You know how I said we can't always get it right? Well, I was right, because I got some stuff wrong in that last post. I have a tendency to let language run away with me, and go with what sounds good rather than what's right. So in the last post, I conceptually missed one really important piece, and messed up in some of my language.
To whit, the idea of us v them (or even us and them). It doesn't work. When I'm talking about me, I can talk about "those who are not like me". But if I'm talking about "us" -- say, feminists, or fat acceptance advocates -- then I can't talk about a "them" -- women of color, or persons with disabilities -- because they are us. There are feminists of color, and disabled fat activists, and fat Brown trans Deaf feminist bisexual women (ok, I don't know of one, but that doesn't mean she doesn't exist), and for them (tricky word!), separating out one "strand" of privilege/oppression is both impossible and ridiculous. It is only when one has most of the cards stacked in one's favor that one has the privilege of pretending that that one axis of oppression can stand alone, be examined alone and dismantled alone.
We have to think about those who are not like us, yes, but we also must remember that those who may belong to a group we do not might also belong to ours. To say "feminists think this and blacks think that" is to ignore Black feminists. To say "well we invited them, why don't they join us?" is to exclude them (to Other "them"), and to render invisible those who are both "us" and
"them".
Intersectionalism is vital -- necessary to life! -- because the world is not made up of white people and black people and feminists and trans people. Rather, the world is made up of persons, who might be any combination of white and black and trans and feminist and disabled and fat and neurotypical and and and and...
It is fine and well to have a focus, a specialty (or two or three or however many). It is natural and understandable to have more expertise in the areas where one personally and intimately experiences oppression. But we cannot, we must not, allow that focus to blind us. We must not use our expertise in one area to exculpate our ignorance in another. Intersectionality doesn't mean we are required to study all areas of oppression equally; it calls us rather to open our eyes, to look to our own privilege when telling of our oppression, and it demands that we rid ourselves of the fallacy of "us" and "them".
Selfishly, I need for intersectionality to succeed, for examples of those who work to end one type of oppression interlinking with others to abound, for the skill of looking beyond oneself to find the "us" in "them" to flourish; I need it to succeed, for it is my only hope of teaching my presumably-straight white middle class son how to look at all areas of his privilege, to work against all the ways those-like-and-not-like-him are oppressed, to recognize the existence of kyriarchy and oppose it always. Those of us with even one area of oppression have an opening, as we learn of privilege, to learn intersectionality; those of us with many are forced to adopt it or self-destruct. My child has nearly every privilege in the world heaped on him, in a society that teaches the ugly art of Othering from birth: I fully admit to maternal selfishness when I say I need intersectionality to succeed so I do not lose him to the kyriarchy, which would have him Other everyone I love -- including me -- out of importance in his life.
So, that's not much of a reason for anyone else to adopt intersectionality (I fully recognize that an argument that sounds rather like "think of the white males!" is hardly much of a draw), but it's one reason, among many, I will defend and promote it as much as I can. I have an obligation to others to avoid oppressing and Othering and rendering them invisible, as I myself have been, as I myself am demanding not to be. And also, yes, I have an urgent desire to demonstrate that skill to a child unlikely to ever have call to learn the hard way why it is so very vital.
Intersectionality: the art of opposing the kyriarchy, one word at a time and all ways at once.
Tuesday, March 31, 2009
Monday, March 30, 2009
On intersectionality
Four months ago, when I was starting this blog, I had never even heard of the word "intersectionality" (wikipedia article, blog post [amazing pictures, but probably NSFW], another blog post, link post). I was aware, in a general way, of race issues, certainly of queer issues, to a lesser extent of trans issues, among others, and I was aware of the language of privilege, of the many ways in which I live with privilege (and the many ways I do not). But "intersectionality" was not a word on my radar, and I didn't really "get" it when I started looking it up -- the arguments "watered down!" "loss of focus!" "not in this movement!" floated through my thinking, though each was, in turn, shot down.
And yet, I think I understood it even then, before I heard it, intuitively; as I named and taglined my blog, while it was primarily about the experience of being a feminist raising a boy, I was clear that he was not just any male, but a white male, a probably-straight male, an American middle class probably-straight white able-bodied male: very nearly the tippy top of the hierarchy, by way of the intersection (!) of all these different aspects of privilege.
The more I've thought about it, and especially after coming upon the word/concept "kyriarchy", the more intersectionality makes sense (kyriarchy is what I was talking about here, though I didn't realize it at the time -- and I was also, unrealizingly, arguing against something of a straw feminism there). Feminism is in opposition to patriarchy, and this is good, but it takes only a moment of thought to realize that this does not and cannot (even at its most inclusive) cover all the ways in which some people are artificially privileged over others. Ultimately, I think it is the very concept of placing persons in a hierarchy (which is to say, it is kyriarchy) which needs to be done away with; and ultimately, it is intersectionalism alone which stands in opposition not just to one strand but, by definition, to all strands of oppression. It is only by working to recognize all forms of oppression/privilege in our work can we oppose all aspects of the kyriarchy; anything less is merely scrabbling for position on that fucked up ladder.
Which is not to say we need to get everything perfectly right all the time; we are human, and therefore both limited and flawed. Furthermore, we are humans raised under kyriarchy, and not one person reading this post can be without at least some privilege (since you've all managed to access the internet in some way or another); we are not going to be able to avoid all slip ups, all language of privilege, all incidents of accidental or oblivious oppression. But we can, and we must, try. Any step is worthy; any mistake is an opportunity to learn; any privilege recognized is a privilege weakened.
This ain't an easy path to walk, and there is no end to it. It would be all too easy to turn aside, to close my eyes, to rest easy on the privilege I do have while screaming for justice for the privilege I don't; but that way lies pain, if not for myself then for others, and if for others, then for all. Intersectionalism isn't diluting our purpose; it isn't putting others ahead of ourselves; it isn't "PC metastized". It is nothing less nor more than refusing to oppress others as we seek to end our own oppression. It is nothing less nor more than basic human compassion. It is nothing less than necessary, and nothing more than possible.
And yet, I think I understood it even then, before I heard it, intuitively; as I named and taglined my blog, while it was primarily about the experience of being a feminist raising a boy, I was clear that he was not just any male, but a white male, a probably-straight male, an American middle class probably-straight white able-bodied male: very nearly the tippy top of the hierarchy, by way of the intersection (!) of all these different aspects of privilege.
The more I've thought about it, and especially after coming upon the word/concept "kyriarchy", the more intersectionality makes sense (kyriarchy is what I was talking about here, though I didn't realize it at the time -- and I was also, unrealizingly, arguing against something of a straw feminism there). Feminism is in opposition to patriarchy, and this is good, but it takes only a moment of thought to realize that this does not and cannot (even at its most inclusive) cover all the ways in which some people are artificially privileged over others. Ultimately, I think it is the very concept of placing persons in a hierarchy (which is to say, it is kyriarchy) which needs to be done away with; and ultimately, it is intersectionalism alone which stands in opposition not just to one strand but, by definition, to all strands of oppression. It is only by working to recognize all forms of oppression/privilege in our work can we oppose all aspects of the kyriarchy; anything less is merely scrabbling for position on that fucked up ladder.
Which is not to say we need to get everything perfectly right all the time; we are human, and therefore both limited and flawed. Furthermore, we are humans raised under kyriarchy, and not one person reading this post can be without at least some privilege (since you've all managed to access the internet in some way or another); we are not going to be able to avoid all slip ups, all language of privilege, all incidents of accidental or oblivious oppression. But we can, and we must, try. Any step is worthy; any mistake is an opportunity to learn; any privilege recognized is a privilege weakened.
This ain't an easy path to walk, and there is no end to it. It would be all too easy to turn aside, to close my eyes, to rest easy on the privilege I do have while screaming for justice for the privilege I don't; but that way lies pain, if not for myself then for others, and if for others, then for all. Intersectionalism isn't diluting our purpose; it isn't putting others ahead of ourselves; it isn't "PC metastized". It is nothing less nor more than refusing to oppress others as we seek to end our own oppression. It is nothing less nor more than basic human compassion. It is nothing less than necessary, and nothing more than possible.
Labels:
intersectionalism,
isms,
kyriarchy,
language,
patriarchy,
privilege,
white privilege
Sunday, March 29, 2009
When the words just won't come
I actually have three drafts sitting in my queue, ideas absolutely worthy of discussion, but almost incoherent in their construction. Seriously, even short posts on discussion forums I try to write leave me scratching my head going "what the heck does that mean?"; I shudder to think what it looks like to others.
I'm not sure what's going on. I probably need to get my thyroid levels checked (actually, I need to anyway, as my script runs out soon and my doc won't represcribe without a blood check). But I'm tired, I've been having more migraines the past few days, and the words are just seriously not coming (at least the latter two are likely connected, as one of the most irritating parts of the neurological storm known as "migraines" is the difficulty thinking of the right word, even when the pain isn't currently active). Terribly disheartening for a word geek and writer like me.
Anyway, I leave you with a few links that I've found interesting recently (some of which I've tried -- and failed -- to write about, so you might hear more about them later. or not.):
And finally, how could anyone not adore this kid?
I'm not sure what's going on. I probably need to get my thyroid levels checked (actually, I need to anyway, as my script runs out soon and my doc won't represcribe without a blood check). But I'm tired, I've been having more migraines the past few days, and the words are just seriously not coming (at least the latter two are likely connected, as one of the most irritating parts of the neurological storm known as "migraines" is the difficulty thinking of the right word, even when the pain isn't currently active). Terribly disheartening for a word geek and writer like me.
Anyway, I leave you with a few links that I've found interesting recently (some of which I've tried -- and failed -- to write about, so you might hear more about them later. or not.):
- Alas, a blog on (avoiding or replacing) the metaphors of madness
- Mom's Tinfoil Hat has not one but two posts up about refusing to perform elective cesareans, and Rixa at Stand and Deliver has an interesting follow up
- Although you'd pretty much have to tie me down with intent to torture to get me to watch Desperate Housewives, Hoyden About Town has an interesting post on the fat politics of a particular episode, that makes me want to go find just that snippet on YouTube
And finally, how could anyone not adore this kid?
Thursday, March 26, 2009
Big fish, small fish, small pond, big ocean: a Seussian experience of feminism
Sometimes I feel like two people: in "real" life, and in some of the online places I frequent, I am about the most radical feminist I know, and one of the few who has even heard the words "intersectionality" or "white privilege" or "cisgender" (much less cissexism). I find myself needing to dispel feminist myths, to spend all my time explaining the most basic vocabulary and concepts. I am a big fish in a small pond.
But in the feminist blogosphere, I am so new, so ignorant still in so many ways, and I spend most of my time just reading and reading and studying and following links and getting challenged, because there is so much I do not yet know about what it means to identify feminist, to exist with so much privilege (white, class, cisgender, able-bodied, etc), to live under kyriarchy. There are still so many myths, and misunderstandings, and consequences of unrecognized privilege within my own mind that I am discovering and attempting to ferret out. I am a very tiny fish in an enormous, diverse, amazing ocean.
