Today's entry to the Womanist/Feminist Parenting Primer comes from a dear friend and occasional reader (if not regular commenter, *ahem*), Courtney Wilder, PhD.
This is a long entry, but well worth it. In it, Courtney first explores the ways that running serves to reify patriarchal gender norms. She then places it in an historically misogynistic context in which women were actively discouraged and often outright barred from and drummed out of athletics and physical pursuits. She ultimately reveals how it is an "ultra-feminist" activity and helps teach her children progressive, feminist values, by showing that women can be strong, by modeling bodily autonomy, and by demonstrating that physical activity is well worth pursuing regardless of whether one meets the patriarchy's sexist standards.
Running as Feminist Pursuit
A couple of years ago, I took up running. It did not feel, at the time, like an activity with particular feminist (or un-feminist) overtones; it did not feel subversive, or especially important to my parenting. It felt like a way to get out of the house, like a way to do something other than slowly go nuts writing the last few chapters of my doctoral dissertation, like a way to breathe some fresh air while my kids were in preschool and first grade, respectively. It was cheaper than the gym, more soothing than using an exercise bike in front of the TV, and I got to know the streets of my neighborhood from a perspective that was different from the ones afforded me by car or bicycle transportation.
Of course, nothing – especially nothing involving women and their bodies – can remain neutral for very long. And nothing, I found, that a mother chooses to engage in can fail to impact her children in some way. I started to run more, and I started to read about running, and I entered longer and longer road races (aiming for a marathon this fall!), and slowly I found my perspective shifting. Running is subversive, it can be ultra-feminist, and my running teaches my children a wealth of things about women, and bodies, and how to be healthy, and what so-called limits they might transcend rather easily.
First, the aspects of running that seem to reify sexist gender stereotypes: I have a range of running clothes now, mostly in shades you’d find in a box of Necco Wafers. I have pink and blue and white tech shirts, and lavender and pink and black running bras, and shorts and running skirts that range from black (with a pink waistband) to blue to gray (with a pink stripe). When I run, I look super, super girly. Sweaty, but girly. Despite the skepticism with which seasoned athletes regard running skirts, I wear them almost exclusively – they’re comfy, they often provide more coverage of leg and ass than running shorts, and I like them. Moreover, I finally found an activity where it’s very likely that you can solve your problems with a new pair of shoes, and since this has long been my practice – to soothe my ego or perk myself up or provide a carrot for myself as the reward for some grueling or dull task – I enjoy having a real reason to choose new shoes.
A more serious overlap between running and traditional, repressive, sexist strictures for women involves the size and shape of my body. As I started to run more, I started to weigh less. I went from a perfectly nice size 8 to 10 body (this, after having given birth twice and breastfed continuously for – drum roll please! – more than seven consecutive years) to a size 4. My parents describe me as “lean,” my husband is somewhat taken aback, the most overtly feminine of my female coworkers talk to me frequently in approving tones about my waist and hips. My sister-in-law, a few months post-partum, sized me up when I came to visit and observed simply, “You’re really thin.” I am. I am really thin. But when I look at my daughter, I can see that she’s also lean; I eat well (and frequently, and in good quantities), and I’m inclined to think this is just what my body looks like when I take care of myself. I am really thin, which pings my feminist anxieties in all kinds of ways, but I am also really damned strong. I am in better shape than I ever was as a teenager, or a college student, or a mother of very young children (mine are now eight and five.)
So: while dressing in a cute pink and gray skirt and dashing along the local running trails in my size four body seems very much in keeping with the sexist stereotypes I deplore as a feminist, I’m convinced that running is actually something very different. While some women no doubt run only to govern their bodies into more socially acceptable forms, this practice pales in comparison to those women who fought for the right to engage in physical activity alongside their brothers and male classmates. Although when I began running, I knew vaguely about Title IX, the 1972 law [in the USA] prohibiting discrimination on the basis of sex in educational settings, I had no idea – none – about how hard aspiring female athletes fought for the simple right to compete in organized events. Early female entrants to marathons disguised their gender on their entry forms, were sometimes chased during the race by angry men, were denied official record of their accomplishments. Although in the United States alone, working class women and farm or pioneer women, not to mention enslaved women, engaged in significant physical labor all their lives, somehow twentieth century women who wanted to engage in athletics were seen as too delicate. With the exception of the 1928 Olympics, where there was a women’s 800 meter event, no woman’s footrace was longer than 200 meters until 1960. Women couldn’t officially run the Boston Marathon until 1972. It was a shock to me that women’s bodies were so tightly, so successfully, controlled in this sphere; I had thought of women’s choices regarding their bodies to be largely a matter of reproductive care – access to birth control and abortion. It had never occurred to me that there was public discourse (in the United States, within the last sixty years) about whether women were biologically fit to run distances further than a mile and a half.
Trust me, my children will never take that discussion seriously. My daughter will never, ever have reason to think she can’t be athletic because of her gender; it will, I hope, never even occur to my son to regard girls and women as fragile little things. My kids have grown used to seeing me head out the door in my running clothes, or slog back in, sweaty and disheveled. They’ll happily make conversation at church potlucks about my latest half-marathon; they ask about how my runs go. Occasionally my daughter will come with me on her bike, although she’s a little fast for me. This is the other interesting wrinkle about running for me, and one reason it has such an impact on my kids. Like my grandfather, my dad, and both of my children, I have asthma. While the kids seem to be growing out of it, I have not. So when I run, I run pretty slowly. I can do comfortable 9:30 miles for a long time, but in the running world, that’s slow.
