Showing posts with label patriarchy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label patriarchy. Show all posts

Wednesday, July 29, 2009

WFPP Guest Post: Talking to Strangers

This entry to the Womanist/Feminist Parenting Primer comes from Amber Strocel, who blogs about parenting, life with kids, and maternity leave at Strocel.com.

As the title implies, this post is about Amber's struggle with first encouraging and then finding herself afraid of her daughter "talking to strangers". She discusses her own socialization to both fear and avoid offending strangers, and neatly elucidates both how and why teaching "stranger danger" is not only ineffective but potentially dangerous.

Although she doesn't explicitly relate her desire for "my daughter to feel confident, to be able to trust herself instead of being nice at all costs" to feminism, her reasonings and decisions are emphatically founded in womanist/feminist ideology. The patriarchy would have us -- all of us, but especially women, children, and most especially girls -- give up our own autonomy and healthy interdependence in favor of unfounded fear and a frightening disregard for our own feelings. Raising a child
, then, to trust herself, and to trust those she feels comfortable with, is revolutionary.

Talking to Strangers

My 4-year-old Hannah is very friendly. At the park she strolls right up to people she's never met and announces, "My name is Hannah!" She tells me, "I say my name and people want to be my friend." It makes no difference to her if they're children or adults, if they respond to her advances or even if they speak English. She will chatter away as long as someone occasionally smiles and nods.

Until about a year ago Hannah was too shy to approach strangers. She didn't have the necessary social or verbal skills to pull off an introduction. I could see her watching kids play and I could tell she wanted to join in but didn't know how. Sometimes I would help her, and sometimes she preferred to just observe. I really wanted for her to find a way to bridge the social gap, since she seemed to really want to.

When Hannah became confident enough to approach people on her own I was happy for her. Most people were happy to listen to my boisterous preschooler chatter away incessantly. And she really chattered, spewing forth all sorts of information in rapid fire fashion. Where she lives. How I let her eat dry cereal off the floor. The names of all her friends at school. That time she accidentally called 9-1-1 and I was mad. It occurs to me I might not always be portrayed in the most flattering light in these little expositions, on closer examination.

And still more climbing

Listening to Hannah talk and talk and talk some part of my brain screamed Danger! After all, kids aren't supposed to talk to strangers. Especially not adult strangers. I certainly wasn't supposed to when I was a kid, anyway. When I was young we were warned about stranger danger and admonished not to accept rides or candy from people we didn't know. As I watched my daughter chat people up on the playground or at the grocery store I wondered if I should let her do this.

The thing is I don't believe admonitions about avoiding strangers are all that effective. Anyone who's ever watched a newsmagazine has seen 7-year-olds get into some guy's van to help him find a lost puppy. Their mothers swore up and down that their kids would know better, and yet they didn't. I remember having a preconceived notion of what a 'stranger' looked like as a kid myself - in my mind a stranger looked sort of like the Hamburglar. I don't think that most kids think that someone who seems nice can be a stranger.

Plus the whole message is really very contradictory. I talk to strangers all the time. My kids see me talk to strangers. At the grocery store or the library or sometimes even the sidewalk I will share words with people I've never seen before and will probably never see again. I even gave birth in front of people I didn't know because my daughter was premature and there was a whole team on hand. I suspect that a lot of talk about stranger danger is confusing and pointless.

Hannah drawing chalk art at the playground

On the other hand I don't want to send my daughter out into the world unequipped. The unfortunate truth is that not everyone has good intentions. While stranger abduction is rare, the statistics about sexual abuse are alarming. According to my local abuse prevention authority 35% of girls in grades 7-12 have experienced sexual abuse. I feel I need to arm my daughter in some way so that she's not a sitting duck.

But how? I thought about my own childhood and what worked (or mostly didn't) for me. Like most girls I was raised to be 'nice'. I wasn't supposed to talk to strangers, but I also wasn't supposed to be rude to them under any circumstances. At no point were my own feelings or instincts considered. I have found myself sitting beside people who made me feel uncomfortable, responding as they engaged me in conversation. As much as I wanted to get up and move I didn't, I ignored the voice in my head because it might have offended someone.

When Hannah talks to strangers she is using her own instincts. As a 4-year-old girl she naturally gravitates towards other children of around the same age. She also likes to talk to other parents, especially if they are playing with their own children. Out in public she talks to the people she sees me talking to - the cashier at the grocery store or the librarian. Although she doesn't verbalize it, she has an idea of who she is comfortable with and who she isn't.

Hannah and the hens

In fact, Hannah is doing exactly what she should do. She is seeking out certain people. She is honing her social skills by interacting with them. She is learning who she can trust and who she can't trust. And she studiously avoids people that she isn't comfortable with. Since she is only 4 of course I am always nearby, in eyeshot and earshot, ready to assist her if she needs it. But so far she really hasn't.

I want my daughter to feel confident, to be able to trust herself instead of being nice at all costs. I want her to learn how to seek out the help of others as required, in a way that makes her feel safe. I don't want her to sit passively beside someone who makes her uncomfortable because she doesn't trust her own intuition. And I want her to engage with others in positive and meaningful ways. I believe that allowing her to talk to strangers on her own terms is critical to that process. Not forcing her, not coercing her, not dictating that she hug someone she doesn't want to hug. But also not intervening or preventing if there's no immediate danger.

The world isn't always a safe or welcoming place. For better or worse, though, our children will live in it. They need to know how to navigate it. And I have come to believe that talking to strangers is one of the best ways to learn.


Amber Strocel blogs about parenting, life with kids and maternity leave at Strocel.com. She is 33 years old and is still afraid to talk to strangers but thanks to her daughter she's finally learning how.

Thursday, July 16, 2009

WFPP Guest Post: FCUKing the Patriarchy

Welcome to the first official entry to the Womanist/Feminist Parenting Primer! Today's guest post comes from a reader who wishes to be known as "Mama of the Family from the Fringes".

The Family from the Fringes Mama is a former academic and editor with a degree in political science and women's studies who now works as a pregnancy, birth and postpartum servant and is training to become a breastfeeding counsellor. She is also a full-time mother to one homeborn, cloth bummed, co-sleeping, babyworn, breastfed, unschooled child who she (and her male partner) are hoping to raise feminist.


To understand the context of this post, which MotFftF places as a PS, it's important to know that fcuk, and slogans playing on fcuk, come from a clothing company, ostensibly as an acronym for French Connection United Kingdom. A series of shirts with lines such as "fcuk fashion" and "hot as fcuk" were released. In this context, the message on the shirt in question goes from an inexplicably misspelled anti-patriarchalism to a fairly clever subversion of a patriarchal clothing line.

Regardless of whether you think placing almost-swear words on an illiterate child is appropriate, or something you yourself would do, this piece is a welcome start to the Primer as the story of the way one feminist family deals with the fallout of raising a child overtly and explicitly anti-patriarchy.

FCUKing The Patriarchy

When Harri was born she received a t-shirt from one of her Aunts, which was bought for Harriet with her mother and father's sense of humour and political leanings in mind. It doesn't get worn out much since a woman in her 60s verbally abused Harriet's Mama in a room full of people, saying "do you want people to think of fucking when they think of your baby girl? Because that's what they will think! You shouldn't be allowed to use your child to promote your political message."

Mama packed the shirt away for a few months, shaken by her public shaming (though it should be noted that before and after the shaming the other women who were present in that room had come to Harriet's Mum to tell her how much they loved and appreciated the shirt). When asked what she thought about the shirt a dear family friend, who we shall call Grace, said "FCUK that woman and her opinion. It's just her opinion! And it is MY opinion that every man, woman and child should have a shirt like that and wear it everywhere!"

Mama stumbled across a slogan today that inspired her to put the shirt back on Harri. It said "Children. Have them. Love them. Radicalize them!" Damn straight. Honestly, in a culture where little boys have "chick magnet" and "lock up your daughters" on their tees and little girls are dressed to look like slutty adults, with toddlers able to get g-strings and bikinis in their size, a little fcuking of the patriarchy can only be a good thing!

We understand the objection to pushing political opinions onto our children that are not their own. But ultimately we see little difference between dressing Harriet in a shirt that promotes bringing an end to male dominance and a shirt that promotes breastfeeding; they both espouse positive ideas that are good for the health of all people (they're just not popular in a capitalist patriarchy).

As Harri grows and forms her own opinions about these issues it will be entirely her choice whether or not she wants to wear clothing with politically motivated messages on them and we have always been honest with her about meanings (from the myth of Santa to the importance of breastfeeding and the problems with patriarchy - which she already experiences first hand as a woman-in-training in this society). For now she seems fine with it:



PS I also love that this shirt is a spoof of the FCUK fashion brand (French Connection United Kingdom) because fashion plays such an important part in upholding patriarchy.