I wasn't really going anywhere with that, I've just had a few experiences recently that have really brought it to my attention. It's a very Seussian form of cognitive dissonance (one fish, two fish, trans fish, cisfish?).
Anyone else ever feel like that?
But in the feminist blogosphere, I am so new, so ignorant still in so many ways, and I spend most of my time just reading and reading and studying and following links and getting challenged, because there is so much I do not yet know about what it means to identify feminist, to exist with so much privilege (white, class, cisgender, able-bodied, etc), to live under kyriarchy. There are still so many myths, and misunderstandings, and consequences of unrecognized privilege within my own mind that I am discovering and attempting to ferret out. I am a very tiny fish in an enormous, diverse, amazing ocean.
I wasn't really going anywhere with that, I've just had a few experiences recently that have really brought it to my attention. It's a very Seussian form of cognitive dissonance (one fish, two fish, trans fish, cisfish?).
Anyone else ever feel like that?
Labels:
identity,
isms,
self-indulgent introspection,
white privilege
Wednesday, March 25, 2009
Passing for straight: parenting with a man as a queer identified woman
I will say this for passing: it gives one a lot more opportunities for coming out.
I just came out to a new friend from massage school. You'd think the act --a short sentence, one second, two words: "I'm bisexual" -- would get easier over time, and with practice. But to the contrary, I find it harder now than it ever was before.
My first coming out as bisexual -- to my first crush, as a freshman in high school, just a few weeks after finally hearing the term and recognizing myself in it -- was met with an anticlimactic "well duh, Arwyn". Two years later, coming out to my first romantic relationship got me an amused "I know".
You might say I did not do in the closet well. I was -- and am, when I feel safe -- a voracious flirt, never adhered to straight female gender roles, and had Ru Paul pinups in my locker instead of the usual... who was usual to crush on? I never kept track. Anyway, "coming out" in adolescence was, contrary to most other QTBLGs' experience, ridiculously easy, an exercise in stating the obvious to anyone who spent any time with me. With the arrogance of ignorance and unacknowledged privilege, I scoffed (in the safety of my own cranium, at least, even then however dimly recognizing its privileged origins) at those who found it hard, who dithered and postponed and passed rather than come out and say it -- or simply live it.
And now, when the moment comes to say it or lie by omission, I find myself hemming and hawing and dithering, and, yes, sometimes shutting up and just plain passing. And I hate it. What happened to "duh"?
Duh is no more, after eleven years with a man (Mr "I know" himself in fact, my first and only), after leaving high school and college and the groups of friends I came out with. And it really vanished after getting pregnant and having a baby, with a man, in the "usual", heteronormative way. After all, I am, indubitably, a breeder now, and everyone knows "breeder" means "straight".
It doesn't matter in the public eye, it seems, what other signals I send: having a child, with a man, makes me straight. After all, this is the Pacific Northwest, and I run with a crunchy crowd: unshaven pits, Birkenstocks year round, having a "partner" instead of a "husband", and being stridently outspoken for "gay rights" merely marks me as yet another crazy white neo-hippie liberal.
Add to that a social network comprised almost entirely of other women-who-spend-the-day-with-their-kids, the fear of losing straight friends to innocent flirting (not an unreasonable fear, I think, in a culture that equates bisexuality with unquenchable nymphomania, and paints us as seductresses and adulterers when it bothers admitting our existence at all), and I find myself, for the first time since I was 14 years old, being perceived as straight not just by a homophobic heteronormative society, but by people who know me. For someone who has been explicitly, outspokenly out for so long, it is a decidedly unexpected and uncomfortable experience.
But the hardest part, the part I cannot figure out how to work around, is that I had always relied on "living out" -- being obvious, refusing to pass -- as my way of dealing with the issue of any children of mine knowing my sexuality. If it were simply a part of my public identity, a fact that anyone who knows me would know, then the Boychick would grow up knowing it, simply and easily and without any fuss. But the very act of his creation has taken my public identity as an out bisexual from hard to maintain (I've spent my entire adult life in a monogamous relationship with a man; it hasn't been exactly easy for a while) to seemingly impossible. To the extent that I "pass", that I am understood by others however falsely to be straight, I am confronted with a dilemma where the Boychick is concerned; being closeted (used here as a verb, of which I am the subject and others the actor) means that I would be forced to decide what and when -- and indeed, whether -- to tell him.
And who wants to hear about their parents' sexuality? If not a part of one's (public) identity, one's sexuality is a matter of what one wants to do to or with whom, which is not information I can see as entirely appropriate to share with my child. If not understood to be a part of my public identity, any outing of myself to him ("honey, I'm bisexual"), would necessarily be followed by his asking "what does that mean?", and then what would I tell him? "Oh nothing, just that sometimes I dream of shagging women, and used to chase the hot queer chicks in high school"? I think not.
I hear some of you wondering "then why bother telling him? if you're monogamous with a man, aren't you basically straight anyway? what does it matter what other people think?" All I can tell you is, it does matter. We are talking about no less than who I am, at my very foundation. I may pass, in this heteronormative society that is so fond of stuffing us in to boxes whether we like them or not, but rather than make my life easy as some may think, passing is excruciatingly painful, like a tourniquet on a limb, like being told every day the sky is yellow when I can see it is blue. It is being forced to agree to a lie I know to be false, a lie about myself. It may seem "unimportant", my sexuality a mere technicality, but in a thousand ways every day, unseen by those blinded by straightness, even a monogamous woman is expected to assert her heterosexuality; the straight world surrounds me with its memes, its jokes, its assumptions, its understanding of the world and of female/male relationships: each is just a tiny little prick to my psyche, but oh do they add up.
I live with enormous heaps of straight privilege. The fact that I can pass when needed, that I could when my unmarried partner was on death's door in a rural hospital in the Midwest proclaim myself his fiancée and thus claim access to his bedside and his medical information, is a huge privilege that humbles me, for I know how many do not have it. I do not pretend that the pain of being invisible holds a candle to the daily risks of a life lived as a queer woman with a female partner, or multiple partners, or no partner at all. I do not claim that merely as an also-queer woman that I know what it is to live as a woman in relationship with a woman. To lay claim to that status is a hubris I strive to avoid -- sometimes at the cost of disassociating from my queer identity altogether.
I can speak with lived authority only of my own pains, my own risks, my own queernesses, small as they are: the pain of being invisible, the risk of either alienating others or dishonoring myself, the queerness of a sexuality half lived... the dilemma of what to do about the Boychick.
The only solution I see, if I cannot live my life obvious (as I once did unthinkingly, without knowing how sweet I had it) -- if I cannot not pass -- is to come out again, and again, and again. Only now am I seeing the value of practices like National Coming Out Day, for if there is one thing I might claim to know better than my woman-partnered sisters, it is invisibility. I may pass for straight, be seen as a breeder and thereby shoved into a closet again and again every moment of my child's life, but I don't have to quietly stay there.
I am happily monogamous with a man. I have a child. And I am bisexual.
I just came out to a new friend from massage school. You'd think the act --a short sentence, one second, two words: "I'm bisexual" -- would get easier over time, and with practice. But to the contrary, I find it harder now than it ever was before.
My first coming out as bisexual -- to my first crush, as a freshman in high school, just a few weeks after finally hearing the term and recognizing myself in it -- was met with an anticlimactic "well duh, Arwyn". Two years later, coming out to my first romantic relationship got me an amused "I know".
You might say I did not do in the closet well. I was -- and am, when I feel safe -- a voracious flirt, never adhered to straight female gender roles, and had Ru Paul pinups in my locker instead of the usual... who was usual to crush on? I never kept track. Anyway, "coming out" in adolescence was, contrary to most other QTBLGs' experience, ridiculously easy, an exercise in stating the obvious to anyone who spent any time with me. With the arrogance of ignorance and unacknowledged privilege, I scoffed (in the safety of my own cranium, at least, even then however dimly recognizing its privileged origins) at those who found it hard, who dithered and postponed and passed rather than come out and say it -- or simply live it.
And now, when the moment comes to say it or lie by omission, I find myself hemming and hawing and dithering, and, yes, sometimes shutting up and just plain passing. And I hate it. What happened to "duh"?
Duh is no more, after eleven years with a man (Mr "I know" himself in fact, my first and only), after leaving high school and college and the groups of friends I came out with. And it really vanished after getting pregnant and having a baby, with a man, in the "usual", heteronormative way. After all, I am, indubitably, a breeder now, and everyone knows "breeder" means "straight".
It doesn't matter in the public eye, it seems, what other signals I send: having a child, with a man, makes me straight. After all, this is the Pacific Northwest, and I run with a crunchy crowd: unshaven pits, Birkenstocks year round, having a "partner" instead of a "husband", and being stridently outspoken for "gay rights" merely marks me as yet another crazy white neo-hippie liberal.
Add to that a social network comprised almost entirely of other women-who-spend-the-day-with-their-kids, the fear of losing straight friends to innocent flirting (not an unreasonable fear, I think, in a culture that equates bisexuality with unquenchable nymphomania, and paints us as seductresses and adulterers when it bothers admitting our existence at all), and I find myself, for the first time since I was 14 years old, being perceived as straight not just by a homophobic heteronormative society, but by people who know me. For someone who has been explicitly, outspokenly out for so long, it is a decidedly unexpected and uncomfortable experience.
But the hardest part, the part I cannot figure out how to work around, is that I had always relied on "living out" -- being obvious, refusing to pass -- as my way of dealing with the issue of any children of mine knowing my sexuality. If it were simply a part of my public identity, a fact that anyone who knows me would know, then the Boychick would grow up knowing it, simply and easily and without any fuss. But the very act of his creation has taken my public identity as an out bisexual from hard to maintain (I've spent my entire adult life in a monogamous relationship with a man; it hasn't been exactly easy for a while) to seemingly impossible. To the extent that I "pass", that I am understood by others however falsely to be straight, I am confronted with a dilemma where the Boychick is concerned; being closeted (used here as a verb, of which I am the subject and others the actor) means that I would be forced to decide what and when -- and indeed, whether -- to tell him.
And who wants to hear about their parents' sexuality? If not a part of one's (public) identity, one's sexuality is a matter of what one wants to do to or with whom, which is not information I can see as entirely appropriate to share with my child. If not understood to be a part of my public identity, any outing of myself to him ("honey, I'm bisexual"), would necessarily be followed by his asking "what does that mean?", and then what would I tell him? "Oh nothing, just that sometimes I dream of shagging women, and used to chase the hot queer chicks in high school"? I think not.
I hear some of you wondering "then why bother telling him? if you're monogamous with a man, aren't you basically straight anyway? what does it matter what other people think?" All I can tell you is, it does matter. We are talking about no less than who I am, at my very foundation. I may pass, in this heteronormative society that is so fond of stuffing us in to boxes whether we like them or not, but rather than make my life easy as some may think, passing is excruciatingly painful, like a tourniquet on a limb, like being told every day the sky is yellow when I can see it is blue. It is being forced to agree to a lie I know to be false, a lie about myself. It may seem "unimportant", my sexuality a mere technicality, but in a thousand ways every day, unseen by those blinded by straightness, even a monogamous woman is expected to assert her heterosexuality; the straight world surrounds me with its memes, its jokes, its assumptions, its understanding of the world and of female/male relationships: each is just a tiny little prick to my psyche, but oh do they add up.