There are a slew of articles – mostly, I’ve noticed, by men – about how disgraceful the current state of things is in the running world, how the marathon is now just open to any fool with shoes, how slow runners should just get some other hobby. I know my kids will encounter this attitude – possibly about their very bodies, possibly about people in general – and I remain hopeful, and confident, that I have provided them with a counter-example to that argument. Because I run, despite the asthma, despite the fraught history of women and their bodies, because I’m confident and strong even in the absence of innate talent or great physical skill – I’m a great feminist role model for my kids. They’ve stopped asking me after races whether I’ve won – the answer will always be no – but they remain proud of my effort. Even in the face of utterly objective measure that tells me I am bad at this, I am slow, I lack talent – I am happily persisting. I hope this is what they learn, my daughter and my son: your body is your body, and you can make it strong, and healthy. No one can tell you what to do with your own body, or that you’re not good enough to do what you enjoy. Your body, however imperfect it might seem by the wildly unattainable standards of our culture, is yours, and it is good.
Courtney Wilder did finish that dissertation, earning a Ph.D. in theology from the University of Chicago, and now teaches in the Religion and Philosophy Department at Midland Lutheran College. She runs and, with her spouse, raises her kids in Omaha, Nebraska.
Showing posts with label fat is a feminist issue. Show all posts
Showing posts with label fat is a feminist issue. Show all posts
Thursday, July 23, 2009
Thursday, July 2, 2009
Blast from the past: I saw my breasts
This is a piece I wrote a long time ago. It actually helped me earn a $48,000 scholarship (to a college I didn't end up attending, unfortunately). I was reminded of it recently by this post at Shapely Prose, and then I read this at Kim Writes and thought that is what this little piece would want to be when it grows up.
I'd do things a bit differently if I were writing this now, hopefully better, and I'd have a lot more to say about the multifunctionality of my breasts, but I still love it for what it is. And while I continued (ok, continue) to work with my body issues, the moment described herein really was pivotal for me: the whole trajectory of my thinking changed course, for the better, and I am still so grateful for that.
November 2000
I Saw My Breasts
I have rarely felt good about my body. The best I have ever had to say about it is that it's "acceptable," at least since I started puberty and grew breasts, and had the rest of my body fleshed out.
To put it bluntly, but truthfully, I am fat. Over-tall, over-wide, and flabby almost everywhere. Being manic-depressive, there are times when I could manage to describe myself as "voluptuous." But the rest of the time, I'm just fat.
My breasts, especially, are a problem for me. In a bra, they are a decent, perhaps impressive, size D, and conform nicely to the shape of the bra. When out of a bra, however, they are triangular shaped, long, and flat. I tend to think of them as shy – when I'm standing up straight, my nipples determinedly stare just a few inches in front of my toes. I have long felt like I have old lady breasts – hanging halfway to my hips – while only a teenager. What's more, never, ever, have I seen breasts like mine on anyone else.
Which, to my depressed and self-loathing mind, made me not just a fat geek, but a fat freak.
Of course, intellectually, I know that humans are unique, and no two are quite the same, and those differences should be valued, cherished, and rejoiced. And I do – in other people. I have enjoyed magazines like Hues and Radiance that embrace the variety of cultures, colors, sizes and shapes that humans come in. But for only short periods of time had I been able to carry that certainty within my heart as well as my head.
It was in one of those magazines, shortly after I started to come to terms with my bipolar disorder, that I saw them. My breasts – my breasts – on another woman.
Radiance, having its annual swimsuit issue, was doing a feature on Aviva Jane Carlin, who had written and was performing in a one woman play, as a nude artist's model.
She looked about 50, and she was no supermodel, although she made a super model. And although not as fat as I, she was definitely not "perfect." But her demeanor and confidence, and lack of self-consciousness, made her beautiful.
And she had my breasts.
I'm not sure which of those two thoughts I had first, but the third was amazement at the previous two – she had my breasts and she was beautiful.
And finally, I knew, I had proof that I wasn't the only one. It shouldn't have mattered, perhaps. But it did.
She wore no clothing. Nothing to hide her wide hips, with all their stretch marks. Nothing to cover her arms, that seemed to yearn for the earth, so much did they hang. Nothing to disguise her thighs, that danced at the least excuse. Her stomach was free, free to fall over her waist, to move when she breathed, to smile when she leaned over. Her hair was loose, wild, a dark springy brown liberally streaked with grey. Even her ankles, wide and solid to support her body's movements and poses, were unfettered and exposed.
But most of all, most important to me, were her breasts. Just like mine, they hung low, and looked like thick Doritos. Her areolas were large and barely distinguishable from the rest of her breasts. And her nipples, cross-eyed like mine as she slouched, stared fixedly down. But looking at her gave me a different perspective on our shared glands cum fat deposits.
On me, those breasts have always seemed shy, or sad – depressed even. Their seeming attitude – of depression and defeat – characterized my attitude about my body and my appearance.
But on her… Her breasts characterized her views as well. They stared lovingly at her stomach, surveyed her hips, caressed her legs with their gaze. They were the caring queens of her body, not rising above their subjects, but joining them, looking not outside their domain with embarrassment, but down at it joyfully.
I had seen my breasts on another woman, and they were queens. They added to her beauty, her dignity, her womanliness.
And they were my breasts.
I am still fat. And my breasts are still overgrown Doritos, hanging halfway to my hips, or at least to my smiling belly button. But my breasts are also queens, and no longer detract from my beauty. I no longer shake my head in bewilderment when my lover comments on their desirability. And I can look at myself in a mirror, and see in it the breasts I share with a proud woman, who is not old before her time, but beautiful because of her years.
Thank you, Ms. Carlin.