Tuesday, July 14, 2009

Neither monsters nor martyrs be: lessons on motherhood from my menstrual cycle

Thanks to the science of charting, I knew enough to pull on my red undies this morning, and toss a couple pads in my bag before heading out for a day on the town. Sure enough, my flow showed as predicted, and I was pleased to be prepared, even if for once I was hoping to be wrong.

Mostly, I'm fine with cycling and menstruating. The way my genitals change over the course of the month -- dormant, dry, raised and closed, through wet, open, swollen and fertile and back again -- never ceases to fascinate me. I like my cloth pads, enjoy making them and using them. I'm in no way ashamed of menstruation, or the cyclical nature of my hormones and their affect on my mood and being; I believe I carry none of the patriarchal conceptions of menstrual or cervical fluids as dirty or disgusting.

But sometimes, I just get tired of it. Especially with 9-10 day luteal phases (standard being 12-16), meaning even fewer opportunities for deliciously natural PIV sex (that being, let me be frank, my prime motivator for charting), and 26-28 day cycles of which 6-7 days are spent bleeding, even menstruation-enthusiast me gets weary of the more-than-monthly bleed, and the associated irritations, discomforts, and duties. It doesn't matter how much we love something, everything complex has its downsides, its annoyances, its downright drags: menstruation, breastfeeding, baby-care, school, blogging; everything.

I was thinking of this just this afternoon, bloody pad between my legs and crying toddler in my arms. We had been in downtown Portland most of the day, chasing him around Powell's City of Books between making sure he didn't kill himself in his enthusiasm for the MAX trains. He was ready for a nap, and I was beyond ready for him to nap, and could have used a quiet lie down myself. When he woke up when we tried to transfer him from the car to the bed, after three minutes' nap, he was cranky and I was crankier.

I love my child with all my heart. I love spending time with him. Although finally getting to the point where I'd jump at the chance to have an evening away with my beloved, and having been in school for nearly a year because I started needing outside pursuits again, I'm perfectly happy spending nearly his every waking moment together. But I need some down time now and then.

That's not exactly a revolutionary confession; at the moment, it seems, there's a whole industry based on the "bad mom" who revels in revealing all the sordid sides of parenting. This is in direct reaction to the previous "good mom", who never admitted anything was less than perfect.

I've never been happy with or identified with either of these stereotypes, because both of these are false constructs of the patriarchy, both serve its goals: the "perfect mom" by raising women who parent up on unreachable pedestals, inhuman, with all us mere mortals able to be treated as rubbish when we inevitably fail to achieve those heights; the "bad mom" by disregarding the blissful moments of parenting, and reducing its rewarding toil to fodder for fecal jokes, deriding those of us who would take seriously this stage of our and our children's lives.

The "perfect mom" would have me write off, suppress, any frustrations around being always on call. The "bad mom" would have me mix a martini and let him squawl, or book a cruise to the Caribbean and abandon him with relatives. Problem is, I don't hit the bottle, my momma taught me not to bottle it up, and if I'm going to a tropical beach I can't imagine leaving him behind.

The thing about the kyriarchy is it dehumanizes us: either we don't admit to having periods, or believe they're dirty and work to do away with them. Either we adore our perfect angels, or we barely tolerate the little snots. Either we are martyrs or we are monsters. I'm not going to pop a pill to stop cycling, I'm not going to drug my kid or let him cry-it-out to nap: I can admit I'd like a break, admit and examine my ambivalence, without being a martyr, without being a monster. The kyriarchy is going to try to shove me in to one of those little limiting boxes, but I say no.

When my child wakes up barely after falling asleep, I take a deep breath (let out a few cries of my own), and figure out a way to survive. When my period shows up without having a chance to take advantage of my unmessy infertile phase, I take a deep breath (mutter a few choice curses), and resolve to plan better next month.

Sure, I'd love a break. But this is life: and on the whole, I wouldn't have it any other way.

Sunday, July 12, 2009

The personal and the political

What do I mean when I say “...getting sucked into attacks and defenses of individual "choices" is not only missing the point, it is supporting the patriarchy”?

It is certainly understandable when faced with the task of changing one's whole culture all in one go to feel overwhelmed, as reader Rachel bemoans: “I think that's what I find daunting about your posts--you address the larger cultural, societal issues that I feel are out of my control. … But my whole culture. That seems impossible.”

And as Jeremy Adam Smith points out over at Daddy Dialectic, there is a trap on the other side, for those who believe “only after the revolution can our piddling interpersonal relationships be lastingly altered” to use this as an excuse to “neglect their family responsibilities, especially the guys.” After all, if equality in individual lives is impossible to achieve, no point trying, right?

Neither of those are what I'm hoping to advocate.

When Rachel says “I can control (as much as anyone I think) what goes on in my family”, she is right. When Jeremy asserts “how vital and immediate it is for heterosexual couples to [establish] a domestic division of labor that makes both parties happy”, he is right. It is only ever in ourselves, for ourselves, that we can choose. It is only ever our own actions and choices over which we have direct, though not complete, control. And it is so vitally important that in our own, personal lives that we work to implement our ideals and values.

That is the personal.

As for the political: we are social creatures. Society is only and simply the gestalt of thousands and millions of individuals. And that makes us – each individual – powerful, for we are society, and each of us has the potential to influence all the dozens and hundreds and thousands of persons in our lives, and through them dozens and hundreds and thousands more.

The personal is political, and the political is personal. Decisions are made by the ones who show up, the ones who speak out, the ones who write letters and raise funds and cast votes and serve dinners and volunteer at clinics; sexism and racism and other facets of the kyriarchy are eliminated by those who demand better, of ourselves and of our kith and kin and coworkers. It is by making connections at the individual level – with your family, your friends, your blog readers, your neighbours, your shops' owners, your company's executives, your government representatives – that we can enact political, societal change.

What does not work, however, and what I speak out against, is the attempt to control those around us, especially through shaming. There may be a fine line between offering influence and attempting control, but it is an important one, and when we are speaking of mothers, who are already a highly persecuted class, already so put-upon and guilt-ridden, maintaining that distinction is even more imperative.

I do not say this because I believe women are fragile, dainty things who cannot take criticism: to the contrary, I am continually amazed by just how much we can take and take on and still do all the work that keeps our families and societies running. But our burdens are already so over-heavy that I decline to add what may be the proverbial straw to any woman's back.

Further, each of us lives in the society we all create, and that society is kyriarchal, actively antagonistic to us living joyful, unconstrained, interdependent, fully human lives. Each of us has our choices constrained if not outright dictated by the circumstances and intersections of our lives – each of which combinations is unique, but all similar for making us less than fully able to live as we would in a saner society.

How, then, can we help change society without hurting our sister sufferers? We can encourage; we must not order. We can offer a shoulder; we must not sit in judgment. We can support; we must not shame. We can influence those around us by example, by sharing our stories, by offering information and support; but they must be open to it. We cannot attempt to control those around us through browbeating or shame or force – or we can, but it is a violation of our values as well as almost inevitably ineffective.

We cannot avoid offending those who are determine to be offended, but we can, and we must, watch our own words and actions to avoid allowing the kyriarchy's voice to speak through our throats: that means, in part, declining to partake in the mommy wars in any of its permutations. That means opposing crying-it-out without attacking those who do it. That means defending breastfeeding without insulting those who weren't able to or chose not to. That means promoting natural family living while acknowledging that all of us have a harmful impact on the planet. That means disagreeing and debating and disputing and refuting each other in a way that respects each side's inherent humanity and dignity, because the only real enemy, the only true evil, is the kyriarchy.

So speak out, yes: live your ideals as best you can, and tell your truth as honestly as possible. I cannot say it any better than it has been said before, so forgive me for ending on what is almost cliched; nevertheless I believe it true: “Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world. Indeed, it is the only thing that ever has.” -- Margaret Mead

Saturday, July 11, 2009

A feminist parenting primer: share your stories through guest blogging

I'm considering running a series of posts on how we live womanist/feminist parenting; a sort of kaleidoscope primer on the day-to-day living of those of us who fight, oppose, undermine, and dismantle the kyriarchy (or at least try to!) that can help answer the questions "Sure, this all sounds good, but how do you DO this?" or "How can the ideals of feminism and anti-kyriarchy really work in real life?"

