Showing posts with label gender roles. Show all posts
Showing posts with label gender roles. Show all posts

Wednesday, July 29, 2009

WFPP Guest Post: Talking to Strangers

This entry to the Womanist/Feminist Parenting Primer comes from Amber Strocel, who blogs about parenting, life with kids, and maternity leave at Strocel.com.

As the title implies, this post is about Amber's struggle with first encouraging and then finding herself afraid of her daughter "talking to strangers". She discusses her own socialization to both fear and avoid offending strangers, and neatly elucidates both how and why teaching "stranger danger" is not only ineffective but potentially dangerous.

Although she doesn't explicitly relate her desire for "my daughter to feel confident, to be able to trust herself instead of being nice at all costs" to feminism, her reasonings and decisions are emphatically founded in womanist/feminist ideology. The patriarchy would have us -- all of us, but especially women, children, and most especially girls -- give up our own autonomy and healthy interdependence in favor of unfounded fear and a frightening disregard for our own feelings. Raising a child
, then, to trust herself, and to trust those she feels comfortable with, is revolutionary.

Talking to Strangers

My 4-year-old Hannah is very friendly. At the park she strolls right up to people she's never met and announces, "My name is Hannah!" She tells me, "I say my name and people want to be my friend." It makes no difference to her if they're children or adults, if they respond to her advances or even if they speak English. She will chatter away as long as someone occasionally smiles and nods.

Until about a year ago Hannah was too shy to approach strangers. She didn't have the necessary social or verbal skills to pull off an introduction. I could see her watching kids play and I could tell she wanted to join in but didn't know how. Sometimes I would help her, and sometimes she preferred to just observe. I really wanted for her to find a way to bridge the social gap, since she seemed to really want to.

When Hannah became confident enough to approach people on her own I was happy for her. Most people were happy to listen to my boisterous preschooler chatter away incessantly. And she really chattered, spewing forth all sorts of information in rapid fire fashion. Where she lives. How I let her eat dry cereal off the floor. The names of all her friends at school. That time she accidentally called 9-1-1 and I was mad. It occurs to me I might not always be portrayed in the most flattering light in these little expositions, on closer examination.

And still more climbing

Listening to Hannah talk and talk and talk some part of my brain screamed Danger! After all, kids aren't supposed to talk to strangers. Especially not adult strangers. I certainly wasn't supposed to when I was a kid, anyway. When I was young we were warned about stranger danger and admonished not to accept rides or candy from people we didn't know. As I watched my daughter chat people up on the playground or at the grocery store I wondered if I should let her do this.

The thing is I don't believe admonitions about avoiding strangers are all that effective. Anyone who's ever watched a newsmagazine has seen 7-year-olds get into some guy's van to help him find a lost puppy. Their mothers swore up and down that their kids would know better, and yet they didn't. I remember having a preconceived notion of what a 'stranger' looked like as a kid myself - in my mind a stranger looked sort of like the Hamburglar. I don't think that most kids think that someone who seems nice can be a stranger.

Plus the whole message is really very contradictory. I talk to strangers all the time. My kids see me talk to strangers. At the grocery store or the library or sometimes even the sidewalk I will share words with people I've never seen before and will probably never see again. I even gave birth in front of people I didn't know because my daughter was premature and there was a whole team on hand. I suspect that a lot of talk about stranger danger is confusing and pointless.

Hannah drawing chalk art at the playground

On the other hand I don't want to send my daughter out into the world unequipped. The unfortunate truth is that not everyone has good intentions. While stranger abduction is rare, the statistics about sexual abuse are alarming. According to my local abuse prevention authority 35% of girls in grades 7-12 have experienced sexual abuse. I feel I need to arm my daughter in some way so that she's not a sitting duck.