I'd do things a bit differently if I were writing this now, hopefully better, and I'd have a lot more to say about the multifunctionality of my breasts, but I still love it for what it is. And while I continued (ok, continue) to work with my body issues, the moment described herein really was pivotal for me: the whole trajectory of my thinking changed course, for the better, and I am still so grateful for that.
November 2000
I Saw My Breasts
I have rarely felt good about my body. The best I have ever had to say about it is that it's "acceptable," at least since I started puberty and grew breasts, and had the rest of my body fleshed out.
To put it bluntly, but truthfully, I am fat. Over-tall, over-wide, and flabby almost everywhere. Being manic-depressive, there are times when I could manage to describe myself as "voluptuous." But the rest of the time, I'm just fat.
My breasts, especially, are a problem for me. In a bra, they are a decent, perhaps impressive, size D, and conform nicely to the shape of the bra. When out of a bra, however, they are triangular shaped, long, and flat. I tend to think of them as shy – when I'm standing up straight, my nipples determinedly stare just a few inches in front of my toes. I have long felt like I have old lady breasts – hanging halfway to my hips – while only a teenager. What's more, never, ever, have I seen breasts like mine on anyone else.
Which, to my depressed and self-loathing mind, made me not just a fat geek, but a fat freak.
Of course, intellectually, I know that humans are unique, and no two are quite the same, and those differences should be valued, cherished, and rejoiced. And I do – in other people. I have enjoyed magazines like Hues and Radiance that embrace the variety of cultures, colors, sizes and shapes that humans come in. But for only short periods of time had I been able to carry that certainty within my heart as well as my head.
It was in one of those magazines, shortly after I started to come to terms with my bipolar disorder, that I saw them. My breasts – my breasts – on another woman.
Radiance, having its annual swimsuit issue, was doing a feature on Aviva Jane Carlin, who had written and was performing in a one woman play, as a nude artist's model.
She looked about 50, and she was no supermodel, although she made a super model. And although not as fat as I, she was definitely not "perfect." But her demeanor and confidence, and lack of self-consciousness, made her beautiful.
And she had my breasts.
I'm not sure which of those two thoughts I had first, but the third was amazement at the previous two – she had my breasts and she was beautiful.
And finally, I knew, I had proof that I wasn't the only one. It shouldn't have mattered, perhaps. But it did.
She wore no clothing. Nothing to hide her wide hips, with all their stretch marks. Nothing to cover her arms, that seemed to yearn for the earth, so much did they hang. Nothing to disguise her thighs, that danced at the least excuse. Her stomach was free, free to fall over her waist, to move when she breathed, to smile when she leaned over. Her hair was loose, wild, a dark springy brown liberally streaked with grey. Even her ankles, wide and solid to support her body's movements and poses, were unfettered and exposed.
But most of all, most important to me, were her breasts. Just like mine, they hung low, and looked like thick Doritos. Her areolas were large and barely distinguishable from the rest of her breasts. And her nipples, cross-eyed like mine as she slouched, stared fixedly down. But looking at her gave me a different perspective on our shared glands cum fat deposits.
On me, those breasts have always seemed shy, or sad – depressed even. Their seeming attitude – of depression and defeat – characterized my attitude about my body and my appearance.
But on her… Her breasts characterized her views as well. They stared lovingly at her stomach, surveyed her hips, caressed her legs with their gaze. They were the caring queens of her body, not rising above their subjects, but joining them, looking not outside their domain with embarrassment, but down at it joyfully.
I had seen my breasts on another woman, and they were queens. They added to her beauty, her dignity, her womanliness.
And they were my breasts.
I am still fat. And my breasts are still overgrown Doritos, hanging halfway to my hips, or at least to my smiling belly button. But my breasts are also queens, and no longer detract from my beauty. I no longer shake my head in bewilderment when my lover comments on their desirability. And I can look at myself in a mirror, and see in it the breasts I share with a proud woman, who is not old before her time, but beautiful because of her years.
Thank you, Ms. Carlin.
Sunday, June 7, 2009
The blogger revealed
I know there haven't been any photos of me on here, nor do I have so much as a profile picture (even though there have been pictures of the Boychick galore, and even of The Man). But it's not some conspiracy, not a deliberate choice for some misplaced reason of delusions of modesty or anonymity/pseudonymity (I'm aware anyone with half a brain and an hour on google could get enough information about me to be really irritating or scary if so inclined).
No, it's just that I don't tend to like photos of myself. And few enough of my close friends or relations are good enough photographers to have produced many photos good enough for me to like (those who are good photographers tend to, rightly!, focus on my beautiful child).
I know it's both cliched and rather patriarchal to dislike being photographed, but here's the thing: I actually like the way I look. I think I'm pretty hot. I even know I'm beautiful. I am not ashamed to show myself, my fat, pale, hairy, un-make-up-ed self, in tank tops and shorts and itty bitty string bikinis. My body image and self confidence are in fact quite spectacularly good, especially considering I am a white American female.
That is, until I see myself in photos. Then, I cringe and feel ugly and start to think I should avoid short sleeves, tight clothing, and revealing my face in public.
I don't know which is the lie and which the truth. I don't know whether I have an inflated ego normally, or know only photographers who mostly fail at capturing my beauty and grace. But if the image of myself in my head is fantastical, then I choose to live in ignorance. I would rather believe myself beautiful and be wrong than to know the truth and defile my soul with self-hatred.
So there aren't a lot of photos of myself around, and fewer still I'm happy to share. But since I don't actually want to be faceless, I've been keeping an eye out for photos to use, and I think I may have had some not-totally-cringe-worthy taken recently at a fair.
Without further ado, I lift teh intarwebz curtain, and reveal the blogger behind the posts:

Wait, not what you had in mind? You wanted my face? Ok, how about this?

