Showing posts with label sexuality. Show all posts
Showing posts with label sexuality. Show all posts

Friday, July 3, 2009

On breastfeeding and things we don't talk about

Raising My Boychick has moved: please read and comment on this post at the new site!

Just in case there was any question, let me state emphatically that I am a breastfeeding supporter, a hard-core breastfeeding advocate, a lactivist (but not a "breastfeeding nazi", please and thank you):

I'm down with child-led weaning. I call nursing for 2+ years "full-term", and anything less than that "abbreviated" or "short" or "premature weaning", and I can't think of anything I would call "extended breastfeeding", except maybe being latched on for 8 hours non-stop.

I think feminists must support breastfeeding, and breastfeeding in public (and pumping, and pumping at work and in public), else they fail at one of the fundamental precepts of feminism.

I believe women have the moral right and must have the legal right to expose however much of their breast they and their child deem necessary, for however long they deem necessary, incidental to the act of breastfeeding, and that a woman has the moral right and must have the legal right to breastfeed or pump anywhere she otherwise has the right to be.

I've nursed my kid in the dark, at the park, in a plane, on a train, in a car, and over a jar (we did EC), and yes, I pull it down and whip it out and no you don't have a right not to see it, though you're more than welcome to avert your gaze.

I've never kept track of how many times the Boychick nursed throughout the day or over the course of a night, because he nursed when he was hungry, or thirsty, or tired, or hurt, or bored, or just because, and all of those are perfectly legitimate reasons to breastfeed in my mind.

When asked when I was going to wean, I say that WHO recommends a minimum of 2 years, but I was pretty sure he'd be done before college. I trust Dettwyler's research showing the natural age of human weaning to be between 2.5-7 years. I told my mom to be prepared for her grandson nursing well into kindergarten, if that's what he wants, and that I would fight to keep nursing for 2 years, with a minimum goal of 2.5

Yes, I am one of those women.

I tell you this, present to you my lactivist credentials so to speak, because when I say that I hate nursing, I want you to have some idea of what it means. So that when I say I hate nursing, and my 28 month old seems to be coming to an end of breastfeeding, you'll maybe get it when I say it makes me cry.

I never know how to describe my problematic feelings about breastfeeding. It isn't the idea of it, obviously. It isn't a matter of getting "touched out": I'm a hugely touchy-feely person, and had no problems having the Boychick on or next to my person most of the day (and on his dad's body the rest of the time). It isn't a matter of dysphoric milk ejection reflex, it's not a history of abuse, and it isn't a chronically painful latch. It's definitely not a matter of being uncomfortable in my own skin, or disliking the animal nature of it. And it's obviously nothing so bad that I was unable to continue, or chose to stop, but it's probably contributing to this (to us) relatively early weaning.

No, it's that for all the lactivist protestations to the contrary, breastfeeding is sexual, at least for me. Whether through biology or socialization (and I'm inclined, as I often am, to say "both"), feeling the child suckling on my breast -- and I should clarify here, it's primarily dry nursing, or comfort nursing, or the lag between the start of nursing and milk ejection, when there's little or no milk being transferred -- often feels sexual to me. And I really don't like it.

I usually use words like "uncomfortable" (because it is), or say it drives me crazy (because it does). I usually don't say I dislike it because it makes my cunt swell and start to throb, because there are all kinds of social stigmas associated with that, above and beyond the usual ignorant bitching about breastfeeding in the first place. Plus, there are people who like that feeling, and not in a pervy "I'm gonna nurse my kids to get my kicks" kind of way (I have met thousands of full-term nursing women, and never, ever have I met one who thought of nursing like that), but just in a happy "hey, this makes my body feel good" kind of way. And I think that's great, and totally normal and healthy. Actually, I'm envious as hell of those women: I'd do anything to have that kind of feeling about the feelings nursing causes.

