagine leaving him behind.

The thing about the kyriarchy is it dehumanizes us: either we don't admit to having periods, or believe they're dirty and work to do away with them. Either we adore our perfect angels, or we barely tolerate the little snots. Either we are martyrs or we are monsters. I'm not going to pop a pill to stop cycling, I'm not going to drug my kid or let him cry-it-out to nap: I can admit I'd like a break, admit and examine my ambivalence, without being a martyr, without being a monster. The kyriarchy is going to try to shove me in to one of those little limiting boxes, but I say no.

When my child wakes up barely after falling asleep, I take a deep breath (let out a few cries of my own), and figure out a way to survive. When my period shows up without having a chance to take advantage of my unmessy infertile phase, I take a deep breath (mutter a few choice curses), and resolve to plan better next month.

Sure, I'd love a break. But this is life: and on the whole, I wouldn't have it any other way.

Monday, July 13, 2009

A Carnival to read and a Primer to name

Over at Mothers for Women's Lib, the Second Carnival of Feminist Parenting is up. There are some great articles up, including the call for submissions for the Feminist Parenting Primer by yours truly.

Some featured posts:

Stephanie Rosado presents Motherhood = Feminism = Activism posted at Mothering in the Margins.

Scott presents On Gendered Interests in Children posted at A Canadian Lefty in Occupied Land.

Kenzie presents Babies and the Cultural Performance of Femininity posted at Birthcycle.

Elisha Webster Emerson presents Would you Like Sex with That Burger? posted at My Inconvenient Body.

Be sure to check it out, and support womanist/feminist blogging parents. And do submit posts for upcoming carnivals!

Speaking of begging for submissions, I'll be posting the first guest entry to what is currently being called the Womanist/Feminist Parenting Primer later this week, but I'm not sure that's the name I want to keep using. It's accurate, sure, but if you have any catchier (or sillier!) suggestions, post a comment. And whatever it's called, write something for it!

Sunday, July 12, 2009

The personal and the political

What do I mean when I say “...getting sucked into attacks and defenses of individual "choices" is not only missing the point, it is supporting the patriarchy”?

It is certainly understandable when faced with the task of changing one's whole culture all in one go to feel overwhelmed, as reader Rachel bemoans: “I think that's what I find daunting about your posts--you address the larger cultural, societal issues that I feel are out of my control. … But my whole culture. That seems impossible.”

And as Jeremy Adam Smith points out over at Daddy Dialectic, there is a trap on the other side, for those who believe “only after the revolution can our piddling interpersonal relationships be lastingly altered” to use this as an excuse to “neglect their family responsibilities, especially the guys.” After all, if equality in individual lives is impossible to achieve, no point trying, right?

Neither of those are what I'm hoping to advocate.

When Rachel says “I can control (as much as anyone I think) what goes on in my family”, she is right. When Jeremy asserts “how vital and immediate it is for heterosexual couples to [establish] a domestic division of labor that makes both parties happy”, he is right. It is only ever in ourselves, for ourselves, that we can choose. It is only ever our own actions and choices over which we have direct, though not complete, control. And it is so vitally important that in our own, personal lives that we work to implement our ideals and values.

That is the personal.

As for the political: we are social creatures. Society is only and simply the gestalt of thousands and millions of individuals. And that makes us – each individual – powerful, for we are society, and each of us has the potential to influence all the dozens and hundreds and thousands of persons in our lives, and through them dozens and hundreds and thousands more.

The personal is political, and the political is personal. Decisions are made by the ones who show up, the ones who speak out, the ones who write letters and raise funds and cast votes and serve dinners and volunteer at clinics; sexism and racism and other facets of the kyriarchy are eliminated by those who demand better, of ourselves and of our kith and kin and coworkers. It is by making connections at the individual level – with your family, your friends, your blog readers, your neighbours, your shops' owners, your company's executives, your government representatives – that we can enact political, societal change.

What does not work, however, and what I speak out against, is the attempt to control those around us, especially through shaming. There may be a fine line between offering influence and attempting control, but it is an important one, and when we are speaking of mothers, who are already a highly persecuted class, already so put-upon and guilt-ridden, maintaining that distinction is even more imperative.

I do not say this because I believe women are fragile, dainty things who cannot take criticism: to the contrary, I am continually amazed by just how much we can take and take on and still do all the work that keeps our families and societies running. But our burdens are already so over-heavy that I decline to add what may be the proverbial straw to any woman's back.