Still not good enough? Geez you're picky. Here, I'm looking straight at the camera in this!

*ducks* Ok, ok, I relent: the pictures those were originally based on:


(Is anyone surprised they're nursing pics?)
So what say you, readership? My 100th post is coming up (this is #99!), and I'd rather like to have a profile pic by then. See anything you like? Post a vote in the comments. (Bear in mind, although I am willing to share these photos, they're still not easy for me to look at. And no, I'm not fishing for compliments, just commenting on the state of my crazy. Nice face paint though, huh?)
No, it's just that I don't tend to like photos of myself. And few enough of my close friends or relations are good enough photographers to have produced many photos good enough for me to like (those who are good photographers tend to, rightly!, focus on my beautiful child).
I know it's both cliched and rather patriarchal to dislike being photographed, but here's the thing: I actually like the way I look. I think I'm pretty hot. I even know I'm beautiful. I am not ashamed to show myself, my fat, pale, hairy, un-make-up-ed self, in tank tops and shorts and itty bitty string bikinis. My body image and self confidence are in fact quite spectacularly good, especially considering I am a white American female.
That is, until I see myself in photos. Then, I cringe and feel ugly and start to think I should avoid short sleeves, tight clothing, and revealing my face in public.
I don't know which is the lie and which the truth. I don't know whether I have an inflated ego normally, or know only photographers who mostly fail at capturing my beauty and grace. But if the image of myself in my head is fantastical, then I choose to live in ignorance. I would rather believe myself beautiful and be wrong than to know the truth and defile my soul with self-hatred.
So there aren't a lot of photos of myself around, and fewer still I'm happy to share. But since I don't actually want to be faceless, I've been keeping an eye out for photos to use, and I think I may have had some not-totally-cringe-worthy taken recently at a fair.
Without further ado, I lift teh intarwebz curtain, and reveal the blogger behind the posts:

Wait, not what you had in mind? You wanted my face? Ok, how about this?

Still not good enough? Geez you're picky. Here, I'm looking straight at the camera in this!

*ducks* Ok, ok, I relent: the pictures those were originally based on:


(Is anyone surprised they're nursing pics?)
So what say you, readership? My 100th post is coming up (this is #99!), and I'd rather like to have a profile pic by then. See anything you like? Post a vote in the comments. (Bear in mind, although I am willing to share these photos, they're still not easy for me to look at. And no, I'm not fishing for compliments, just commenting on the state of my crazy. Nice face paint though, huh?)
Saturday, May 30, 2009
Now that I'm caught up in Google Reader...
(and yes, it was largely thanks to liberal use of the "Mark all read" button)
...I have some links I want to share. I'm only sorry I didn't share them sooner.
First (well, most recently, because I'm working backward in my Reader Starred folder), PhD in Parenting wrote Feminism, fathers, and valuing parenting:
So much agreement. (My only complaint is the heterocentrism of the post: I don't see any acknowledgment that families come in more than one mom + one dad.)
Next up, Mikhela at Fly My Pretty proves that great insight can come from mundane "mommy blogging", in day 2 of her "exercise in recording a week in my mothering life":
This may be old news to you, because it came out about a month ago now, but one-of-those-women wrote the best response to the horrific The Case Against Breastfeeding article, titled The Case Against Reasoning, and it is so long and so good, I'm not sure I can pick a favorite summing paragraph. But I must point out how I simply adore the way she manages to reframe the conversation from "breast is best" to "formula is worse" without once denigrating or insulting formula users (well, Rosin the TCAB author, but not for using formula). I want all lactivists to be like her (but, y'know, still like themselves!).
(Ok, one snippet:
Last, Spilt Milk talks about her step-mom in A mother's work is... done?
What fascinates me about this, and I haven't quite managed to articulate my thoughts on it, is the idea that this is why we can't have our entire identities wrapped up in our mothering: because someday, our children will move on, and we will be done with mothering, or at least its active stage. And that's both normal and good. There's something refreshingly feminist, and ultimately pro-mother, in that idea to me.
ETA Missed one! It wasn't starred, but I mailed it to myself: Shapely Prose had a quick hit up on The nocebo effect:
So, anything you think I might have missed in my massive Reader skimming and "Mark all read"-clicking spree? Post a link -- or several -- in the comments please!
...I have some links I want to share. I'm only sorry I didn't share them sooner.
First (well, most recently, because I'm working backward in my Reader Starred folder), PhD in Parenting wrote Feminism, fathers, and valuing parenting:
We need to push for a society that values family and parenthood. One that recognizes that role that parents play in raising the next generation. One that recognizes that fathers, like mothers, may need to strike a balance between their career and their family life. One where women don’t feel that they have to be an equally uninvolved parent in order to reach their goals, but where they can ask their partner to step up too.
So much agreement. (My only complaint is the heterocentrism of the post: I don't see any acknowledgment that families come in more than one mom + one dad.)
Next up, Mikhela at Fly My Pretty proves that great insight can come from mundane "mommy blogging", in day 2 of her "exercise in recording a week in my mothering life":
It struck me how I had been negatively interpreting Pearl's behaviour of trying to engage me in what she was doing in everything we do (she constantly wants to be picked up, she doesn't sit and play by herself in the loungeroom, she has to watch me having a shower) - thinking that she still needs to develop her confidence. I wasn't trying to hurry her, but I had been thinking, 'Oh, Louis is really more emotionally developed and centred at this age.' It was really good to have another way of labelling it. I think my tendency to do this - assume interdependency is a sign of being less emotionally developed - is a product of our social expectation that babies have to become 'independent'. This then, I think, goes back to male development being the yardstick by which human development is measured...I would take it further, and say the tendency is a product of our social expectation that we're all supposed to be(come) fully (pathologically) independent. And in a society that forces dependence on parents, generally mothers, who spend their time raising their children, I find that a deeply misogynistic expectation. Everything in my life tells me that interdependence is the normal, healthy state of the human animal, of every gender and age.