But no, breastfeeding feels sexual, and it feels uncomfortable, and it makes me want to take a cheese grater to my nipples, or cut off my breasts, or crawl out of my skin, or get up and run away and claw my eyes out. And I have resorted to pain as a coping mechanism: biting my hand or pulling my hair or digging nails into my flesh, anything, anything to distract me long enough for him to finish, to calm down, to fall asleep, to get a letdown going, whatever he needs. But I can't always manage it, and it's leading to a downward spiral, where I have less milk, so I can't nurse him as much, so I have less milk, so... And on and on, until he's falling asleep to The Man reading to him and snuggling him in bed, and I'm out in the livingroom crying because I can't be the woman I want to be, can't do the thing I want to do.

I hate breastfeeding, and I hate that I hate it. I hate that, as much as I love the idea of comfort nursing, it is anything but comfortable for me. I hate that the way I want to mother, with breastfeeding a wholly holy joy and there for him whenever he needs or wants it, is not possible for me. I hate that there have been nights both he and I have cried to sleep because I just. couldn't. do it anymore. I hate that it's causing our nursing relationship to come to an end so soon. And I hate, I hate, that talking about it like this will make some people think "then what the hell are you still doing it for?"

I'm "still" doing it because I love it. I love snuggling him close to me while his eyes stutter close and roll back in bliss. I love playing stinky feet and having him try not to laugh so he doesn't delatch. I love the twenty extra minutes I can buy myself in the morning for lounging under the covers and scrolling through Google Reader. I love how he asks to nurse after he gets really hurt because "it makes me better". I love knowing he's getting immunological and nutritional substances he wouldn't get anywhere else. I love everything about breastfeeding -- except, more and more though still not always, the actual physical act.

Our nursing relationship is going to come to an end someday, likely sooner rather than later. This is normal, and natural, and has to happen sometime. And almost everyone I know speaks about weaning with ambivalence, so my experience is hardly unique in that respect. But this -- being a lactivist who often hates the experience of breastfeeding, mourning an early weaning at 28 months -- isn't something I see talked about much, if ever.

There are so many forces telling me not to publish this post: there's the patriarchy saying that nursing a 2yo is disgusting, that having genital sensations during breastfeeding is perverted, that nursing should be perfect and lovely and angelic, not messy and complicated and human. There's lactivism saying I'm just giving fuel to anti-breastfeeders, I shouldn't talk about the bad times, the hard times, that I'm going to scare people off. There's feminism saying I should make it all about the kyriarchy (when the truth is I'm too tired and too hurting to think that big right now), and that this is all so much middle class privileged white woman mommy blogging whining, and I should be using my platform to spotlight those with real problems. The lactivism and feminism sides even have good points.

But ultimately, I'm sharing this because I can't be the only one. I'm not so special or so unique that no one else feels this way. I'm sharing this because women's stories are important: not just our beautiful stories, not just our predictable stories, not just our uncomplicated damn-the-patriarchy moralistic stories, but all of them, messy and complicated and contradictory and nuanced and ugly and difficult and mundane and human and boring and silly. And it is through sharing our stories and connecting with others leading complicated-human-nuanced lives that we become strong.

And I need strength right now. I needed strength when the Boychick was a mewling newborn, who only knew that suckling was comfort and love and safety and peace, and didn't know it was discomfort and ugly and painful and hard for me, and I need strength now that he is recognizing I sometimes grimace and pull away and push him away when he seeks the comfort he knows at my breast, and is preempting that pain for both of us by turning elsewhere for his needs.

We're not meant to do this alone. I don't regret a moment I've spent nursing my child, not even the moments I was crying and hurting myself to cope. But I regret doing it in isolation, with no one to tell me I wasn't alone, I wasn't abnormal, and I wasn't wrong for doing it anyway.

Share your stories. Even your ugly stories, even your hard ones. Someone out there is going through it too, and they need to hear from you. I surely did.

Raising My Boychick has moved: please read and comment on this post at the new site!

