I first wrote this four months ago; I'm not really sure why I didn't publish it then. I looked at it again recently, thinking it was much more draft-y and much less coherent than it turned out to be, discovered it wasn't that bad, dusted it off, and here it is.
First, let me say that I've been praying that I can write out these thoughts in a coherent way without tripping up on my privilege and unrecognized prejudices too damned bad. Second, let me say that I know I'm just not gonna get it all right, and I apologize in advance, and request gentle corrections so that I can learn and do better next time.
After my post about why I call the Boychick "presumably-straight", I started thinking, again, about why it is we have transgender and transsexual persons, but not transracial (the questionable case of Michael Jackson, may he finally be at peace, aside). What is it about race and gender that makes being trans one but not trans the other make sense? The most bigoted of "radfems" and the ignorant masses notwithstanding, it is not possible to be rational and be exposed to the stories and lives of trans persons and still claim that they are "really" the gender into which they were assigned at birth. Any rational society would recognize that, would allow for graceful transitions, would legally protect these (and all) persons against discrimination, would provide what medical services they require, would allow appropriate and easy alteration of legal documents, would laugh the "trans-panic defense" out of the court, etc., etc. (And any not-totally-jacked society would get the damn pronouns right!)
And yet, the idea of someone like the Boychick being "transracial", that is, born into one race ("white") and deciding/discovering that he's "really" another race (say, "black") is ridiculous. It's nonsensical. And more than that, it simply doesn't happen. The closest to it is people trying to pass to access the privilege denied to them by racist societies. We are not a rational society when it comes to race, so we cannot claim that it is the fair and equitable way race is dealt with (hah!) that prevents "pressure" from "creating" "transracial" persons; therefore, neither can we say that the real pressures present in a patriarchy are "creating" transgender/transsexual persons -- surely if it were just self-hatred caused by living under a kyriarchy that devalues the body one lives in, we would see far more people of color clamouring for such an identity.
So what makes the difference? Gender is based on sex, which has been a part of our genetics since probably the first multicellular organism. From way, way, way back in our evolutionary history, we instinctively know that there are more or less two types of individuals, and we generally expect to identify as one or the other. Because we are complicated animals, and because of the power of our social memes, gender is an amazingly complex construction, based in genetics and environment and biology and society and psychology and who knows what else -- but there is, inherent in us, some expectation of being gendered, whether that's male or female or something more complex. There is nothing in us that pops us out of the womb wanting pink or blue, nail polish or RC trucks; this is the societal construction of the expression and performance of gender. But if the Boychick lived in a society that gendered yellow teeth female, he might be one of those born with penises who grow up dreaming of dental dye; not because desire for yellow teeth is inborn (which is no more ridiculous an idea than a desire for pink toenails being inborn), but because their internal gender draws them to those things their society genders female, regardless of their external sex.
Race, however, is an entirely social construction, an entirely modern -- in the evolutionary scale -- idea. There is nothing in us that expects to be "race-ed"; genes dictate that the Boychick's skin is less pigmented than others, his eyes have more creases, his nose is more pointed, but there is no gene, or chromosome combination, for defining him as "racially White", or any one else as "Black" or "Asian" or "Aboriginal". What there are, instead, are memes; for this is not to try to argue a colorblind (aka racist, however well intended) ideology: race is entirely real, because we believe it to be so, based only on minute skin tone and facial differences, and we are creatures with amazingly powerful intellects and social memes. (Case in point: there may be no culture that escapes from the ills of racism, but by no means is racial identity universal; what we call "Black" in the US may be "morena or mulata" in Brazil.)
The irony, then, if that is the right word, is that the reason he is only presumably male is because masculinity, male-ness, is something at least partially inborn; the reason he can never be anything but white is because whiteness is entirely socially constructed. The one that is more "real" is the one that an individual may "change"; the one that is more "artificial" is immutable by the individual.
So this is the Boychick I am raising: presumably straight, presumably male, but definitely white.
Showing posts with label white privilege. Show all posts
Showing posts with label white privilege. Show all posts
Monday, July 27, 2009
Monday, July 20, 2009
Sula and sleep: on raising a white child and reading "the n word"
The Man and I have a years-long tradition of reading to each other in bed to help us sleep. Although the arrival of the Boychick changed the purpose of this nightly ritual from decompression- and snuggle-time to help-Arwyn-survive-breastfeeding-baby-to-sleep time, it didn't really change the books we chose. We've always read books with “adult content”, and we don't see why we should limit our selections to exclusively “children's books” just because we have a child now. Still, as he's grown, we've gotten just a little pickier about the content, trying to balance the desire to expose him to enjoyable, mind-expanding literature with not wanting to expose him to too much in the way of inappropriate language or ideas. It's sometimes hard finding books we enjoy, that work well read aloud, and that have a low enough objectionable-to-laudable scene ratio in them; but mostly, we pick books that will interest and engage us: he's just along for the ride.
The other night, having decided that The Canterbury Tales was too difficult to follow while half asleep and too misogynistic for any time of day, I brought to bed Sula by Toni Morrison. I had picked up the novel on sale years ago, knowing that I admired Morrison's work but not having read this one before. It languished in our library, unopened and unread, as Half Price Books and under-treated bipolar disorder left me at the time with more books acquired than actually appreciated. But this night I was looking for something new, something thinner in size if not in scope than our recent hefty choices, and I spotted it, and thought, why not?
The possible answer to "why not?" came in the form of "the n word" appearing half a dozen times in the first five pages. After the third or fourth iteration, The Man abruptly stopped reading, and asked -- more like demanded, desperate for an answer -- "should I be reading that word aloud?" I said the only thing I could: "I don't know."
I don't know. I know I want to teach the Boychick about the evils some people (people who look a lot like him) have done and still do against other people (people who look slightly less like him but are still fundamentally the same as him). I know I want to be able to have calm and rational conversations with him about the N word and why it is a word he is not ever allowed to use, even if he one day has friends who use it for themselves. I know I want to expose him to the profound and beautiful literature this hateful language -- and the even more hateful actions it represents -- have inspired in those who have endured and survived it, expose him to stories of lives he will never have to live, stories I hope he will help to make unnecessary for the next generation to write.
But he's two years old. He is a linguistic sponge, surprises everyone with his vocabulary and complex sentence structure and clarity of speech and thought -- and he will repeat the words he hears, even if he doesn't know what they mean, even if he can't understand why he mustn't use them. Even if we agree he's old enough to be exposed to the ugliness of life (more on that in a moment), I'm not sure he's yet cognitively able to hear and discuss and understand the explanations about the uses and implications of racial slurs, and until he is, I'm not sure we should expose him to the words and thus risk him exposing others -- who would understand, who could be hurt unnecessarily but understandably -- to them when he repeats them.
It is, of course, entirely due to white privilege that we have the choice whether to expose him to those slurs: he is white, we are white, most of our friends are white, and we travel primarily in a social sphere where racism is institutionalized, not explicated, subtle, not overt. A parent of color, or a parent of a child of color, all too often has the choice taken away from them, as these words are forced on them, flung at them like filth. It is entirely privilege unearned that allows me to sit comfortably in my sub/urban house, in a residential neighbourhood overwhelmingly white, in a city blindingly white, in a country still controlled by whiteness for all it is headed by a half black (but entirely Black) man, and indulge in angst over whether to allow my child to hear an ugly word that will never, ever be used against him.
But I think it is also white responsibility, stemming from that white privilege, to think about that language, to examine the role I play in perpetuating it, to act to counter it. I have a responsibility to teach my child about the word, about the larger evils it represents, yes: but I also have a responsibility to ensure my child does not hurt those around him by repeating it before he knows better, do I not?
So do we read the word aloud and hope he is able to understand our explanations? Substitute it with a euphemism more palatable but ultimately no less kyriarchal? Mumble it and hope he doesn't ask for clarification? Put the book away until he's "old enough", whenever that is? If we do that last, are we whitewashing his world, perpetuating racism-through-exclusion? Or would we be ensuring that in his formative years he only is exposed to positive images of people of color, friendly interactions between people of different races? I come around to the answer I gave that night: I don't know.
I don't have all the answers; some days, it feels I don't have any. I only hope that seeing me struggle to seek them will serve the Boychick well, because he's going to be white -- in a world that privileges whiteness above all others -- for the rest of his life. As I hold him close to me at night, thinking of another mother clutching her child after being exposed to the word in a way she couldn't control, would never have chosen, I whisper a prayer to whatever god/desses are listening: please, please let him do better. Let him work to oppose that privilege. Let the answers come easier to him. Let his generation grow beyond this ugliness. Let that word become meaningless, powerless, within his lifetime. Let him know how lucky he is; how no more worthy than any others, only luckier. Let him be white without perpetuating whiteness. Please.