But how? I thought about my own childhood and what worked (or mostly didn't) for me. Like most girls I was raised to be 'nice'. I wasn't supposed to talk to strangers, but I also wasn't supposed to be rude to them under any circumstances. At no point were my own feelings or instincts considered. I have found myself sitting beside people who made me feel uncomfortable, responding as they engaged me in conversation. As much as I wanted to get up and move I didn't, I ignored the voice in my head because it might have offended someone.

When Hannah talks to strangers she is using her own instincts. As a 4-year-old girl she naturally gravitates towards other children of around the same age. She also likes to talk to other parents, especially if they are playing with their own children. Out in public she talks to the people she sees me talking to - the cashier at the grocery store or the librarian. Although she doesn't verbalize it, she has an idea of who she is comfortable with and who she isn't.

Hannah and the hens

In fact, Hannah is doing exactly what she should do. She is seeking out certain people. She is honing her social skills by interacting with them. She is learning who she can trust and who she can't trust. And she studiously avoids people that she isn't comfortable with. Since she is only 4 of course I am always nearby, in eyeshot and earshot, ready to assist her if she needs it. But so far she really hasn't.

I want my daughter to feel confident, to be able to trust herself instead of being nice at all costs. I want her to learn how to seek out the help of others as required, in a way that makes her feel safe. I don't want her to sit passively beside someone who makes her uncomfortable because she doesn't trust her own intuition. And I want her to engage with others in positive and meaningful ways. I believe that allowing her to talk to strangers on her own terms is critical to that process. Not forcing her, not coercing her, not dictating that she hug someone she doesn't want to hug. But also not intervening or preventing if there's no immediate danger.

The world isn't always a safe or welcoming place. For better or worse, though, our children will live in it. They need to know how to navigate it. And I have come to believe that talking to strangers is one of the best ways to learn.


Amber Strocel blogs about parenting, life with kids and maternity leave at Strocel.com. She is 33 years old and is still afraid to talk to strangers but thanks to her daughter she's finally learning how.

Sunday, July 5, 2009

The problem with "the problem with men"

This is how feminists get a reputation for being humorless: we fail to laugh at jokes or quips that serve the kyriarchy. Like the one I heard yesterday, from D, an otherwise dear friend, spouse of my sister-in-all-but-genetics-and-law.

He and The Man were outside with the Boychick and his cousin, watching them run through the sprinklers (well, encouraging them to, anyway: the Boychick was standing at the edges saying it was "too cold!", while his cousin happily ran around getting soaked). D came in, and my sister asked if they had towels out there for them. D's reply was "Of course not: we're men, we don't think that far ahead!"

He didn't understand why I raised an eyebrow and rolled my eyes, and nor did anyone else in the room.

The Man would have gotten it.

The problem with "the problem with men" type "jokes" is that they serve to support the patriarchy-assigned sexist gender-roles. Although directed at men, and not women, and supposedly OK and "not sexist" by being at the expense of men, and not women, by supporting the limiting and dehumanizing gender roles of the patriarchy, they ultimately hurt women. Not to mention being incredibly insulting to men who have worked hard to get past said limiting stereotypes.

These jokes are especially problematical when about the incompetence of men in the domestic sphere, for by casting men as bumbling idiots in the home, it falls on women to pick up the slack there, keeping us tethered to the domestic sphere, leaving the public sphere, with its associated privilege and power, exclusively the domain of men.

So call me a humorless feminist all you like, but I fail to see why I should laugh at tired old sexist tropes that dehumanize and underestimate the capabilities of my best beloveds, many of whom are male, while ultimately reinforcing my own oppression.

It's not that I don't have a sense of humor, it's that I'd much rather laugh at the patriarchy rather than with it, and that requires thinking for yourself instead of regurgitating the partriarchy's old standbys.

You can do it. I believe in you.

Thursday, May 28, 2009

Makeup spam? Really?

Most of you probably missed it, but for about half an hour yesterday, Raising My Boychick was the dubiously-proud owner of a couple pieces of comment spam for "semi-permanent make up". I had several thoughts rapidly go through my mind when I saw it:

1) Drat, I was hoping for some real comments. (That's a hint, by the way, for those of you still reading.)