This may have some overlap with bluemilk's What does a feminist mother look like?/10 feminist mother questions meme, and the Carnival of Feminist Parenting, but I'm looking for something a little different: an image of your day, or a snapshot of a particular moment, or the tale of a decision you made, or your "feminist family mission statement" and how you try to follow it. Something practical that shows how we really put our ideals into practice. Here are a few of my posts that sort of show what I mean, but I'm really looking for your stories, and your ways of storytelling.

I'm not looking for perfection: sometimes the best opportunities for learning or teaching come when we mess up. And don't worry about it being "good enough" in either feminist content or writing quality -- I'm not going to judge the former, and I can help with the latter. I'm just looking for a picture, big or little, of some way you try to enact womanism/feminism in your life as a parent, and raise the next generation more aware of and less enslaved by kyriarchy/patriarchy.

I'd especially like to get the perspective of parents ("regular", step, adoptive, birth, and to-be or hoping-to-be) who are not male-partnered, white, able-bodied, middle-class, American women -- though even if you are all those things don't let that stop you from submitting.

So what do you think? Sound like a good idea?

Anyone interested, whether you know what to write or not, contact me at raisingmyboychick at gmail dot com.

Please and thank you!


ETA A couple of questions have come up. One, I don't require anyone to identify as a "feminist parent" to participate in this, nor even especially as a "womanist" or "feminist". Identity is up to you. What I am interested in is stories about trying to parent in line with womanist/feminist values, whether identified that way or not: striving for equal coparenting; raising children without limiting gender roles; opposing instances of sexism or racism or other facets of the kyriarchy in your children's lives. Whether you use the words "womanist" or "feminist" or kyriarchy/patriarchy is sort of irrelevant to me (although if you don't, I must admit I'm a little mystified why you'd be reading here!).

The other is that I do want to hear from those who are not-yet-parents: many of us have been opposing the kyriarchy in the parenting realm since we first started whispering the possibility that children might be on the horizon; or even earlier, if we have particularly obnoxious relations. I'd love to hear those stories. And all of us have been children, and had parents or parent stand-ins: perhaps you have a story about being raised by womanists/feminists, or who would never have identified as such but who nevertheless managed to ignite some important proto-feminist spark in you; or, perhaps your parents were Exhibit A in how not to raise children free of kyriarchy -- those could be instructive stories as well.

And if you really just don't have anything to share right now, sit back and enjoy the reading; but I intend for this to be an ever-evolving primer, so don't be surprised if one day you realize there's a story tapping on your shoulder, waiting to be shared. I'll be here.

Sunday, July 5, 2009

The problem with "the problem with men"

This is how feminists get a reputation for being humorless: we fail to laugh at jokes or quips that serve the kyriarchy. Like the one I heard yesterday, from D, an otherwise dear friend, spouse of my sister-in-all-but-genetics-and-law.

He and The Man were outside with the Boychick and his cousin, watching them run through the sprinklers (well, encouraging them to, anyway: the Boychick was standing at the edges saying it was "too cold!", while his cousin happily ran around getting soaked). D came in, and my sister asked if they had towels out there for them. D's reply was "Of course not: we're men, we don't think that far ahead!"

He didn't understand why I raised an eyebrow and rolled my eyes, and nor did anyone else in the room.

The Man would have gotten it.

The problem with "the problem with men" type "jokes" is that they serve to support the patriarchy-assigned sexist gender-roles. Although directed at men, and not women, and supposedly OK and "not sexist" by being at the expense of men, and not women, by supporting the limiting and dehumanizing gender roles of the patriarchy, they ultimately hurt women. Not to mention being incredibly insulting to men who have worked hard to get past said limiting stereotypes.

These jokes are especially problematical when about the incompetence of men in the domestic sphere, for by casting men as bumbling idiots in the home, it falls on women to pick up the slack there, keeping us tethered to the domestic sphere, leaving the public sphere, with its associated privilege and power, exclusively the domain of men.

So call me a humorless feminist all you like, but I fail to see why I should laugh at tired old sexist tropes that dehumanize and underestimate the capabilities of my best beloveds, many of whom are male, while ultimately reinforcing my own oppression.

It's not that I don't have a sense of humor, it's that I'd much rather laugh at the patriarchy rather than with it, and that requires thinking for yourself instead of regurgitating the partriarchy's old standbys.

You can do it. I believe in you.

Friday, July 3, 2009

On breastfeeding and things we don't talk about

Raising My Boychick has moved: please read and comment on this post at the new site!

Just in case there was any question, let me state emphatically that I am a breastfeeding supporter, a hard-core breastfeeding advocate, a lactivist (but not a "breastfeeding nazi", please and thank you):

I'm down with child-led weaning. I call nursing for 2+ years "full-term", and anything less than that "abbreviated" or "short" or "premature weaning", and I can't think of anything I would call "extended breastfeeding", except maybe being latched on for 8 hours non-stop.

I think feminists must support breastfeeding, and breastfeeding in public (and pumping, and pumping at work and in public), else they fail at one of the fundamental precepts of feminism.

I believe women have the moral right and must have the legal right to expose however much of their breast they and their child deem necessary, for however long they deem necessary, incidental to the act of breastfeeding, and that a woman has the moral right and must have the legal right to breastfeed or pump anywhere she otherwise has the right to be.

I've nursed my kid in the dark, at the park, in a plane, on a train, in a car, and over a jar (we did EC), and yes, I pull it down and whip it out and no you don't have a right not to see it, though you're more than welcome to avert your gaze.

I've never kept track of how many times the Boychick nursed throughout the day or over the course of a night, because he nursed when he was hungry, or thirsty, or tired, or hurt, or bored, or just because, and all of those are perfectly legitimate reasons to breastfeed in my mind.

When asked when I was going to wean, I say that WHO recommends a minimum of 2 years, but I was pretty sure he'd be done before college. I trust Dettwyler's research showing the natural age of human weaning to be between 2.5-7 years. I told my mom to be prepared for her grandson nursing well into kindergarten, if that's what he wants, and that I would fight to keep nursing for 2 years, with a minimum goal of 2.5

Yes, I am one of those women.

I tell you this, present to you my lactivist credentials so to speak, because when I say that I hate nursing, I want you to have some idea of what it means. So that when I say I hate nursing, and my 28 month old seems to be coming to an end of breastfeeding, you'll maybe get it when I say it makes me cry.

I never know how to describe my problematic feelings about breastfeeding. It isn't the idea of it, obviously. It isn't a matter of getting "touched out": I'm a hugely touchy-feely person, and had no problems having the Boychick on or next to my person most of the day (and on his dad's body the rest of the time). It isn't a matter of dysphoric milk ejection reflex, it's not a history of abuse, and it isn't a chronically painful latch. It's definitely not a matter of being uncomfortable in my own skin, or disliking the animal nature of it. And it's obviously nothing so bad that I was unable to continue, or chose to stop, but it's probably contributing to this (to us) relatively early weaning.

No, it's that for all the lactivist protestations to the contrary, breastfeeding is sexual, at least for me. Whether through biology or socialization (and I'm inclined, as I often am, to say "both"), feeling the child suckling on my breast -- and I should clarify here, it's primarily dry nursing, or comfort nursing, or the lag between the start of nursing and milk ejection, when there's little or no milk being transferred -- often feels sexual to me. And I really don't like it.

I usually use words like "uncomfortable" (because it is), or say it drives me crazy (because it does). I usually don't say I dislike it because it makes my cunt swell and start to throb, because there are all kinds of social stigmas associated with that, above and beyond the usual ignorant bitching about breastfeeding in the first place. Plus, there are people who like that feeling, and not in a pervy "I'm gonna nurse my kids to get my kicks" kind of way (I have met thousands of full-term nursing women, and never, ever have I met one who thought of nursing like that), but just in a happy "hey, this makes my body feel good" kind of way. And I think that's great, and totally normal and healthy. Actually, I'm envious as hell of those women: I'd do anything to have that kind of feeling about the feelings nursing causes.

But no, breastfeeding feels sexual, and it feels uncomfortable, and it makes me want to take a cheese grater to my nipples, or cut off my breasts, or crawl out of my skin, or get up and run away and claw my eyes out. And I have resorted to pain as a coping mechanism: biting my hand or pulling my hair or digging nails into my flesh, anything, anything to distract me long enough for him to finish, to calm down, to fall asleep, to get a letdown going, whatever he needs. But I can't always manage it, and it's leading to a downward spiral, where I have less milk, so I can't nurse him as much, so I have less milk, so... And on and on, until he's falling asleep to The Man reading to him and snuggling him in bed, and I'm out in the livingroom crying because I can't be the woman I want to be, can't do the thing I want to do.