Wednesday, June 17, 2009

28 day cycle! And let's talk about sex

(But no, I didn't ovulate on day 14. Interesting factoid: the cycle I did finally conceive the Boychick, I not only ovulated on day 14, but then birthed him at 40w9d, which is the actual average length of gestation for a spontaneous labor in a primipara. He was a by the book baby!)

So I started my period today, indicating another cycle we successfully evaded pregnancy, and I'd like to take a moment to wax lyrical about two of the contraceptive methods we use, both of which are generally poohpoohed or dismissed for the very reason I like them: they either require or accept the male partner's full involvement.

Method one: "coitus interruptus", or withdrawal. And no, I don't mean "pull and pray". Withdrawal, when practiced appropriately, is just about on par with condoms in preventing pregnancy (my edition of Contraceptive Technologies places it at 94% efficacy when practiced perfectly, compared to condoms' 95%; the above link places it more at 96% to condoms' 98%). The reasons it's not recommended, as opposed to condoms, are: it does diddly to protect against diseases, it's awfully hard for many to practice perfectly, and it requires the woman to trust and rely on her male partner.

My answer to both the first and the last reasons is: this is why it is not recommended outside of a healthy (emotionally and physically) monogamous relationship, but also why it is a good option inside of one. When almost all other forms of contraception require the woman to do the work (take a pill, get a shot, have a device inserted permanently or temporarily), it's wonderfully refreshing to have a method that requires the man's full buy in and participation, and puts the onus on him for once.

To the middle objection, that it's rarely put into perfect use: well, that's true. Most people don't even know what appropriate use of the withdrawal method calls for, which is:
  • either a lack of ejaculation or ejaculating far away from the vagina (pulling out barely in time only to spooge on the vulva really doesn't do any good)
  • AND a lack of having already ejaculated in the previous 24 hours
The reasoning for the second is that although "precum" (properly called pre-ejaculate) does not contain sperm (really!), it might wash out sperm that has been hanging out in the urethra from a previous ejaculation. But since sperm don't survive long at all outside of a fertile vaginal/uterine environment, even that small chance is over after 24 hours.

So, that's withdrawal: a perfectly acceptable and effective birth control method for those in an emotionally and physically healthy relationship, with a man willing and able to control himself during PIV (penis in vagina) sex, and who can refrain from orgasm in the 24 hours prior to the PIV moment.

The other, as y'all know by now, is the fertility awareness method. This one doesn't require full male participation (although it does require at least some, since it involves either abstaining or using back up methods during fertile times), but can: in our house, The Man's alarm goes off at 6:30am every morning, he gets out the thermometer, turns it on, and wakes me up enough to hand it to me, I stick it in my mouth until it beeps to indicate it's done, he takes it back, and when he gets up he records the temperature. He also records any factors that might influence the temperature, such as illness or time variation, and the date of any PIV sex and the backup contraceptive method used, if any. I (when I, erm, bother to) record my menstruation and cervical fluids (I also used to chart cervical texture and positioning, which was a really strong indicator, but alas that has become unreadable since birthing the Boychick), and do most of the interpreting.

I'm not going to debate or defend FAM much except to say that it is only as effective as the method used during fertile or unidentifiable times: that is, when full abstention is used during all potentially fertile times (about 1/3 of the month for the average woman, closer to 1/2 for me since I have such a short luteal phase), and potentially fertile times are indeed identifiable (they are not for all women) and defined quite conservatively, it can be highly effective. For us, because we use condoms and withdrawal methods during fertile times, it is closer to 94% (possibly even less, because the efficacy numbers for condoms and withdrawal come from using them across the cycle, not just during known fertile times), which we are comfortable with.

There's something fabulously feminist about a birth prevention method in which a male partner can participate so fully. Not only do I gain so much information about my body and its workings through charting (which would be reason enough to chart, even if a man weren't involved at all), but we can on occasion have "deliciously natural sex"* without me imbibing anything that alters or affects my biology, and The Man has to do most of the (minimal) work. What's not to love about that?