I live with enormous heaps of straight privilege. The fact that I can pass when needed, that I could when my unmarried partner was on death's door in a rural hospital in the Midwest proclaim myself his fiancée and thus claim access to his bedside and his medical information, is a huge privilege that humbles me, for I know how many do not have it. I do not pretend that the pain of being invisible holds a candle to the daily risks of a life lived as a queer woman with a female partner, or multiple partners, or no partner at all. I do not claim that merely as an also-queer woman that I know what it is to live as a woman in relationship with a woman. To lay claim to that status is a hubris I strive to avoid -- sometimes at the cost of disassociating from my queer identity altogether.
I can speak with lived authority only of my own pains, my own risks, my own queernesses, small as they are: the pain of being invisible, the risk of either alienating others or dishonoring myself, the queerness of a sexuality half lived... the dilemma of what to do about the Boychick.
The only solution I see, if I cannot live my life obvious (as I once did unthinkingly, without knowing how sweet I had it) -- if I cannot not pass -- is to come out again, and again, and again. Only now am I seeing the value of practices like National Coming Out Day, for if there is one thing I might claim to know better than my woman-partnered sisters, it is invisibility. I may pass for straight, be seen as a breeder and thereby shoved into a closet again and again every moment of my child's life, but I don't have to quietly stay there.
I am happily monogamous with a man. I have a child. And I am bisexual.
Sunday, March 22, 2009
Independence, attachment parenting, and societal misogyny
I was in one of those sort of surreal conversations the other day, where someone was telling me that, now that he's two, the Boychick really should spend some time away from The Man and me, so he can "develop independence".
I tried to stutter a defense about how he has a lot of independence already, just within the context of our family unit (see? I can't even articulate the thought well in retrospect), which earned me a patronizing head shake.
But it got me thinking: what IS independence? And why is it seen as so damned important?
Here's the thing: the Boychick has never been away from The Man or me. One or the other of us has been with him, been the one primarily responsible for overseeing his well-being, at all times. We've never had a "date night" where we left him with someone else. We're not, at this age, absolutely opposed to the idea, but we have no particular desire for it, either. We've had lots of dates, and lots of adult conversations, with the Boychick around, and all three of us like it that way just fine. (This is in no way meant to condemn those who do desire -- even need -- breaks from their children, dates with their partners, or to work in child-free environments part or full time. Although I am overtly and entirely in favor of attachment parenting, I have no desire to police what that looks like in other families, nor even whether they choose it or not.)
In the popular conception, at least in America, this makes the Boychick horribly smothered, denied the opportunity to be "independent", tied to us (literally, at times) in ways sure to stunt him in the long run.
And yet, no one would ever accuse us of being helicopter parents:
Modern American culture is horrified by almost all these things. We raise the spectre of Stranger Danger, of the Pedophile Lurking in the Bushes, of the omnipresent and omni-oppressive What If? at every turn, restricting and limiting and oppressing -- and yes, smothering -- our children, even as we push them away.
It seems to me, then, that The Man's and my sin in the eyes of "mainstream" culture is not failing to foster independence, but our refusal to force detachment -- what I sometimes call "pathological independence". It is our willingness and commitment to provide a safe base from which the Boychick may explore, and to which he always may return, that earns us ire and shaming clucks of the tongue.
Independence, no matter what popular culture says, cannot be created by forcing the chick out of the nest; that is only detachment, which teaches children they cannot trust those around them, and cuts off their rightful sense of interdependence. Real independence, which is entirely capable of coexistence with interdependence and thus dependence as well, is grown in to, at one's own pace, under one's own power, and comes from knowing that one is free to roam, free to leap, and yes, free to fall -- which children are so much more likely to risk when they know they have a soft space to land.
We spend so much time demanding "independence" in our offspring's infancy (demanding they sleep alone, forgo our embrace, learn to "self-soothe"), then refusing to let them taste anything approaching real independence (freedom to explore and exist unobserved and unoppressed, along with responsibilities to others who depend on them) when they are at the age they most need it. How much more backwards can we get?
To take this, once again, from the personal to the political: I suggest there is something inherently anti-feminist -- misogynist -- in this backwards stance.
First, we replace mother's own (ideal, biological default) milk with man-made artificial infant food; a parent's arms with artificial rockers, swings, play pens, etc; a parent's bed and a mother's breast with barred cribs and artificial white-noise and silicone "nipples"; we tell parents to ignore their instincts, and allow their babies to cry themselves to sleep. Not to put too much biology-is-destiny spin on it, but all of this serves to separate and detach the motherbaby -- which biologically ought still be thought of as one unit even after birth, only gradually and mutually separating over time (with "mother" here being substitutable with any number of close allomothers; the point being that infants and to a lesser extent toddlers biologically expect the constant presence of a known, loving, familiar adult or near-adult) -- damaging a mother's belief in her own abilities and conceptualizing her as broken, incomplete, inconsequential.
Then, when both primary caregiver and child ought to be naturally starting to get ready for the child to explore ever further afield, we demand constant vigilance: children must NEVER be left alone or unobserved for even a moment, "because something might happen, dun dun DUUUUUUUUUUUN!"; this serves to tie the primary caregiver, usually a woman (either the primary mother or a usually-female allomother in the form of daycare workers, school teachers, playground monitors, etc), to the child, never allowed to pursue her own goals and career, required always to have her attention focused completely and near-exclusively on the child(ren), or risk being cited negligent, labeled a Bad Mother -- even risk having her child(ren) taken away by a system that declares alone time under some arbitrary and ridiculously high age actually illegal.
This is classic patriarchy modus operandi: declare women broken, insufficient, lesser-than, dangerous even; then demand our complete sacrifice and subsumation of self under some pretext (which also inevitably serves its end goals), usually exactly counter to the previous demands (thereby, if we are to follow, requiring suspension of rational, logical thought); make it almost impossible to deviate from the demands (lack of allomothers, break up of neighbourhoods, laws and a Big Brother culture quick to dial 911 to enforce the norms); and punish us completely out of proportion to the "offense" if we dare to deviate.
So no, we're not going to leave the Boychick with a sitter or take him to daycare just so he can taste "independence"; nor will we refrain from leaving him in our yard to play, or home alone when he is ready, just so he can be "safe": I may not be totally (hah!) independent from the patriarchy, but neither will I bow down and allow it to define "independence" for my child.
I tried to stutter a defense about how he has a lot of independence already, just within the context of our family unit (see? I can't even articulate the thought well in retrospect), which earned me a patronizing head shake.
But it got me thinking: what IS independence? And why is it seen as so damned important?
Here's the thing: the Boychick has never been away from The Man or me. One or the other of us has been with him, been the one primarily responsible for overseeing his well-being, at all times. We've never had a "date night" where we left him with someone else. We're not, at this age, absolutely opposed to the idea, but we have no particular desire for it, either. We've had lots of dates, and lots of adult conversations, with the Boychick around, and all three of us like it that way just fine. (This is in no way meant to condemn those who do desire -- even need -- breaks from their children, dates with their partners, or to work in child-free environments part or full time. Although I am overtly and entirely in favor of attachment parenting, I have no desire to police what that looks like in other families, nor even whether they choose it or not.)
In the popular conception, at least in America, this makes the Boychick horribly smothered, denied the opportunity to be "independent", tied to us (literally, at times) in ways sure to stunt him in the long run.
And yet, no one would ever accuse us of being helicopter parents:
- At the park, I plop myself down on a bench with a book or my schoolwork or my iPhone, and gently encourage the Boychick to run and play -- and eventually, when he's ready to, he does, and wanders far and wide, though usually within my sight.
- At home, he plays on his own while I do my work, and has done since he was a few months old -- a few minutes at a time at first, in my lap or on the floor right next to me, now for hours a day (with numerous swings back to show me this or that), and often in other rooms.
- We are entirely in favor of free range parenting, and I, as a former latch-key kid who started biking home by myself at age 8, was recently horrified to discover that Oregon law strongly discourages children under 10 years old being left home alone for even "short" periods of time. (I also discovered I could be prosecuted for leaving my sleeping toddler in the car in our own driveway to run inside, pee, and get the bed ready for transferring him. But noooo, surely society is not at all oppressive of women-who-caretake!)
- We love the book Whistle for Willie, published in 1964, in part because of its portrayal of a perhaps 5-8 year old boy playing on his own in his neighbourhood, even getting sent on an errand to the corner store by himself -- of course, he's not actually alone, because there are several other kids also outside playing (without an adult in sight).
Modern American culture is horrified by almost all these things. We raise the spectre of Stranger Danger, of the Pedophile Lurking in the Bushes, of the omnipresent and omni-oppressive What If? at every turn, restricting and limiting and oppressing -- and yes, smothering -- our children, even as we push them away.
It seems to me, then, that The Man's and my sin in the eyes of "mainstream" culture is not failing to foster independence, but our refusal to force detachment -- what I sometimes call "pathological independence". It is our willingness and commitment to provide a safe base from which the Boychick may explore, and to which he always may return, that earns us ire and shaming clucks of the tongue.
Independence, no matter what popular culture says, cannot be created by forcing the chick out of the nest; that is only detachment, which teaches children they cannot trust those around them, and cuts off their rightful sense of interdependence. Real independence, which is entirely capable of coexistence with interdependence and thus dependence as well, is grown in to, at one's own pace, under one's own power, and comes from knowing that one is free to roam, free to leap, and yes, free to fall -- which children are so much more likely to risk when they know they have a soft space to land.
We spend so much time demanding "independence" in our offspring's infancy (demanding they sleep alone, forgo our embrace, learn to "self-soothe"), then refusing to let them taste anything approaching real independence (freedom to explore and exist unobserved and unoppressed, along with responsibilities to others who depend on them) when they are at the age they most need it. How much more backwards can we get?
To take this, once again, from the personal to the political: I suggest there is something inherently anti-feminist -- misogynist -- in this backwards stance.
First, we replace mother's own (ideal, biological default) milk with man-made artificial infant food; a parent's arms with artificial rockers, swings, play pens, etc; a parent's bed and a mother's breast with barred cribs and artificial white-noise and silicone "nipples"; we tell parents to ignore their instincts, and allow their babies to cry themselves to sleep. Not to put too much biology-is-destiny spin on it, but all of this serves to separate and detach the motherbaby -- which biologically ought still be thought of as one unit even after birth, only gradually and mutually separating over time (with "mother" here being substitutable with any number of close allomothers; the point being that infants and to a lesser extent toddlers biologically expect the constant presence of a known, loving, familiar adult or near-adult) -- damaging a mother's belief in her own abilities and conceptualizing her as broken, incomplete, inconsequential.