****************
What do you do? Those who have had the choice taken away from you, or who chose to take the plunge and read it aloud, what did you say to your children? Were they able to understand the explanations? If you haven't addressed this issue, why not, and how have you worked to counter the privilege inherent in that choice?
The other night, having decided that The Canterbury Tales was too difficult to follow while half asleep and too misogynistic for any time of day, I brought to bed Sula by Toni Morrison. I had picked up the novel on sale years ago, knowing that I admired Morrison's work but not having read this one before. It languished in our library, unopened and unread, as Half Price Books and under-treated bipolar disorder left me at the time with more books acquired than actually appreciated. But this night I was looking for something new, something thinner in size if not in scope than our recent hefty choices, and I spotted it, and thought, why not?
The possible answer to "why not?" came in the form of "the n word" appearing half a dozen times in the first five pages. After the third or fourth iteration, The Man abruptly stopped reading, and asked -- more like demanded, desperate for an answer -- "should I be reading that word aloud?" I said the only thing I could: "I don't know."
I don't know. I know I want to teach the Boychick about the evils some people (people who look a lot like him) have done and still do against other people (people who look slightly less like him but are still fundamentally the same as him). I know I want to be able to have calm and rational conversations with him about the N word and why it is a word he is not ever allowed to use, even if he one day has friends who use it for themselves. I know I want to expose him to the profound and beautiful literature this hateful language -- and the even more hateful actions it represents -- have inspired in those who have endured and survived it, expose him to stories of lives he will never have to live, stories I hope he will help to make unnecessary for the next generation to write.
But he's two years old. He is a linguistic sponge, surprises everyone with his vocabulary and complex sentence structure and clarity of speech and thought -- and he will repeat the words he hears, even if he doesn't know what they mean, even if he can't understand why he mustn't use them. Even if we agree he's old enough to be exposed to the ugliness of life (more on that in a moment), I'm not sure he's yet cognitively able to hear and discuss and understand the explanations about the uses and implications of racial slurs, and until he is, I'm not sure we should expose him to the words and thus risk him exposing others -- who would understand, who could be hurt unnecessarily but understandably -- to them when he repeats them.
It is, of course, entirely due to white privilege that we have the choice whether to expose him to those slurs: he is white, we are white, most of our friends are white, and we travel primarily in a social sphere where racism is institutionalized, not explicated, subtle, not overt. A parent of color, or a parent of a child of color, all too often has the choice taken away from them, as these words are forced on them, flung at them like filth. It is entirely privilege unearned that allows me to sit comfortably in my sub/urban house, in a residential neighbourhood overwhelmingly white, in a city blindingly white, in a country still controlled by whiteness for all it is headed by a half black (but entirely Black) man, and indulge in angst over whether to allow my child to hear an ugly word that will never, ever be used against him.
But I think it is also white responsibility, stemming from that white privilege, to think about that language, to examine the role I play in perpetuating it, to act to counter it. I have a responsibility to teach my child about the word, about the larger evils it represents, yes: but I also have a responsibility to ensure my child does not hurt those around him by repeating it before he knows better, do I not?
So do we read the word aloud and hope he is able to understand our explanations? Substitute it with a euphemism more palatable but ultimately no less kyriarchal? Mumble it and hope he doesn't ask for clarification? Put the book away until he's "old enough", whenever that is? If we do that last, are we whitewashing his world, perpetuating racism-through-exclusion? Or would we be ensuring that in his formative years he only is exposed to positive images of people of color, friendly interactions between people of different races? I come around to the answer I gave that night: I don't know.
I don't have all the answers; some days, it feels I don't have any. I only hope that seeing me struggle to seek them will serve the Boychick well, because he's going to be white -- in a world that privileges whiteness above all others -- for the rest of his life. As I hold him close to me at night, thinking of another mother clutching her child after being exposed to the word in a way she couldn't control, would never have chosen, I whisper a prayer to whatever god/desses are listening: please, please let him do better. Let him work to oppose that privilege. Let the answers come easier to him. Let his generation grow beyond this ugliness. Let that word become meaningless, powerless, within his lifetime. Let him know how lucky he is; how no more worthy than any others, only luckier. Let him be white without perpetuating whiteness. Please.
****************
What do you do? Those who have had the choice taken away from you, or who chose to take the plunge and read it aloud, what did you say to your children? Were they able to understand the explanations? If you haven't addressed this issue, why not, and how have you worked to counter the privilege inherent in that choice?
Labels:
books,
kyriarchy,
parenting,
racism,
white privilege
Thursday, June 4, 2009
Racism in my brain
This is going to be another not-very-fun post for me to write.
First, let me say that I love being reminded of the ways in which humans are at essence primates. We are so very, very similar to our also-primate cousins in so many ways, and it makes me smile to notice the behaviors that are so obviously primate based: the way we touch to communicate and cement relationships, how we use grooming to comfort, the group dynamics that tell us instantly when people in a crowd are part of a family. Maybe I'm weird, but seriously, that makes me happy.
This, however, does not.
Yesterday I was driving along, and glanced over at a car next to me. There was a lovely Asian family driving and having a conversation. The shape of their faces, with the mouth just a little farther (farther from what? from mine, from a more European face, from "normal") out from their faces, reminded me of chimpanzees. Which, not really thinking about it, reminded me that humans are primates, which made me smile.
The smile froze on my face, as I realized holy shit, that is fucking racist.
Using oneself and one's body as the base model to which all others are compared is normal human (primate, I would argue) thinking, but becomes extremely problematical when the "I" doing the thinking is a member of a race which systematically and horrifically has dominated and oppressed all other races throughout history, so that's a big damn problem right there. And the trope that people of color are more like animals, more animalistic, closer to animals and less evolved (again, using white as "normal" from which other races "deviate") is one of the more pervasive, evil racist constructions, which has been used to justify the enslavement, murder, colonization, and de-humanization of millions of people. And it's in my brain.
When really looked at, it's obvious the construction is such bullshit, too. The very darkness of skin of people of color is, rather than being "animalistic", a sign of more evolution away from our primate cousins: chimpanzees underneath their fur, just like white/European humans, have no need for skin pigmentation, and are therefore pale. The excessive hairiness of limb, torso, and male face of white humans is more similar to our furry relations than is the comparatively lesser hairiness of many other races. So it would be easy and at least as accurate to construct an argument that white people are the more animalistic, the less evolved, the less human; or at least (and most accurately) to see in all humans things that remind us of other animals: face here, hair there, and all of us so obviously primates in body and behavior.
But that's not the way racism works. Whiteness has constructed itself as normal, human, most highly evolved, and all others as deviations and therefore lesser. In this framework, in which we all reside and by which my brain has been thoroughly colonized, whiteness cannot be understood as animal-like because whiteness defines what "human" is; only those who are outside of whiteness can be understood to be different from human and therefore like animals.
And it's in my brain.
I didn't even know about it. I had known about and hated the trope of the "savage, animalistic darkie", scoffed at those who used it, gotten angry at examples of it along with everyone else, and I never realized it was part of my own thinking. How could it be? That's a horrible, evil, racist thought, and I'm not racist, so I couldn't think like that.
But I do.
As a feminist, trying to raise my white male child in a womanist/feminist, anti-racist, anti-kyriarchy manner, to come across such a blatantly racist construction in my own mind is pretty damn horrifying. It's entirely too tempting to shove it aside, to not think about it, to deny it: and that is white privilege. White privilege means not having to think about race or to acknowledge racism when I encounter it, even (especially) in my own thinking. White privilege means I can accept that whiteness=normal, because I am white and it is human nature to think of ourselves as the norm. White privilege means everything in my culture is telling me "you are normal, you are the standard, you are the pinnacle from which all others are deviations"; white privilege means I could choose to not feel bad, to not think too hard, to not talk about it, to not admit it. I would not be directly hurt if I allowed this racism to continue; I would only be going along with the status quo and no one with power would blame me: that is white privilege.
I choose not to accept that privilege (it is white privilege that I have a choice, and I cannot do away with that privilege), and so I expose that thought, talk about it, deconstruct it, and work to do away with it from my own mind.
Now I wonder: how do I stop the thought from colonizing the Boychick's mind? When everything in his culture is telling him whiteness, and therefore he, is the default, when his own normal egocentricism agrees, how do I combat it? I can point out the ways in which all humans look and act like the animals we are; I can talk about how his father is hairy just like other primates, and how he will eventually be as well; I can avoid the "colorblind" ideology that prohibits mention of race at all, thereby reinforcing the white-as-standard meme: but I don't know if that will be enough.
The only thing I am certain of is that it is only possible to counter and defend against something when we know it's there, and so I am grateful to that racist thought, in debt to that family: for without the realization that came after, I would still be coasting along, smug in my superiority, unaware I carried that ugly construct within myself.