I've heard and understand the arguments why women shouldn't rely on men for their pregnancy prevention, and while I understand the need to avoid helpless dependence in most situations, I also think we can go too far into pathological independence. In certain types of relationships, both withdrawal and FAM can be used to encourage male involvement and investment in the birth control method, heighten the relationship between lovers and the quality of lovemaking, and build the best kind of interdependence wherein both parties work together for the benefit of all. And that's as feminist a goal for birth control methods as any I can think of.



*I love this phrase for PIV sex only inasmuch as "natural" is understood to mean "without barriers or other substances", and not implying that only PIV sex is "natural", which of course would be both false and offensive.

Friday, May 1, 2009

This just in: Great Britain's new Poet Laureate

Blogging from my car, because I just heard on the radio: GB's new Poet Laureate is the first woman to be offered the post in the 400 years of its existance. And she's feminist. And a mother. And bisexual. Someone pinch me and tell mr I'm dreaming, or the radio was garbled -- or better yet, post a link of confirmation!

I might go in to my thoughts on why the US's appointments of women PLs and the UK's lack thereof (before now!) are both reflective of the patriarchy at some other time, but since I owe you a BADD post already today, and must go stop the child from learning how to drive before he learns to tie his shoes, I'll just leave this post at begging for someone to post a link.

Wednesday, March 25, 2009

Passing for straight: parenting with a man as a queer identified woman

I will say this for passing: it gives one a lot more opportunities for coming out.

I just came out to a new friend from massage school. You'd think the act --a short sentence, one second, two words: "I'm bisexual" -- would get easier over time, and with practice. But to the contrary, I find it harder now than it ever was before.

My first coming out as bisexual -- to my first crush, as a freshman in high school, just a few weeks after finally hearing the term and recognizing myself in it -- was met with an anticlimactic "well duh, Arwyn". Two years later, coming out to my first romantic relationship got me an amused "I know".

You might say I did not do in the closet well. I was -- and am, when I feel safe -- a voracious flirt, never adhered to straight female gender roles, and had Ru Paul pinups in my locker instead of the usual... who was usual to crush on? I never kept track. Anyway, "coming out" in adolescence was, contrary to most other QTBLGs' experience, ridiculously easy, an exercise in stating the obvious to anyone who spent any time with me. With the arrogance of ignorance and unacknowledged privilege, I scoffed (in the safety of my own cranium, at least, even then however dimly recognizing its privileged origins) at those who found it hard, who dithered and postponed and passed rather than come out and say it -- or simply live it.

And now, when the moment comes to say it or lie by omission, I find myself hemming and hawing and dithering, and, yes, sometimes shutting up and just plain passing. And I hate it. What happened to "duh"?

Duh is no more, after eleven years with a man (Mr "I know" himself in fact, my first and only), after leaving high school and college and the groups of friends I came out with. And it really vanished after getting pregnant and having a baby, with a man, in the "usual", heteronormative way. After all, I am, indubitably, a breeder now, and everyone knows "breeder" means "straight".

It doesn't matter in the public eye, it seems, what other signals I send: having a child, with a man, makes me straight. After all, this is the Pacific Northwest, and I run with a crunchy crowd: unshaven pits, Birkenstocks year round, having a "partner" instead of a "husband", and being stridently outspoken for "gay rights" merely marks me as yet another crazy white neo-hippie liberal.

Add to that a social network comprised almost entirely of other women-who-spend-the-day-with-their-kids, the fear of losing straight friends to innocent flirting (not an unreasonable fear, I think, in a culture that equates bisexuality with unquenchable nymphomania, and paints us as seductresses and adulterers when it bothers admitting our existence at all), and I find myself, for the first time since I was 14 years old, being perceived as straight not just by a homophobic heteronormative society, but by people who know me. For someone who has been explicitly, outspokenly out for so long, it is a decidedly unexpected and uncomfortable experience.