Then, when both primary caregiver and child ought to be naturally starting to get ready for the child to explore ever further afield, we demand constant vigilance: children must NEVER be left alone or unobserved for even a moment, "because something might happen, dun dun DUUUUUUUUUUUN!"; this serves to tie the primary caregiver, usually a woman (either the primary mother or a usually-female allomother in the form of daycare workers, school teachers, playground monitors, etc), to the child, never allowed to pursue her own goals and career, required always to have her attention focused completely and near-exclusively on the child(ren), or risk being cited negligent, labeled a Bad Mother -- even risk having her child(ren) taken away by a system that declares alone time under some arbitrary and ridiculously high age actually illegal.
This is classic patriarchy modus operandi: declare women broken, insufficient, lesser-than, dangerous even; then demand our complete sacrifice and subsumation of self under some pretext (which also inevitably serves its end goals), usually exactly counter to the previous demands (thereby, if we are to follow, requiring suspension of rational, logical thought); make it almost impossible to deviate from the demands (lack of allomothers, break up of neighbourhoods, laws and a Big Brother culture quick to dial 911 to enforce the norms); and punish us completely out of proportion to the "offense" if we dare to deviate.
So no, we're not going to leave the Boychick with a sitter or take him to daycare just so he can taste "independence"; nor will we refrain from leaving him in our yard to play, or home alone when he is ready, just so he can be "safe": I may not be totally (hah!) independent from the patriarchy, but neither will I bow down and allow it to define "independence" for my child.
Tuesday, March 17, 2009
Lesson learned
1 sick child + last of birthday carrot cake + 3/4 very large orange + 1 lemon fish pill = first ever non-spitup vomiting.
Lesson learned.
Please chime in with your life lessons (especially as pertains to toddlers and/or food and/or illness) so others (eg me) may gain from your experience! Or so we can laugh, which lightens our load, or so we can commiserate, which lightens yours. You know you have a story or three to share.
Lesson learned.
Please chime in with your life lessons (especially as pertains to toddlers and/or food and/or illness) so others (eg me) may gain from your experience! Or so we can laugh, which lightens our load, or so we can commiserate, which lightens yours. You know you have a story or three to share.
Monday, March 16, 2009
It's that time again
So, I forgot to post last month, and I almost didn't again this month (can I just say how bloody -- ahem! -- weird it is to be cycling the same as Renee, from whom I ruthlessly stole the idea for period posting to begin with? it's a little creepy, actually), but although you might have thought, wished even!, that I'd forgotten or given up, I laugh and say nay, it is time for another round of:
I'm menstruating!
Some thoughts this time around:
1) My luteal phase is short. Like, really short. 12-16 days from ovulation to menstruation is considered normal (18 is considered proof of pregnancy!); 10-11 is borderline infertile. This month it was 10. Last month it was 9. Nine. Now, I have really truly no desire to get pregnant again anytime soon, if ever (among other things, I am SO not nursing through pregnancy, and the Boychick is SO not ready to wean), but a 9-10 day luteal phase is just not healthy. It's a symptom of something being not right with me hormonally. I'm not sure what, if anything, I'm going to do with this information yet, but I'll be seeing my primary care doc in a month or so, and I'll talk with her about it then. While this doesn't exactly make me happy to know, it does actually feel good to KNOW that I know, if you know what I mean; super fun condomless baby-making-less sex is not the only reason I chart, and recommend charting to others; it's such a powerful tool for knowing what's going on with our bodies, and, as they say, knowledge is power.
2) I need more pads. I've needed more pads since I started cycling again. OK, I've needed more pads since I got off the pill and started having real periods instead of psuedoperiods, which is what I was having when I made the batch I'm currently using. And every month, I say "That's it, this time I'm really going to make more!" And every month, I don't. This month, though, I'm actually remembering why I didn't do it last month: we seem to have lost the custom pattern I made. Cutting and sewing new pads is enough work; I really, really am not up to reverse engineering the pattern anew, cutting it out and protecting it, and THEN cutting and sewing new pads, all while I am cramping and cranky and bleeding and racing to get it done while the toddler is distracted. So I resign myself to yet another cycle of making sure the wash gets done at least every day and a half, and pretend that this month, I really will make more pads before I really need them again. Really. I swear.
3) I need a "moon pot" (soaking bowl with lid for cloth menstrual pads), but in the meantime, I love that The Man has no problem with me taking over the sink for soaking for several days. His job in the morning is to drain the sink, squeeze the pads out a bit, and set them aside so he can brush his teeth, and he both doesn't complain and, when asked, doesn't see what there might be to complain about. He rocks.
That is all. Between bleeding, ill child, finals week, and the high likelihood that I'll be getting sick next, I anticipate a slow week blogging. See y'all around!
I'm menstruating!
Some thoughts this time around:
1) My luteal phase is short. Like, really short. 12-16 days from ovulation to menstruation is considered normal (18 is considered proof of pregnancy!); 10-11 is borderline infertile. This month it was 10. Last month it was 9. Nine. Now, I have really truly no desire to get pregnant again anytime soon, if ever (among other things, I am SO not nursing through pregnancy, and the Boychick is SO not ready to wean), but a 9-10 day luteal phase is just not healthy. It's a symptom of something being not right with me hormonally. I'm not sure what, if anything, I'm going to do with this information yet, but I'll be seeing my primary care doc in a month or so, and I'll talk with her about it then. While this doesn't exactly make me happy to know, it does actually feel good to KNOW that I know, if you know what I mean; super fun condomless baby-making-less sex is not the only reason I chart, and recommend charting to others; it's such a powerful tool for knowing what's going on with our bodies, and, as they say, knowledge is power.
2) I need more pads. I've needed more pads since I started cycling again. OK, I've needed more pads since I got off the pill and started having real periods instead of psuedoperiods, which is what I was having when I made the batch I'm currently using. And every month, I say "That's it, this time I'm really going to make more!" And every month, I don't. This month, though, I'm actually remembering why I didn't do it last month: we seem to have lost the custom pattern I made. Cutting and sewing new pads is enough work; I really, really am not up to reverse engineering the pattern anew, cutting it out and protecting it, and THEN cutting and sewing new pads, all while I am cramping and cranky and bleeding and racing to get it done while the toddler is distracted. So I resign myself to yet another cycle of making sure the wash gets done at least every day and a half, and pretend that this month, I really will make more pads before I really need them again. Really. I swear.
3) I need a "moon pot" (soaking bowl with lid for cloth menstrual pads), but in the meantime, I love that The Man has no problem with me taking over the sink for soaking for several days. His job in the morning is to drain the sink, squeeze the pads out a bit, and set them aside so he can brush his teeth, and he both doesn't complain and, when asked, doesn't see what there might be to complain about. He rocks.
That is all. Between bleeding, ill child, finals week, and the high likelihood that I'll be getting sick next, I anticipate a slow week blogging. See y'all around!
Sunday, March 15, 2009
Mmmm, caaaake...
Just for posterity, I thought I'd post the recipe for the Boychick's birthday carrot cake. I never manage to make quite the same cake twice (I always seem to forget which starting recipe I use), but I always make similar alterations, and according to some rather discriminating tasters, it always turns out well. I figure if I post it, maybe I'll actually remember to find it for next time, and not have to do all the work of finding and tinkering with a new recipe.
Here was this year's: (And no, it's not in metric measurements: sue me, I'm American! I'd be happy to change if every one else will, but in the meantime, my spoons say "teaspoon" and my cups say "cup", so it's what I use. Apologies to those living in more rational societies.)
Cake:
- 4 eggs
- 3/4 cup coconut oil
- 1 cup dehydrated cane syrup, aka "natural sugar"
- 1 cup brown sugar
- 1 cup ground flaxseed
- 1/2 teaspoon nutmeg
- 4 cups grated carrots
- 2-3 cups chopped walnuts
- 1 cup dried unsweetened shredded coconut
DIRECTIONS
- Preheat oven to 350 degrees F (175 degrees C).
- Grease and flour a 9x13 inch pan.
- Melt coconut oil in oven (eg in Pyrex measuring cup) or on stove.
- (Remove butter and cream cheese for frosting from refrigerator
and place on counter to soften.)
- In a small or medium bowl, mix flour, baking soda, baking powder, salt, nutmeg, and cinnamon.
- In a large bowl, beat together eggs, oil, sugar and vanilla.
- Stir in flour mixture. Do not over-stir.
- Stir in carrots. Fold (or "cut") in walnuts and coconut.
- Scoop and gently press into prepared pan. (Mixture will be stiff.)
- Bake in the preheated oven for 40 to 50 minutes, or until a toothpick inserted into the center of the cake comes out clean.
Frosting:
- 1/2 cup butter, softened
- 8 ounces cream cheese, softened
- 2-3 cups confectioners' sugar
- 1 1/2 teaspoon vanilla extract
DIRECTIONS:
- In a medium bowl, cream butter, cream cheese, and vanilla.
- Add confectioners' sugar. Beat until the mixture is smooth and creamy.
- Frost the cooled cake.
Enjoy; try not to allow sugar-high toddlers to overwhelm sugar-comatose adults.
Here was this year's: (And no, it's not in metric measurements: sue me, I'm American! I'd be happy to change if every one else will, but in the meantime, my spoons say "teaspoon" and my cups say "cup", so it's what I use. Apologies to those living in more rational societies.)
Cake:
- 4 eggs
- 3/4 cup coconut oil
- 1 cup dehydrated cane syrup, aka "natural sugar"
- 1 cup brown sugar
- 2-3 teaspoons vanilla extract
- 1 cup all-purpose flour
- 1 cup whole wheat flour- 1 cup all-purpose flour
- 1 cup ground flaxseed
- 2 teaspoons baking soda
- 2 teaspoons baking powder
- 1/2 teaspoon salt
- 1 tablespoon ground cinnamon- 2 teaspoons baking powder
- 1/2 teaspoon salt
- 1/2 teaspoon nutmeg
- 4 cups grated carrots
- 2-3 cups chopped walnuts
- 1 cup dried unsweetened shredded coconut
DIRECTIONS
- Preheat oven to 350 degrees F (175 degrees C).
- Grease and flour a 9x13 inch pan.
- (Remove butter and cream cheese for frosting from refrigerator
and place on counter to soften.)
- In a small or medium bowl, mix flour, baking soda, baking powder, salt, nutmeg, and cinnamon.
- In a large bowl, beat together eggs, oil, sugar and vanilla.
- Stir in flour mixture. Do not over-stir.
- Stir in carrots. Fold (or "cut") in walnuts and coconut.
- Scoop and gently press into prepared pan. (Mixture will be stiff.)
- Bake in the preheated oven for 40 to 50 minutes, or until a toothpick inserted into the center of the cake comes out clean.
- Let cool in pan for 10 minutes, then turn out onto a wire rack and cool completely. (Or, cool in pan while making frosting, then frost in pan.)
Frosting:
- 1/2 cup butter, softened
- 2-3 cups confectioners' sugar
- 1 1/2 teaspoon vanilla extract
DIRECTIONS:
- In a medium bowl, cream butter, cream cheese, and vanilla.
- Add confectioners' sugar. Beat until the mixture is smooth and creamy.
- Frost the cooled cake.
Enjoy; try not to allow sugar-high toddlers to overwhelm sugar-comatose adults.
