You know how I said we can't always get it right? Well, I was right, because I got some stuff wrong in that last post. I have a tendency to let language run away with me, and go with what sounds good rather than what's right. So in the last post, I conceptually missed one really important piece, and messed up in some of my language.
To whit, the idea of us v them (or even us and them). It doesn't work. When I'm talking about me, I can talk about "those who are not like me". But if I'm talking about "us" -- say, feminists, or fat acceptance advocates -- then I can't talk about a "them" -- women of color, or persons with disabilities -- because they are us. There are feminists of color, and disabled fat activists, and fat Brown trans Deaf feminist bisexual women (ok, I don't know of one, but that doesn't mean she doesn't exist), and for them (tricky word!), separating out one "strand" of privilege/oppression is both impossible and ridiculous. It is only when one has most of the cards stacked in one's favor that one has the privilege of pretending that that one axis of oppression can stand alone, be examined alone and dismantled alone.
We have to think about those who are not like us, yes, but we also must remember that those who may belong to a group we do not might also belong to ours. To say "feminists think this and blacks think that" is to ignore Black feminists. To say "well we invited them, why don't they join us?" is to exclude them (to Other "them"), and to render invisible those who are both "us" and
"them".
Intersectionalism is vital -- necessary to life! -- because the world is not made up of white people and black people and feminists and trans people. Rather, the world is made up of persons, who might be any combination of white and black and trans and feminist and disabled and fat and neurotypical and and and and...
It is fine and well to have a focus, a specialty (or two or three or however many). It is natural and understandable to have more expertise in the areas where one personally and intimately experiences oppression. But we cannot, we must not, allow that focus to blind us. We must not use our expertise in one area to exculpate our ignorance in another. Intersectionality doesn't mean we are required to study all areas of oppression equally; it calls us rather to open our eyes, to look to our own privilege when telling of our oppression, and it demands that we rid ourselves of the fallacy of "us" and "them".
Selfishly, I need for intersectionality to succeed, for examples of those who work to end one type of oppression interlinking with others to abound, for the skill of looking beyond oneself to find the "us" in "them" to flourish; I need it to succeed, for it is my only hope of teaching my presumably-straight white middle class son how to look at all areas of his privilege, to work against all the ways those-like-and-not-like-him are oppressed, to recognize the existence of kyriarchy and oppose it always. Those of us with even one area of oppression have an opening, as we learn of privilege, to learn intersectionality; those of us with many are forced to adopt it or self-destruct. My child has nearly every privilege in the world heaped on him, in a society that teaches the ugly art of Othering from birth: I fully admit to maternal selfishness when I say I need intersectionality to succeed so I do not lose him to the kyriarchy, which would have him Other everyone I love -- including me -- out of importance in his life.
So, that's not much of a reason for anyone else to adopt intersectionality (I fully recognize that an argument that sounds rather like "think of the white males!" is hardly much of a draw), but it's one reason, among many, I will defend and promote it as much as I can. I have an obligation to others to avoid oppressing and Othering and rendering them invisible, as I myself have been, as I myself am demanding not to be. And also, yes, I have an urgent desire to demonstrate that skill to a child unlikely to ever have call to learn the hard way why it is so very vital.
Intersectionality: the art of opposing the kyriarchy, one word at a time and all ways at once.
Showing posts with label intersectionalism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label intersectionalism. Show all posts
Tuesday, March 31, 2009
Monday, March 30, 2009
On intersectionality
Four months ago, when I was starting this blog, I had never even heard of the word "intersectionality" (wikipedia article, blog post [amazing pictures, but probably NSFW], another blog post, link post). I was aware, in a general way, of race issues, certainly of queer issues, to a lesser extent of trans issues, among others, and I was aware of the language of privilege, of the many ways in which I live with privilege (and the many ways I do not). But "intersectionality" was not a word on my radar, and I didn't really "get" it when I started looking it up -- the arguments "watered down!" "loss of focus!" "not in this movement!" floated through my thinking, though each was, in turn, shot down.
And yet, I think I understood it even then, before I heard it, intuitively; as I named and taglined my blog, while it was primarily about the experience of being a feminist raising a boy, I was clear that he was not just any male, but a white male, a probably-straight male, an American middle class probably-straight white able-bodied male: very nearly the tippy top of the hierarchy, by way of the intersection (!) of all these different aspects of privilege.