2) Does this mean I've "made it" in a perverse way? Is it a sign RMB has gotten large enough to get noticed? Is it time I get some kind of spam/comment filter?

But mostly I was thinking:

3) Wow, they really don't know their audience.

I know, I know, lots of feminists wear makeup, probably most of you do (and I'm sure you all look lovely), and perhaps triple-shift women (work, kids, home) are most likely to think semi/permanent makeup is a good idea (really though?), but I still can't help but snicker. Permanent make up ads on a feminist blog? That's some kind of either hubris or idiocy, and either way it amuses the heck out of me.

Saturday, May 23, 2009

If I Twittered, this would be a Tweet

The Man with no ponytail is hardly The Man at all.

And also: It takes a lot longer than you'd think to cut through a braid. We were surprised, anyway.

(I could go on a feminist rant about how ridiculous it is that women can have almost any length hair -- as long as it's pornulated styled "right", of course -- whereas men, if they want to get employed, simply can't, and that yes, this is sexist in a way that still manages to oppress women, but I'm still too shell-shocked. Thus the tweet-that's-not-a-tweet.)

Saturday, May 2, 2009

Of pink shirts and mary janes

Scene one: It is morning, ninety minutes into our attempts to clothe the child and get ready for the day. We have achieved pants, and just managed to slip a grey shirt over his acquiescing but still squirmy head. And so, of course, he changes his mind, insists he needs to change his shirt. "I need flowers! I need the one with the flowers!" His voice is firm, his breath belabored, each word proclaimed as if inscribed in stone, hard at work as he always is when reaching to make each word just so, make sure he is understood. We ask him if he's sure, verify his request and then again, and he is: there's only one shirt with flowers, bright, dark, shockingly pink, and it's getting too small for him, its sleeves, always abbreviated on his simian arms, now almost right again, falling halfway between his wrists and elbows, their fashion belied by the pooch of belly just sticking out from under the hem. Now he's decided to cooperate, excited he's gotten his flowers, he's dressed in a snap, and runs off to play. I turn to his dad, both of us quirking our lips, and say, "I think we need to get him more shirts with flowers." He nods, agreeing, and heads out after our pink-clad Boychick.

Scene two: I'm piled under papers, pen clenched absently between my teeth, flipping through the book balanced on my knee, looking for the piriformis, trying to ignore the near fetish-like way the anatomical illustrator sketches a circumcised penis into every portrayal of palpation around the thighs -- my phone rings, I scramble. It is my love, out for a while, ostensibly to take the child shopping, really just to give me time to play catch up from my procrastination. "So it looks like he's a size nine, and he's really grown out of his current shoes, I can't believe we waited so long. They have a bunch of sandals here, well, these are sort of sandals, but they have straps, and when I got him to put his foot up to see if they would fit, he shucked his shoes and insisted on putting these on. So what should I look for in shoes?" I take a deep breath, trying to drive away my discombobulation, but still thinking about piriformis and penis fetishists and how the hell am I going to get all this done in the next -- calculating -- four hours, and I babble something about looking for really flexible soles, something he can fold in half between finger and thumb, best for foot development, but my eye's glancing back over the scattered papers, trying to sort my scattered mind. "I don't think they have anything like that, but I'll look. The ones he has are pretty flexible, and I'm not sure I can get them off him, to be honest." If they're cheap, I say, and he really wants them... "Alright. I'll see. Either way, we'll be home soon." Then they are, and The Man is carrying his old shoes, and the Boychick is wearing his new, shiny, stiff-soled black ones. "Those are mary janes," I say. "Are they? He really wanted them. He likes the flowers on the inside." "Ah," I nod, as I restack my shuffled papers, clearing my lap for my milk-demanding toddler, and wondering whether any of the flexible-sole shoe companies make shiny black mary janes and if they'd come in his size.