Two years today
Two years ago today, you were inside me -- and then you weren't.
Two years ago today, I wasn't a mother -- and then I was.
Two years ago today, you were in me and my life was my own, and then you came out into my life, and it's been inevitably, irrevocably, incredibly changed by that one transcendent moment and all the millions of glorious, mundane, humbling, awesome moments that came after.
I so miss who you were, and I so enjoy who you are, and I can hardly wait to see who you will become.
My Boychick, my child, my little love: Thank you. I love you. Happy birthday.
Two years ago today, I wasn't a mother -- and then I was.
Two years ago today, you were in me and my life was my own, and then you came out into my life, and it's been inevitably, irrevocably, incredibly changed by that one transcendent moment and all the millions of glorious, mundane, humbling, awesome moments that came after.
I so miss who you were, and I so enjoy who you are, and I can hardly wait to see who you will become.
My Boychick, my child, my little love: Thank you. I love you. Happy birthday.
Thursday, March 12, 2009
More thoughts on the mommy wars
A thought I didn't quite articulate but alluded to in my last post:
There is a moderately sizable movement that purports to be "anti mommy wars", of which Dawn's post (and especially the comment thread, last I checked) is a very good example. This side takes the position that since the mommy wars are supposed to be WOHM v SAHM, breast v bottle, cosleep v cry it out, then they can sidestep the misogyny by saying none of it matters, just do whatever works for you.
It is not a position without merit. Certainly it is admirable in that it is attempting to get away from the us v them impotent infighting of the traditional mommy wars. It's very post-modern in its relativism, and all the more appealing therefore to a certain type of privileged intellectual (in which group I usually include myself; certainly relativism is my default stance on many topics).
The problem is, in trying to avoid the mommy wars by "rising above", it fails, and indeed perpetuates just another variation of it. When I read a comment thread like that, what I hear is "aren't we all so much better than those small little women who have Positions on those issues and try to advocate for them". It ends up being another case of the "nonjudg(e)mental" sounding at least as judgmental and superior as those they're complaining about.
Again, this isn't to pick on this article as an example, nor even to shame that idea's adherents as a whole; that would be both hypocritical and counterproductive. Instead, I'm hoping to point out how, once again, the patriarchy has managed to frame the conversation in such a way as to always advantage and privilege and perpetuate itself, by making sure some women somewhere in the conversation are getting hated on and put down; and worst of all, it's making us do it to ourselves, by people who are trying to do better.
So, taking a position in the mommy wars, playing in to the us v them, "if you're not doing it like me you're doing it wrong and you're a bad mom and shame on you" = hating on women and supporting the patriarchy.
And, not taking sides, saying "it's all the same, none of it matters in the long run, it's all about individual choice, shame on you for caring what anyone else does" = hating on women and supporting the patriarchy.
So what's left? It would appear to be a double bind, and certainly societal forces are going to use all their resources of shame and misrepresentation to try to stuff us in to one of those boxes, no matter how hard we try to escape them, but I do believe there is an alternate path, that can have a righteous moral position and avoid misogynistic mother shaming. And surprise surprise: it starts with blaming the patriarchy.
It starts with accepting and understanding the idea that women are people, with full moral agency and ability to make choices that are right for them; and that the we live in a patriarchy that severely and overtly and subtly oppresses women and constrains what options and resources we have available.
It starts with saying that if we are pro-choice, we damn well ought to be working to make sure that women have REAL choice, and the ability to choose, not just to fantasize about what we might do under other, better circumstances.
It starts with recognizing that the language of choice is privileged to start with, that the idea of bickering over whether staying home or having a career is laughable to a woman without class privilege, white privilege, hetero privilege, cisgender privilege, able privilege, neurotypical privilege, age privilege, who may be fighting just to keep her children fed, keep them uninjured, keep them unhated, keep them alive, or just keep them when society would declare her "unfit".
It starts with saying that the system is fucked, and that under the system we are fucked, and that patriarchy is our enemy, and women -- all women, women like us and women dissimilar, women who agree with us and women we vehemently disagree with -- are the ones we are fighting for, not fighting with, even if on some small skirmish they are on "the other side".
It starts with saying that while not all mothers are good mothers, most are, and that being a good mother has NOTHING to do with some stupid checklist, and everything to do with loving one's children and doing one's good enough to be good enough (not even necessarily one's best to be good enough), and that one's worth as a mother is not measurable by how one's child "turns out", and furthermore one's worth as a woman is not dependent on one's worth as a mother.
In short, it starts with recognizing and rejecting every lie the patriarchy tries to feed us about mothers and motherhood.
Got all that? Ok. Given that -- but try not to take it as a given, for I know I for one am prone to slipping up and forgetting parts or all on a regular basis -- we can direct our attacks at the systemic ways the patriarchy influences and constrains choices, and promotes choices that promote its own ends: how a culture of detachment which promotes a pathological level of "independence" encourages aggression and devalues women and their work; how birth practices and the birth culture shames and vilifies women's bodies, protects institutionalized violence against women, and removes women's confidence and trust in our own power; how the belittlization of breastfeeding and especially the attacks on nursing in public shames and vilifies women's bodies, and promotes a false dichotomy between a woman's freedom and her child's health.
I could go on, but that's sufficient to exemplify how a conversation could and must be framed to attack systems and institutions that devalue -- dehumanize -- women, without attacking women or their choices at all.
In such a conversation, we must remember that it is not -- cannot -- be the goal to have all women choose the "right" action, even as we recognize and believe that as the systems are rectified the proportions will shift. There will always be disagreement and variation and that must be not only accepted but celebrated. We must also remember that as we champion our causes, we must take issue with the ideology, never take issue with individuals. We can debate how various practices affect women's status, and value parenting practices for how they avoid or conform to patriarchal goals, without valuing individual women for how they "measure up" to some imposed ideal.
There will always be those who take offense, who take criticism of ideology as personal attack; there will be times when we slip up under the weight of patriarchal pressures and violate the above starting points; there will be those who simply deny or reject some or all of those precepts entirely; but as much as we are able within the patriarchal, misogynistic societies we live in, this can point our way toward avoiding the so-called "mommy wars" while still fighting for feminist paths in parenting.
And the patriarchy is gonna hate it.
There is a moderately sizable movement that purports to be "anti mommy wars", of which Dawn's post (and especially the comment thread, last I checked) is a very good example. This side takes the position that since the mommy wars are supposed to be WOHM v SAHM, breast v bottle, cosleep v cry it out, then they can sidestep the misogyny by saying none of it matters, just do whatever works for you.
It is not a position without merit. Certainly it is admirable in that it is attempting to get away from the us v them impotent infighting of the traditional mommy wars. It's very post-modern in its relativism, and all the more appealing therefore to a certain type of privileged intellectual (in which group I usually include myself; certainly relativism is my default stance on many topics).
The problem is, in trying to avoid the mommy wars by "rising above", it fails, and indeed perpetuates just another variation of it. When I read a comment thread like that, what I hear is "aren't we all so much better than those small little women who have Positions on those issues and try to advocate for them". It ends up being another case of the "nonjudg(e)mental" sounding at least as judgmental and superior as those they're complaining about.
Again, this isn't to pick on this article as an example, nor even to shame that idea's adherents as a whole; that would be both hypocritical and counterproductive. Instead, I'm hoping to point out how, once again, the patriarchy has managed to frame the conversation in such a way as to always advantage and privilege and perpetuate itself, by making sure some women somewhere in the conversation are getting hated on and put down; and worst of all, it's making us do it to ourselves, by people who are trying to do better.
So, taking a position in the mommy wars, playing in to the us v them, "if you're not doing it like me you're doing it wrong and you're a bad mom and shame on you" = hating on women and supporting the patriarchy.
And, not taking sides, saying "it's all the same, none of it matters in the long run, it's all about individual choice, shame on you for caring what anyone else does" = hating on women and supporting the patriarchy.
So what's left? It would appear to be a double bind, and certainly societal forces are going to use all their resources of shame and misrepresentation to try to stuff us in to one of those boxes, no matter how hard we try to escape them, but I do believe there is an alternate path, that can have a righteous moral position and avoid misogynistic mother shaming. And surprise surprise: it starts with blaming the patriarchy.
It starts with accepting and understanding the idea that women are people, with full moral agency and ability to make choices that are right for them; and that the we live in a patriarchy that severely and overtly and subtly oppresses women and constrains what options and resources we have available.
It starts with saying that if we are pro-choice, we damn well ought to be working to make sure that women have REAL choice, and the ability to choose, not just to fantasize about what we might do under other, better circumstances.
It starts with recognizing that the language of choice is privileged to start with, that the idea of bickering over whether staying home or having a career is laughable to a woman without class privilege, white privilege, hetero privilege, cisgender privilege, able privilege, neurotypical privilege, age privilege, who may be fighting just to keep her children fed, keep them uninjured, keep them unhated, keep them alive, or just keep them when society would declare her "unfit".
It starts with saying that the system is fucked, and that under the system we are fucked, and that patriarchy is our enemy, and women -- all women, women like us and women dissimilar, women who agree with us and women we vehemently disagree with -- are the ones we are fighting for, not fighting with, even if on some small skirmish they are on "the other side".
It starts with saying that while not all mothers are good mothers, most are, and that being a good mother has NOTHING to do with some stupid checklist, and everything to do with loving one's children and doing one's good enough to be good enough (not even necessarily one's best to be good enough), and that one's worth as a mother is not measurable by how one's child "turns out", and furthermore one's worth as a woman is not dependent on one's worth as a mother.
In short, it starts with recognizing and rejecting every lie the patriarchy tries to feed us about mothers and motherhood.
Got all that? Ok. Given that -- but try not to take it as a given, for I know I for one am prone to slipping up and forgetting parts or all on a regular basis -- we can direct our attacks at the systemic ways the patriarchy influences and constrains choices, and promotes choices that promote its own ends: how a culture of detachment which promotes a pathological level of "independence" encourages aggression and devalues women and their work; how birth practices and the birth culture shames and vilifies women's bodies, protects institutionalized violence against women, and removes women's confidence and trust in our own power; how the belittlization of breastfeeding and especially the attacks on nursing in public shames and vilifies women's bodies, and promotes a false dichotomy between a woman's freedom and her child's health.
I could go on, but that's sufficient to exemplify how a conversation could and must be framed to attack systems and institutions that devalue -- dehumanize -- women, without attacking women or their choices at all.
In such a conversation, we must remember that it is not -- cannot -- be the goal to have all women choose the "right" action, even as we recognize and believe that as the systems are rectified the proportions will shift. There will always be disagreement and variation and that must be not only accepted but celebrated. We must also remember that as we champion our causes, we must take issue with the ideology, never take issue with individuals. We can debate how various practices affect women's status, and value parenting practices for how they avoid or conform to patriarchal goals, without valuing individual women for how they "measure up" to some imposed ideal.