This may be old news to you, because it came out about a month ago now, but one-of-those-women wrote the best response to the horrific The Case Against Breastfeeding article, titled The Case Against Reasoning, and it is so long and so good, I'm not sure I can pick a favorite summing paragraph. But I must point out how I simply adore the way she manages to reframe the conversation from "breast is best" to "formula is worse" without once denigrating or insulting formula users (well, Rosin the TCAB author, but not for using formula). I want all lactivists to be like her (but, y'know, still like themselves!).
(Ok, one snippet:
See? Love it.)I think it's more useful to look at why this article is being propagated so powerfully. What is happening socially: why it is being so well received. [...].Well, to begin with, there is the 'pressure' that no one in the article, or in the subsequent discussions has touched upon... the commercial interests in making sure that breastfeeding is slagged off at all opportunities.
Last, Spilt Milk talks about her step-mom in A mother's work is... done?
Anyhow, we got to talking a little about mothers and J said to me ‘I don’t feel like a mother anymore. I’m just not a mother anymore. I’m finished with that.’ What she meant was that now that her two biological daughters and I are all grown women, she doesn’t feel the same tugs on the proverbial apron strings and nor does she miss them. She said, simply, ‘I don’t do nurturer anymore.’
What fascinates me about this, and I haven't quite managed to articulate my thoughts on it, is the idea that this is why we can't have our entire identities wrapped up in our mothering: because someday, our children will move on, and we will be done with mothering, or at least its active stage. And that's both normal and good. There's something refreshingly feminist, and ultimately pro-mother, in that idea to me.
ETA Missed one! It wasn't starred, but I mailed it to myself: Shapely Prose had a quick hit up on The nocebo effect:
Fat people are unceasingly told that the size of their bodies will kill them — if not personally by their doctors, families, and acquaintances, then collectively by the media or by strangers. [...] Think about it. Being convinced you’re sick can kill. Being convinced you’re well can cure. If indeed fat folks are iller, can we really be surprised?There's already excellent evidence that it is not fat but the damage of repeated weight loss and weight gain that causes the heart damage stereotypical of obesity; there's also evidence, as discussed in the comments of the thread, that the stress fat people routinely live with chronically (by living in a persecuted body in a fat-phobic society) causes damage to our health; and there's almost no evidence that the average person -- of any size! -- can substantially and permanently change their weight: so why, exactly, do we continue to think that shaming people into dieting is "good for them"? Do you really need to ask who I blame? (Hint: it starts with ky, and rhymes with patriarchy.)
So, anything you think I might have missed in my massive Reader skimming and "Mark all read"-clicking spree? Post a link -- or several -- in the comments please!
Thursday, May 21, 2009
...oh yes, and I'm bleeding
Extra-long cycle this time, which if I weren't charting would likely have scared the beejeebuz out of us, but as it is was just a wee bit irritating. Although I'm still not positive I ovulated, because charting for the past week or so -- surprise! -- has been a little bit off.
But regardless, here I bleed, proof again I am a human female of fertile age. Not sure why the universe thinks we need so many reminders, but oh well.
I wore my brand new bright red string bikini in massage class tonight, and nearly forgot about it until it came time to strip down to be a body for another student's practice. Somehow, the existence of a hairy-legged and -pitted menstruating fat chick in a red string bikini and naught else failed to implode the universe, start a riot, blind all who saw, or make anyone swear off women or join a monastery.
I guess the patriarchy isn't right about everything after all. Who knew?
But regardless, here I bleed, proof again I am a human female of fertile age. Not sure why the universe thinks we need so many reminders, but oh well.
I wore my brand new bright red string bikini in massage class tonight, and nearly forgot about it until it came time to strip down to be a body for another student's practice. Somehow, the existence of a hairy-legged and -pitted menstruating fat chick in a red string bikini and naught else failed to implode the universe, start a riot, blind all who saw, or make anyone swear off women or join a monastery.
I guess the patriarchy isn't right about everything after all. Who knew?
Sunday, April 12, 2009
On fat
This has been sitting in my draft queue for over a week. I don't know why I didn't just publish it then; I think I forgot about it, or thought it needed more clean up than it did (I only tweaked a couple tiny things; no, it's not perfect, but I'm posting it anyway, so there). Ah well, better late than never. Also, fair warning: it's very rant-y and personal. Read elsewhere if your "fuck" quotient has been met for the day.
Did I mention I'm a fat acceptance advocate? 'Cause, yea, I am. My own mother raised me so, God/dess bless her a thousand times.
So I'm reading with interest this post, and I find it really interesting, and then I read the comments, which are interesting in another way, and then comes this:
Because it's so. fucking. wrong.
You know why my mom is fat? And I'm talking really fat, lose one or two hundred pounds and still be morbidly obese fat. You really wanna know why?
Because she dieted.
Because she was told that her 170 lb, 5'5" body, her healthy, strong body, her beautiful, perfect body, was "too fat".
So she dieted, and lost 20 pounds. And then gained 25.
And dieted again, and lost 20 pounds. And then gained 30.
And dieted and lost 20 and gained 40, and lost 30 and gained 40, and had one kid (while finishing medical school back when women were so small a minority there were "doctor" lockers for the men and "nurses" lockers for the women) and gained 40, and lost 40 and gained 80, and, and, and... Until her body, still beautiful, still perfect, still strong, was actually fat, and not quite as healthy, and in rather more pain.