First, let me say that I love being reminded of the ways in which humans are at essence primates. We are so very, very similar to our also-primate cousins in so many ways, and it makes me smile to notice the behaviors that are so obviously primate based: the way we touch to communicate and cement relationships, how we use grooming to comfort, the group dynamics that tell us instantly when people in a crowd are part of a family. Maybe I'm weird, but seriously, that makes me happy.
This, however, does not.
Yesterday I was driving along, and glanced over at a car next to me. There was a lovely Asian family driving and having a conversation. The shape of their faces, with the mouth just a little farther (farther from what? from mine, from a more European face, from "normal") out from their faces, reminded me of chimpanzees. Which, not really thinking about it, reminded me that humans are primates, which made me smile.
The smile froze on my face, as I realized holy shit, that is fucking racist.
Using oneself and one's body as the base model to which all others are compared is normal human (primate, I would argue) thinking, but becomes extremely problematical when the "I" doing the thinking is a member of a race which systematically and horrifically has dominated and oppressed all other races throughout history, so that's a big damn problem right there. And the trope that people of color are more like animals, more animalistic, closer to animals and less evolved (again, using white as "normal" from which other races "deviate") is one of the more pervasive, evil racist constructions, which has been used to justify the enslavement, murder, colonization, and de-humanization of millions of people. And it's in my brain.
When really looked at, it's obvious the construction is such bullshit, too. The very darkness of skin of people of color is, rather than being "animalistic", a sign of more evolution away from our primate cousins: chimpanzees underneath their fur, just like white/European humans, have no need for skin pigmentation, and are therefore pale. The excessive hairiness of limb, torso, and male face of white humans is more similar to our furry relations than is the comparatively lesser hairiness of many other races. So it would be easy and at least as accurate to construct an argument that white people are the more animalistic, the less evolved, the less human; or at least (and most accurately) to see in all humans things that remind us of other animals: face here, hair there, and all of us so obviously primates in body and behavior.
But that's not the way racism works. Whiteness has constructed itself as normal, human, most highly evolved, and all others as deviations and therefore lesser. In this framework, in which we all reside and by which my brain has been thoroughly colonized, whiteness cannot be understood as animal-like because whiteness defines what "human" is; only those who are outside of whiteness can be understood to be different from human and therefore like animals.
And it's in my brain.
I didn't even know about it. I had known about and hated the trope of the "savage, animalistic darkie", scoffed at those who used it, gotten angry at examples of it along with everyone else, and I never realized it was part of my own thinking. How could it be? That's a horrible, evil, racist thought, and I'm not racist, so I couldn't think like that.
But I do.
As a feminist, trying to raise my white male child in a womanist/feminist, anti-racist, anti-kyriarchy manner, to come across such a blatantly racist construction in my own mind is pretty damn horrifying. It's entirely too tempting to shove it aside, to not think about it, to deny it: and that is white privilege. White privilege means not having to think about race or to acknowledge racism when I encounter it, even (especially) in my own thinking. White privilege means I can accept that whiteness=normal, because I am white and it is human nature to think of ourselves as the norm. White privilege means everything in my culture is telling me "you are normal, you are the standard, you are the pinnacle from which all others are deviations"; white privilege means I could choose to not feel bad, to not think too hard, to not talk about it, to not admit it. I would not be directly hurt if I allowed this racism to continue; I would only be going along with the status quo and no one with power would blame me: that is white privilege.
I choose not to accept that privilege (it is white privilege that I have a choice, and I cannot do away with that privilege), and so I expose that thought, talk about it, deconstruct it, and work to do away with it from my own mind.
Now I wonder: how do I stop the thought from colonizing the Boychick's mind? When everything in his culture is telling him whiteness, and therefore he, is the default, when his own normal egocentricism agrees, how do I combat it? I can point out the ways in which all humans look and act like the animals we are; I can talk about how his father is hairy just like other primates, and how he will eventually be as well; I can avoid the "colorblind" ideology that prohibits mention of race at all, thereby reinforcing the white-as-standard meme: but I don't know if that will be enough.
The only thing I am certain of is that it is only possible to counter and defend against something when we know it's there, and so I am grateful to that racist thought, in debt to that family: for without the realization that came after, I would still be coasting along, smug in my superiority, unaware I carried that ugly construct within myself.
Labels:
kyriarchy,
parenting,
privilege,
racism,
white privilege
Friday, April 24, 2009
Andrade is guilty, and so am I
I have been half following the Angie Zapata murder case, reading the posts on TransGriot about it, but not reading the links because I am a conscientious objector to the mainstream media (and have been having enough trouble keeping up with my feed reader as it is). I was, well, not pleased exactly (it's hard to be happy about the pitiful "justice" our punitive system offers) to hear that a fully guilty verdict was rendered, including the hate crime charge; I was overjoyed that for once, a "trans panic" defense had so thoroughly failed.
Then I read about Angie's family's reaction, and was struck dumb by the simultaneous realization and the refutation of my own assumptions.
I had thought, here was this little Latina trans girl, murdered by her maybe-boyfriend. I thought I knew her; she'd be kicked out by her transphobic Hispanic family, trying to make it on her own, possibly turning tricks to survive. Good little White Liberal Ally was I, so cynical about her chances for justice, so certain of her alienation.
But then I read her brother's words:
I was wrong. I was guilty of racism, of the most pervasive sort of cisgenderism: the ignore-ance of a trans person's own existence. I committed a hate crime in the whitewashed confines of my own head.
White privilege doesn't go away. Cisgender privilege doesn't go away. We can't do our course in Racism 101 and Transphobia 101 and then wash our hands of the blood of those whiteness has killed, of those cisgender bias has killed.
This doesn't give me much hope for the Boychick. Bashes the rose-colored glasses right off my "raise a post-racist generation" face, in fact. Which is probably a good thing; helps me see how the world actually is, how hard a journey is ahead. Best hope I have is to ground him in a childhood of racism- and cisgenderism-awareness, and show him that it never stops; privilege never goes away, no matter how much we want it to, so our obligation as possessors of privilege to learn, to listen, to humble ourselves, and to root out the prejudices hidden in the darkest corners of our own heads -- which will always be there, more persistent than cockroaches and uglier still -- never goes away.
I am so sorry for what I did to you, how I erased you in my own mind, Angie. Your memory deserves so much more than that. Angie's family: I can only beg forgiveness. Even if you never learn of my assumptions about you, even if you never learn I exist, I have wronged you, and I owe you. I am sorry.
Then I read about Angie's family's reaction, and was struck dumb by the simultaneous realization and the refutation of my own assumptions.
I had thought, here was this little Latina trans girl, murdered by her maybe-boyfriend. I thought I knew her; she'd be kicked out by her transphobic Hispanic family, trying to make it on her own, possibly turning tricks to survive. Good little White Liberal Ally was I, so cynical about her chances for justice, so certain of her alienation.
But then I read her brother's words:
Angie was my sister.And I had to confront my own heart, who thought that by knowing the plight of the plot of too many trans women of color's lives that I knew the circumstances of her life; who thought that since I knew the color of her family's skin that I knew the contents of their hearts. I made so many assumptions about her, not bothering to read further, not even realizing I had made them; as much as I thought about it, which was hardly at all, I thought I knew what I needed to know about her.
She was a member of our family. We loved her very much, and we will miss her every day. Every day and every night our mom has to deal with great pain of ... one of her babies being buried. Every day our siblings and I reach for the phone and realize we’ll never hear her voice. There’s no answer anymore.
A part of our family is missing, stolen from us. Angie was 18, her life was just beginning. She was brave, she had guts, she had courage, and she was beautiful, fun and loving. She was our little sister.
I was wrong. I was guilty of racism, of the most pervasive sort of cisgenderism: the ignore-ance of a trans person's own existence. I committed a hate crime in the whitewashed confines of my own head.
White privilege doesn't go away. Cisgender privilege doesn't go away. We can't do our course in Racism 101 and Transphobia 101 and then wash our hands of the blood of those whiteness has killed, of those cisgender bias has killed.
This doesn't give me much hope for the Boychick. Bashes the rose-colored glasses right off my "raise a post-racist generation" face, in fact. Which is probably a good thing; helps me see how the world actually is, how hard a journey is ahead. Best hope I have is to ground him in a childhood of racism- and cisgenderism-awareness, and show him that it never stops; privilege never goes away, no matter how much we want it to, so our obligation as possessors of privilege to learn, to listen, to humble ourselves, and to root out the prejudices hidden in the darkest corners of our own heads -- which will always be there, more persistent than cockroaches and uglier still -- never goes away.
I am so sorry for what I did to you, how I erased you in my own mind, Angie. Your memory deserves so much more than that. Angie's family: I can only beg forgiveness. Even if you never learn of my assumptions about you, even if you never learn I exist, I have wronged you, and I owe you. I am sorry.