I hate breastfeeding, and I hate that I hate it. I hate that, as much as I love the idea of comfort nursing, it is anything but comfortable for me. I hate that the way I want to mother, with breastfeeding a wholly holy joy and there for him whenever he needs or wants it, is not possible for me. I hate that there have been nights both he and I have cried to sleep because I just. couldn't. do it anymore. I hate that it's causing our nursing relationship to come to an end so soon. And I hate, I hate, that talking about it like this will make some people think "then what the hell are you still doing it for?"

I'm "still" doing it because I love it. I love snuggling him close to me while his eyes stutter close and roll back in bliss. I love playing stinky feet and having him try not to laugh so he doesn't delatch. I love the twenty extra minutes I can buy myself in the morning for lounging under the covers and scrolling through Google Reader. I love how he asks to nurse after he gets really hurt because "it makes me better". I love knowing he's getting immunological and nutritional substances he wouldn't get anywhere else. I love everything about breastfeeding -- except, more and more though still not always, the actual physical act.

Our nursing relationship is going to come to an end someday, likely sooner rather than later. This is normal, and natural, and has to happen sometime. And almost everyone I know speaks about weaning with ambivalence, so my experience is hardly unique in that respect. But this -- being a lactivist who often hates the experience of breastfeeding, mourning an early weaning at 28 months -- isn't something I see talked about much, if ever.

There are so many forces telling me not to publish this post: there's the patriarchy saying that nursing a 2yo is disgusting, that having genital sensations during breastfeeding is perverted, that nursing should be perfect and lovely and angelic, not messy and complicated and human. There's lactivism saying I'm just giving fuel to anti-breastfeeders, I shouldn't talk about the bad times, the hard times, that I'm going to scare people off. There's feminism saying I should make it all about the kyriarchy (when the truth is I'm too tired and too hurting to think that big right now), and that this is all so much middle class privileged white woman mommy blogging whining, and I should be using my platform to spotlight those with real problems. The lactivism and feminism sides even have good points.

But ultimately, I'm sharing this because I can't be the only one. I'm not so special or so unique that no one else feels this way. I'm sharing this because women's stories are important: not just our beautiful stories, not just our predictable stories, not just our uncomplicated damn-the-patriarchy moralistic stories, but all of them, messy and complicated and contradictory and nuanced and ugly and difficult and mundane and human and boring and silly. And it is through sharing our stories and connecting with others leading complicated-human-nuanced lives that we become strong.

And I need strength right now. I needed strength when the Boychick was a mewling newborn, who only knew that suckling was comfort and love and safety and peace, and didn't know it was discomfort and ugly and painful and hard for me, and I need strength now that he is recognizing I sometimes grimace and pull away and push him away when he seeks the comfort he knows at my breast, and is preempting that pain for both of us by turning elsewhere for his needs.

We're not meant to do this alone. I don't regret a moment I've spent nursing my child, not even the moments I was crying and hurting myself to cope. But I regret doing it in isolation, with no one to tell me I wasn't alone, I wasn't abnormal, and I wasn't wrong for doing it anyway.

Share your stories. Even your ugly stories, even your hard ones. Someone out there is going through it too, and they need to hear from you. I surely did.

Raising My Boychick has moved: please read and comment on this post at the new site!

Sunday, June 28, 2009

Two things I do believe and several things I don't

I believe "crying it out"* is not good. I believe it should never be the default method of sleep training, and I question whether "sleep training" is even the way we should think about babies and sleep. I believe it can be ever so slightly bad, or pretty bad, or very very bad, depending on a whole load of variables, and while I believe it might sometimes be the least bad of the limited options available (and I blame the kyriarchy and a society that isolates women who mother for those limitations), still I believe it is never a good thing.

Now here are many things I do not believe:
  • I do not believe using CIO makes one a bad person.
  • I do not believe using CIO makes one a bad parent.
  • I do not believe that parents who use CIO do not love their children.
  • I do not believe that parents who do not use CIO love their children more than those who do.
  • I do not believe that all children are measurably and irreparably harmed by CIO.
  • I do not believe that using CIO will definitely make your child hate you, or think you don't love them.
  • I do not believe that CIO should be illegal.
  • I do not believe people who use CIO should be shunned or ostracized.
  • I do not believe I have any right (or desire) to tell any other parent what to do.
  • And I do not believe that saying that I believe CIO is not good says any of the above.

Another thing I do believe is that it is possible to critique a widespread (dare I say dominant) parenting practice without criticizing individual parents -- and I believe it is necessary to try to do so. I believe it is my right, and possibly my responsibility, to explicate the ways that patriarchy both creates and benefits from a society that promotes and routinely uses detachment parenting practices such as CIO -- and I believe that until the society changes such that patriarchy is not limiting and influencing our choices this way, getting sucked into attacks and defenses of individual "choices" is not only missing the point, it is supporting the patriarchy.

Which is not any individual's fault, of course. But we can choose to work to avoid it -- work to avoid both giving and taking offense as we work to change minds and cultures -- and I believe doing so has the power to change the world.



*"Crying it out" or CIO is here defined as any method of sleep training involving leaving a child or infant alone to cry for any length of time with the intent of getting them to go to sleep by themselves. Crying in arms and leaving a child crying alone for a time because one is unable to cope with the crying any longer without risking damage to oneself or the child are not CIO.

Monday, June 15, 2009

Irritations with Blogger, and the beginnings of a comment policy

Obviously, I need a new blog host, one that will actually inform me when I get new comments, instead of only if/when it feels like it/the moon aligns/some random key generator has been met/whatever the hell it is that makes it decide to inform me today and not half the other days.

Also, I obviously need a comments policy, because this is NOT the place to say X makes anyone a "bad mom/bad parent" if X does not equal abuse and/or murder -- and y'know what, even then said abuse is usually perpetuated due to having previously experienced abuse and misogyny and often occurs in conjunction with untreated or poorly treated mental illness, so let's just skip it altogether, shall we? Again, I'm not denying that "bad moms" exist, I'm just saying that that shit is way too complicated and inevitably exists within a kyriarchal framework, actively antagonistic to women who parent, and I would much rather be focusing on the root causes of abusive parenting than assigning blame (which does absolutely nothing to help) to individual perpetrator/victim women.

And still more lessons from recent debacles, if you refer to your spouse as "wifey" (and not in an ironical reclaiming queer way), and me as "lady" (and not in a hot and/or respectful "I agree completely, my lady!" way), odds are really, really great I'm gonna delete your ass comment.

Further, this is so not the place to play protect the patriarchy through straw arguments, m'kay? It's one thing if you don't understand what I mean by "the patriarchy" or "the kyriarchy" or any other womanist/feminist term, want to learn more, and are asking sincere questions, but another altogether if you come in with your own, erroneous, definition, and call me misguided based on that.

And while I'm at it, let me make abundantly, explicitly clear that to the best of my ability, I will protect this place from comments that are willfully sexist, classist, racist, cissexist, transphobic, homophobic, heterosexist, ableist, sizeist, fatphobic, ageist, or in any other way exhibit fear, prejudice, or discrimination toward any other person based on an immutable or inherent characteristic about themselves -- and yes, that includes bullshit arguments over whether things like fat and queerness are inherent or immutable, 'cause they are. I know I'm gonna slip up and things will slip in, either through Blogger messing up and failing to inform me such a comment has been posted, or through my own ignorance and unexamined privilege and prejudice, and so I respectfully and humbly request y'all's assistance, and promise that when such slip ins/slip ups are pointed out to me, I will thank you, apologize, fix it, and move on.

Spam, obviously, is right out.

Within this comment policy, there is room for disagreement and debate, and ginormous room for discussion and developing our feminist discourse; there is only a dearth of room for discrimination or the defense thereof.

Comments welcome.

Sunday, June 14, 2009

Raising a not-rapist

This post is dedicated to Ruth Moss, who put up two posts both of which prompted and contributed to this one.

In her most recent (because, of course, I never quite managed to finish my response to the older), she poses the question:
...surely in that Glorious Utopian Future gender won’t matter at all anyway? Why would I treat my kid any differently than a girl if he turns out to be making the journey along the “path to manhood“?
And the answer is, of course, that men rape (among other things; in this post I will primarily be focusing on rape, although this argument is equally applicable to the fact that men beat, murder, attack, and abuse).

Not all men, of course, or most men, not even only men; but, in overwhelming majority, rapists are men, and far too large a minority of men prove they are capable of rape.

As Ruth put it so well in the older post, the only way to stop rape is: "Men refusing to rape. That will stop rape."