And no, she doesn't have the healthiest of eating habits. You wanna know why?
Because she dieted.
Because her entire life people have told her to clean her plate, to not eat so much, that these foods were "bad", that these foods were "good", that she could have cake if she were good, that she had to eat her veggies or she'd be bad, that she should just avoid fat, that she should just avoid carbs, that she should just use a sugar substitute, that she should eat small meals, that she should eat once a day, that she should swallow sponges, that she should count points, that she should chew 50 times, that she should drink more water, that she should stop drinking anything, that she should, she should, she should, she should, she should. Golly gee fucking wiz, you think maybe she lost touch with her hunger and her fullness and her inner guidance there just a little bit?
So no, she doesn't make "perfect" eating choices. And you know what else? Neither do a fuck load of skinny people. In fact, she eats a lot less than a lot of not-fat people I know, and a lot "healthier", and she's moving around a whole lot more weight (pssst, weight bearing is good for your bones -- her osteoporosis scans give her the bone density of a woman 20 years younger than she is), which, let me think, burns more calories.
So, perfect diet? No, even if there were such a thing. "Worst possible food choices"? FUCK YOU. What the hell does that mean, anyway?
Me? I'm just fat. Morbidly obese? Meh. I don't keep track. I certainly was, at one point. Why, you ask? It's called necessary medication, and it made me gain somewhere over 100 pounds (I was fat to start with, and fucking hot, thank you very much), without me doing a thing. When I got off it, I lost 75 pounds, without doing a thing. You know why? Because I'm just fat. Because my body has a weight it likes being at. Because I'm a sedentary American. Because both my parents are fat. Because half of my aunts and uncles are fat. Because I don't have 40 hours a week to spend in a gym, nor the money to pay someone to oversee my continual starvation. Without starvation and a full time job exercising, I will never be thin. If I moved more, I would be healthier, and have more muscle mass, and maybe lose a little bit of weight, but I wouldn't be thin. Why? Because I'm just fat. And I am beautiful. And I have a pretty healthy relationship with food. And I am strong. And I am smart.
"Worst possible food choices"? FUCK... well, you know.
Did I mention I'm a fat acceptance advocate? 'Cause, yea, I am. My own mother raised me so, God/dess bless her a thousand times.
So I'm reading with interest this post, and I find it really interesting, and then I read the comments, which are interesting in another way, and then comes this:
And I just stop and want to scream at my computer FUCK YOU!!!“Does there always need to be an ‘underlying cause’ though? ”
When you hit morbid obesity, yes, I think there has to be something that drove the individual to make the worst possible food choices (and continue making them, even if they have WLS).
Because it's so. fucking. wrong.
You know why my mom is fat? And I'm talking really fat, lose one or two hundred pounds and still be morbidly obese fat. You really wanna know why?
Because she dieted.
Because she was told that her 170 lb, 5'5" body, her healthy, strong body, her beautiful, perfect body, was "too fat".
So she dieted, and lost 20 pounds. And then gained 25.
And dieted again, and lost 20 pounds. And then gained 30.
And dieted and lost 20 and gained 40, and lost 30 and gained 40, and had one kid (while finishing medical school back when women were so small a minority there were "doctor" lockers for the men and "nurses" lockers for the women) and gained 40, and lost 40 and gained 80, and, and, and... Until her body, still beautiful, still perfect, still strong, was actually fat, and not quite as healthy, and in rather more pain.
And no, she doesn't have the healthiest of eating habits. You wanna know why?
Because she dieted.
Because her entire life people have told her to clean her plate, to not eat so much, that these foods were "bad", that these foods were "good", that she could have cake if she were good, that she had to eat her veggies or she'd be bad, that she should just avoid fat, that she should just avoid carbs, that she should just use a sugar substitute, that she should eat small meals, that she should eat once a day, that she should swallow sponges, that she should count points, that she should chew 50 times, that she should drink more water, that she should stop drinking anything, that she should, she should, she should, she should, she should. Golly gee fucking wiz, you think maybe she lost touch with her hunger and her fullness and her inner guidance there just a little bit?
So no, she doesn't make "perfect" eating choices. And you know what else? Neither do a fuck load of skinny people. In fact, she eats a lot less than a lot of not-fat people I know, and a lot "healthier", and she's moving around a whole lot more weight (pssst, weight bearing is good for your bones -- her osteoporosis scans give her the bone density of a woman 20 years younger than she is), which, let me think, burns more calories.
So, perfect diet? No, even if there were such a thing. "Worst possible food choices"? FUCK YOU. What the hell does that mean, anyway?
Me? I'm just fat. Morbidly obese? Meh. I don't keep track. I certainly was, at one point. Why, you ask? It's called necessary medication, and it made me gain somewhere over 100 pounds (I was fat to start with, and fucking hot, thank you very much), without me doing a thing. When I got off it, I lost 75 pounds, without doing a thing. You know why? Because I'm just fat. Because my body has a weight it likes being at. Because I'm a sedentary American. Because both my parents are fat. Because half of my aunts and uncles are fat. Because I don't have 40 hours a week to spend in a gym, nor the money to pay someone to oversee my continual starvation. Without starvation and a full time job exercising, I will never be thin. If I moved more, I would be healthier, and have more muscle mass, and maybe lose a little bit of weight, but I wouldn't be thin. Why? Because I'm just fat. And I am beautiful. And I have a pretty healthy relationship with food. And I am strong. And I am smart.
"Worst possible food choices"? FUCK... well, you know.