Labels:
cisgender privilege,
parenting,
privilege,
racism,
white privilege
Friday, April 3, 2009
These are not fun links...*
But they're good. I can't really add anything, because, well... because. Because you should go read the links. (I've read all of these in the last couple of days, and they're all related, at least in my mind. I've put them in the order I encountered them.) Also, read the comments. Yes, all of them.
Renee's "'I'm not an ally but'" (read the comments)
we dont need another anti-racism 101 (read the comments, really)
The White Anti-Racist (read the whole thing, and really, read the comments -- OK, I haven't read all of them yet, but really, read them)
White Anti Racists Open Letter (you don't have to read the comments, but only because there aren't any)
Yes, I saw myself reflected in a lot of this. And I'm just going to sit with that for a while.
* That is, they weren't actually much fun for me to read.** But I still wanted to share them.
** OK, except for White Anti-Racist, which did make me laugh, even as I cringed because I saw myself.
Renee's "'I'm not an ally but'" (read the comments)
we dont need another anti-racism 101 (read the comments, really)
The White Anti-Racist (read the whole thing, and really, read the comments -- OK, I haven't read all of them yet, but really, read them)
White Anti Racists Open Letter (you don't have to read the comments, but only because there aren't any)
Yes, I saw myself reflected in a lot of this. And I'm just going to sit with that for a while.
* That is, they weren't actually much fun for me to read.** But I still wanted to share them.
** OK, except for White Anti-Racist, which did make me laugh, even as I cringed because I saw myself.
Tuesday, March 31, 2009
More on intersectionality
You know how I said we can't always get it right? Well, I was right, because I got some stuff wrong in that last post. I have a tendency to let language run away with me, and go with what sounds good rather than what's right. So in the last post, I conceptually missed one really important piece, and messed up in some of my language.
To whit, the idea of us v them (or even us and them). It doesn't work. When I'm talking about me, I can talk about "those who are not like me". But if I'm talking about "us" -- say, feminists, or fat acceptance advocates -- then I can't talk about a "them" -- women of color, or persons with disabilities -- because they are us. There are feminists of color, and disabled fat activists, and fat Brown trans Deaf feminist bisexual women (ok, I don't know of one, but that doesn't mean she doesn't exist), and for them (tricky word!), separating out one "strand" of privilege/oppression is both impossible and ridiculous. It is only when one has most of the cards stacked in one's favor that one has the privilege of pretending that that one axis of oppression can stand alone, be examined alone and dismantled alone.
We have to think about those who are not like us, yes, but we also must remember that those who may belong to a group we do not might also belong to ours. To say "feminists think this and blacks think that" is to ignore Black feminists. To say "well we invited them, why don't they join us?" is to exclude them (to Other "them"), and to render invisible those who are both "us" and
"them".
Intersectionalism is vital -- necessary to life! -- because the world is not made up of white people and black people and feminists and trans people. Rather, the world is made up of persons, who might be any combination of white and black and trans and feminist and disabled and fat and neurotypical and and and and...
It is fine and well to have a focus, a specialty (or two or three or however many). It is natural and understandable to have more expertise in the areas where one personally and intimately experiences oppression. But we cannot, we must not, allow that focus to blind us. We must not use our expertise in one area to exculpate our ignorance in another. Intersectionality doesn't mean we are required to study all areas of oppression equally; it calls us rather to open our eyes, to look to our own privilege when telling of our oppression, and it demands that we rid ourselves of the fallacy of "us" and "them".
Selfishly, I need for intersectionality to succeed, for examples of those who work to end one type of oppression interlinking with others to abound, for the skill of looking beyond oneself to find the "us" in "them" to flourish; I need it to succeed, for it is my only hope of teaching my presumably-straight white middle class son how to look at all areas of his privilege, to work against all the ways those-like-and-not-like-him are oppressed, to recognize the existence of kyriarchy and oppose it always. Those of us with even one area of oppression have an opening, as we learn of privilege, to learn intersectionality; those of us with many are forced to adopt it or self-destruct. My child has nearly every privilege in the world heaped on him, in a society that teaches the ugly art of Othering from birth: I fully admit to maternal selfishness when I say I need intersectionality to succeed so I do not lose him to the kyriarchy, which would have him Other everyone I love -- including me -- out of importance in his life.
So, that's not much of a reason for anyone else to adopt intersectionality (I fully recognize that an argument that sounds rather like "think of the white males!" is hardly much of a draw), but it's one reason, among many, I will defend and promote it as much as I can. I have an obligation to others to avoid oppressing and Othering and rendering them invisible, as I myself have been, as I myself am demanding not to be. And also, yes, I have an urgent desire to demonstrate that skill to a child unlikely to ever have call to learn the hard way why it is so very vital.
Intersectionality: the art of opposing the kyriarchy, one word at a time and all ways at once.
To whit, the idea of us v them (or even us and them). It doesn't work. When I'm talking about me, I can talk about "those who are not like me". But if I'm talking about "us" -- say, feminists, or fat acceptance advocates -- then I can't talk about a "them" -- women of color, or persons with disabilities -- because they are us. There are feminists of color, and disabled fat activists, and fat Brown trans Deaf feminist bisexual women (ok, I don't know of one, but that doesn't mean she doesn't exist), and for them (tricky word!), separating out one "strand" of privilege/oppression is both impossible and ridiculous. It is only when one has most of the cards stacked in one's favor that one has the privilege of pretending that that one axis of oppression can stand alone, be examined alone and dismantled alone.
We have to think about those who are not like us, yes, but we also must remember that those who may belong to a group we do not might also belong to ours. To say "feminists think this and blacks think that" is to ignore Black feminists. To say "well we invited them, why don't they join us?" is to exclude them (to Other "them"), and to render invisible those who are both "us" and
"them".
Intersectionalism is vital -- necessary to life! -- because the world is not made up of white people and black people and feminists and trans people. Rather, the world is made up of persons, who might be any combination of white and black and trans and feminist and disabled and fat and neurotypical and and and and...
It is fine and well to have a focus, a specialty (or two or three or however many). It is natural and understandable to have more expertise in the areas where one personally and intimately experiences oppression. But we cannot, we must not, allow that focus to blind us. We must not use our expertise in one area to exculpate our ignorance in another. Intersectionality doesn't mean we are required to study all areas of oppression equally; it calls us rather to open our eyes, to look to our own privilege when telling of our oppression, and it demands that we rid ourselves of the fallacy of "us" and "them".
Selfishly, I need for intersectionality to succeed, for examples of those who work to end one type of oppression interlinking with others to abound, for the skill of looking beyond oneself to find the "us" in "them" to flourish; I need it to succeed, for it is my only hope of teaching my presumably-straight white middle class son how to look at all areas of his privilege, to work against all the ways those-like-and-not-like-him are oppressed, to recognize the existence of kyriarchy and oppose it always. Those of us with even one area of oppression have an opening, as we learn of privilege, to learn intersectionality; those of us with many are forced to adopt it or self-destruct. My child has nearly every privilege in the world heaped on him, in a society that teaches the ugly art of Othering from birth: I fully admit to maternal selfishness when I say I need intersectionality to succeed so I do not lose him to the kyriarchy, which would have him Other everyone I love -- including me -- out of importance in his life.
So, that's not much of a reason for anyone else to adopt intersectionality (I fully recognize that an argument that sounds rather like "think of the white males!" is hardly much of a draw), but it's one reason, among many, I will defend and promote it as much as I can. I have an obligation to others to avoid oppressing and Othering and rendering them invisible, as I myself have been, as I myself am demanding not to be. And also, yes, I have an urgent desire to demonstrate that skill to a child unlikely to ever have call to learn the hard way why it is so very vital.
Intersectionality: the art of opposing the kyriarchy, one word at a time and all ways at once.
Labels:
intersectionalism,
isms,
kyriarchy,
language,
privilege,
white privilege
Monday, March 30, 2009
On intersectionality
Four months ago, when I was starting this blog, I had never even heard of the word "intersectionality" (wikipedia article, blog post [amazing pictures, but probably NSFW], another blog post, link post). I was aware, in a general way, of race issues, certainly of queer issues, to a lesser extent of trans issues, among others, and I was aware of the language of privilege, of the many ways in which I live with privilege (and the many ways I do not). But "intersectionality" was not a word on my radar, and I didn't really "get" it when I started looking it up -- the arguments "watered down!" "loss of focus!" "not in this movement!" floated through my thinking, though each was, in turn, shot down.
