Showing posts with label privilege. Show all posts
Showing posts with label privilege. Show all posts

Wednesday, August 5, 2009

"How else would you have us say it?"

What are you doing reading this here? You could have read it 18 hours earlier if you were updated to the new feed! Remember, if you want to post a comment, it needs to be over at www.raisingmyboychick.com; I'll keep updating you here for a while longer, but you really should switch now!

*************************************************

Reader Gayle left a fabulously intelligent question on the post The personal and the political:

I have seen debates on the subjects you mention where one side mentions that what the other side has said hurts them/shames them/makes them feel inadequate. To which the other side replies, “How else would you have us say it?” What are you thoughts on that power shifting? Or is some hurt inevitable, even if it is unintended, especially in these subjects which are so emotionally charged to begin with?

I was so inspired my response comment turned into a post all its own:

I think you put your finger on it with the phrase "power shifting". When that question is asked by a group with power (privilege) to a group without/with lesser power (privilege), I think it's extremely problematical. I see that dynamic a whole lot more in discussions on race, sexuality, and so on: less often, I think, in parenting, where we are ALL very low on the power structure (in the eyes of kyriarchy; it'll put us on a pedestal, sure, when it's not trampling all over us, but let us have real power? no way!).

The reason it is problematical within certain power dynamics (say if I, as a white cis woman, were to say that to Monica Roberts, a black trans woman, should she have reason to call me on my language) is because it shifts the responsibility -- the work, the onus -- from the oppressors to the oppressed. It says "I don't need to do any learning, I'm going to make you figure this out, I'm going to make you teach me, I'm going to make you justify your pain, make you be responsible for avoiding your own hurt." It also ignores that odds are excellent there already is an abundance of answers to that very question from the oppressed group, and asking it betrays that one is unwilling to do even a cursory examination of the existing thoughts on the topic; that is, that one is ignorant of and unwilling to do the (incredibly simple!) work of finding and listening to the voices of those without power.

That, obviously, is not good. That power shifting, in fact, is one of the prime ways that kyriarchy -- acting through those with privilege against those without -- protects itself.

However, in the context of parenting, and the in-fighting of "the mommy wars" and discussions about parenting practices, the power dynamic is, generally, quite different. While someone who uses formula has huge, moneyed, powerful, corporate, industrial aspects of the kyriarchy backing up hir "choice", on an individual level a formula feeder and a breastfeeder are both on the same bottom rung of the kyriarchy (all else being equal; which, granted, they rarely are). So in that context, asking "how would you have us say it?" can be an act of compassionate bridge-making; but, it requires both being willing to humble oneself and really, truly being willing to listen to and hear the answer.

To further complicate things, there is a significant corporate/kyriarchal interest in many of these topics: there is huge money in undermining breastfeeding, in selling plastic parent-substitutes, in medicalizing birth, et cetera and so on, in addition to the less financial but no less real and powerful kyriarchal forces wishing to convince us that our bodies are broken, that interdependence is wrong, that we are incapable of knowing how to raise our children without the advice of patronizing, patriarchal "experts". So when I say "formula is inferior" -- because it is, because human milk is the biological norm, the standard, and formula simply fails to measure up -- I am simultaneously speaking truth to power, and potentially hurting my sister oppressed mothers who for whatever reason use(d) formula. So, if I change my language, soften it, sacrifice strength and accuracy for kindness and palatability, am I being compassionate to my beloved sisters? Or am I acceding to the pressures of the powerful, greedy, immoral formula industry?

Unfortunately, I think the answer is "yes". We are left facing a choice; compassion for our sisters? Or effecting change by standing up to the kyriarchy? I don't think there is any single right answer, but the best path at any given time is going to depend on the specific circumstances.

When speaking with a woman who could not or did not breastfeed, perhaps that is not the best time for using our most powerful lactivist language; instead then we might talk about how fortunate we are that formula is adequate to sustain life now, or perhaps even bemoan the lack of support women have for establishing and sustaining breastfeeding, or discuss the local milk bank or milk share program we're working to get started. But when writing material directed at formula companies, at women who are facing the "choice" of feeding method, when we are discussing as lactivists the best way to get our message across, when we, as I try to do on this blog, are discussing the larger culture and the kyriarchal influences on our individual lives: then, I think that language is appropriate and valuable.