Saturday, January 31, 2009
I feel like I'm losing my mother
I almost titled this "My mother is considering weight loss surgery", but while the latter is factual, what I have up there gets to the meaning of the post.
I need to preface this by saying that I was raised, to the best of my mother's ability and against my father's wishes, with the basic idea, if not the exact words, of Health At Every Size. I have never deliberately dieted in my life. I have lost significant amounts of weight twice, once in high school because I was accidentally starving myself (if I didn't eat breakfast, I found I only needed a Mt Dew and maybe a pastry at school, had to eat a meal at 5pm when I got home from play rehearsal, then wouldn't be really hungry for dinner at 6:30. I do not recommend this), and again after I got off Depakote, which had royally fucked up my body and my appetite and caused me to gain in the vicinity of 100lbs over two or three years, most of which I lost after getting the hell off it; neither of these times were health-promoting for me. I do not want to hear about your diet. I will bitchslap you (or at least fantasize about it) if you moan about getting fat in my presence, and you weigh less than 150% of what you did two months ago. I do not want to hear about your diet. I have recently fallen hard for Harding et al at Shapely Prose. I do not want to hear about your diet.
And this is how my good mama raised me. She was fucked over by the patriarchy and fatphobia and an asshole dad who thought "not starving" = "fat" (and yet insisted that no food be wasted at the table and all plates must be cleaned), and my asshole dad who thought fat = bad and ugly, and a diet industry that told her swallowing sponges = good. She promised to do better with me, her showing-every-sign-of-being-fat daughter, and though I wish she'd gotten a clue in time to save my seven-years-older brother (who once got in a yelling match with my dad about how fat I was WHEN I WAS FUCKING FIVE), I am beyond grateful that she did it more or less right with me. She wasn't perfect (who is?), and I do not have a perfect relationship with food (who does?), but once I was talking with her (at her, really, with her nose buried in a magazine, she occasionally emitting an appropriate-sounding "uh huh") and casually said "Mom, would it be OK if I dye it?" talking about my hair, and her head snapped up with the exclamation "you certainly may not diet!" Bless her a thousand times for that one, and for the subscription to Radiance, and then to Hues (both now defunct, unfortunately but unsurprisingly), and for putting herself between my dad's fatphobic vitriol and me, and for the thousand other things she did to try to avoid fucking me up as badly as she had been.
Bless her also, while I'm on the topic, for plonking $1000 at a trip at boutique clothing stores that sold clothes at which I was a size 1 as soon as I hit adolescence (the $1000 was only once, and bought abundant [pun intended] clothes for both of us; but the general gist of go shopping, spend lots, make shopkeepers grin and stay open late for us continued). Bless her for giving me a wardrobe that looked fucking fabulous on me, whatever size I was at the time, for making shopping a joy and a treat and a way to surround myself with older women who also Got It, and told me how amazing I looked (because I did!) and offered to pay me to model for them. Bless her.
Thus, difficulties that many fat acceptance converts struggle with, I largely avoided. I grew up knowing dieting was stupid and unhealthy and didn't work (knowing indeed that dieting was responsible for turning my 160lb mom into my 400ishlb mom), even if I did also watch her try PhenFen and every other "it's medicine and scientific so it must be healthy" prescription diet drug that came out. I did not usually know my weight or consider it an important indicator of health, even as she had discussions with her doctors about hers. Bless her for that as well.
And now... weight loss surgery. Stomach stapling. Bariatric bypass.
I need to preface this by saying that I was raised, to the best of my mother's ability and against my father's wishes, with the basic idea, if not the exact words, of Health At Every Size. I have never deliberately dieted in my life. I have lost significant amounts of weight twice, once in high school because I was accidentally starving myself (if I didn't eat breakfast, I found I only needed a Mt Dew and maybe a pastry at school, had to eat a meal at 5pm when I got home from play rehearsal, then wouldn't be really hungry for dinner at 6:30. I do not recommend this), and again after I got off Depakote, which had royally fucked up my body and my appetite and caused me to gain in the vicinity of 100lbs over two or three years, most of which I lost after getting the hell off it; neither of these times were health-promoting for me. I do not want to hear about your diet. I will bitchslap you (or at least fantasize about it) if you moan about getting fat in my presence, and you weigh less than 150% of what you did two months ago. I do not want to hear about your diet. I have recently fallen hard for Harding et al at Shapely Prose. I do not want to hear about your diet.
And this is how my good mama raised me. She was fucked over by the patriarchy and fatphobia and an asshole dad who thought "not starving" = "fat" (and yet insisted that no food be wasted at the table and all plates must be cleaned), and my asshole dad who thought fat = bad and ugly, and a diet industry that told her swallowing sponges = good. She promised to do better with me, her showing-every-sign-of-being-fat daughter, and though I wish she'd gotten a clue in time to save my seven-years-older brother (who once got in a yelling match with my dad about how fat I was WHEN I WAS FUCKING FIVE), I am beyond grateful that she did it more or less right with me. She wasn't perfect (who is?), and I do not have a perfect relationship with food (who does?), but once I was talking with her (at her, really, with her nose buried in a magazine, she occasionally emitting an appropriate-sounding "uh huh") and casually said "Mom, would it be OK if I dye it?" talking about my hair, and her head snapped up with the exclamation "you certainly may not diet!" Bless her a thousand times for that one, and for the subscription to Radiance, and then to Hues (both now defunct, unfortunately but unsurprisingly), and for putting herself between my dad's fatphobic vitriol and me, and for the thousand other things she did to try to avoid fucking me up as badly as she had been.