And yet, I think I understood it even then, before I heard it, intuitively; as I named and taglined my blog, while it was primarily about the experience of being a feminist raising a boy, I was clear that he was not just any male, but a white male, a probably-straight male, an American middle class probably-straight white able-bodied male: very nearly the tippy top of the hierarchy, by way of the intersection (!) of all these different aspects of privilege.
The more I've thought about it, and especially after coming upon the word/concept "kyriarchy", the more intersectionality makes sense (kyriarchy is what I was talking about here, though I didn't realize it at the time -- and I was also, unrealizingly, arguing against something of a straw feminism there). Feminism is in opposition to patriarchy, and this is good, but it takes only a moment of thought to realize that this does not and cannot (even at its most inclusive) cover all the ways in which some people are artificially privileged over others. Ultimately, I think it is the very concept of placing persons in a hierarchy (which is to say, it is kyriarchy) which needs to be done away with; and ultimately, it is intersectionalism alone which stands in opposition not just to one strand but, by definition, to all strands of oppression. It is only by working to recognize all forms of oppression/privilege in our work can we oppose all aspects of the kyriarchy; anything less is merely scrabbling for position on that fucked up ladder.
Which is not to say we need to get everything perfectly right all the time; we are human, and therefore both limited and flawed. Furthermore, we are humans raised under kyriarchy, and not one person reading this post can be without at least some privilege (since you've all managed to access the internet in some way or another); we are not going to be able to avoid all slip ups, all language of privilege, all incidents of accidental or oblivious oppression. But we can, and we must, try. Any step is worthy; any mistake is an opportunity to learn; any privilege recognized is a privilege weakened.
This ain't an easy path to walk, and there is no end to it. It would be all too easy to turn aside, to close my eyes, to rest easy on the privilege I do have while screaming for justice for the privilege I don't; but that way lies pain, if not for myself then for others, and if for others, then for all. Intersectionalism isn't diluting our purpose; it isn't putting others ahead of ourselves; it isn't "PC metastized". It is nothing less nor more than refusing to oppress others as we seek to end our own oppression. It is nothing less nor more than basic human compassion. It is nothing less than necessary, and nothing more than possible.
And yet, I think I understood it even then, before I heard it, intuitively; as I named and taglined my blog, while it was primarily about the experience of being a feminist raising a boy, I was clear that he was not just any male, but a white male, a probably-straight male, an American middle class probably-straight white able-bodied male: very nearly the tippy top of the hierarchy, by way of the intersection (!) of all these different aspects of privilege.
The more I've thought about it, and especially after coming upon the word/concept "kyriarchy", the more intersectionality makes sense (kyriarchy is what I was talking about here, though I didn't realize it at the time -- and I was also, unrealizingly, arguing against something of a straw feminism there). Feminism is in opposition to patriarchy, and this is good, but it takes only a moment of thought to realize that this does not and cannot (even at its most inclusive) cover all the ways in which some people are artificially privileged over others. Ultimately, I think it is the very concept of placing persons in a hierarchy (which is to say, it is kyriarchy) which needs to be done away with; and ultimately, it is intersectionalism alone which stands in opposition not just to one strand but, by definition, to all strands of oppression. It is only by working to recognize all forms of oppression/privilege in our work can we oppose all aspects of the kyriarchy; anything less is merely scrabbling for position on that fucked up ladder.
Which is not to say we need to get everything perfectly right all the time; we are human, and therefore both limited and flawed. Furthermore, we are humans raised under kyriarchy, and not one person reading this post can be without at least some privilege (since you've all managed to access the internet in some way or another); we are not going to be able to avoid all slip ups, all language of privilege, all incidents of accidental or oblivious oppression. But we can, and we must, try. Any step is worthy; any mistake is an opportunity to learn; any privilege recognized is a privilege weakened.
This ain't an easy path to walk, and there is no end to it. It would be all too easy to turn aside, to close my eyes, to rest easy on the privilege I do have while screaming for justice for the privilege I don't; but that way lies pain, if not for myself then for others, and if for others, then for all. Intersectionalism isn't diluting our purpose; it isn't putting others ahead of ourselves; it isn't "PC metastized". It is nothing less nor more than refusing to oppress others as we seek to end our own oppression. It is nothing less nor more than basic human compassion. It is nothing less than necessary, and nothing more than possible.
Labels:
intersectionalism,
isms,
kyriarchy,
language,
patriarchy,
privilege,
white privilege
Thursday, March 26, 2009
Big fish, small fish, small pond, big ocean: a Seussian experience of feminism
Sometimes I feel like two people: in "real" life, and in some of the online places I frequent, I am about the most radical feminist I know, and one of the few who has even heard the words "intersectionality" or "white privilege" or "cisgender" (much less cissexism). I find myself needing to dispel feminist myths, to spend all my time explaining the most basic vocabulary and concepts. I am a big fish in a small pond.
But in the feminist blogosphere, I am so new, so ignorant still in so many ways, and I spend most of my time just reading and reading and studying and following links and getting challenged, because there is so much I do not yet know about what it means to identify feminist, to exist with so much privilege (white, class, cisgender, able-bodied, etc), to live under kyriarchy. There are still so many myths, and misunderstandings, and consequences of unrecognized privilege within my own mind that I am discovering and attempting to ferret out. I am a very tiny fish in an enormous, diverse, amazing ocean.
I wasn't really going anywhere with that, I've just had a few experiences recently that have really brought it to my attention. It's a very Seussian form of cognitive dissonance (one fish, two fish, trans fish, cisfish?).
Anyone else ever feel like that?
But in the feminist blogosphere, I am so new, so ignorant still in so many ways, and I spend most of my time just reading and reading and studying and following links and getting challenged, because there is so much I do not yet know about what it means to identify feminist, to exist with so much privilege (white, class, cisgender, able-bodied, etc), to live under kyriarchy. There are still so many myths, and misunderstandings, and consequences of unrecognized privilege within my own mind that I am discovering and attempting to ferret out. I am a very tiny fish in an enormous, diverse, amazing ocean.
I wasn't really going anywhere with that, I've just had a few experiences recently that have really brought it to my attention. It's a very Seussian form of cognitive dissonance (one fish, two fish, trans fish, cisfish?).
Anyone else ever feel like that?
Labels:
identity,
isms,
self-indulgent introspection,
white privilege
Thursday, March 12, 2009
More thoughts on the mommy wars
A thought I didn't quite articulate but alluded to in my last post:
There is a moderately sizable movement that purports to be "anti mommy wars", of which Dawn's post (and especially the comment thread, last I checked) is a very good example. This side takes the position that since the mommy wars are supposed to be WOHM v SAHM, breast v bottle, cosleep v cry it out, then they can sidestep the misogyny by saying none of it matters, just do whatever works for you.
It is not a position without merit. Certainly it is admirable in that it is attempting to get away from the us v them impotent infighting of the traditional mommy wars. It's very post-modern in its relativism, and all the more appealing therefore to a certain type of privileged intellectual (in which group I usually include myself; certainly relativism is my default stance on many topics).
The problem is, in trying to avoid the mommy wars by "rising above", it fails, and indeed perpetuates just another variation of it. When I read a comment thread like that, what I hear is "aren't we all so much better than those small little women who have Positions on those issues and try to advocate for them". It ends up being another case of the "nonjudg(e)mental" sounding at least as judgmental and superior as those they're complaining about.
Again, this isn't to pick on this article as an example, nor even to shame that idea's adherents as a whole; that would be both hypocritical and counterproductive. Instead, I'm hoping to point out how, once again, the patriarchy has managed to frame the conversation in such a way as to always advantage and privilege and perpetuate itself, by making sure some women somewhere in the conversation are getting hated on and put down; and worst of all, it's making us do it to ourselves, by people who are trying to do better.
So, taking a position in the mommy wars, playing in to the us v them, "if you're not doing it like me you're doing it wrong and you're a bad mom and shame on you" = hating on women and supporting the patriarchy.
And, not taking sides, saying "it's all the same, none of it matters in the long run, it's all about individual choice, shame on you for caring what anyone else does" = hating on women and supporting the patriarchy.
So what's left? It would appear to be a double bind, and certainly societal forces are going to use all their resources of shame and misrepresentation to try to stuff us in to one of those boxes, no matter how hard we try to escape them, but I do believe there is an alternate path, that can have a righteous moral position and avoid misogynistic mother shaming. And surprise surprise: it starts with blaming the patriarchy.
It starts with accepting and understanding the idea that women are people, with full moral agency and ability to make choices that are right for them; and that the we live in a patriarchy that severely and overtly and subtly oppresses women and constrains what options and resources we have available.
It starts with saying that if we are pro-choice, we damn well ought to be working to make sure that women have REAL choice, and the ability to choose, not just to fantasize about what we might do under other, better circumstances.