I have a son. He is a boy, who will grow in to a man.* He will have the potential to rape. The only way to be sure he does not become a rapist is to make sure he learns not to rape.

That is the difference between raising boys and raising girls: we need to raise both of them free of gender stereotypes and arbitrary gender roles, but to ignore their sex and the roles their gender will push them toward in society is as ridiculous a proposition as raising children "colorblind" in regards to race: all it does is reify the dominant paradigm, prop up racism and sexism and the entire kyriarchy, because we cannot fight what we do not acknowledge exists. In this case, that is the truth that some boy children will grow up to be rapists.

This is something a lot of parents don't want to think about -- I know I would really rather not. This is my perfect little baby we're talking about! And he is; he is beautiful, and sweet, and loving, and empathetic, and caring, and absolutely perfect.

Of course, every baby is perfect. And yet, some men are rapists. Somehow, perfect babies grow up in to men who rape. It would be so easy, so reassuring, to hide behind the lie that it couldn't happen to my baby, that I don't have to think about that, that that only happens to those other people and their defective children. But that line of thinking is just another tool of the patriarchy, trying to defend itself; if it can just make us blind enough, we'll do all the defending it needs for it.

No, the only way to make sure that my boy does not become a rapist is to teach him not to rape. And that starts now.

Ruth also asks:
...I do think we have influence. Or at least, I hope we do. Because I don’t want my kid to grow into One of Those Men. So where to start?
It starts with teaching him that no means no, and that only yes means yes. It means that even though his best friend is almost a year older than he is (just-3, to his over-2), and taller, and larger, and more energetic, and arguably more aggressive -- even though she is all that, he is male, and she is not, and while I don't encourage her to walk all over him either, I do insist that he really listen to her noes, or make sure he gets yeses, when he wants to hug and kiss and touch and play with her.

It starts with teaching him that I have boundaries and limits and needs, too; this is a tough one, because I also believe that the more a child's needs are unconditionally met now, in infancy and toddlerhood and childhood, the better off they are for a lifetime. I encounter this conflict primarily when he needs to nurse (often it is a true need, whether for nutrition or liquid or comfort or sleep) and my body is feeling touched out. I'm not sure where the best balance is between these two needs, but I know we will both be better off for trying to find it together, rather than subsuming myself entirely to his demands.

And yes, as Ruth points out, it also starts with teaching him that his own feelings matter, that his own noes are respected, that those who are bigger and stronger do not get what they want through force and committing violence upon those who are smaller and weaker. Remember, the patriarchy creates rapists by raping them; it creates soldiers who can look at a person and see only a soulless enemy by first dehumanizing them; it creates bullies by bullying them when they are younger. The most revolutionary thing when raising a boy, then, is to protect and respect his humanity; not place his right to personal agency on a pedestal, or place him at the center of the universe, as the patriarchy does, but to ground him in soul-full humanity, help him grow up centered in his own being, capable of saying "namaste" to others because the divine is still in him to honor the divine in others.

In short, and coming back down from my culturally-appropriating neo-Pagan high, raising not-rapists means raising our boys womanist/feminist, protecting them to the best of our power from the damage the patriarchy would do to them.

I'm not saying I know exactly how to do all this. I don't know exactly how to balance his needs for me and my need for me, or wanting to encourage him to be friendly with wanting to ensure he gets permission from others first, or his need to be fully human with recognizing the ways in which male privilege structures only him-as-male as fully a person. And I'm sure there are more aspects of this endeavor that I haven't figured out yet. But I do think these are good places to start.




*Probably. The odds are certainly enough slanted to him being a cissexed male that I must, in this post and in parenting him, take certain actions based on that assumption.

Sunday, June 7, 2009

The blogger revealed

I know there haven't been any photos of me on here, nor do I have so much as a profile picture (even though there have been pictures of the Boychick galore, and even of The Man). But it's not some conspiracy, not a deliberate choice for some misplaced reason of delusions of modesty or anonymity/pseudonymity (I'm aware anyone with half a brain and an hour on google could get enough information about me to be really irritating or scary if so inclined).

No, it's just that I don't tend to like photos of myself. And few enough of my close friends or relations are good enough photographers to have produced many photos good enough for me to like (those who are good photographers tend to, rightly!, focus on my beautiful child).

I know it's both cliched and rather patriarchal to dislike being photographed, but here's the thing: I actually like the way I look. I think I'm pretty hot. I even know I'm beautiful. I am not ashamed to show myself, my fat, pale, hairy, un-make-up-ed self, in tank tops and shorts and itty bitty string bikinis. My body image and self confidence are in fact quite spectacularly good, especially considering I am a white American female.

That is, until I see myself in photos. Then, I cringe and feel ugly and start to think I should avoid short sleeves, tight clothing, and revealing my face in public.

I don't know which is the lie and which the truth. I don't know whether I have an inflated ego normally, or know only photographers who mostly fail at capturing my beauty and grace. But if the image of myself in my head is fantastical, then I choose to live in ignorance. I would rather believe myself beautiful and be wrong than to know the truth and defile my soul with self-hatred.

So there aren't a lot of photos of myself around, and fewer still I'm happy to share. But since I don't actually want to be faceless, I've been keeping an eye out for photos to use, and I think I may have had some not-totally-cringe-worthy taken recently at a fair.

Without further ado, I lift teh intarwebz curtain, and reveal the blogger behind the posts:


Wait, not what you had in mind? You wanted my face? Ok, how about this?


Still not good enough? Geez you're picky. Here, I'm looking straight at the camera in this!


*ducks* Ok, ok, I relent: the pictures those were originally based on:



(Is anyone surprised they're nursing pics?)

So what say you, readership? My 100th post is coming up (this is #99!), and I'd rather like to have a profile pic by then. See anything you like? Post a vote in the comments. (Bear in mind, although I am willing to share these photos, they're still not easy for me to look at. And no, I'm not fishing for compliments, just commenting on the state of my crazy. Nice face paint though, huh?)

Saturday, May 30, 2009

More on checklists

Reply-turned-post style. I think I'm giving it its own post half because I may have done a better job explaining myself in the reply (mixed metaphors and bad Titanic reference withstanding) than in the original post, and half because I feel weird having a comment that's longer than many of my posts. Plus, I can correct all the little things I wanted to change right after I posted it, but couldn't because damned Blogger won't let me edit comments. And yes, I am crazy enough to care.

Anyway, Summer (who kicks ass and just had a beautiful baby and for whose bloggy babymoon I really thought about submitting a guest post but was far too procrastinatey and perfectionist to actually do it in time), wrote:
The check list can be a great way to break the ice and start the conversation, but like you said you have to go deeper than the superficial on the surface crap.

To which my reply is:

Yes, the superficialities can absolutely be great icebreakers, and are useful in that they might lead to uncovering whole underwater glaciers of similarities and compatibilities (or was that the wrong metaphor?). But, because what's underneath the water might or might not be accurately reflected by what's on the surface, relying on those external indicators -- the checklist boxes -- can lead us into making colossal (Titanic, if you will) errors, writing off people who might be perfect for us (or getting into fights with our kids over things we should be happy for them about), or having us cling to groups that aren't really good for us (or ignoring that our straight-A student is also an anti-feminist selfish weanie).

So yea, absolutely if I see someone at the park with a wee baby on her back in a wrap (or lovely pit hair peeking out from under her tie-dyed tank top, or a rainbow bumper sticker on her bio-diesel volvo), I'm going to sidle over to her and strike up a conversation in a way that I wouldn't with someone bottle-feeding a pink-clad girl-child in a baby-bucket. And I might even be "right" to write off the bottle feeder, because unless there's an underlying story there (special needs infant and the mom's on chemo, as an example), we probably don't have much in common, at least in parenting philosophies.

But the point is more that, well, you can't judge a book by its cover, I guess. I really do look for friends who value breastfeeding, and attachment, and environmentalism, and women's rights, and that's not going to stop anytime soon, so this isn't an exhortation to just love everyone kumbaya (although, y'know, do); rather, it's just a reminder that I can't tell who cares about attachment just by checking off a list of what they did with their kids. One of the most attachment-minded women I know almost never used a carrier, did use a bucket in a stroller, had her breastfed, pacifier-addicted baby on a nursing schedule, and bought both a crib and a bassinet before her child was born (in a hospital!). She's an AP-checklist fail. But I swear to high holy heathen heaven, she is a better, more attached mom than I am, even if I could get a near-perfect score on stupid crunchy quizzes and she couldn't. The fact that she's attachment-minded matters to me, so it's not a matter of "who cares about how we treat our kids, let's hang out anyway!" Rather, I've learned to toss out the snap judgment comparisons because the attachment level of our parenting isn't easily quantifiable by snappy checklist bullet points.