Further, each of us lives in the society we all create, and that society is kyriarchal, actively antagonistic to us living joyful, unconstrained, interdependent, fully human lives. Each of us has our choices constrained if not outright dictated by the circumstances and intersections of our lives – each of which combinations is unique, but all similar for making us less than fully able to live as we would in a saner society.

How, then, can we help change society without hurting our sister sufferers? We can encourage; we must not order. We can offer a shoulder; we must not sit in judgment. We can support; we must not shame. We can influence those around us by example, by sharing our stories, by offering information and support; but they must be open to it. We cannot attempt to control those around us through browbeating or shame or force – or we can, but it is a violation of our values as well as almost inevitably ineffective.

We cannot avoid offending those who are determine to be offended, but we can, and we must, watch our own words and actions to avoid allowing the kyriarchy's voice to speak through our throats: that means, in part, declining to partake in the mommy wars in any of its permutations. That means opposing crying-it-out without attacking those who do it. That means defending breastfeeding without insulting those who weren't able to or chose not to. That means promoting natural family living while acknowledging that all of us have a harmful impact on the planet. That means disagreeing and debating and disputing and refuting each other in a way that respects each side's inherent humanity and dignity, because the only real enemy, the only true evil, is the kyriarchy.

So speak out, yes: live your ideals as best you can, and tell your truth as honestly as possible. I cannot say it any better than it has been said before, so forgive me for ending on what is almost cliched; nevertheless I believe it true: “Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world. Indeed, it is the only thing that ever has.” -- Margaret Mead

Saturday, July 11, 2009

A feminist parenting primer: share your stories through guest blogging

I'm considering running a series of posts on how we live womanist/feminist parenting; a sort of kaleidoscope primer on the day-to-day living of those of us who fight, oppose, undermine, and dismantle the kyriarchy (or at least try to!) that can help answer the questions "Sure, this all sounds good, but how do you DO this?" or "How can the ideals of feminism and anti-kyriarchy really work in real life?"

This may have some overlap with bluemilk's What does a feminist mother look like?/10 feminist mother questions meme, and the Carnival of Feminist Parenting, but I'm looking for something a little different: an image of your day, or a snapshot of a particular moment, or the tale of a decision you made, or your "feminist family mission statement" and how you try to follow it. Something practical that shows how we really put our ideals into practice. Here are a few of my posts that sort of show what I mean, but I'm really looking for your stories, and your ways of storytelling.

I'm not looking for perfection: sometimes the best opportunities for learning or teaching come when we mess up. And don't worry about it being "good enough" in either feminist content or writing quality -- I'm not going to judge the former, and I can help with the latter. I'm just looking for a picture, big or little, of some way you try to enact womanism/feminism in your life as a parent, and raise the next generation more aware of and less enslaved by kyriarchy/patriarchy.

I'd especially like to get the perspective of parents ("regular", step, adoptive, birth, and to-be or hoping-to-be) who are not male-partnered, white, able-bodied, middle-class, American women -- though even if you are all those things don't let that stop you from submitting.

So what do you think? Sound like a good idea?

Anyone interested, whether you know what to write or not, contact me at raisingmyboychick at gmail dot com.

Please and thank you!


ETA A couple of questions have come up. One, I don't require anyone to identify as a "feminist parent" to participate in this, nor even especially as a "womanist" or "feminist". Identity is up to you. What I am interested in is stories about trying to parent in line with womanist/feminist values, whether identified that way or not: striving for equal coparenting; raising children without limiting gender roles; opposing instances of sexism or racism or other facets of the kyriarchy in your children's lives. Whether you use the words "womanist" or "feminist" or kyriarchy/patriarchy is sort of irrelevant to me (although if you don't, I must admit I'm a little mystified why you'd be reading here!).

The other is that I do want to hear from those who are not-yet-parents: many of us have been opposing the kyriarchy in the parenting realm since we first started whispering the possibility that children might be on the horizon; or even earlier, if we have particularly obnoxious relations. I'd love to hear those stories. And all of us have been children, and had parents or parent stand-ins: perhaps you have a story about being raised by womanists/feminists, or who would never have identified as such but who nevertheless managed to ignite some important proto-feminist spark in you; or, perhaps your parents were Exhibit A in how not to raise children free of kyriarchy -- those could be instructive stories as well.

And if you really just don't have anything to share right now, sit back and enjoy the reading; but I intend for this to be an ever-evolving primer, so don't be surprised if one day you realize there's a story tapping on your shoulder, waiting to be shared. I'll be here.