What about those individuals who encounter it, even in those contexts, and are still hurt? At some point, I think there is a level of individual responsibility that must be taken (remembering that we are discussing a situation among those with roughly equal power and privilege -- or lack thereof); at some point, one has to be able to step back and avoid taking, as well as giving, offense unnecessarily.

Sometimes language makes us uncomfortable; sometimes critiques of kyriarchy make us squirm. My responsibility as a woman both with and without privilege is to make sure I'm keeping my side of the street clean: is my language accurate? Is it chosen wisely? Is this the right time and place to say it? Is there a way to say this that will still speak truth while hurting my sister mothers less? Am I speaking from a place grounded in justice? Am I directing my anger at institutions, not individuals? If I am sure my side is clean, as it were, I am free to offer compassion to those who are wounded by my words, without choosing to change them. I am responsible for me, including, yes, how and when I present my thoughts, but I cannot be responsible for what another does with them when she receives them.

Is hurt inevitable? Probably. We live in a society that attacks us women who parent at every turn, when it is not shoving us up on inhuman pedestals and demanding inhuman feats of perfection. We live in a society that is constantly hurting us, telling us we are wrong, telling us we are bad, telling us we are broken, and which is remarkably good at making us tell each other and ourselves that. We are highly sensitive to any perceived criticism, and not without good reason. Of course we are likely to encounter a factual statement like "formula is inferior" or "crying-it-out is not good" and internalize it as "I am a bad mother, I am hurting my child". And of course we're likely to lash out when we do.

But I do not believe this is a reason to give up our ideals or our goals or our activism. We can only watch our own words, take responsibility for what is ours to control, and offer compassion and understanding to those who are hurting. To avoid speaking truth to avoid ever causing any pain would be allowing the kyriarchy to control us even more. The world is better served when we can work to change the institutions belittling and constricting and attacking us -- including by using words that may be challenging, no matter how carefully they are chosen.


******************************

Hey, you're missing the conversation that's happening over at the new site! Update your feed, subscribe by email, or head over there now.

Monday, June 15, 2009

Irritations with Blogger, and the beginnings of a comment policy

Obviously, I need a new blog host, one that will actually inform me when I get new comments, instead of only if/when it feels like it/the moon aligns/some random key generator has been met/whatever the hell it is that makes it decide to inform me today and not half the other days.

Also, I obviously need a comments policy, because this is NOT the place to say X makes anyone a "bad mom/bad parent" if X does not equal abuse and/or murder -- and y'know what, even then said abuse is usually perpetuated due to having previously experienced abuse and misogyny and often occurs in conjunction with untreated or poorly treated mental illness, so let's just skip it altogether, shall we? Again, I'm not denying that "bad moms" exist, I'm just saying that that shit is way too complicated and inevitably exists within a kyriarchal framework, actively antagonistic to women who parent, and I would much rather be focusing on the root causes of abusive parenting than assigning blame (which does absolutely nothing to help) to individual perpetrator/victim women.

And still more lessons from recent debacles, if you refer to your spouse as "wifey" (and not in an ironical reclaiming queer way), and me as "lady" (and not in a hot and/or respectful "I agree completely, my lady!" way), odds are really, really great I'm gonna delete your ass comment.

Further, this is so not the place to play protect the patriarchy through straw arguments, m'kay? It's one thing if you don't understand what I mean by "the patriarchy" or "the kyriarchy" or any other womanist/feminist term, want to learn more, and are asking sincere questions, but another altogether if you come in with your own, erroneous, definition, and call me misguided based on that.

And while I'm at it, let me make abundantly, explicitly clear that to the best of my ability, I will protect this place from comments that are willfully sexist, classist, racist, cissexist, transphobic, homophobic, heterosexist, ableist, sizeist, fatphobic, ageist, or in any other way exhibit fear, prejudice, or discrimination toward any other person based on an immutable or inherent characteristic about themselves -- and yes, that includes bullshit arguments over whether things like fat and queerness are inherent or immutable, 'cause they are. I know I'm gonna slip up and things will slip in, either through Blogger messing up and failing to inform me such a comment has been posted, or through my own ignorance and unexamined privilege and prejudice, and so I respectfully and humbly request y'all's assistance, and promise that when such slip ins/slip ups are pointed out to me, I will thank you, apologize, fix it, and move on.