But the hardest part, the part I cannot figure out how to work around, is that I had always relied on "living out" -- being obvious, refusing to pass -- as my way of dealing with the issue of any children of mine knowing my sexuality. If it were simply a part of my public identity, a fact that anyone who knows me would know, then the Boychick would grow up knowing it, simply and easily and without any fuss. But the very act of his creation has taken my public identity as an out bisexual from hard to maintain (I've spent my entire adult life in a monogamous relationship with a man; it hasn't been exactly easy for a while) to seemingly impossible. To the extent that I "pass", that I am understood by others however falsely to be straight, I am confronted with a dilemma where the Boychick is concerned; being closeted (used here as a verb, of which I am the subject and others the actor) means that I would be forced to decide what and when -- and indeed, whether -- to tell him.

And who wants to hear about their parents' sexuality? If not a part of one's (public) identity, one's sexuality is a matter of what one wants to do to or with whom, which is not information I can see as entirely appropriate to share with my child. If not understood to be a part of my public identity, any outing of myself to him ("honey, I'm bisexual"), would necessarily be followed by his asking "what does that mean?", and then what would I tell him? "Oh nothing, just that sometimes I dream of shagging women, and used to chase the hot queer chicks in high school"? I think not.

I hear some of you wondering "then why bother telling him? if you're monogamous with a man, aren't you basically straight anyway? what does it matter what other people think?" All I can tell you is, it does matter. We are talking about no less than who I am, at my very foundation. I may pass, in this heteronormative society that is so fond of stuffing us in to boxes whether we like them or not, but rather than make my life easy as some may think, passing is excruciatingly painful, like a tourniquet on a limb, like being told every day the sky is yellow when I can see it is blue. It is being forced to agree to a lie I know to be false, a lie about myself. It may seem "unimportant", my sexuality a mere technicality, but in a thousand ways every day, unseen by those blinded by straightness, even a monogamous woman is expected to assert her heterosexuality; the straight world surrounds me with its memes, its jokes, its assumptions, its understanding of the world and of female/male relationships: each is just a tiny little prick to my psyche, but oh do they add up.

I live with enormous heaps of straight privilege. The fact that I can pass when needed, that I could when my unmarried partner was on death's door in a rural hospital in the Midwest proclaim myself his fiancée and thus claim access to his bedside and his medical information, is a huge privilege that humbles me, for I know how many do not have it. I do not pretend that the pain of being invisible holds a candle to the daily risks of a life lived as a queer woman with a female partner, or multiple partners, or no partner at all. I do not claim that merely as an also-queer woman that I know what it is to live as a woman in relationship with a woman. To lay claim to that status is a hubris I strive to avoid -- sometimes at the cost of disassociating from my queer identity altogether.

I can speak with lived authority only of my own pains, my own risks, my own queernesses, small as they are: the pain of being invisible, the risk of either alienating others or dishonoring myself, the queerness of a sexuality half lived... the dilemma of what to do about the Boychick.

The only solution I see, if I cannot live my life obvious (as I once did unthinkingly, without knowing how sweet I had it) -- if I cannot not pass -- is to come out again, and again, and again. Only now am I seeing the value of practices like National Coming Out Day, for if there is one thing I might claim to know better than my woman-partnered sisters, it is invisibility. I may pass for straight, be seen as a breeder and thereby shoved into a closet again and again every moment of my child's life, but I don't have to quietly stay there.

I am happily monogamous with a man. I have a child. And I am bisexual.

Tuesday, March 3, 2009

Why "presumably-straight"?

My friend Lisa asked in a comment on another post:
Why do you say your son is "presumably straight"?
It's a good question, one I realized I haven't explicitly answered anywhere yet. In thinking about it, it seems to come down to three things:
  1. He probably is (going to be) straight. Even with a queer-identified mother (which may or may not affect the odds, and if so, doesn't very much), he has, what, a 90-99% chance of identifying as heterosexual, depending on whose numbers you believe? So, simply, I use "presumably" because it sounds better than "probably", and he probably is.