It starts with recognizing that the language of choice is privileged to start with, that the idea of bickering over whether staying home or having a career is laughable to a woman without class privilege, white privilege, hetero privilege, cisgender privilege, able privilege, neurotypical privilege, age privilege, who may be fighting just to keep her children fed, keep them uninjured, keep them unhated, keep them alive, or just keep them when society would declare her "unfit".
It starts with saying that the system is fucked, and that under the system we are fucked, and that patriarchy is our enemy, and women -- all women, women like us and women dissimilar, women who agree with us and women we vehemently disagree with -- are the ones we are fighting for, not fighting with, even if on some small skirmish they are on "the other side".
It starts with saying that while not all mothers are good mothers, most are, and that being a good mother has NOTHING to do with some stupid checklist, and everything to do with loving one's children and doing one's good enough to be good enough (not even necessarily one's best to be good enough), and that one's worth as a mother is not measurable by how one's child "turns out", and furthermore one's worth as a woman is not dependent on one's worth as a mother.
In short, it starts with recognizing and rejecting every lie the patriarchy tries to feed us about mothers and motherhood.
Got all that? Ok. Given that -- but try not to take it as a given, for I know I for one am prone to slipping up and forgetting parts or all on a regular basis -- we can direct our attacks at the systemic ways the patriarchy influences and constrains choices, and promotes choices that promote its own ends: how a culture of detachment which promotes a pathological level of "independence" encourages aggression and devalues women and their work; how birth practices and the birth culture shames and vilifies women's bodies, protects institutionalized violence against women, and removes women's confidence and trust in our own power; how the belittlization of breastfeeding and especially the attacks on nursing in public shames and vilifies women's bodies, and promotes a false dichotomy between a woman's freedom and her child's health.
I could go on, but that's sufficient to exemplify how a conversation could and must be framed to attack systems and institutions that devalue -- dehumanize -- women, without attacking women or their choices at all.
In such a conversation, we must remember that it is not -- cannot -- be the goal to have all women choose the "right" action, even as we recognize and believe that as the systems are rectified the proportions will shift. There will always be disagreement and variation and that must be not only accepted but celebrated. We must also remember that as we champion our causes, we must take issue with the ideology, never take issue with individuals. We can debate how various practices affect women's status, and value parenting practices for how they avoid or conform to patriarchal goals, without valuing individual women for how they "measure up" to some imposed ideal.
There will always be those who take offense, who take criticism of ideology as personal attack; there will be times when we slip up under the weight of patriarchal pressures and violate the above starting points; there will be those who simply deny or reject some or all of those precepts entirely; but as much as we are able within the patriarchal, misogynistic societies we live in, this can point our way toward avoiding the so-called "mommy wars" while still fighting for feminist paths in parenting.
And the patriarchy is gonna hate it.
There is a moderately sizable movement that purports to be "anti mommy wars", of which Dawn's post (and especially the comment thread, last I checked) is a very good example. This side takes the position that since the mommy wars are supposed to be WOHM v SAHM, breast v bottle, cosleep v cry it out, then they can sidestep the misogyny by saying none of it matters, just do whatever works for you.
It is not a position without merit. Certainly it is admirable in that it is attempting to get away from the us v them impotent infighting of the traditional mommy wars. It's very post-modern in its relativism, and all the more appealing therefore to a certain type of privileged intellectual (in which group I usually include myself; certainly relativism is my default stance on many topics).
The problem is, in trying to avoid the mommy wars by "rising above", it fails, and indeed perpetuates just another variation of it. When I read a comment thread like that, what I hear is "aren't we all so much better than those small little women who have Positions on those issues and try to advocate for them". It ends up being another case of the "nonjudg(e)mental" sounding at least as judgmental and superior as those they're complaining about.
Again, this isn't to pick on this article as an example, nor even to shame that idea's adherents as a whole; that would be both hypocritical and counterproductive. Instead, I'm hoping to point out how, once again, the patriarchy has managed to frame the conversation in such a way as to always advantage and privilege and perpetuate itself, by making sure some women somewhere in the conversation are getting hated on and put down; and worst of all, it's making us do it to ourselves, by people who are trying to do better.
So, taking a position in the mommy wars, playing in to the us v them, "if you're not doing it like me you're doing it wrong and you're a bad mom and shame on you" = hating on women and supporting the patriarchy.
And, not taking sides, saying "it's all the same, none of it matters in the long run, it's all about individual choice, shame on you for caring what anyone else does" = hating on women and supporting the patriarchy.
So what's left? It would appear to be a double bind, and certainly societal forces are going to use all their resources of shame and misrepresentation to try to stuff us in to one of those boxes, no matter how hard we try to escape them, but I do believe there is an alternate path, that can have a righteous moral position and avoid misogynistic mother shaming. And surprise surprise: it starts with blaming the patriarchy.
It starts with accepting and understanding the idea that women are people, with full moral agency and ability to make choices that are right for them; and that the we live in a patriarchy that severely and overtly and subtly oppresses women and constrains what options and resources we have available.
It starts with saying that if we are pro-choice, we damn well ought to be working to make sure that women have REAL choice, and the ability to choose, not just to fantasize about what we might do under other, better circumstances.
It starts with recognizing that the language of choice is privileged to start with, that the idea of bickering over whether staying home or having a career is laughable to a woman without class privilege, white privilege, hetero privilege, cisgender privilege, able privilege, neurotypical privilege, age privilege, who may be fighting just to keep her children fed, keep them uninjured, keep them unhated, keep them alive, or just keep them when society would declare her "unfit".
It starts with saying that the system is fucked, and that under the system we are fucked, and that patriarchy is our enemy, and women -- all women, women like us and women dissimilar, women who agree with us and women we vehemently disagree with -- are the ones we are fighting for, not fighting with, even if on some small skirmish they are on "the other side".
It starts with saying that while not all mothers are good mothers, most are, and that being a good mother has NOTHING to do with some stupid checklist, and everything to do with loving one's children and doing one's good enough to be good enough (not even necessarily one's best to be good enough), and that one's worth as a mother is not measurable by how one's child "turns out", and furthermore one's worth as a woman is not dependent on one's worth as a mother.
In short, it starts with recognizing and rejecting every lie the patriarchy tries to feed us about mothers and motherhood.
Got all that? Ok. Given that -- but try not to take it as a given, for I know I for one am prone to slipping up and forgetting parts or all on a regular basis -- we can direct our attacks at the systemic ways the patriarchy influences and constrains choices, and promotes choices that promote its own ends: how a culture of detachment which promotes a pathological level of "independence" encourages aggression and devalues women and their work; how birth practices and the birth culture shames and vilifies women's bodies, protects institutionalized violence against women, and removes women's confidence and trust in our own power; how the belittlization of breastfeeding and especially the attacks on nursing in public shames and vilifies women's bodies, and promotes a false dichotomy between a woman's freedom and her child's health.
I could go on, but that's sufficient to exemplify how a conversation could and must be framed to attack systems and institutions that devalue -- dehumanize -- women, without attacking women or their choices at all.
In such a conversation, we must remember that it is not -- cannot -- be the goal to have all women choose the "right" action, even as we recognize and believe that as the systems are rectified the proportions will shift. There will always be disagreement and variation and that must be not only accepted but celebrated. We must also remember that as we champion our causes, we must take issue with the ideology, never take issue with individuals. We can debate how various practices affect women's status, and value parenting practices for how they avoid or conform to patriarchal goals, without valuing individual women for how they "measure up" to some imposed ideal.
There will always be those who take offense, who take criticism of ideology as personal attack; there will be times when we slip up under the weight of patriarchal pressures and violate the above starting points; there will be those who simply deny or reject some or all of those precepts entirely; but as much as we are able within the patriarchal, misogynistic societies we live in, this can point our way toward avoiding the so-called "mommy wars" while still fighting for feminist paths in parenting.
And the patriarchy is gonna hate it.
Thursday, February 5, 2009
Boys and dolls: an exploration of gender, sexuality -- and race
First, it was pretty much a no-brainer that we were getting the Boychick a doll for Solstice. He likes dolls at other people's houses, he plays with his own bunnies and monkeys frequently, asks to wear said toys, nurses them and potties them and walks up and down the hall shushing them (wonder where he got that one...). Boy needed a doll; therefore, boy was going to get a doll.
Neither The Man nor I have any of the objections to or hangups around boys with dolls frequently found in our patriarchal society. So we figured it should be simple, even if we were a little picky: we wanted soft, natural fibers; neutral facial expression; a good size for holding (14 or 16", we figured, based on measuring other toys of his); able to sit; male; anatomically correct preferred but not required. We had a good size budget, access to the whole internet. Easy peasy, right?