Denouement: I don't much like pink; I'm not sure there is actually anything pink in my wardrobe. I wear plain brown Birkenstocks year-round, though I do own a pair of black slightly-heeled boots, faux-fur lined, remnants from living where there was real winter. I do enjoy flowers, but prefer them outside where they belong, and don't distinguish much between the exotic beauty of an orchid and the everyday beauty of a dandelion. I wonder if I could accept a girlchild loving pink and flowers and patent leather mary janes, whether I am unknowingly pushing my boychild into defying gender norms to fulfill my own anti-patriarchal desires. But then I look at my child, dressed in a shark-covered blue hoodie, jeans with flowers around the waist, grey socks and his new shiny mary janes, tossing his babydoll and nursing his cheetah, and I think no, this is just who he is: for a while, just for now, just until his awareness of the outside world and its strictly-defined gender norms increases, he is simply a child, who likes pink and blue and flowers and fish and bugs and bows; he is simply himself; simply my Boychick.

Tuesday, March 3, 2009

Why "presumably-straight"?

My friend Lisa asked in a comment on another post:
Why do you say your son is "presumably straight"?
It's a good question, one I realized I haven't explicitly answered anywhere yet. In thinking about it, it seems to come down to three things:
  1. He probably is (going to be) straight. Even with a queer-identified mother (which may or may not affect the odds, and if so, doesn't very much), he has, what, a 90-99% chance of identifying as heterosexual, depending on whose numbers you believe? So, simply, I use "presumably" because it sounds better than "probably", and he probably is.

  2. Although he probably is (going to be) straight, he might not be. Saying he "presumably" is straight is opening up the door to the idea that he might be something other than straight, and hopefully challenges people's assumptions. Which brings us to:

  3. In our heterosexist, heteronormative society, he is presumed by the wider culture (to the point of few even being aware of the presumption) to be straight until proven otherwise. While I do my best to resist this presumption, or to counter it when we encounter it, I cannot entirely do away with it, as much as I might wish. I sometimes feel I can hardly do away with it at all. The vast majority of interactions he has with others are and will continue to be based on the presumption that he is (going to be) straight, and this assumption/presumption colors far more than we are usually aware. Whether or not it turns out to be who in fact he is (he might turn out to not be a "he" at all; I could easily add "presumably" in front of male as well), he will be seen by most in his life as a straight white male (yes, even as a toddler; even at birth!), with all the privilege and roles and stereotypes thereof; and it will affect him, subtly and profoundly; and my only hope of countering the damage those role assignments bring lies in first recognizing them.
Thus presumably-straight.

Thursday, February 5, 2009

Boys and dolls: an exploration of gender, sexuality -- and race

First, it was pretty much a no-brainer that we were getting the Boychick a doll for Solstice. He likes dolls at other people's houses, he plays with his own bunnies and monkeys frequently, asks to wear said toys, nurses them and potties them and walks up and down the hall shushing them (wonder where he got that one...). Boy needed a doll; therefore, boy was going to get a doll.

Neither The Man nor I have any of the objections to or hangups around boys with dolls frequently found in our patriarchal society. So we figured it should be simple, even if we were a little picky: we wanted soft, natural fibers; neutral facial expression; a good size for holding (14 or 16", we figured, based on measuring other toys of his); able to sit; male; anatomically correct preferred but not required. We had a good size budget, access to the whole internet. Easy peasy, right?

Well, no. Maybe if we'd not waited until the last minute, and took the time to custom order a doll, we would have been set. But by the time we were looking, all the custom slots were for, oh, March. And most of them were outside even our generous budget (triple digit prices for a soft fabric doll? maybe when it's not for a not-even-two year old). We did in fact find beautiful dolls made locally that would have been perfect -- except the price. On Etsy we could find reasonable priced custom dolls -- but then there was that wait-list thing.