  2. Although he probably is (going to be) straight, he might not be. Saying he "presumably" is straight is opening up the door to the idea that he might be something other than straight, and hopefully challenges people's assumptions. Which brings us to:

  3. In our heterosexist, heteronormative society, he is presumed by the wider culture (to the point of few even being aware of the presumption) to be straight until proven otherwise. While I do my best to resist this presumption, or to counter it when we encounter it, I cannot entirely do away with it, as much as I might wish. I sometimes feel I can hardly do away with it at all. The vast majority of interactions he has with others are and will continue to be based on the presumption that he is (going to be) straight, and this assumption/presumption colors far more than we are usually aware. Whether or not it turns out to be who in fact he is (he might turn out to not be a "he" at all; I could easily add "presumably" in front of male as well), he will be seen by most in his life as a straight white male (yes, even as a toddler; even at birth!), with all the privilege and roles and stereotypes thereof; and it will affect him, subtly and profoundly; and my only hope of countering the damage those role assignments bring lies in first recognizing them.
Thus presumably-straight.

Friday, February 20, 2009

On abortion

Just to make clear, in case there was any doubt, I am emphatically pro-choice. I do not believe that "life" starts at conception or that aborting an embryo can by a rational omnivorous person be said to be murder (I give more leeway here to vegans, though not if they swat at flies or squish spiders, not even the giant poisonous ones they find crawling up a leg -- only if one can consider squishing a gnat murder will I allow you the moral standing to call abortion murder, though I'll still fight you if you wish to impose your beliefs on others).

I am pro-choice to the point that when I finally got pregnant, after over a year of trying to conceive, I told myself every day for the first trimester that I could have an abortion still. A lot of people look at me askance when I say that, to put it mildly, but it wasn't for lack of love of the potential person growing inside me nor even due to an excess of ambivalence -- of course I had doubts and concerns, but it was an unequivocally wanted pregnancy -- but rather that the reminder of the choice I had reassured me every day that I had options, that I chose this, that I could still make another choice if it was too much. The fact that I chose, actively chose, every day for three months, to keep the pregnancy helped carry me through the long months ahead when bearing the baby was the only path available. It later brought me joy to remember that each day for those early months I chose to welcome this potentiality in to my life. Far from being pathological, contemplating abortion of a tried-for pregnancy was a practice in falling in love with my baby-to-be.

Anyway, all that is to say I am most definitely pro-choice. So when I read Twisty (at I Blame the Patriarchy) say that expressing a desire to reduce the number of abortions is inherently an anti-feminist stance, I do something of a double take (ok, perhaps that's not exactly what she said, but that's how I read "More abortions, fewer abortions — what’s the diff? The numbers are irrelevant.").

I can see how an anti-abortion, pro-choice position could be non-feminist, where abortion is seen as taking a life but is a lesser evil than those which happen when abortion is illegal. Any time the focus is on the embryo or fetus and a comparative analysis of being terminated pre-consciousness v living a life unwanted, the stance is non-feminist (though not necessarily anti-feminist).

But I do believe there is a feminist stance that says fewer abortions are better than more. My reasons for that position, as passionately pro-choice and abortion neutral as I am, are woman-centric:

  • First and simplest and at the root of all the other reasons, if a woman doesn't want to bear a child, she shouldn't have to get pregnant in the first place. Contraception and sex positive education should be universally and freely available. All humans should know about fertility awareness and all women who want to should be helped to chart their cycles. Men who don't want to wear condoms or become a parent should have vasectomies. All adolescents should be taught how to have fabulously enjoyable orgasmic sex without risk of pregnancy, starting with themselves (don't want your daughter to get pregnant? forget the lectures and the condoms, have a beloved aunt take her toy shopping). No one should feel forced to have sex for money or touch or food or safety or grades or housing or any other bullshit reason the patriarchally constrained choices offer her today. And rape, of course, needs to go buhbye, with all women taught assertiveness and self-protection and all men taught to not be sexist raping asses, and with a legal stance of assumed non-consent for women (second half of the post: brilliant idea I wish were mine; now that I know of it, though, I'm bringing it up every chance I get). There are a hundred thousand ways we can make abortion less necessary starting with avoiding unwanted pregnancy, and none of them have to do with moralizing or shaming or "abstinence promotion" and all of them start with the radical idea that women are people.