And I can think of a dozen more examples, for every label you care to name. People might surprise you. They regularly shock the shit out of me, mostly in fabulously awesome ways.

That's my point.

Friday, May 29, 2009

On checklists

I think I've mentioned my deep and abiding loathing for checklists before, usually in the context of the "mommy wars" crap: "I babywear and EC and homebirth and no-vax, and (only) if you do all those things I can be friends with you", etc. Hate. It. I mean, I could rattle off a checklist that would win me most crunchy/AP pissing contests, but really, what does that tell you about who I am, or even how I parent? Almost nothing. I know a lot of women who wouldn't fair near so well on such a checklist comparison, but are definitely better, more patient parents than I am.

The topic of checklists came up for me again today, in the context of how much we want our kids to be like us when they grow up. And I thought about my conflicts with my own mother over some choices I've made in my life, different choices than she would have made, and the conflicts almost inevitably came up when we were focusing on the specifics -- the checklist -- rather than on the underlying values that the choices reflect. When we did look past the specifics down to what made me make the choices in the first place, we inevitably found common ground that had gotten obscured by the superficial differences.

And that's the thing: I loathe checklists, I find them close to or worse than useless in discovering any truths about another person, but that isn't the same as saying that what we do doesn't matter. What we do, the choices we make, do matter, but I care far more about the process of how decisions are made and the values they reflect than I do about the end specifics. Processes and values are only so, so loosely reflected in checklists, which are all about the end specifics; they are shadows only, if that, especially when there are so many forces outside of our control acting to limit and shape and constrain and dictate what choices we even have available to us.

But I can't just say that our choices don't matter, because I do care about the values: I find that I'm going to get along best with other parents who care about attachment with their children, and who care about the environment, and want to teach equality and empathy to their children, and who try to live both authentically and joyfully. And I want the Boychick to grow up valuing justice and social responsibility and simple living and creativity. I think attachment parenting/biologically appropriate parenting and environmentalism and feminism/anti-kyriarchy are inherently good things, things I am passionate about, things I will promote and defend and that I think are worth investing in, and I'm not going to write them off in the name of being "tolerant", or "unjudgmental", or what-have-you.

But there are so many ways that those values can be reflected in one's life, and so many ways life can interfere with their enactment, that a checklist is of so little value in figuring out what a person's actual beliefs are. And even when there are differences in the beliefs, there is almost always some commonality that can be found once we stop going down our checklists and start actually seeing the person in front of us.

I find it's hard to remember that sometimes, because the end result, the specifics, are what we outwardly present to the world, and it's so tempting to use them as short hand, both with our friends and our kids: "she breastfeeds, check, he made it into a good college, check, they use a baby bucket, fail, she wants to be a cheerleader, fail." No. The real stories will usually surprise those who rely on the external checklists, and they will always be more interesting and revealing. If you want to really know a person, know whether they might be a good friend for you, whether you should be proud of this person you helped raise, toss out the checklists and prepare to spend some time actually listening.

Of course, the kyriarchy doesn't want us to do that. No, patriarchy and consumerism and racism train us and encourage us and try to force us to focus only on the superficialities: the color of skin, the bits between our legs, the cars we (don't) drive and products we (don't) buy. They create the checklists, and make us create our own checklists, and try to ensure we never go beyond them, never dig deeper, never make real connections with other real people.

So destroy the kyriarchy: throw out the checklists. Take the time to look past them. It'll be worth it. And it'll be revolutionary.

Tuesday, May 12, 2009

Not the first: a belated Mother's Day post

My mother recently accused me, and my contemporaries, of thinking or talking as though we were the first generation of feminists trying to raise anti-sexist boys.

I don't know where she got that impression, but it's certainly not one I ever meant to give. I am aware and more than aware, I am indebted to the generations that came before me, doing their part to raise their sons as well as daughters as free from patriarchy's grasp as possible. Without them, my job would be that much harder. Without them, I wouldn't have a male partner to share this trial with (without them, no men would be able to be true partners, having been overly damaged by patriarchy). Without them, the road ahead would be that much steeper, and dirtier, and darker.

My mother, for all that she at times has been known to say "I'm really more of a humanist", did a pretty good job of raising a feminist boy. One of my favorite stories is that, he being a first child but with the anticipation he not be an only, my brother's wardrobe for his first three years consisted of an equal mix of "boy" clothes and "girl"clothes, with the rationale that all the clothes would get handed down (to a girl, my mother hoped), and the next child shouldn't be the only one wearing the "wrong" gendered clothes.

Her relationship, though hardly ideal, was remarkably equitable for her generation. Although my father hardly did his share of housework, and all the executive daily management of the family was hers alone, he more often than not was the one to take me to school, to stay home if I was sick, and his only reaction to her practice flourishing and her eventually earning more than he was pride and relief.

And it worked: my brother, privileged straight white male that he is, openly identified as a feminist, at least while in college. And I, of course, am hard at work raising her grandson feminist.

So I am quite aware of the debt owed to the feminists who came before, imperfect as they were. They did pretty good, considering. Their relationships were pretty equitable, considering. Now, of course, we can sit back and say "but we've hardly progressed at all! there's still so much to do!" We can pick, and point, and critique, and criticize -- and to be sure, there is an abundance to criticize in the generation of Steinem-inspired feminists raising boys in the 70s -- but ultimately, they made progress, and there is so much we have learned from their efforts, from both their successes and their failures.

My hope is that the next generation can say the same about us, that our progress is such that they can look back and say "well, those old broads did pretty well, considering", that they take what we struggle for almost for granted, and that they look around and set their shoulders to all the work that will still be left to do. Let them, as I do, see the progress the previous generation made, and let them think it not yet enough.

To my mother and all her sisters: thank you. Happy Mother's Day.

Tuesday, May 5, 2009

We are not bad moms -- but are we good moms?

Reader sarah replied to my post We are not bad moms* with the following:
There is a corollary to this post that I think should also be said. Babywearing, breastfeeding, EC, etc. don't necessarily make you a good mom. There is a world of hurt you can bring on your child even if you practice those parenting techniques, they don't inure anyone from the negative aspects of parenting.

I just feel like this needs to be said (and repeated over and over) as I see my friends lulled into a false sense of safety and superiority because they subscribe to a certain set of parenting practices. We need to constantly challenge ourselves to look past our more superficial lifestyle choices to how our personalities, histories, family structures, and communities impact our children in a way that is beyond our control.
First, sarah, thank you so much for the comment and the post inspiration. I'd like to reply to this -- agreeing and disagreeing and expanding and being inspired by -- in three parts.

To the first:
Babywearing, breastfeeding, EC, etc. don't necessarily make you a good mom. There is a world of hurt you can bring on your child even if you practice those parenting techniques, they don't inure anyone from the negative aspects of parenting.
I really hesitate to agree, although I think it is technically true. But as I've mentioned before, everyone and everything in our society jumps at any opportunity to either knock us down and declare us horrid mothers, or place us on Olympian pedestals no one could hope to live up to. I am therefore loathe to take part in any of this game, to spend any of my time lending any credence to the bad-mother meme. I am in fact, in general, loathe to even place mothers on any kind of good/bad spectrum, nor to attempt to define what a "good mother" is, such that someone who breastfeeds and babywears, or who formula feeds and lugs a baby bucket, might or might not be one, because of or in spite of those practices.

Furthermore, I believe that babywearing and breastfeeding and elimination communication are good things in their own right; all other things being equal, it is better to breastfeed than to not, better to practice EC than to not. These practices have tangible, intrinsic benefits, to infants, to the parent-child relationship, to parents, to the environment, to society; I do not want to see them placed in opposition to intangible "good parenting", as though it were a trade-off (although I will say I know sometimes it is a trade-off, especially with the limited amount of energy and resources mothers have available to them in the early months and years, but no one can know from the outside the balance of a mother's choices; what costs time and energy for one person might be a simplification and a lifesaver for another). An inherently good thing is good whether or not one is managing to do other good things, and whether or not it protects you from the damage of other not-good things.** And, as they are minority practices, which are often attacked in a very misogynistic way (often supported in a misogynistic way as well, I will grant you), I am loathe as well to contribute to the belittling or dismissing of these parenting choices.

(I also wish to discuss whether or not or in what way(s) attachment parenting practices might indeed protect against "the negative aspects of parenting", but I'll leave that for another post, because it's a complex issue in its own right.)