There will always be those who take offense, who take criticism of ideology as personal attack; there will be times when we slip up under the weight of patriarchal pressures and violate the above starting points; there will be those who simply deny or reject some or all of those precepts entirely; but as much as we are able within the patriarchal, misogynistic societies we live in, this can point our way toward avoiding the so-called "mommy wars" while still fighting for feminist paths in parenting.
And the patriarchy is gonna hate it.
Wednesday, March 11, 2009
The patriarchy loves the mommy wars
Dawn at this woman's work has an interesting post up about should-ing on an already overwhelmed mother. She framed it as those self-righteous LLLers (these, I should say, as she was one of them) versus a woman who just needed to hear that CIO (the act of leaving a baby alone to "cry it out" as a method of sleep training) was just fine in her situation.
I take objection to this, yes in part because I am a "self-righteous LLL-type" who believes that CIO is harmful (to infants, to their parents, and to the adults they grow into), but mostly because I think the situation thus framed misses the point.
The point? US society hates women, and alternatingly exalts (without offering any actual support), hates, and ignores mothers. Anytime an issue like this is framed as an individual choice issue, while neglecting to point out the ways in which the patriarchy has forced women in to this bind in the first place, we're supporting the patriarchy and its lies about women and mothers and parenting.
The point here should not be to tsk the LLL women for failing to encourage a harmful practice, nor to applaud the woman for taking care of her own needs so she doesn't endanger her children; the point should be that in a sane society, no way would a woman with three children under five be expected to care for them essentially on her own, with a "partner" in the picture only enough to pay the bills. Of course she's exhausted, and of course she shouldn't be shamed or blamed for doing something -- the only thing available to her -- to get enough sleep to stay sane and able to function during the day. But it's criminal that she was put in that position in the first place; there should be parental leave and daycare subsidies and mother's helpers and community resources available to make sure she and her infant got the sleep and the care they needed and deserved.
And I know I just railed against placing individual blame, but now let me encourage individual responsibility by saying that "community" can and must (for the patriarchy surely isn't going to step up to the plate) start with us. Rather than condemning or encouraging an individual "choosing" CIO, why don't concerned community members pitch in to make it unnecessary? In this situation, the LLL members could have offered to take her other children for a few afternoons so she could sleep when the baby napped. They could have pitched together to bring her dinners for her family and cleaned her house while her partner was out of town to take some of her burdens off. The truly radical could have offered to take the baby overnight to nurse for her so she could have a night of blissful, restorative, uninterrupted sleep. And regardless of what this woman did, they could spend a couple hours every month sending letters and calling their representatives -- or the HR departments of local businesses! -- to make sure their money went where their mouths are to support real family friendly policies.
The point of this isn't to turn around and shame the LLL ladies, who were only trying to do their best, as was the mom of three, but to attempt to reframe the conversation. All too often we see this as a mommy war issue -- sanctimonious APers v pragmatic CIOers -- on which we are supposed to take "sides", without anyone taking issue with the whole mommy war idea to start with. I will never stop saying CIO is harmful, but there's a whole universe of ways to support women without compromising on that issue; we just have to start taking a broader, and dare I say more political, view first. Stop blaming individuals, either way: start blaming the patriarchy.
I take objection to this, yes in part because I am a "self-righteous LLL-type" who believes that CIO is harmful (to infants, to their parents, and to the adults they grow into), but mostly because I think the situation thus framed misses the point.
The point? US society hates women, and alternatingly exalts (without offering any actual support), hates, and ignores mothers. Anytime an issue like this is framed as an individual choice issue, while neglecting to point out the ways in which the patriarchy has forced women in to this bind in the first place, we're supporting the patriarchy and its lies about women and mothers and parenting.
The point here should not be to tsk the LLL women for failing to encourage a harmful practice, nor to applaud the woman for taking care of her own needs so she doesn't endanger her children; the point should be that in a sane society, no way would a woman with three children under five be expected to care for them essentially on her own, with a "partner" in the picture only enough to pay the bills. Of course she's exhausted, and of course she shouldn't be shamed or blamed for doing something -- the only thing available to her -- to get enough sleep to stay sane and able to function during the day. But it's criminal that she was put in that position in the first place; there should be parental leave and daycare subsidies and mother's helpers and community resources available to make sure she and her infant got the sleep and the care they needed and deserved.
And I know I just railed against placing individual blame, but now let me encourage individual responsibility by saying that "community" can and must (for the patriarchy surely isn't going to step up to the plate) start with us. Rather than condemning or encouraging an individual "choosing" CIO, why don't concerned community members pitch in to make it unnecessary? In this situation, the LLL members could have offered to take her other children for a few afternoons so she could sleep when the baby napped. They could have pitched together to bring her dinners for her family and cleaned her house while her partner was out of town to take some of her burdens off. The truly radical could have offered to take the baby overnight to nurse for her so she could have a night of blissful, restorative, uninterrupted sleep. And regardless of what this woman did, they could spend a couple hours every month sending letters and calling their representatives -- or the HR departments of local businesses! -- to make sure their money went where their mouths are to support real family friendly policies.
The point of this isn't to turn around and shame the LLL ladies, who were only trying to do their best, as was the mom of three, but to attempt to reframe the conversation. All too often we see this as a mommy war issue -- sanctimonious APers v pragmatic CIOers -- on which we are supposed to take "sides", without anyone taking issue with the whole mommy war idea to start with. I will never stop saying CIO is harmful, but there's a whole universe of ways to support women without compromising on that issue; we just have to start taking a broader, and dare I say more political, view first. Stop blaming individuals, either way: start blaming the patriarchy.
Tuesday, March 10, 2009
Here, have a quickie
Since The Man surviving another round of layoffs today (his company is, we swear, trying to downsize itself out of existence) is a blessing that nevertheless makes me scared shitless, and I have 57% of my take home final (which is due at exactly 6:30pm tomorrow) left to do, oh, and I'm up waaaaaaaaaaay too late as it is, here's a quickie link post for your perusing pleasure...
The difficult but beautiful: I just discovered Crazy Like Us? ("[UK] Feminists write about mental health") and am in love. Some raw honest painful beauty in there. I recommend it only for high spoon days, but I definitely recommend it.
Next up, the outdated but still oh-so-needed: a post revisiting Classic Feminist Programming for Children. If there were a Classic Feminist Programming channel, we might not be TV-free anymore.
And finally, the purely offtopic just 'cause it makes me happy: Beaker sings. How can you not love it?
The difficult but beautiful: I just discovered Crazy Like Us? ("[UK] Feminists write about mental health") and am in love. Some raw honest painful beauty in there. I recommend it only for high spoon days, but I definitely recommend it.
Next up, the outdated but still oh-so-needed: a post revisiting Classic Feminist Programming for Children. If there were a Classic Feminist Programming channel, we might not be TV-free anymore.
And finally, the purely offtopic just 'cause it makes me happy: Beaker sings. How can you not love it?
Saturday, March 7, 2009
What price mental health? part II
The overall piece is on the literal and figurative costs of bipolar disorder: getting to sanity, staying sane while parenting, and raising a child with a high likelihood of inheriting the tendency. Part one, the preamble, is here. Part two covers the actual dollar costs of getting me to stable; I have limited it to a particular time period in my life during which my primary focus was on my own (mental) health, although if I traced the journey from beginning to end there would be years added on, with the potential for a case being made to count my entire birth to now; that, however, would not be as readily calculable. Thus, the following is about the years 2002-2005, when The Man and I lived, for various reasons, in the middle of America, far away from anyone and anything we knew.
The things it took to bring me from hell to now (not heaven, but the glorious mundanity of earth) were: talk therapy; psychotropic medications; massage therapy; acupuncture; lots and lots of fish oil; and lifestyle and thought pattern and dietary changes too numerous and subtle to list here (arguably the biggest and most important of those: regular and regulated sleep, which is one of the many reasons new parents whether biological or not are at risk for PPD and other postpartum disorders). It took several years, and a hell of a lot of work, and ultimately required moving across the country out of a psychic-black-hole cesspool of a house and to a city where my heart sang "Home!" to get to a real, lasting, joyful stability.
And it cost a lot of money.
How much money exactly? First, I should point out that because of where we were and how I was doing, my parents financed all of this. There is simply no way I could have done any of this without them; I could probably not afford to do it all even now. The privilege in having parents who were able and willing to do this for me is breathtaking and humbling. I was blessed to be the late-born daughter of doctorate-holding, career-stable, mortgage-paying, middle-class, married white American parents who are mental-health knowledgeable and alternative-therapy-tolerant. If not for them and for their multiple states of privilege, I simply would not have been able to spend those years pursuing health and stability in the way I did, and would likely not be sane today. It is privilege, pure and simple, that allowed me to, via my parents, afford these things. It is criminal that so many do not have the financial or social access to resources that my privilege granted me. I take none of this for granted. (Conversely, at least a significant portion of these costs could have been avoided with even a rudimentary Universal Health Care system in place. If that be socialism, than socialist I be.)
And now, in the honor of American tax time, an itemized list, primarily covering the years 2002-2005 (unlike the IRS, I do not expect an audit; numbers are rounded and approximated for ease of calculation):
First, there was the health insurance, which you will see did not do much to pay for the things that got me to wellness, but was viewed as necessary by those around me; to be sure, we would all have been grateful for it should a hospitalization ever have proven necessary. The first year or so I was still, barely, able to be on my parents' employer subsidized insurance, at probably $75/month (did I mention they had good jobs?). The next two years they paid for COBRA coverage for me, at approximately $400/month, after which I had no insurance. Total cost: $10,500
There was the psychotropic medication, a "premium" formulation new enough it was not on my insurance's preferred formulary, but considered worth it because I only had to take it once a day, and had more flexibility in timing its ingestion without incurring negative effects. I was on it for approximately the same three years I had health insurance, at $80 every three months. Sub total: $640. There were also numerous blood draws and psychiatric visits for medication management, not all of which were covered for one reason or another (my medication cessation management was overseen by a DO, after I lost insurance, with whom each visit was over $100), and a brief (comparatively) stint on an additional antidepressant medication and the attendant psych visits. So, let's call the total an even $1000.
When medication alone proved not to be sufficient, I was recommended by a college adviser to see a psychologist known for his quirky humor and Buddhist-influenced woo-ish talk therapy, with particular experience with bipolar spectrum disorders. We were, indeed, a good fit, and I saw him nearly every week for those four years; the attempt to switch to every two weeks proved problematical, as did the attempt to switch therapists. He charged $100 per 50 minute session (he actually raised it $5 every calendar year I saw him, and was due to hit $115 when we moved back across the continent; conveniently averaging $100 for the four years I saw him). And my insurance did cover him, with only a $15 copay... for the first 22 visits a year. Copay subtotal: $1000. Out of pocket total: $14,400.