  • Next up on my list of feminist reasons why fewer abortions would be better: abortion, either chemical or surgical, is not exactly easy on the female body. While assuredly safer than pregnancy and birth, even just a couple weeks of pregnancy followed by termination takes a physical toll and carries real, if minute, risks. While the anti-science anti-abortion Bush-funded propaganda linking abortion to cancer was patently bullshit, that doesn't mean that pregnancy and termination are toll-free either. There's the nausea, exhaustion, and pain of early pregnancy (unmitigated by the joy and excitement of a chosen pregnancy), the blood loss of expulsion, and either the risk of surgical uterine/cervical scars or flooding the body with artificial hormones, both of which get more and more dangerous with repeated use. This is in no way meant to scare women away from abortion (again, it's still easier on your body than a full pregnancy and birth, and I say that as a rabidly pregnancy-positive, birth-positive, crunchy-granola aspiring homebirth midwife, who has a tendency to open up whoopass when people start spouting misogynistic bs about the ickiness and terror of childbearing), but just to point out that once again it is women's bodies bearing the burden of patriarchy's fuckups, women's bodies wracked if not wrecked for men's pleasure.

  • Then there's the financial issue. While as feminists we should be working on universal health care for all with abortion 100% covered and 100% available, in the meantime abortion (if you can get it) ain't cheap, at $350-1000+ a pop, unless one is privileged to have insurance that covers it (compare this please to the cost of a one-time vasectomy at $500-1000+, which could prevent untold numbers of abortions, carries none of the stigma of abortion, is a vastly simpler procedure, and is more likely to be covered by insurance). Even if women earned as much as men, as long as the burden paying for terminating an unwanted pregnancy falls to women, we're going to be at a disadvantage. Paying for an abortion can mean the difference between paying the rent and having to find someone to stay with; it can mean the difference between being able to afford this semester of college or not, between applying to grad schools this year or not; it can mean the difference between getting the hell out of dodge or having to stay in a town with the dickwad who spewed his wad and fucked you over in the first place. Of course we need to give away abortions free, but until we get to utopia, damn right I'm going to say there need to be fewer abortions; not more babies, but fewer pregnancies to start with, because one way or another it is women who are literally paying the price of our PIV-sex obsessed culture.

  • Last and probably most controversially in feminist culture, there need to be fewer abortions because having an abortion usually sucks -- not in a "post-abortion-syndrome" way, but just in a that-shit-ain't-easy way. I have not yet been there myself (though if I had gotten pregnant when the Boychick was less than a year, I would have been at my local clinic that very day, and I'm not sure what I would do if that happened now; termination would certainly be on the table for consideration), but having watched others go through it, having miscarried an unwanted, unknown pregnancy myself, having listened to feminist women discuss the destiny of their frozen fertilized embryos, my conclusion is that it sucks; not for everyone, not every time, not horribly, but I do not believe that it is only "pro-life" propaganda that makes it, for some, an emotionally difficult experience. I do believe that the guilt around the choice to terminate is a cultural patriarchal construct, as most woman-guilt is, and to be sure an abortion can also be simply an entirely joyful decision, but it's such a complex one that there is no one way women will ever feel about it. There is no wrong way to feel and no right way to feel, and anyone attempting to invade women's minds to dictate to them what they "should" feel during or after the event needs to be bitchslapped as hard as anyone attempting to invade her body, whether that's the religionists telling her it's murder she must carry the guilt for or radfems telling her it's simply nothing and any effect it has on her is merely her weakness to patriarchal bullcrap. Some women feel joy at an abortion; some women mourn their potential baby; some women feel easy relief; many women feel all of the above and more. But as long as any woman is drained by the experience; as long as any woman dislikes it; as long as any woman would make another choice under less patriarchally insane circumstances; as long as any woman would rather have not had to face this choice: I am going to say we should work to need fewer abortions.