Jumping to the end of the comment:
We need to constantly challenge ourselves to look past our more superficial lifestyle choices to how our personalities, histories, family structures, and communities impact our children in a way that is beyond our control.
I can give a big ol' Amen! to the bolded part. Certainly when we look at the ways in which the kyriarchy constantly constrains our choices, debating diapering methods can seem like rearranging the deck chairs on the Titanic. Mothers are a persecuted subset of a persecuted gender; mothers who exist without white, straight, able, or class privilege even more so. So much of the damage that is done to our children is out of our control, dictated by the work choices we (don't) have, the community support we (don't) have, the parental benefits we (don't) have, the schooling options we (don't) have, and so on, et cetera, ad nauseum. Even those of us hell-bent on countering the kyriarchy and the dominant culture to the best of our ability recognize that our children will grow up in this society, influenced by its memes and beliefs and ideals and prejudices, fully versed in its gender and racial and sexual norms and mores, and there's not a damn thing we can do about it, except try to at least help them be able to see and recognize those influences in their lives, and thereby, if we are very lucky, reduce their power at least a little.

That said, I'm not sure I can agree with the "We need to constantly challenge ourselves to look past our more superficial lifestyle choices" preamble. Although that is, at least in part, what I try to do with this blog, I recognize that it is something I am able to do due to privilege: I do not have to worry about where my child's next meal will come from, whether his water is going to make him ill, how to pay for any injury he might incur running around like the toddler he is, or how to protect him from any abusive relations; and so I am able to spend my time thinking about paid family leave, environmentalism, universal health care, and preventing domestic violence, and the role of the kyriarchy in the lack of these things (which is not to say that only those who exist with privilege, like myself, can think big thoughts, or need to "fix" things for "them", just that I have far fewer roadblocks in my way than does someone who is oppressed in more ways -- these roadblocks are one of the many ways the kyriarchy seeks to protect itself). Further, "constantly challeng[ing]" myself does, to an extent, fulfill me and give me energy, but I am not hubristic enough to think that therefore everyone must lead the examined life: for some, letting go of the need to examine and challenge themselves is the healthier path.

Finally, looking at the middle part, where I think the meat is:
I see my friends lulled into a false sense of safety and superiority because they subscribe to a certain set of parenting practices.
Here we have the twofold point: "superiority" speaks to women who attempt to build themselves up by placing themselves ahead of others, because the kyriarchy has ensured that hierarchy is the only organizational principle they know (even in trying to be grateful, we too often make it about being better off than others); "safety" speaks to women who are seeking to protect themselves, because they are under constant attack by the kyriarchy and forces of anti-mother misogyny, threatened always with the spectre of the "bad mom" label if they don't do things "just right". And although I don't think that being "lulled into a false sense of safety and security" (by clinging to breastfeeding or babywearing or what-have-you) is a good thing, I also cannot blame them, or fault the inclination. Because we are under attack, because there is so much out of our control, and if clinging to cloth diapers like they were lifesavers is what helps a mother get through the tsunami of hate, from outside and in, that comes with the early years of parenting... well, she gets through, and that survival is worth celebrating, an intrinsic Good Thing, even if she might have done it "better".

The "mommy wars" suck. (A lot.) Possibly the most evil thing about them is the way they make us turn against each other, first by scrambling to place ourselves on a hierarchy of most attached/most crunchy/most Super/most whatever, then by attacking each other with "[not] necessarily... a good mom" when we recognize the fallacy of the hierarchy. Dismantling the kyriarchy without undermining each other, critiquing parenting choices without criticizing fellow parents: these are not easy tasks. It is not an easy dance, and it is so easy to make a misstep -- just as with parenting itself. But it is necessary to try, and it is necessary to forgive ourselves because we will get it wrong sometimes -- just as with parenting itself.

So no, putting the telly on for your toddler doesn't make you a bad mom, and knowing a dozen carries to do with a 5m wrap doesn't make you a good mom. But what might make you a revolutionary is to let go of both the fear of being a bad mom, and the need to be a good mom. Let go of the good mom/bad mom hierarchy altogether. Just be a mom -- a bad-ass mom in your own right -- and tell the hierarchy it can go to hell.



*Which is, by far and without question, my most popular post, which still kind of mystifies me. The reaction to it has been amazing, and humbles me. Thank you to everyone who read, and especially to everyone who commented or passed it on.

**An analogy: recycling is a Good Thing (as is reducing and reusing). I do my best to reduce my consumption of paper and plastic containers, and reuse or recycle what we do bring home. I also drive well over 100 miles a week, when I could take public transit, or avoid travel altogether. Does my typical American use of the car, which has a much greater overall impact on the environment than the waste I produce and how I deal with it, mean that "recycling doesn't make me a good environmentalist"? Does my use of the car somehow negate the Good Thing that recycling is? It's not exactly a rhetorical question, but I have an answer that I can live with for myself, and I hope you do too.

Monday, April 13, 2009

We are not bad moms

(Inspired by an off-hand comment from a friend of mine, but applicable to pretty much every mom I've ever met. Very, very few of the dads, though. And no, that is not a coincidence.)

Allowing, or even encouraging, your toddler to watch TV does not make you a bad mom (or mum).

Using disposable diapers/nappies, whether regularly or occasionally, does not make you a bad mom.

Pushing your child around in a stroller does not make you a bad mom.

Using bribes or coercion or even lying to your child does not make you a bad mom.

Sending your child to daycare or public school, whether so you can work or just because you need the break -- all together now! -- does not make you a bad mom.

I am a TV-free advocate. I am an Elimination Communication (with cloth diaper back up) enthusiast. I adore and enjoy teaching babywearing, and prove daily that a stroller is not an essential baby-accessory (we don't own one at all). I firmly believe in unconditional parenting (and unconditionality), and strive for consensual living. I believe in attachment theory (about the same way I believe in the theory of gravity), and advocate for attachment parenting, and think the public school system, in the US at least, is fundamentally flawed.

But parenting -- life -- is not a checklist. It is not a competition. And you are not a bad mom.

This is not to say that anything goes, or that having ideals and standards and beliefs and goals is wrong, or mistaken, or pointless. Far from it; I am, as the above list shows, a fan of ideals and standards and beliefs and goals. This is not to say there are not right and wrong choices in parenting (feeding your kids is right, beating them is wrong); it is not to say there are not things better and worse for kids (exclusive breastfeeding for the first half-year is better, yelling at them for developmentally appropriate behavior is worse). Rather, it is to plea with all those reading to recognize that even making a "bad" choice does not make you a bad mom. Even if we agree that a particular choice or action is less than ideal (today I have yelled at my child, threatened him, bribed him, ignored his cries, and generally made some less than stellar parenting choices), making that choice, or doing that action, or failing to meet that standard, does not make you a bad mom.

The whole world is filled with people who are eager to tell us what a bad job we are doing, that we are ruining our children, that we as women are inferior, that we are incompetent, that we are hated, that we can never be good enough, that mothers are worthless, that we are worthless mothers, that mother love is instinctual, that mothers must be perfect, that if we achieve perfection it is no big deal, that if we fall from perfection we are broken, that we are bad moms.

These are lies. These are misogynistic lies, put forth by the patriarchy. And we swallow them whole, and we spit them back out, at each other, at ourselves.

Don't do the patriarchy's work for it. Reject the lies. If you let your toddler watch TV, even if you don't like that s/he watches, that's OK. If you don't feel guilty letting your toddler watch TV, that's OK too. (If you try to argue with me that there's nothing wrong on a large scale with infant TV watching, I'll argue back, but no way am I going to tell you what to do in your own life.) You are not a bad mom. You do not have to call yourself a bad mom when you admit it, as though it were some kind of protective amulet (mothers are hardly the only ones who do this: it's just shades of "yes massa" "I'm just a silly blonde" "you know how we Jews are"); you may get a pat on the back from the patriarchy, but all it does is perpetuate the hate. And you are still being oppressed.

What we do is not who we are. What we do in the early years of parenting our children really is not who we are. Our choices matter, yes; activism and advocacy matter; and there really are bad moms out there.

But really? We don't need to prefix or suffix our "failures" with self-flaggelation. If parking your kid in front of the TV so you can get a break (or cook dinner, or take a shower, or just because they enjoy it) is the worst you do on a regular basis, I can say with all confidence you are not a bad mom.

Thumb your nose at the patriarchy: next time the words "bad mom" start to fall from your lips, change it to bad-ass mom. Because you are.