The more I've thought about it, and especially after coming upon the word/concept "kyriarchy", the more intersectionality makes sense (kyriarchy is what I was talking about here, though I didn't realize it at the time -- and I was also, unrealizingly, arguing against something of a straw feminism there). Feminism is in opposition to patriarchy, and this is good, but it takes only a moment of thought to realize that this does not and cannot (even at its most inclusive) cover all the ways in which some people are artificially privileged over others. Ultimately, I think it is the very concept of placing persons in a hierarchy (which is to say, it is kyriarchy) which needs to be done away with; and ultimately, it is intersectionalism alone which stands in opposition not just to one strand but, by definition, to all strands of oppression. It is only by working to recognize all forms of oppression/privilege in our work can we oppose all aspects of the kyriarchy; anything less is merely scrabbling for position on that fucked up ladder.
Which is not to say we need to get everything perfectly right all the time; we are human, and therefore both limited and flawed. Furthermore, we are humans raised under kyriarchy, and not one person reading this post can be without at least some privilege (since you've all managed to access the internet in some way or another); we are not going to be able to avoid all slip ups, all language of privilege, all incidents of accidental or oblivious oppression. But we can, and we must, try. Any step is worthy; any mistake is an opportunity to learn; any privilege recognized is a privilege weakened.
This ain't an easy path to walk, and there is no end to it. It would be all too easy to turn aside, to close my eyes, to rest easy on the privilege I do have while screaming for justice for the privilege I don't; but that way lies pain, if not for myself then for others, and if for others, then for all. Intersectionalism isn't diluting our purpose; it isn't putting others ahead of ourselves; it isn't "PC metastized". It is nothing less nor more than refusing to oppress others as we seek to end our own oppression. It is nothing less nor more than basic human compassion. It is nothing less than necessary, and nothing more than possible.
And yet, I think I understood it even then, before I heard it, intuitively; as I named and taglined my blog, while it was primarily about the experience of being a feminist raising a boy, I was clear that he was not just any male, but a white male, a probably-straight male, an American middle class probably-straight white able-bodied male: very nearly the tippy top of the hierarchy, by way of the intersection (!) of all these different aspects of privilege.
The more I've thought about it, and especially after coming upon the word/concept "kyriarchy", the more intersectionality makes sense (kyriarchy is what I was talking about here, though I didn't realize it at the time -- and I was also, unrealizingly, arguing against something of a straw feminism there). Feminism is in opposition to patriarchy, and this is good, but it takes only a moment of thought to realize that this does not and cannot (even at its most inclusive) cover all the ways in which some people are artificially privileged over others. Ultimately, I think it is the very concept of placing persons in a hierarchy (which is to say, it is kyriarchy) which needs to be done away with; and ultimately, it is intersectionalism alone which stands in opposition not just to one strand but, by definition, to all strands of oppression. It is only by working to recognize all forms of oppression/privilege in our work can we oppose all aspects of the kyriarchy; anything less is merely scrabbling for position on that fucked up ladder.
Which is not to say we need to get everything perfectly right all the time; we are human, and therefore both limited and flawed. Furthermore, we are humans raised under kyriarchy, and not one person reading this post can be without at least some privilege (since you've all managed to access the internet in some way or another); we are not going to be able to avoid all slip ups, all language of privilege, all incidents of accidental or oblivious oppression. But we can, and we must, try. Any step is worthy; any mistake is an opportunity to learn; any privilege recognized is a privilege weakened.
This ain't an easy path to walk, and there is no end to it. It would be all too easy to turn aside, to close my eyes, to rest easy on the privilege I do have while screaming for justice for the privilege I don't; but that way lies pain, if not for myself then for others, and if for others, then for all. Intersectionalism isn't diluting our purpose; it isn't putting others ahead of ourselves; it isn't "PC metastized". It is nothing less nor more than refusing to oppress others as we seek to end our own oppression. It is nothing less nor more than basic human compassion. It is nothing less than necessary, and nothing more than possible.
Labels:
intersectionalism,
isms,
kyriarchy,
language,
patriarchy,
privilege,
white privilege
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)