I am pro-choice. I believe feminists need to work toward a world with assumed non-consent, where health care, day care, family-friendly employment, contraception, sex-positive education, and abortion are universally available and accessible, where every family doctor, general practitioner, gynecologist, nurse practitioner, and nurse midwife is trained in and offers safe abortions; and I believe that to the extent this or any step toward this reduces the number of abortions without increasing the number of unwanted, unchosen babies, this is to be celebrated. There will always be abortions, because there will always be contraceptive failures, changes of situation, and changes of mind. But we don't need to be anti-feminist "babyists" to believe fewer abortions is a good thing to work toward.



Note: This is not the place to debate abortion. One does not have to agree with me, nor even be pro-choice, in order to comment, but posts that are exclusively moralizing, actively anti-choice, or exist only to register one's disagreement with a pro-choice stance will be deleted. All other comments are welcome and invited.

Sunday, January 18, 2009

This is why it matters

Hellen G commented on my post "there's my rabbit Bob..." that:
many trans people know from a very early age that they have a gender identity issue, even if we don't necessarily have the words to describe it - I was about 5 when I knew that 'something wasn't right' about my body...
Another person I was talking with in the last week said that she knew she was attracted only to other girls by five, as much as a five year old can be (theirs may be an immature sexuality, but it is real nonetheless).

The only reason at age five I didn't know my own sexuality was because I had no word for it, no admittance in my culture that it even existed. By the time I was five, I knew I was attracted to boys and girls (and genderqueers and androgynes and other variations, as much as they showed up in suburban kindergarten land), but it wasn't until a decade later that I had a word for it. I knew most girls liked boys, and some girls liked just girls, but no one liked both. I thought there was something wrong with me, because there were no words for what I was, no bisexuals in my story books, no bi parents, no bi pride marches.

There were straights, and I wasn't that, and there were gays, and I wasn't that either, and there were sluts, of course, but that definitely wasn't me. I didn't even kiss anyone (except for my best friend when she and I were 5, hidden under my parents' waterbed) until The Man. I had no one at all in my culture to connect to, so I wasn't bisexual or pansexual or plain ol' happy queer, I was just a confused mess, wondering why I dreamed both about Wesley Crusher and Xena, Warrior Princess.

And I grew up in a fairly gay-friendly progressive household, and I knew that I wouldn't be kicked out if I came out as queer. I found out years after I came out (with reactions from my friends ranging from "uh huh" to "duh" -- I wasn't exactly good at hiding my queerness in the first place) that my own mother was bisexual, but as a monogamous married woman with kids didn't think it was "worth it" to be out, it "didn't matter".

I still sometimes feel like screaming at her "of course it fucking mattered! I could have saved myself a decade of pain and confusion if you were out!" I needed someone, anyone, to say to me "these people exist. this sexuality, this gender, these intrinsic inclinations are normal." And I was ready to hear that by age five. Helen was ready to hear that by age five.

This is why it matters when our kids' books have only white, able-bodied, neurotypical, cisgendered, gender-stereotyped characters. This is why it matters that we talk with our toddlers and our preschoolers about diversity and gender and sexuality and race and privilege, to the best of our ability, in ways they can understand. They may not know exactly what they are inside yet, they may not know exactly what race means yet or exactly what sex is yet, so it might seem to "not matter", but so, so soon they will. And their friends will. And we need to give them the words to explain it, and the room to celebrate it.