Counterpoint to talk therapy was massage therapy; massage grounded me, tethered me to reality and the body and the now at times when I felt like flying right out of my skin. It also helped me learn to accept and love my body again, after side effects of the medication made me feel it had betrayed me. I was blessed to have first one and then another excellent massage therapist, each of whom was willing to offer me amazing deals that amounted to $100/month for biweekly or semimonthly massage. Times three years (2003-2005), that totals: $3600
Acupuncture I started a year after massage therapy, on alternate biweeks from the massage; with offering me a student discount, even though I was primarily studying myself at that point in my life, sessions were $40 each, a bargain when his sessions were 1.5-2 hours, and we have yet to find another acupuncturist who holds a candle to how caring, involved, respectful, informative, and effective he was. Total cost: $1900
What finally clicked for me (although it could not have worked without all the rest of it) was high omega 3 (specifically EPA 50% by weight) fish oil. I had heard bits about it in terms of mental health before, but was convinced to start trying it based on a metastudy published in a peer-reviewed psychiatric journal that showed high EPA was as or more effective than standard psychiatric medications for mild to moderate cases of bipolar disorder, depression, bipolar depression, and even schitzophrenia. I started taking it a year or so before getting off the psychotropic mood stabilizer, and finally felt what I imagine the prescription was supposed to feel like: real mood stability and uplift. This is hardest to calculate, because my dose has fluctuated so much over the years, from as little as 2 caps to as many as 8 a day. My most common dose, though, was 2g twice a day; thus, at $15 for a 90-capsule bottle (purchased online at 50% discount off the $30 retail price), over two years, totals $500.
There were many other pieces to bridge to sanity I built, but though not without cost, they are harder to put a price tag on: getting regular and regulated sleep (8-10 hours, every night, no exceptions, which at times meant turning down concerts with friends, trips to big cities, and all of my night-writing, which is previously when I'd gotten the bulk of my inspirations); learning to listen to and trust my body, and eating foods that truly nourished me; avoiding anything that encouraged the mind-fuck mentality, which is pretty much all American media (and most Americans); avoiding artificial additives as much as possible; and avoiding subjecting myself to unnecessary stressors in all forms, from full time regular employment to countless well-practiced thought patterns. Did I mention it took a lot of work? But that was largely of the emotion-work category, which we are oh so good at avoiding in our calculations of Gross Domestic Product, so we'll leave those out of these numbers (how does one count the cost of taking an hour to go outside and connect with the dirt for a while? it was on a doctor's orders, but somehow I don't think I could bill my insurance for it).
Grand total of the pieces easy to quantify: $31,900.
$31,900
For my international readers, that's 25213 Euro, 22569 GBP, 41080 CAD, or 49754 AUD, in today's currency at least (converter found here). That's more than The Man's mother grossed in an entire year, even right before retirement, after 20 years at the same job as a nurse's aide. Then again, it's only one base-price luxury compact SUV. It's half of what the mortgage on the hell-hole house was, two-thirds of what we sold it for.
It's a lot of money.
Some of these numbers have been very hard for me to type. $14,400 to sit in a room and talk to a guy for an hour once a week (total talk time: 200 hours)? Seriously? And yet, it was invaluable in terms of my mental health. Many weeks I walked out wondering what the point of it was; but each week, little by little, with leaps forward and setbacks suffered, life got better. Weeks I decided I didn't need it, it wasn't "doing anything", and didn't go in, were the hardest weeks to get through.
Maybe I could have, should have, gotten that therapy free from a 12 step program (which one, though? I had avoided most of the addictions commonly used to self-treat bipolar disorder, such as alcohol, drugs, sex, and shopping. where in that small town was the 12 step program for the woman who had everything and could do nothing? for moody artistic introspective types who didn't plan or attempt suicide, nor cut open her flesh, but found getting a nice rhythm going with her head on the wall quite soothing? there may be a hundred AA-inspired groups out there, but some niches are yet to be covered), but this was what was available, this was what worked for me.
To own those numbers without hesitation or reservation, I have to be able to say, at some level, I am worth it. And I am. But even 200 hours of therapy hasn't made that easy for me to proclaim, when everything in my culture tells me different.
How hard is it to admit to this much privilege? Very. (About $31,900 hard?) I could not have afforded this on my own. The Man's mother, even if she were alive and still working at that time, couldn't have afforded it. My own parents, after a long illness and a stock market crash, couldn't afford it now. The privilege of being supported, not having to work for my food or shelter, taking four years to work exclusively on my self and my health... it is profound.
Will we be able to afford this for the Boychick? Will he need it? I pray he won't, and we will even so, but the thought terrifies me.
Scarier thought still: will I need it again? Will he be raised by a mother, not blessed with sanity paid for with privilege, but wracked with instability and unable to sufficiently treat it?
cont. in part III
The things it took to bring me from hell to now (not heaven, but the glorious mundanity of earth) were: talk therapy; psychotropic medications; massage therapy; acupuncture; lots and lots of fish oil; and lifestyle and thought pattern and dietary changes too numerous and subtle to list here (arguably the biggest and most important of those: regular and regulated sleep, which is one of the many reasons new parents whether biological or not are at risk for PPD and other postpartum disorders). It took several years, and a hell of a lot of work, and ultimately required moving across the country out of a psychic-black-hole cesspool of a house and to a city where my heart sang "Home!" to get to a real, lasting, joyful stability.
And it cost a lot of money.
How much money exactly? First, I should point out that because of where we were and how I was doing, my parents financed all of this. There is simply no way I could have done any of this without them; I could probably not afford to do it all even now. The privilege in having parents who were able and willing to do this for me is breathtaking and humbling. I was blessed to be the late-born daughter of doctorate-holding, career-stable, mortgage-paying, middle-class, married white American parents who are mental-health knowledgeable and alternative-therapy-tolerant. If not for them and for their multiple states of privilege, I simply would not have been able to spend those years pursuing health and stability in the way I did, and would likely not be sane today. It is privilege, pure and simple, that allowed me to, via my parents, afford these things. It is criminal that so many do not have the financial or social access to resources that my privilege granted me. I take none of this for granted. (Conversely, at least a significant portion of these costs could have been avoided with even a rudimentary Universal Health Care system in place. If that be socialism, than socialist I be.)
And now, in the honor of American tax time, an itemized list, primarily covering the years 2002-2005 (unlike the IRS, I do not expect an audit; numbers are rounded and approximated for ease of calculation):
First, there was the health insurance, which you will see did not do much to pay for the things that got me to wellness, but was viewed as necessary by those around me; to be sure, we would all have been grateful for it should a hospitalization ever have proven necessary. The first year or so I was still, barely, able to be on my parents' employer subsidized insurance, at probably $75/month (did I mention they had good jobs?). The next two years they paid for COBRA coverage for me, at approximately $400/month, after which I had no insurance. Total cost: $10,500
There was the psychotropic medication, a "premium" formulation new enough it was not on my insurance's preferred formulary, but considered worth it because I only had to take it once a day, and had more flexibility in timing its ingestion without incurring negative effects. I was on it for approximately the same three years I had health insurance, at $80 every three months. Sub total: $640. There were also numerous blood draws and psychiatric visits for medication management, not all of which were covered for one reason or another (my medication cessation management was overseen by a DO, after I lost insurance, with whom each visit was over $100), and a brief (comparatively) stint on an additional antidepressant medication and the attendant psych visits. So, let's call the total an even $1000.
When medication alone proved not to be sufficient, I was recommended by a college adviser to see a psychologist known for his quirky humor and Buddhist-influenced woo-ish talk therapy, with particular experience with bipolar spectrum disorders. We were, indeed, a good fit, and I saw him nearly every week for those four years; the attempt to switch to every two weeks proved problematical, as did the attempt to switch therapists. He charged $100 per 50 minute session (he actually raised it $5 every calendar year I saw him, and was due to hit $115 when we moved back across the continent; conveniently averaging $100 for the four years I saw him). And my insurance did cover him, with only a $15 copay... for the first 22 visits a year. Copay subtotal: $1000. Out of pocket total: $14,400.
Counterpoint to talk therapy was massage therapy; massage grounded me, tethered me to reality and the body and the now at times when I felt like flying right out of my skin. It also helped me learn to accept and love my body again, after side effects of the medication made me feel it had betrayed me. I was blessed to have first one and then another excellent massage therapist, each of whom was willing to offer me amazing deals that amounted to $100/month for biweekly or semimonthly massage. Times three years (2003-2005), that totals: $3600
Acupuncture I started a year after massage therapy, on alternate biweeks from the massage; with offering me a student discount, even though I was primarily studying myself at that point in my life, sessions were $40 each, a bargain when his sessions were 1.5-2 hours, and we have yet to find another acupuncturist who holds a candle to how caring, involved, respectful, informative, and effective he was. Total cost: $1900
What finally clicked for me (although it could not have worked without all the rest of it) was high omega 3 (specifically EPA 50% by weight) fish oil. I had heard bits about it in terms of mental health before, but was convinced to start trying it based on a metastudy published in a peer-reviewed psychiatric journal that showed high EPA was as or more effective than standard psychiatric medications for mild to moderate cases of bipolar disorder, depression, bipolar depression, and even schitzophrenia. I started taking it a year or so before getting off the psychotropic mood stabilizer, and finally felt what I imagine the prescription was supposed to feel like: real mood stability and uplift. This is hardest to calculate, because my dose has fluctuated so much over the years, from as little as 2 caps to as many as 8 a day. My most common dose, though, was 2g twice a day; thus, at $15 for a 90-capsule bottle (purchased online at 50% discount off the $30 retail price), over two years, totals $500.
There were many other pieces to bridge to sanity I built, but though not without cost, they are harder to put a price tag on: getting regular and regulated sleep (8-10 hours, every night, no exceptions, which at times meant turning down concerts with friends, trips to big cities, and all of my night-writing, which is previously when I'd gotten the bulk of my inspirations); learning to listen to and trust my body, and eating foods that truly nourished me; avoiding anything that encouraged the mind-fuck mentality, which is pretty much all American media (and most Americans); avoiding artificial additives as much as possible; and avoiding subjecting myself to unnecessary stressors in all forms, from full time regular employment to countless well-practiced thought patterns. Did I mention it took a lot of work? But that was largely of the emotion-work category, which we are oh so good at avoiding in our calculations of Gross Domestic Product, so we'll leave those out of these numbers (how does one count the cost of taking an hour to go outside and connect with the dirt for a while? it was on a doctor's orders, but somehow I don't think I could bill my insurance for it).
Grand total of the pieces easy to quantify: $31,900.
$31,900
For my international readers, that's 25213 Euro, 22569 GBP, 41080 CAD, or 49754 AUD, in today's currency at least (converter found here). That's more than The Man's mother grossed in an entire year, even right before retirement, after 20 years at the same job as a nurse's aide. Then again, it's only one base-price luxury compact SUV. It's half of what the mortgage on the hell-hole house was, two-thirds of what we sold it for.
It's a lot of money.
Some of these numbers have been very hard for me to type. $14,400 to sit in a room and talk to a guy for an hour once a week (total talk time: 200 hours)? Seriously? And yet, it was invaluable in terms of my mental health. Many weeks I walked out wondering what the point of it was; but each week, little by little, with leaps forward and setbacks suffered, life got better. Weeks I decided I didn't need it, it wasn't "doing anything", and didn't go in, were the hardest weeks to get through.