Spam, obviously, is right out.

Within this comment policy, there is room for disagreement and debate, and ginormous room for discussion and developing our feminist discourse; there is only a dearth of room for discrimination or the defense thereof.

Comments welcome.

Thursday, June 4, 2009

Racism in my brain

This is going to be another not-very-fun post for me to write.

First, let me say that I love being reminded of the ways in which humans are at essence primates. We are so very, very similar to our also-primate cousins in so many ways, and it makes me smile to notice the behaviors that are so obviously primate based: the way we touch to communicate and cement relationships, how we use grooming to comfort, the group dynamics that tell us instantly when people in a crowd are part of a family. Maybe I'm weird, but seriously, that makes me happy.

This, however, does not.

Yesterday I was driving along, and glanced over at a car next to me. There was a lovely Asian family driving and having a conversation. The shape of their faces, with the mouth just a little farther (farther from what? from mine, from a more European face, from "normal") out from their faces, reminded me of chimpanzees. Which, not really thinking about it, reminded me that humans are primates, which made me smile.

The smile froze on my face, as I realized holy shit, that is fucking racist.

Using oneself and one's body as the base model to which all others are compared is normal human (primate, I would argue) thinking, but becomes extremely problematical when the "I" doing the thinking is a member of a race which systematically and horrifically has dominated and oppressed all other races throughout history, so that's a big damn problem right there. And the trope that people of color are more like animals, more animalistic, closer to animals and less evolved (again, using white as "normal" from which other races "deviate") is one of the more pervasive, evil racist constructions, which has been used to justify the enslavement, murder, colonization, and de-humanization of millions of people. And it's in my brain.

When really looked at, it's obvious the construction is such bullshit, too. The very darkness of skin of people of color is, rather than being "animalistic", a sign of more evolution away from our primate cousins: chimpanzees underneath their fur, just like white/European humans, have no need for skin pigmentation, and are therefore pale. The excessive hairiness of limb, torso, and male face of white humans is more similar to our furry relations than is the comparatively lesser hairiness of many other races. So it would be easy and at least as accurate to construct an argument that white people are the more animalistic, the less evolved, the less human; or at least (and most accurately) to see in all humans things that remind us of other animals: face here, hair there, and all of us so obviously primates in body and behavior.

But that's not the way racism works. Whiteness has constructed itself as normal, human, most highly evolved, and all others as deviations and therefore lesser. In this framework, in which we all reside and by which my brain has been thoroughly colonized, whiteness cannot be understood as animal-like because whiteness defines what "human" is; only those who are outside of whiteness can be understood to be different from human and therefore like animals.

And it's in my brain.

I didn't even know about it. I had known about and hated the trope of the "savage, animalistic darkie", scoffed at those who used it, gotten angry at examples of it along with everyone else, and I never realized it was part of my own thinking. How could it be? That's a horrible, evil, racist thought, and I'm not racist, so I couldn't think like that.

But I do.

As a feminist, trying to raise my white male child in a womanist/feminist, anti-racist, anti-kyriarchy manner, to come across such a blatantly racist construction in my own mind is pretty damn horrifying. It's entirely too tempting to shove it aside, to not think about it, to deny it: and that is white privilege. White privilege means not having to think about race or to acknowledge racism when I encounter it, even (especially) in my own thinking. White privilege means I can accept that whiteness=normal, because I am white and it is human nature to think of ourselves as the norm. White privilege means everything in my culture is telling me "you are normal, you are the standard, you are the pinnacle from which all others are deviations"; white privilege means I could choose to not feel bad, to not think too hard, to not talk about it, to not admit it. I would not be directly hurt if I allowed this racism to continue; I would only be going along with the status quo and no one with power would blame me: that is white privilege.

I choose not to accept that privilege (it is white privilege that I have a choice, and I cannot do away with that privilege), and so I expose that thought, talk about it, deconstruct it, and work to do away with it from my own mind.