Well, no. Maybe if we'd not waited until the last minute, and took the time to custom order a doll, we would have been set. But by the time we were looking, all the custom slots were for, oh, March. And most of them were outside even our generous budget (triple digit prices for a soft fabric doll? maybe when it's not for a not-even-two year old). We did in fact find beautiful dolls made locally that would have been perfect -- except the price. On Etsy we could find reasonable priced custom dolls -- but then there was that wait-list thing.
So, prefab dolls it is. That's fine, lots of choices there. Nova Natural alone sells, what, three, four brands? And this is when we could no longer ignore the astounding gender disparity among dolls. They're made in about a 3-1 ratio of girl to boy just in terms of selection options, and that's not even looking at the numbers of dolls made or sold. We knew we wanted a boy doll, even if we'd given up on the wee penis, because we didn't want the Boychick to think only girls were soft and doll-like, plus we wanted him to identify with the doll, and as far as we know, he's a boy.
Thus our choices were limited in the male-doll department. And thus we came to race...
Do we get him a White doll? Or a doll of color? A Black doll? Or sort of split the difference and get a light-brown-skin doll? We couldn't get a doll that looked just like him (there were White dolls aplenty, but none with his lovely complex grey-green eyes), we weren't about to get the Perfect Aryan Nation blond hair blue eyed doll, 'cause that was just too squicky, but then... what? If we get him a doll that doesn't look like him, why not a doll that really doesn't look like him? Wouldn't diversity in his doll collection be good? Invisibility is the most basic form of discrimination, so wouldn't a black doll be showing that we're trying to Do Things Right? Anyway, his favorite book character is Little Pumpkin from More More More Said the Baby (don't ask us why, he's never told us; because s/he loses hir shoes? because s/he's black? because s/he has a grandma? just because?), so maybe he'd like a doll just like hir? Nothing wrong with a white kid playing with a black doll, right? That's just racist thinking, right?
Except...
We live in the whitest damn city in the US (no wait, now only the fifth whitest damn city). Very, very few of the children the Boychick plays with are children of color. This both makes it very important that he sees the full spectrum of humanity, but it also makes it set off my squickometer when the most frequent interaction with a being of color would be his plaything to do with what he will. Is that body of color, in doll form though it may be, ours to appropriate for our child's play? What is the line between appreciation and appropriation? Between exploration and exploitation? Doesn't it set off anyone else's bells to have a blond-haired presumably-straight white male only play with a body of color as his toy? Does it support the Waldorf-is-for-Whites-only ideology to buy a White Waldorf-style doll? Is this white guilt talking, or an awareness of white privilege? Is this justifying racism, or trying to avoid it?
I don't know. We didn't know. Nothing we chose felt quite right. We were safe when we were planning on getting him a doll that looked Just Like Him. We even felt safe looking at a doll with dark hair (which he eventually will have; we don't stay blond in either of our families) and dark eyes, or a doll with light brown skin and sandy brown hair with eyes like his. But when the choices came down to blond haired blue eyed, or Black, or White that otherwise had nothing in common with him... it felt like there were no right choices. Every option was fraught with race implications. Every choice could be seen to be wrong.
In the end, we went with the red-haired, brown-eyed White doll. Why? Because the dolls in the size we wanted that we could afford were White. Four girls, two boys, all White, White, White. We weren't touching the so-blond-it-was-white blue-eyed doll, we wanted a doll big enough for him to play with, we couldn't afford the ones that had dolls of many colors, so that's what we bought. Neatly side-stepping the whole thorny race-issue (thank you, white privilege), neatly supporting a company with a racist selection (or non-selection) of dolls.
And the Boychick likes him. We've named him Ira ("what's your dolly's name?" "eye!" "eye?" "eye!" "that's your dolly's name?" "eye!" "um... well, we could go with Ira, I guess..." and it stuck). He spends most of his time tossing him in the air or throwing him on the floor, but that's OK. He's also nursed him, and worn him, and fed him, and undressed and dressed him, and pottied him, and brushed his hair, and done all the things we were hoping he'd get to do with him. As Solstice presents go, it was a success, even if not quite as cool as his play kitchen.
I don't know if we made the right decision. I don't know if there was a right decision. "Raise boy anti-sexist with open, flexible gender roles": check. "Raise White child anti-racist with white privilege awareness and racial sensitivity": ...maybe not so much. I don't know. I just know that my boy has a doll, and I'm stumbling around in the dark -- no, in a light so White it's blinding my way.
Neither The Man nor I have any of the objections to or hangups around boys with dolls frequently found in our patriarchal society. So we figured it should be simple, even if we were a little picky: we wanted soft, natural fibers; neutral facial expression; a good size for holding (14 or 16", we figured, based on measuring other toys of his); able to sit; male; anatomically correct preferred but not required. We had a good size budget, access to the whole internet. Easy peasy, right?
Well, no. Maybe if we'd not waited until the last minute, and took the time to custom order a doll, we would have been set. But by the time we were looking, all the custom slots were for, oh, March. And most of them were outside even our generous budget (triple digit prices for a soft fabric doll? maybe when it's not for a not-even-two year old). We did in fact find beautiful dolls made locally that would have been perfect -- except the price. On Etsy we could find reasonable priced custom dolls -- but then there was that wait-list thing.
So, prefab dolls it is. That's fine, lots of choices there. Nova Natural alone sells, what, three, four brands? And this is when we could no longer ignore the astounding gender disparity among dolls. They're made in about a 3-1 ratio of girl to boy just in terms of selection options, and that's not even looking at the numbers of dolls made or sold. We knew we wanted a boy doll, even if we'd given up on the wee penis, because we didn't want the Boychick to think only girls were soft and doll-like, plus we wanted him to identify with the doll, and as far as we know, he's a boy.
Thus our choices were limited in the male-doll department. And thus we came to race...
Do we get him a White doll? Or a doll of color? A Black doll? Or sort of split the difference and get a light-brown-skin doll? We couldn't get a doll that looked just like him (there were White dolls aplenty, but none with his lovely complex grey-green eyes), we weren't about to get the Perfect Aryan Nation blond hair blue eyed doll, 'cause that was just too squicky, but then... what? If we get him a doll that doesn't look like him, why not a doll that really doesn't look like him? Wouldn't diversity in his doll collection be good? Invisibility is the most basic form of discrimination, so wouldn't a black doll be showing that we're trying to Do Things Right? Anyway, his favorite book character is Little Pumpkin from More More More Said the Baby (don't ask us why, he's never told us; because s/he loses hir shoes? because s/he's black? because s/he has a grandma? just because?), so maybe he'd like a doll just like hir? Nothing wrong with a white kid playing with a black doll, right? That's just racist thinking, right?
Except...
We live in the whitest damn city in the US (no wait, now only the fifth whitest damn city). Very, very few of the children the Boychick plays with are children of color. This both makes it very important that he sees the full spectrum of humanity, but it also makes it set off my squickometer when the most frequent interaction with a being of color would be his plaything to do with what he will. Is that body of color, in doll form though it may be, ours to appropriate for our child's play? What is the line between appreciation and appropriation? Between exploration and exploitation? Doesn't it set off anyone else's bells to have a blond-haired presumably-straight white male only play with a body of color as his toy? Does it support the Waldorf-is-for-Whites-only ideology to buy a White Waldorf-style doll? Is this white guilt talking, or an awareness of white privilege? Is this justifying racism, or trying to avoid it?
I don't know. We didn't know. Nothing we chose felt quite right. We were safe when we were planning on getting him a doll that looked Just Like Him. We even felt safe looking at a doll with dark hair (which he eventually will have; we don't stay blond in either of our families) and dark eyes, or a doll with light brown skin and sandy brown hair with eyes like his. But when the choices came down to blond haired blue eyed, or Black, or White that otherwise had nothing in common with him... it felt like there were no right choices. Every option was fraught with race implications. Every choice could be seen to be wrong.
In the end, we went with the red-haired, brown-eyed White doll. Why? Because the dolls in the size we wanted that we could afford were White. Four girls, two boys, all White, White, White. We weren't touching the so-blond-it-was-white blue-eyed doll, we wanted a doll big enough for him to play with, we couldn't afford the ones that had dolls of many colors, so that's what we bought. Neatly side-stepping the whole thorny race-issue (thank you, white privilege), neatly supporting a company with a racist selection (or non-selection) of dolls.
And the Boychick likes him. We've named him Ira ("what's your dolly's name?" "eye!" "eye?" "eye!" "that's your dolly's name?" "eye!" "um... well, we could go with Ira, I guess..." and it stuck). He spends most of his time tossing him in the air or throwing him on the floor, but that's OK. He's also nursed him, and worn him, and fed him, and undressed and dressed him, and pottied him, and brushed his hair, and done all the things we were hoping he'd get to do with him. As Solstice presents go, it was a success, even if not quite as cool as his play kitchen.