Monday, March 30, 2009

On intersectionality

Four months ago, when I was starting this blog, I had never even heard of the word "intersectionality" (wikipedia article, blog post [amazing pictures, but probably NSFW], another blog post, link post). I was aware, in a general way, of race issues, certainly of queer issues, to a lesser extent of trans issues, among others, and I was aware of the language of privilege, of the many ways in which I live with privilege (and the many ways I do not). But "intersectionality" was not a word on my radar, and I didn't really "get" it when I started looking it up -- the arguments "watered down!" "loss of focus!" "not in this movement!" floated through my thinking, though each was, in turn, shot down.

And yet, I think I understood it even then, before I heard it, intuitively; as I named and taglined my blog, while it was primarily about the experience of being a feminist raising a boy, I was clear that he was not just any male, but a white male, a probably-straight male, an American middle class probably-straight white able-bodied male: very nearly the tippy top of the hierarchy, by way of the intersection (!) of all these different aspects of privilege.

The more I've thought about it, and especially after coming upon the word/concept "kyriarchy", the more intersectionality makes sense (kyriarchy is what I was talking about here, though I didn't realize it at the time -- and I was also, unrealizingly, arguing against something of a straw feminism there). Feminism is in opposition to patriarchy, and this is good, but it takes only a moment of thought to realize that this does not and cannot (even at its most inclusive) cover all the ways in which some people are artificially privileged over others. Ultimately, I think it is the very concept of placing persons in a hierarchy (which is to say, it is kyriarchy) which needs to be done away with; and ultimately, it is intersectionalism alone which stands in opposition not just to one strand but, by definition, to all strands of oppression. It is only by working to recognize all forms of oppression/privilege in our work can we oppose all aspects of the kyriarchy; anything less is merely scrabbling for position on that fucked up ladder.

Which is not to say we need to get everything perfectly right all the time; we are human, and therefore both limited and flawed. Furthermore, we are humans raised under kyriarchy, and not one person reading this post can be without at least some privilege (since you've all managed to access the internet in some way or another); we are not going to be able to avoid all slip ups, all language of privilege, all incidents of accidental or oblivious oppression. But we can, and we must, try. Any step is worthy; any mistake is an opportunity to learn; any privilege recognized is a privilege weakened.

This ain't an easy path to walk, and there is no end to it. It would be all too easy to turn aside, to close my eyes, to rest easy on the privilege I do have while screaming for justice for the privilege I don't; but that way lies pain, if not for myself then for others, and if for others, then for all. Intersectionalism isn't diluting our purpose; it isn't putting others ahead of ourselves; it isn't "PC metastized". It is nothing less nor more than refusing to oppress others as we seek to end our own oppression. It is nothing less nor more than basic human compassion. It is nothing less than necessary, and nothing more than possible.

Sunday, March 22, 2009

Independence, attachment parenting, and societal misogyny

I was in one of those sort of surreal conversations the other day, where someone was telling me that, now that he's two, the Boychick really should spend some time away from The Man and me, so he can "develop independence".

I tried to stutter a defense about how he has a lot of independence already, just within the context of our family unit (see? I can't even articulate the thought well in retrospect), which earned me a patronizing head shake.

But it got me thinking: what IS independence? And why is it seen as so damned important?

Here's the thing: the Boychick has never been away from The Man or me. One or the other of us has been with him, been the one primarily responsible for overseeing his well-being, at all times. We've never had a "date night" where we left him with someone else. We're not, at this age, absolutely opposed to the idea, but we have no particular desire for it, either. We've had lots of dates, and lots of adult conversations, with the Boychick around, and all three of us like it that way just fine. (This is in no way meant to condemn those who do desire -- even need -- breaks from their children, dates with their partners, or to work in child-free environments part or full time. Although I am overtly and entirely in favor of attachment parenting, I have no desire to police what that looks like in other families, nor even whether they choose it or not.)

In the popular conception, at least in America, this makes the Boychick horribly smothered, denied the opportunity to be "independent", tied to us (literally, at times) in ways sure to stunt him in the long run.

And yet, no one would ever accuse us of being helicopter parents:

  • At the park, I plop myself down on a bench with a book or my schoolwork or my iPhone, and gently encourage the Boychick to run and play -- and eventually, when he's ready to, he does, and wanders far and wide, though usually within my sight.


  • At home, he plays on his own while I do my work, and has done since he was a few months old -- a few minutes at a time at first, in my lap or on the floor right next to me, now for hours a day (with numerous swings back to show me this or that), and often in other rooms.


  • We are entirely in favor of free range parenting, and I, as a former latch-key kid who started biking home by myself at age 8, was recently horrified to discover that Oregon law strongly discourages children under 10 years old being left home alone for even "short" periods of time. (I also discovered I could be prosecuted for leaving my sleeping toddler in the car in our own driveway to run inside, pee, and get the bed ready for transferring him. But noooo, surely society is not at all oppressive of women-who-caretake!)


  • We love the book Whistle for Willie, published in 1964, in part because of its portrayal of a perhaps 5-8 year old boy playing on his own in his neighbourhood, even getting sent on an errand to the corner store by himself -- of course, he's not actually alone, because there are several other kids also outside playing (without an adult in sight).

Modern American culture is horrified by almost all these things. We raise the spectre of Stranger Danger, of the Pedophile Lurking in the Bushes, of the omnipresent and omni-oppressive What If? at every turn, restricting and limiting and oppressing -- and yes, smothering -- our children, even as we push them away.

It seems to me, then, that The Man's and my sin in the eyes of "mainstream" culture is not failing to foster independence, but our refusal to force detachment -- what I sometimes call "pathological independence". It is our willingness and commitment to provide a safe base from which the Boychick may explore, and to which he always may return, that earns us ire and shaming clucks of the tongue.

Independence, no matter what popular culture says, cannot be created by forcing the chick out of the nest; that is only detachment, which teaches children they cannot trust those around them, and cuts off their rightful sense of interdependence. Real independence, which is entirely capable of coexistence with interdependence and thus dependence as well, is grown in to, at one's own pace, under one's own power, and comes from knowing that one is free to roam, free to leap, and yes, free to fall -- which children are so much more likely to risk when they know they have a soft space to land.

We spend so much time demanding "independence" in our offspring's infancy (demanding they sleep alone, forgo our embrace, learn to "self-soothe"), then refusing to let them taste anything approaching real independence (freedom to explore and exist unobserved and unoppressed, along with responsibilities to others who depend on them) when they are at the age they most need it. How much more backwards can we get?

To take this, once again, from the personal to the political: I suggest there is something inherently anti-feminist -- misogynist -- in this backwards stance.

First, we replace mother's own (ideal, biological default) milk with man-made artificial infant food; a parent's arms with artificial rockers, swings, play pens, etc; a parent's bed and a mother's breast with barred cribs and artificial white-noise and silicone "nipples"; we tell parents to ignore their instincts, and allow their babies to cry themselves to sleep. Not to put too much biology-is-destiny spin on it, but all of this serves to separate and detach the motherbaby -- which biologically ought still be thought of as one unit even after birth, only gradually and mutually separating over time (with "mother" here being substitutable with any number of close allomothers; the point being that infants and to a lesser extent toddlers biologically expect the constant presence of a known, loving, familiar adult or near-adult) -- damaging a mother's belief in her own abilities and conceptualizing her as broken, incomplete, inconsequential.

Then, when both primary caregiver and child ought to be naturally starting to get ready for the child to explore ever further afield, we demand constant vigilance: children must NEVER be left alone or unobserved for even a moment, "because something might happen, dun dun DUUUUUUUUUUUN!"; this serves to tie the primary caregiver, usually a woman (either the primary mother or a usually-female allomother in the form of daycare workers, school teachers, playground monitors, etc), to the child, never allowed to pursue her own goals and career, required always to have her attention focused completely and near-exclusively on the child(ren), or risk being cited negligent, labeled a Bad Mother -- even risk having her child(ren) taken away by a system that declares alone time under some arbitrary and ridiculously high age actually illegal.

This is classic patriarchy modus operandi: declare women broken, insufficient, lesser-than, dangerous even; then demand our complete sacrifice and subsumation of self under some pretext (which also inevitably serves its end goals), usually exactly counter to the previous demands (thereby, if we are to follow, requiring suspension of rational, logical thought); make it almost impossible to deviate from the demands (lack of allomothers, break up of neighbourhoods, laws and a Big Brother culture quick to dial 911 to enforce the norms); and punish us completely out of proportion to the "offense" if we dare to deviate.

So no, we're not going to leave the Boychick with a sitter or take him to daycare just so he can taste "independence"; nor will we refrain from leaving him in our yard to play, or home alone when he is ready, just so he can be "safe": I may not be totally (hah!) independent from the patriarchy, but neither will I bow down and allow it to define "independence" for my child.