Now I wonder: how do I stop the thought from colonizing the Boychick's mind? When everything in his culture is telling him whiteness, and therefore he, is the default, when his own normal egocentricism agrees, how do I combat it? I can point out the ways in which all humans look and act like the animals we are; I can talk about how his father is hairy just like other primates, and how he will eventually be as well; I can avoid the "colorblind" ideology that prohibits mention of race at all, thereby reinforcing the white-as-standard meme: but I don't know if that will be enough.

The only thing I am certain of is that it is only possible to counter and defend against something when we know it's there, and so I am grateful to that racist thought, in debt to that family: for without the realization that came after, I would still be coasting along, smug in my superiority, unaware I carried that ugly construct within myself.

Monday, June 1, 2009

Flash-bulb moment: musings on parking spaces and bipolar disorder

I was reading about the Australian disability parking scheme bruhaha at Hoyden About Town, when I read this quote (long, but worth it):

These existing schemes usually have some kind of distance measure, which says something like ‘person’s impairment would be unduly affected by walking 50m/100m.’ When you compare the “harmonisation” proposal with that, something becomes clear: what they’re doing is mandating what kind of impairment you have, rather than assessing the effect of the combination of the impairment and the disabling context of distant or inaccessible parking. We’re moving away from an acknowledgement of the way that parking requirements can be disabling for particular people, whatever their type of impairment, and at reducing that disability by accommodations. We’re moving towards configuring particular people as ‘deserving’ based on an assessment of the type of their impairment or their dependency.

One of the major problems here is that it requires PWD to provide evidence of dependency. You have to prove that if you push yourself too hard, if you work beyond your known limits and ‘act’ like an able-bodied person, not only that you can’t do it but that you will need physical help from another person to walk. It makes dependence, again, the supposed essence of disability, and it attributes this to the individual, rather that seeing it as occurring at the intersection of ‘normal’ parking and impairment.


And my eyes popped wide and my jaw went slack; something clicked for me.

I've long struggled with trying to resolve my identity as a person with mental illness, my current status as basically sane and stable, and the fact that I haven't, don't, won't, and probably just can't hold down a traditional full time office job.

Lots of people with bipolar disorder do manage it, just fine, both with and without medication. My dad's work, the responsibility and need to drag himself out of bed every morning, was at times the only thing that kept him going at all. My brother, with the help of medication, thrives in a high stress, high stakes job in the financial industry. So why can't I? is the refrain the crazy voice uses to castigate me with.

These quotes did two things for me: one, pointed out the fallacy of categorizing people's need for accommodations based on diagnosis, rather than disability. That is, what does it matter that someone else with my diagnosis can work? I can't. Saying "but they do!" isn't going to change my own ability, and it's ridiculous to try to make it.

Two, and the more "aha!" of the points, although you'd think I'd have learned this by now (I know I've brought up the spoon theory here before), is that, just like the person with an invisible physical disability who "could" walk farther, all that trying to pretend that I am "normal", that I am not disabled, does for me is wear me out and make me sick.

Ironic (Alanis Morissettey definition) isn't it, that as long as I acknowledge that I am sick, then I can be well. If I try to pretend I am not, if I park myself too far from my destination, push myself too hard, then I will get sick.

This is something I've known for a while (I don't try to work full time, after all, and the Boychick is only a part of that), but I've never entirely been comfortable with it. Reading about others, who have "real", physical, if too oft-maligned, disabilities, struggle with the same issue, if in a different plane, was eye-opening for me. It is only the crazy voice, which does its best to convince me I'm not "really" sick (does that amuse anyone else? the crazy voice saying I'm not crazy?), that would have me disassociate from others with disabilities; but if I acknowledge and accept my shared commonalities with people with physical disabilities, suddenly I feel, and act, much saner.

I don't know the course of my disease, much less my life: I may yet wind up over the edge, hospitalized and incapacitated; I may yet wind up thriving in an office 40 hours a week. But one thing I am certain of: the more I push myself toward the latter, denying myself the accommodations I need and deserve, the more likely I'll find myself in the former.