I don't know if we made the right decision. I don't know if there was a right decision. "Raise boy anti-sexist with open, flexible gender roles": check. "Raise White child anti-racist with white privilege awareness and racial sensitivity": ...maybe not so much. I don't know. I just know that my boy has a doll, and I'm stumbling around in the dark -- no, in a light so White it's blinding my way.
Labels:
gender roles,
parenting,
racism,
toys,
white privilege
Wednesday, January 21, 2009
Can we stop saying patriarchy is good for men?
If the patriarchy is good for men, then feminism, which opposes and seeks to dismantle the patriarchy, must be bad for men, and men become feminist's enemies, the pawns and bishop and knights of the patriarchy, if you will. We need to recruit allies, not create enemies which the "us v. them" rhetoric does quite well.
And patriarchy really isn't good for men, except in comparison to how truly horrible it is for women.
What the patriarchy does is create a hierarchy with (straight white rich thin ablebodied nuerotypical cisgendered) men at top, and (queer black poor fat disabled neurodivergent trans) women at bottom. It piles every privilege on men; values their work and their bodies as the standard; instills in them surety of their superiority; tells them they are closest to God (made in His image!); and gives them free reign to express their anger and hatred with any violence they please to use, at least as long as it's against a woman.
Sound great? Compared to getting pissed on and shat on and beat on and hated on and enslaved and raped and killed at the bottom of the patriarchal ladder, of course it does. Of course it is. It's a hundred thousand million times better and easier to live at the top as a straight white rich thin ablebodied nuerotypical cisgendered man than at the bottom as a queer poor fat disabled neurodivergent trans woman of color, and any man who tries to play the "you think you've got it hard??" game with a woman deserves, well, any violent expression of anger and hatred she pleases to use.
But simply rearranging that fucked up hierarchy, moving around the pieces so different types get piled on and get to sit on top, isn't what feminism is about. Feminism (and anti-racism and neurodiversity and other power-protesting movements) is about dismantling the whole unholy ladder entirely. It's about saying that the circumstances of your birth -- your gender, your race, your sexuality, your able-ity -- don't give you more value than anyone else. Men don't deserve bowing and scraping and every blessing of capitalism; no one does. Power corrupts, and privilege is ugly, and having power and privilege above others is bad for the soul of anyone.
The thing about the patriarchy is that while it gives men more freedom than anyone else by a factor of a thousand, it is not a perfect freedom. Men are allowed to show anger, but not fear or gentleness or vulnerability. Their work is valued, unless they want to do what is considered feminine. Their bodies are valued, as long as their bodies are manly enough. They are like God, but lose the chance to know Goddess as an equal. They are placed above all, and their humanity and humility corroded thereby.
What feminism offers men is a removal of those restrictions. No longer will men be pampered by the service of women, but rather they will be presented with strong, proud partners they can work with. Men won't be privileged above all others, but all the others will rise up and will join together to the benefit of all. Only the brainwashing of the patriarchy tells us that superiority is better than equality.
In the patriarchy, it is women who get the short end of the stick, to be sure, but I look at my Boychick, as beautiful and vulnerable and perfect as all babies are but "privileged" to be at the top of a stinking ugly inhumane heap of humanity, and I just want to get rid of the damned stick altogether. From here on out, the patriarchy is only going to hurt him, damage him, make him uglier, even as it makes him hurt those below him a million times more. How can that be "good" for him?
And patriarchy really isn't good for men, except in comparison to how truly horrible it is for women.
What the patriarchy does is create a hierarchy with (straight white rich thin ablebodied nuerotypical cisgendered) men at top, and (queer black poor fat disabled neurodivergent trans) women at bottom. It piles every privilege on men; values their work and their bodies as the standard; instills in them surety of their superiority; tells them they are closest to God (made in His image!); and gives them free reign to express their anger and hatred with any violence they please to use, at least as long as it's against a woman.
Sound great? Compared to getting pissed on and shat on and beat on and hated on and enslaved and raped and killed at the bottom of the patriarchal ladder, of course it does. Of course it is. It's a hundred thousand million times better and easier to live at the top as a straight white rich thin ablebodied nuerotypical cisgendered man than at the bottom as a queer poor fat disabled neurodivergent trans woman of color, and any man who tries to play the "you think you've got it hard??" game with a woman deserves, well, any violent expression of anger and hatred she pleases to use.
But simply rearranging that fucked up hierarchy, moving around the pieces so different types get piled on and get to sit on top, isn't what feminism is about. Feminism (and anti-racism and neurodiversity and other power-protesting movements) is about dismantling the whole unholy ladder entirely. It's about saying that the circumstances of your birth -- your gender, your race, your sexuality, your able-ity -- don't give you more value than anyone else. Men don't deserve bowing and scraping and every blessing of capitalism; no one does. Power corrupts, and privilege is ugly, and having power and privilege above others is bad for the soul of anyone.
The thing about the patriarchy is that while it gives men more freedom than anyone else by a factor of a thousand, it is not a perfect freedom. Men are allowed to show anger, but not fear or gentleness or vulnerability. Their work is valued, unless they want to do what is considered feminine. Their bodies are valued, as long as their bodies are manly enough. They are like God, but lose the chance to know Goddess as an equal. They are placed above all, and their humanity and humility corroded thereby.
What feminism offers men is a removal of those restrictions. No longer will men be pampered by the service of women, but rather they will be presented with strong, proud partners they can work with. Men won't be privileged above all others, but all the others will rise up and will join together to the benefit of all. Only the brainwashing of the patriarchy tells us that superiority is better than equality.
In the patriarchy, it is women who get the short end of the stick, to be sure, but I look at my Boychick, as beautiful and vulnerable and perfect as all babies are but "privileged" to be at the top of a stinking ugly inhumane heap of humanity, and I just want to get rid of the damned stick altogether. From here on out, the patriarchy is only going to hurt him, damage him, make him uglier, even as it makes him hurt those below him a million times more. How can that be "good" for him?
Labels:
isms,
male privilege,
men,
patriarchy,
racism,
white privilege
Sunday, January 18, 2009
Something I said in my last post has been bugging me
I said:
It doesn't work that way, of course.
The very fact that I can think and say that my child may not know what race is at not-quite-two is because I am white, and my child is white, and The Man is white, and I swim, eat, breathe white privilege. Of course my child doesn't have to "deal with" race yet, or understand that the color of his skin speaks of so much more than how much melanin he produces; not because he is two, but because he is white. We have the option of talking with him about racism, or not. We have the option of talking with him about privilege, or not. That is one small aspect of this giant napsack of white privilege: the option to ignore it exists.
And being white; having this privilege I did not ask for and do not want; having been raised knowing racism was bad but never talking about race; having been taught that to be "color blind" was the goal so if we all (by which of course we mean white people) just squeezed our eyes shut real tight and held on and wished hard, it would go away (it being race and racism and privilege and difficult conversations and horrific pasts and horrific presents)... it's hard to talk about.
I have to anyway. Even if I don't always know what to say. Even if I get it wrong sometimes (which I did, and which I will again). Because I have to, else the Boychick will become just another damn clueless white guy, and I can't let that happen.
This is why it matters when our kids' books have only white, able-bodied, neurotypical, cisgendered, gender-stereotyped characters. This is why it matters that we talk with our toddlers and our preschoolers about diversity and gender and sexuality and race and privilege, to the best of our ability, in ways they can understand. They may not know exactly what they are inside yet, they may not know exactly what race means yet or exactly what sex is yet, so it might seem to "not matter", but so, so soon they will.I've been thinking a lot recently about race, and racism, and white privilege, and the intersection of feminism and anti-racism (and the intersections of feminism and racism), and I think that was part of why I was trying to do the ultra-liberal thing of conflating all -isms together in one big homogeneous lump and treating them all with "these suck, don't do them" stick.
It doesn't work that way, of course.
The very fact that I can think and say that my child may not know what race is at not-quite-two is because I am white, and my child is white, and The Man is white, and I swim, eat, breathe white privilege. Of course my child doesn't have to "deal with" race yet, or understand that the color of his skin speaks of so much more than how much melanin he produces; not because he is two, but because he is white. We have the option of talking with him about racism, or not. We have the option of talking with him about privilege, or not. That is one small aspect of this giant napsack of white privilege: the option to ignore it exists.
And being white; having this privilege I did not ask for and do not want; having been raised knowing racism was bad but never talking about race; having been taught that to be "color blind" was the goal so if we all (by which of course we mean white people) just squeezed our eyes shut real tight and held on and wished hard, it would go away (it being race and racism and privilege and difficult conversations and horrific pasts and horrific presents)... it's hard to talk about.
I have to anyway. Even if I don't always know what to say. Even if I get it wrong sometimes (which I did, and which I will again). Because I have to, else the Boychick will become just another damn clueless white guy, and I can't let that happen.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)