Bless her also, while I'm on the topic, for plonking $1000 at a trip at boutique clothing stores that sold clothes at which I was a size 1 as soon as I hit adolescence (the $1000 was only once, and bought abundant [pun intended] clothes for both of us; but the general gist of go shopping, spend lots, make shopkeepers grin and stay open late for us continued). Bless her for giving me a wardrobe that looked fucking fabulous on me, whatever size I was at the time, for making shopping a joy and a treat and a way to surround myself with older women who also Got It, and told me how amazing I looked (because I did!) and offered to pay me to model for them. Bless her.
Thus, difficulties that many fat acceptance converts struggle with, I largely avoided. I grew up knowing dieting was stupid and unhealthy and didn't work (knowing indeed that dieting was responsible for turning my 160lb mom into my 400ishlb mom), even if I did also watch her try PhenFen and every other "it's medicine and scientific so it must be healthy" prescription diet drug that came out. I did not usually know my weight or consider it an important indicator of health, even as she had discussions with her doctors about hers. Bless her for that as well.
And now... weight loss surgery. Stomach stapling. Bariatric bypass.
Maybe.
If I still had all the old Radiance issues I could pull out all the articles that talk about what a Dumb, Self-Hating Idea it is, but she'd dismiss them because "the surgeries are really different now, and I know a lot of women for whom it really was good". And she may be right. The surgeries are safer now (it would have been hard for them to get less safe!), and there are women for whom it was a godsend. And with her other health issues (notably her mobility issues, which are aggravated though not caused by her weight), maybe it would be good for her, too. We've had several discussions on the topic, each trying to listen to the other, each trying to be heard. I am open to the possibility that it might be the right decision for her.
But I still feel like I'm losing her. Not because, if she went through with it, her beautiful body would melt away (seriously, my mother is the most beautiful person in the world to me, with the only sometimes exception of my child, and it's not that she has "such a pretty face", though she does, nor in spite of her size, nor even really because of it, but simply because she is so. damn. beautiful, just as she is). Nor because she'd be making a choice I disagreed with (she's an allopathic drug dealing MD, I'm a crunchy woowoo acupuncture-loving fish-oil-swilling neo-hippie; we're used to disagreeing and still loving and respecting each other). Not even because, no matter how safe it is, the surgery still might kill her.
No, it's because I find an article like this one that I so want to email to her because she'd Get It... and I don't. It's because I used to always talk to her about my own weight and health and body acceptance issues... and now I feel I can't.
I'm losing her. My rock -- no, my squishy safe bed with the softest pillows and the monster-repelling covers -- my loving mother, my protectress, my goddess, the one person who would stand up for me and my right to love my body just the way it is thank you all very fucking much... isn't anymore. I can't send her those articles because she'd think I was trying to make a point with her and whether to do the surgery, when I just want to share my joy. I can't talk to her about my stuff, because it'll sound like it's about hers. It sometimes makes me miss my mother so much I start to cry.
Which is so much self-indulgent angst and a slap in the face to everyone who actually has lost a mother in the real dead-and-gone sense (my own beloved lifemate included), but they're my feelings, and I'm sticking to them... the way my mama taught me.
(Any comments in favor of her doing the surgery because weight loss always = good, saying I don't want her to because then I'll be the fattest, supporting the dangerous myth that fat = unhealthy, promoting your own diet, talking about the weight you "need" to lose, or in any other way displaying willful fatphobia or thin privilege will be deleted. Consider that fair warning.)
If I still had all the old Radiance issues I could pull out all the articles that talk about what a Dumb, Self-Hating Idea it is, but she'd dismiss them because "the surgeries are really different now, and I know a lot of women for whom it really was good". And she may be right. The surgeries are safer now (it would have been hard for them to get less safe!), and there are women for whom it was a godsend. And with her other health issues (notably her mobility issues, which are aggravated though not caused by her weight), maybe it would be good for her, too. We've had several discussions on the topic, each trying to listen to the other, each trying to be heard. I am open to the possibility that it might be the right decision for her.
But I still feel like I'm losing her. Not because, if she went through with it, her beautiful body would melt away (seriously, my mother is the most beautiful person in the world to me, with the only sometimes exception of my child, and it's not that she has "such a pretty face", though she does, nor in spite of her size, nor even really because of it, but simply because she is so. damn. beautiful, just as she is). Nor because she'd be making a choice I disagreed with (she's an allopathic drug dealing MD, I'm a crunchy woowoo acupuncture-loving fish-oil-swilling neo-hippie; we're used to disagreeing and still loving and respecting each other). Not even because, no matter how safe it is, the surgery still might kill her.
No, it's because I find an article like this one that I so want to email to her because she'd Get It... and I don't. It's because I used to always talk to her about my own weight and health and body acceptance issues... and now I feel I can't.
I'm losing her. My rock -- no, my squishy safe bed with the softest pillows and the monster-repelling covers -- my loving mother, my protectress, my goddess, the one person who would stand up for me and my right to love my body just the way it is thank you all very fucking much... isn't anymore. I can't send her those articles because she'd think I was trying to make a point with her and whether to do the surgery, when I just want to share my joy. I can't talk to her about my stuff, because it'll sound like it's about hers. It sometimes makes me miss my mother so much I start to cry.
Which is so much self-indulgent angst and a slap in the face to everyone who actually has lost a mother in the real dead-and-gone sense (my own beloved lifemate included), but they're my feelings, and I'm sticking to them... the way my mama taught me.
(Any comments in favor of her doing the surgery because weight loss always = good, saying I don't want her to because then I'll be the fattest, supporting the dangerous myth that fat = unhealthy, promoting your own diet, talking about the weight you "need" to lose, or in any other way displaying willful fatphobia or thin privilege will be deleted. Consider that fair warning.)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)