Further, and worse, as the HAT article points out is happening with physical disabilities in Australia, I am not offered accommodations by the state (or society at large), because as long as I don't try to act sane, I remain sane. I do not meet, as WildlyParenthetical says, the medical/dependency model of "disabled": as long as I do not seek to work in a traditional job, I am able to dress myself, get out of the house, make required phone calls, pay my bills (with money my partner earns for us), and do all those things that the state uses as markers for sanity/ability. I can even manage to do those things when I am unstable from working: I am "unduly affected", and have panic attacks before every call and during every trip to the store, but I still technically could, and thus fail to meet the medical model of disability, so I am denied any work compensation or disability acknowledgments.

And I manage despite this only because I exist with so much privilege: my race, my class, my partnership with a man, my (for now) lack of any other cognitive or physical disabilities. Because of all that, I don't really need the disability benefits I am denied: I have income and health insurance from other sources, access to health care providers, resources to purchase the substances that help keep me sane. Many others like me do not exist with such an abundance of privilege, and are, literally, driven crazy, and only then (and only if they are still lucky and probably privileged) are they "gifted" with acknowledgment of their disability and assistance from society.

I trust I do not need to explain just how horrifying this is, how wrong, and how no (hah!) sane society would allow this state of affairs to continue.

So I'll take that parking spot, thank you, and I'll fight anyone who tries to take away from me or any of my people. Will you join us?



ETA Those of you in Australia can act directly on this particular parking space issue with a letter to government or an open letter to organizations. Thank you!

Friday, May 8, 2009

Best comment I've read all day

(on a blog not-my-own):

"Privilege is so often invisible (silent, but deadly. Like dog flatulence)"

Win!

(Found here)

Tuesday, May 5, 2009

We are not bad moms -- but are we good moms?

Reader sarah replied to my post We are not bad moms* with the following:
There is a corollary to this post that I think should also be said. Babywearing, breastfeeding, EC, etc. don't necessarily make you a good mom. There is a world of hurt you can bring on your child even if you practice those parenting techniques, they don't inure anyone from the negative aspects of parenting.

I just feel like this needs to be said (and repeated over and over) as I see my friends lulled into a false sense of safety and superiority because they subscribe to a certain set of parenting practices. We need to constantly challenge ourselves to look past our more superficial lifestyle choices to how our personalities, histories, family structures, and communities impact our children in a way that is beyond our control.
First, sarah, thank you so much for the comment and the post inspiration. I'd like to reply to this -- agreeing and disagreeing and expanding and being inspired by -- in three parts.

To the first:
Babywearing, breastfeeding, EC, etc. don't necessarily make you a good mom. There is a world of hurt you can bring on your child even if you practice those parenting techniques, they don't inure anyone from the negative aspects of parenting.
I really hesitate to agree, although I think it is technically true. But as I've mentioned before, everyone and everything in our society jumps at any opportunity to either knock us down and declare us horrid mothers, or place us on Olympian pedestals no one could hope to live up to. I am therefore loathe to take part in any of this game, to spend any of my time lending any credence to the bad-mother meme. I am in fact, in general, loathe to even place mothers on any kind of good/bad spectrum, nor to attempt to define what a "good mother" is, such that someone who breastfeeds and babywears, or who formula feeds and lugs a baby bucket, might or might not be one, because of or in spite of those practices.

Furthermore, I believe that babywearing and breastfeeding and elimination communication are good things in their own right; all other things being equal, it is better to breastfeed than to not, better to practice EC than to not. These practices have tangible, intrinsic benefits, to infants, to the parent-child relationship, to parents, to the environment, to society; I do not want to see them placed in opposition to intangible "good parenting", as though it were a trade-off (although I will say I know sometimes it is a trade-off, especially with the limited amount of energy and resources mothers have available to them in the early months and years, but no one can know from the outside the balance of a mother's choices; what costs time and energy for one person might be a simplification and a lifesaver for another). An inherently good thing is good whether or not one is managing to do other good things, and whether or not it protects you from the damage of other not-good things.** And, as they are minority practices, which are often attacked in a very misogynistic way (often supported in a misogynistic way as well, I will grant you), I am loathe as well to contribute to the belittling or dismissing of these parenting choices.