Maybe I could have, should have, gotten that therapy free from a 12 step program (which one, though? I had avoided most of the addictions commonly used to self-treat bipolar disorder, such as alcohol, drugs, sex, and shopping. where in that small town was the 12 step program for the woman who had everything and could do nothing? for moody artistic introspective types who didn't plan or attempt suicide, nor cut open her flesh, but found getting a nice rhythm going with her head on the wall quite soothing? there may be a hundred AA-inspired groups out there, but some niches are yet to be covered), but this was what was available, this was what worked for me.
To own those numbers without hesitation or reservation, I have to be able to say, at some level, I am worth it. And I am. But even 200 hours of therapy hasn't made that easy for me to proclaim, when everything in my culture tells me different.
How hard is it to admit to this much privilege? Very. (About $31,900 hard?) I could not have afforded this on my own. The Man's mother, even if she were alive and still working at that time, couldn't have afforded it. My own parents, after a long illness and a stock market crash, couldn't afford it now. The privilege of being supported, not having to work for my food or shelter, taking four years to work exclusively on my self and my health... it is profound.
Will we be able to afford this for the Boychick? Will he need it? I pray he won't, and we will even so, but the thought terrifies me.
Scarier thought still: will I need it again? Will he be raised by a mother, not blessed with sanity paid for with privilege, but wracked with instability and unable to sufficiently treat it?
cont. in part III
Friday, March 6, 2009
I'm so happy the Boychick didn't nap
Normally, I hate no-nap days. And I really, really wasn't expecting today to be one, after the 2 mile hike at a local state park (two hours of running around a forest with five other 2-5 year olds), tiring out enough to want up in the sling (! and I almost didn't bother bringing it, it's been so long since he's wanted it) at the very end, then a nice looooong drive home. He didn't quite tucker out in the car as we'd hoped, but came home nicely worn out. And then he voluntarily climbed in to bed and yelled at me to come nap with him. Sweet! I thought. Alas, not so much. The Man comes home at 4:30pm, not calling even though he's home early, because he was sure the Boychick would be asleep. Hah! No such luck.
So why am I so happy? Because right now, the cat and I have the house to ourselves, while The Man and the Boychick and the dog take a walk -- with the Boychick happily riding on his father's back.
Twice in one day! Since the time about four months ago he discovered he could walk in stores, and started insisting on walking everywhere "my own self!", babywearing tanked from something we did 1-12 times a day to something measured in times per month. As in maybe twice a month.
I haven't really written about the cessation of babywearing, although it's something I think about a lot. I smile in melancholy remembrance when I see a sleeping toddler on a back in the library, an alert infant on a hip in a pouch, a tell-tale bump of baby under a stretchy wrap. It actually hurts to think about not having that anymore.
I sometimes put off the hurt by joking "Didn't he get the memo that babywearing leads to over dependence?" I mean, really. Worn every single day for the first 1.5+ years of life, napped exclusively in a lap or carrier or in bed with us (ok, sometimes in the carseat, though only in the car!) until well over a year, never bothered with or needed a stroller or pram, still breastfeeding at 2 with no end in sight... He should be the poster child for all the "ONOZ, AP=clingy spoiled brat that'll never let you put hir down!!" types, right?
I wish. No, really, I do; at least, a part of me does. I miss wearing him, miss that physical closeness, the snuggles, the weight and feel and smell of him. So, maybe my back doesn't miss it, but it was always worth it.
And I miss seeing him and The Man together. Although they still have so many sweet, caring moments together, so many hugs and kisses and snuggles, I miss the pure joy of watching my two favorite people together like that, enjoying the sight of the at once utterly mundane and sublime expression of love that babywearing is.
So even though a late nap (for they returned, the Boychick's eyes oh so heavily lidded, and he nursed to sleep at last in my arms) means a hard night, and a hard tomorrow, it was worth it; the hard night, the closet full of carriers kept just in case, the emergency carrier stashed in the car, the chiropractor visits for wearing 30 squirming pounds: it's all worth it, just to have him close, to see that joy, to be able to say "yes, even though you walk everywhere your own self now, we will still be here to carry you whenever you wish, as long as you need". That, as they say, is priceless.
So why am I so happy? Because right now, the cat and I have the house to ourselves, while The Man and the Boychick and the dog take a walk -- with the Boychick happily riding on his father's back.
Twice in one day! Since the time about four months ago he discovered he could walk in stores, and started insisting on walking everywhere "my own self!", babywearing tanked from something we did 1-12 times a day to something measured in times per month. As in maybe twice a month.
I haven't really written about the cessation of babywearing, although it's something I think about a lot. I smile in melancholy remembrance when I see a sleeping toddler on a back in the library, an alert infant on a hip in a pouch, a tell-tale bump of baby under a stretchy wrap. It actually hurts to think about not having that anymore.
I sometimes put off the hurt by joking "Didn't he get the memo that babywearing leads to over dependence?" I mean, really. Worn every single day for the first 1.5+ years of life, napped exclusively in a lap or carrier or in bed with us (ok, sometimes in the carseat, though only in the car!) until well over a year, never bothered with or needed a stroller or pram, still breastfeeding at 2 with no end in sight... He should be the poster child for all the "ONOZ, AP=clingy spoiled brat that'll never let you put hir down!!" types, right?
I wish. No, really, I do; at least, a part of me does. I miss wearing him, miss that physical closeness, the snuggles, the weight and feel and smell of him. So, maybe my back doesn't miss it, but it was always worth it.
And I miss seeing him and The Man together. Although they still have so many sweet, caring moments together, so many hugs and kisses and snuggles, I miss the pure joy of watching my two favorite people together like that, enjoying the sight of the at once utterly mundane and sublime expression of love that babywearing is.
So even though a late nap (for they returned, the Boychick's eyes oh so heavily lidded, and he nursed to sleep at last in my arms) means a hard night, and a hard tomorrow, it was worth it; the hard night, the closet full of carriers kept just in case, the emergency carrier stashed in the car, the chiropractor visits for wearing 30 squirming pounds: it's all worth it, just to have him close, to see that joy, to be able to say "yes, even though you walk everywhere your own self now, we will still be here to carry you whenever you wish, as long as you need". That, as they say, is priceless.
Tuesday, March 3, 2009
Why "presumably-straight"?
My friend Lisa asked in a comment on another post:
Why do you say your son is "presumably straight"?It's a good question, one I realized I haven't explicitly answered anywhere yet. In thinking about it, it seems to come down to three things:
- He probably is (going to be) straight. Even with a queer-identified mother (which may or may not affect the odds, and if so, doesn't very much), he has, what, a 90-99% chance of identifying as heterosexual, depending on whose numbers you believe? So, simply, I use "presumably" because it sounds better than "probably", and he probably is.
- Although he probably is (going to be) straight, he might not be. Saying he "presumably" is straight is opening up the door to the idea that he might be something other than straight, and hopefully challenges people's assumptions. Which brings us to:
- In our heterosexist, heteronormative society, he is presumed by the wider culture (to the point of few even being aware of the presumption) to be straight until proven otherwise. While I do my best to resist this presumption, or to counter it when we encounter it, I cannot entirely do away with it, as much as I might wish. I sometimes feel I can hardly do away with it at all. The vast majority of interactions he has with others are and will continue to be based on the presumption that he is (going to be) straight, and this assumption/presumption colors far more than we are usually aware. Whether or not it turns out to be who in fact he is (he might turn out to not be a "he" at all; I could easily add "presumably" in front of male as well), he will be seen by most in his life as a straight white male (yes, even as a toddler; even at birth!), with all the privilege and roles and stereotypes thereof; and it will affect him, subtly and profoundly; and my only hope of countering the damage those role assignments bring lies in first recognizing them.
Labels:
gender roles,
identity,
male privilege,
parenting,
sexuality,
societal pressures
Monday, March 2, 2009
My new favorite word, and some kick-ass links
My new favorite word? Kyriarchy.
On to things I wish I'd said:
This woman's work over at Spilt Milk
On squeaky wheels at Shapely Prose:
But for now, I'll leave you with a call to head over to Raise the Change to answer a question I posed there on Women's History Month:
Kyriarchy - a neologism coined by Elisabeth Schussler Fiorenza and derived from the Greek words for “lord” or “master” (kyrios) and “to rule or dominate” (archein) which seeks to redefine the analytic category of patriarchy in terms of multiplicative intersecting structures of domination…Kyriarchy is best theorized as a complex pyramidal system of intersecting multiplicative social structures of superordination and subordination, of ruling and oppression.That is it, all over. It gets the win. I'm using it as frequently as I can from now on. I blame the kyriarchy. I should rename the blog that (nah). But still: love.
On to things I wish I'd said:
This woman's work over at Spilt Milk
But the bulk of emotionwork within families remains a burden that women bear. Some of the blame for that needs to lie with women themselves who, in hanging onto whatever small powers they feel able to weild, continue to perpetuate the myth that men are hopeless and oafish when it comes to finer points of running a connected household. Relinquishing this sham is essential to laying down some of the burden. But we can’t discount that traditional gender roles and the structures - especially workplaces - which continue to both support and rely on them are the main reason why women must do most emotionwork[...](My reply, minus the giddy jig of joy: "This is what’s so often missing even in households where housework is supposedly shared “equally”. The woman (especially if she’s the mother) is the one to keep track of who needs to do what when, and organizes and cares for the family’s social life/relationship obligations. This more than the dishes or the nappy changes seems to be the last bastion of “women’s work” even among the “enlightened” men I know.")
On squeaky wheels at Shapely Prose:
Kate recently defined privilege as “the luxury of not thinking about it much,” which I think is perfect. One of the consequences of privilege, then, is that if you want people to be inclusive of you, you often have to remind them that you exist. It sucks to have to do this all the time, which is part of why so many people — particularly those struggling to understand their own privilege — confuse privilege with prejudice or ignorance. Even if you’re not actively oppressing those who lack the privileges you have, you are oppressing them by failing to consider them part of the status quo, by requiring them to make explicit requests for basic representation or consideration. We need to be aware of that when it comes to the privileges we have — do you, by default, consider everybody or only the people whose experiences you find familiar?Which makes me want to delve in to the post on privilege and "in the family" that's been bubbling away in my cranium for a while ("The Boychick and Dykes to Watch Out For!" how can you not love that title?), but as it is I'm on borrowed time here. Which is to say: this is me, putting off one thing (actually, three or a dozen+ things, depending on how we're counting) by coming here to say I'm putting off another thing. Yes, I have achieved multitasking procrastination! Just one of my many talents I get to hone to a fine edge thanks to having the Boychick in tow.
But for now, I'll leave you with a call to head over to Raise the Change to answer a question I posed there on Women's History Month:
I read some really interesting critiques of Black History Month last month (check out Womanist Musings's thoughts on the topic), and was wondering if any of the same applies to Women's History month. Is it a good thing to be spotlighted like this? An unfortunate practice that will be unnecessary after the revolution? A ghettoization that keeps us in our place? What are your thoughts?Feel free to leave an answer in the comments, though I'd love to see you over there as well. Also note that I hesitated a long time before using the word "ghettoization", and ultimately used it because I could think of none better; caring critiques and alternate suggestions welcome.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)