So, prefab dolls it is. That's fine, lots of choices there. Nova Natural alone sells, what, three, four brands? And this is when we could no longer ignore the astounding gender disparity among dolls. They're made in about a 3-1 ratio of girl to boy just in terms of selection options, and that's not even looking at the numbers of dolls made or sold. We knew we wanted a boy doll, even if we'd given up on the wee penis, because we didn't want the Boychick to think only girls were soft and doll-like, plus we wanted him to identify with the doll, and as far as we know, he's a boy.

Thus our choices were limited in the male-doll department. And thus we came to race...

Do we get him a White doll? Or a doll of color? A Black doll? Or sort of split the difference and get a light-brown-skin doll? We couldn't get a doll that looked just like him (there were White dolls aplenty, but none with his lovely complex grey-green eyes), we weren't about to get the Perfect Aryan Nation blond hair blue eyed doll, 'cause that was just too squicky, but then... what? If we get him a doll that doesn't look like him, why not a doll that really doesn't look like him? Wouldn't diversity in his doll collection be good? Invisibility is the most basic form of discrimination, so wouldn't a black doll be showing that we're trying to Do Things Right? Anyway, his favorite book character is Little Pumpkin from More More More Said the Baby (don't ask us why, he's never told us; because s/he loses hir shoes? because s/he's black? because s/he has a grandma? just because?), so maybe he'd like a doll just like hir? Nothing wrong with a white kid playing with a black doll, right? That's just racist thinking, right?

Except...

We live in the whitest damn city in the US (no wait, now only the fifth whitest damn city). Very, very few of the children the Boychick plays with are children of color. This both makes it very important that he sees the full spectrum of humanity, but it also makes it set off my squickometer when the most frequent interaction with a being of color would be his plaything to do with what he will. Is that body of color, in doll form though it may be, ours to appropriate for our child's play? What is the line between appreciation and appropriation? Between exploration and exploitation? Doesn't it set off anyone else's bells to have a blond-haired presumably-straight white male only play with a body of color as his toy? Does it support the Waldorf-is-for-Whites-only ideology to buy a White Waldorf-style doll? Is this white guilt talking, or an awareness of white privilege? Is this justifying racism, or trying to avoid it?

I don't know. We didn't know. Nothing we chose felt quite right. We were safe when we were planning on getting him a doll that looked Just Like Him. We even felt safe looking at a doll with dark hair (which he eventually will have; we don't stay blond in either of our families) and dark eyes, or a doll with light brown skin and sandy brown hair with eyes like his. But when the choices came down to blond haired blue eyed, or Black, or White that otherwise had nothing in common with him... it felt like there were no right choices. Every option was fraught with race implications. Every choice could be seen to be wrong.

In the end, we went with the red-haired, brown-eyed White doll. Why? Because the dolls in the size we wanted that we could afford were White. Four girls, two boys, all White, White, White. We weren't touching the so-blond-it-was-white blue-eyed doll, we wanted a doll big enough for him to play with, we couldn't afford the ones that had dolls of many colors, so that's what we bought. Neatly side-stepping the whole thorny race-issue (thank you, white privilege), neatly supporting a company with a racist selection (or non-selection) of dolls.

And the Boychick likes him. We've named him Ira ("what's your dolly's name?" "eye!" "eye?" "eye!" "that's your dolly's name?" "eye!" "um... well, we could go with Ira, I guess..." and it stuck). He spends most of his time tossing him in the air or throwing him on the floor, but that's OK. He's also nursed him, and worn him, and fed him, and undressed and dressed him, and pottied him, and brushed his hair, and done all the things we were hoping he'd get to do with him. As Solstice presents go, it was a success, even if not quite as cool as his play kitchen.

I don't know if we made the right decision. I don't know if there was a right decision. "Raise boy anti-sexist with open, flexible gender roles": check. "Raise White child anti-racist with white privilege awareness and racial sensitivity": ...maybe not so much. I don't know. I just know that my boy has a doll, and I'm stumbling around in the dark -- no, in a light so White it's blinding my way.