(I also wish to discuss whether or not or in what way(s) attachment parenting practices might indeed protect against "the negative aspects of parenting", but I'll leave that for another post, because it's a complex issue in its own right.)

Jumping to the end of the comment:
We need to constantly challenge ourselves to look past our more superficial lifestyle choices to how our personalities, histories, family structures, and communities impact our children in a way that is beyond our control.
I can give a big ol' Amen! to the bolded part. Certainly when we look at the ways in which the kyriarchy constantly constrains our choices, debating diapering methods can seem like rearranging the deck chairs on the Titanic. Mothers are a persecuted subset of a persecuted gender; mothers who exist without white, straight, able, or class privilege even more so. So much of the damage that is done to our children is out of our control, dictated by the work choices we (don't) have, the community support we (don't) have, the parental benefits we (don't) have, the schooling options we (don't) have, and so on, et cetera, ad nauseum. Even those of us hell-bent on countering the kyriarchy and the dominant culture to the best of our ability recognize that our children will grow up in this society, influenced by its memes and beliefs and ideals and prejudices, fully versed in its gender and racial and sexual norms and mores, and there's not a damn thing we can do about it, except try to at least help them be able to see and recognize those influences in their lives, and thereby, if we are very lucky, reduce their power at least a little.

That said, I'm not sure I can agree with the "We need to constantly challenge ourselves to look past our more superficial lifestyle choices" preamble. Although that is, at least in part, what I try to do with this blog, I recognize that it is something I am able to do due to privilege: I do not have to worry about where my child's next meal will come from, whether his water is going to make him ill, how to pay for any injury he might incur running around like the toddler he is, or how to protect him from any abusive relations; and so I am able to spend my time thinking about paid family leave, environmentalism, universal health care, and preventing domestic violence, and the role of the kyriarchy in the lack of these things (which is not to say that only those who exist with privilege, like myself, can think big thoughts, or need to "fix" things for "them", just that I have far fewer roadblocks in my way than does someone who is oppressed in more ways -- these roadblocks are one of the many ways the kyriarchy seeks to protect itself). Further, "constantly challeng[ing]" myself does, to an extent, fulfill me and give me energy, but I am not hubristic enough to think that therefore everyone must lead the examined life: for some, letting go of the need to examine and challenge themselves is the healthier path.

Finally, looking at the middle part, where I think the meat is:
I see my friends lulled into a false sense of safety and superiority because they subscribe to a certain set of parenting practices.
Here we have the twofold point: "superiority" speaks to women who attempt to build themselves up by placing themselves ahead of others, because the kyriarchy has ensured that hierarchy is the only organizational principle they know (even in trying to be grateful, we too often make it about being better off than others); "safety" speaks to women who are seeking to protect themselves, because they are under constant attack by the kyriarchy and forces of anti-mother misogyny, threatened always with the spectre of the "bad mom" label if they don't do things "just right". And although I don't think that being "lulled into a false sense of safety and security" (by clinging to breastfeeding or babywearing or what-have-you) is a good thing, I also cannot blame them, or fault the inclination. Because we are under attack, because there is so much out of our control, and if clinging to cloth diapers like they were lifesavers is what helps a mother get through the tsunami of hate, from outside and in, that comes with the early years of parenting... well, she gets through, and that survival is worth celebrating, an intrinsic Good Thing, even if she might have done it "better".

The "mommy wars" suck. (A lot.) Possibly the most evil thing about them is the way they make us turn against each other, first by scrambling to place ourselves on a hierarchy of most attached/most crunchy/most Super/most whatever, then by attacking each other with "[not] necessarily... a good mom" when we recognize the fallacy of the hierarchy. Dismantling the kyriarchy without undermining each other, critiquing parenting choices without criticizing fellow parents: these are not easy tasks. It is not an easy dance, and it is so easy to make a misstep -- just as with parenting itself. But it is necessary to try, and it is necessary to forgive ourselves because we will get it wrong sometimes -- just as with parenting itself.

So no, putting the telly on for your toddler doesn't make you a bad mom, and knowing a dozen carries to do with a 5m wrap doesn't make you a good mom. But what might make you a revolutionary is to let go of both the fear of being a bad mom, and the need to be a good mom. Let go of the good mom/bad mom hierarchy altogether. Just be a mom -- a bad-ass mom in your own right -- and tell the hierarchy it can go to hell.



*Which is, by far and without question, my most popular post, which still kind of mystifies me. The reaction to it has been amazing, and humbles me. Thank you to everyone who read, and especially to everyone who commented or passed it on.

**An analogy: recycling is a Good Thing (as is reducing and reusing). I do my best to reduce my consumption of paper and plastic containers, and reuse or recycle what we do bring home. I also drive well over 100 miles a week, when I could take public transit, or avoid travel altogether. Does my typical American use of the car, which has a much greater overall impact on the environment than the waste I produce and how I deal with it, mean that "recycling doesn't make me a good environmentalist"? Does my use of the car somehow negate the Good Thing that recycling is? It's not exactly a rhetorical question, but I have an answer that I can live with for myself, and I hope you do too.

Friday, May 1, 2009

Blogging Against Disablism Day, 2009

Blogging Against Disablism Day, May 1st 2009

I've struggled with what to write for this post.

I've thought about writing about the shared identity I have as the daughter of a woman with a physical disability: how I learned growing up first to look for seats and benches everywhere, before she got her chair, then later to scan ahead for ramps and wide enough doors and spaces to maneuver; how I felt when I overheard adults who should have known better say she wasn't disabled, she was just fat and lazy; how the Boychick has learned to love electric carts and thinks everyone in one is a grandparent just waiting to take him on a ride.

I've thought about writing more about my struggles with bipolar disorder, maybe finish up part three of the mental health series I've been promising for a while: maybe tell the story of ruining Christmas three years running, anxiety attacks coming out in force with the rising chorus of Christmas carols; maybe the one where I was overwhelmed by the crush of crowds, and had to be lead through IKEA like a woman without sight, because I could see too much, and ended up hiding in an empty slot in the warehouse, exactly like a scared animal because that's all I was, until the crowds and the panic thinned and I could escape; or perhaps tell you about the probably-concussion I suffered when the self-soothing head-on-wall went a little too far, undiagnosed because it was beyond me even to contemplate an explanation when merely existing in my skin was too hard already.

I've thought about getting on my high horse, pulling out my pompous thesaurus, hiding behind a wall of intellectualism, and lecturing about the Evils of Disablism and the Privilege of the Abled -- with just enough self-disclosure and self-flagellation to not lose all your interest, I'd hope.

And I've thought again and again about abandoning the idea of writing about it at all, because it feels like so much hubris, because I'm not ill enough not disabled enough not crazy enough to be worthy of writing about disablism -- and you likely have to be at least as crazy as I am, or love someone who is, to recognize the insanity in that declaration of being too-sane.

That last one is true, in a way; my illness is invisible: my body is not twisted as my mind is, my crutches are hidden as behavioral quirks, not strapped to my arms, and though I walk through life with a devil riding me, my body's back is unbowed. More, too, for I am -- and this is I will admit a relative comparison -- basically sane at the moment, mostly functional in my daily life, able to do normal(ish) things in a normal(ish) way.

Which is all to say, I do not suffer daily disablism the way so many do: insults do not get hurled at me regularly; my basic worth and competence and humanity are not questioned or outright dismissed by those around me. I pass, for sane, for able, for "normal".

But I'm not. I infiltrate. I am quiet, unseen. And so I hear what is said.

I hear bipolar/postpartum depression/post traumatic stress disorder/social anxiety dismissed as a quack diagnosis. I hear fibromyalgia/chronic fatigue syndrome belittled as so much whinging. I hear the jokes about chill pills and happy pills and pill-popping, always implying the joke's subject takes too many or doesn't take enough. I hear the tuts of tongues saying well she's too ill to deserve children, they should take them away and tie her tubes. I hear the perky voices proclaiming it could all be better with positive thinking. I hear the declarations of her as incurable, him soulless. I hear the never-ending refrains of it's not that bad, just stay home, just go out, just be normal, just don't be like that, just don't be you.

I hear it all, and it hurts me all. Sometimes I speak up, and sometimes I don't; sometimes I let the pain show, and sometimes I don't; sometimes I out myself and sometimes I don't. Sometimes I have the strength, the energy, the reserves, the coping ability, the buffer. Sometimes I don't.

I've been called names, dismissed to my face, asked to do too much, told I'm not doing enough. But it is in my invisibility, my passing, that I am most affected by (dis)ablism; it is the side comments, the snide comments, the jokes and the jabs about "them" that are really about me and mine, that I suffer from most frequently.

You may not see me when we are out in the world together, may not see my diagnosis, see my illness, see my allegiance to the tribe of the disabled -- but I see you. And I hear you. And I remember.

Friday, April 24, 2009

Andrade is guilty, and so am I

I have been half following the Angie Zapata murder case, reading the posts on TransGriot about it, but not reading the links because I am a conscientious objector to the mainstream media (and have been having enough trouble keeping up with my feed reader as it is). I was, well, not pleased exactly (it's hard to be happy about the pitiful "justice" our punitive system offers) to hear that a fully guilty verdict was rendered, including the hate crime charge; I was overjoyed that for once, a "trans panic" defense had so thoroughly failed.

Then I read about Angie's family's reaction, and was struck dumb by the simultaneous realization and the refutation of my own assumptions.

I had thought, here was this little Latina trans girl, murdered by her maybe-boyfriend. I thought I knew her; she'd be kicked out by her transphobic Hispanic family, trying to make it on her own, possibly turning tricks to survive. Good little White Liberal Ally was I, so cynical about her chances for justice, so certain of her alienation.

But then I read her brother's words:
Angie was my sister.

She was a member of our family. We loved her very much, and we will miss her every day. Every day and every night our mom has to deal with great pain of ... one of her babies being buried. Every day our siblings and I reach for the phone and realize we’ll never hear her voice. There’s no answer anymore.

A part of our family is missing, stolen from us. Angie was 18, her life was just beginning. She was brave, she had guts, she had courage, and she was beautiful, fun and loving. She was our little sister.
And I had to confront my own heart, who thought that by knowing the plight of the plot of too many trans women of color's lives that I knew the circumstances of her life; who thought that since I knew the color of her family's skin that I knew the contents of their hearts. I made so many assumptions about her, not bothering to read further, not even realizing I had made them; as much as I thought about it, which was hardly at all, I thought I knew what I needed to know about her.

I was wrong. I was guilty of racism, of the most pervasive sort of cisgenderism: the ignore-ance of a trans person's own existence. I committed a hate crime in the whitewashed confines of my own head.

White privilege doesn't go away. Cisgender privilege doesn't go away. We can't do our course in Racism 101 and Transphobia 101 and then wash our hands of the blood of those whiteness has killed, of those cisgender bias has killed.

This doesn't give me much hope for the Boychick. Bashes the rose-colored glasses right off my "raise a post-racist generation" face, in fact. Which is probably a good thing; helps me see how the world actually is, how hard a journey is ahead. Best hope I have is to ground him in a childhood of racism- and cisgenderism-awareness, and show him that it never stops; privilege never goes away, no matter how much we want it to, so our obligation as possessors of privilege to learn, to listen, to humble ourselves, and to root out the prejudices hidden in the darkest corners of our own heads -- which will always be there, more persistent than cockroaches and uglier still -- never goes away.

I am so sorry for what I did to you, how I erased you in my own mind, Angie. Your memory deserves so much more than that. Angie's family: I can only beg forgiveness. Even if you never learn of my assumptions about you, even if you never learn I exist, I have wronged you, and I owe you. I am sorry.

Monday, April 20, 2009

The difference between gratitude and gloating

I found this when looking through my email drafts folder; I'd typed it up on the iPhone nearly two weeks ago. I'm sure I was interrupted before I could finish, and I really don't remember where I was going with it, so it just kind of ends with no conclusion, but I thought it was an interesting enough snippet it could stand as-is. Feel free (encouraged!) to comment if you can expand on the thought for me.


Gratitude is good, right? It's good for you, it helps you be a better person, everyone should keep a gratitude journal, count their blessings, make every day Thanksgiving, etc, etc... Right?

Maybe. Except when it's not, and that "gratitude" is really gloating, and helps reinforce and blind you to privilege.

Gratitude is saying "I'm glad I'm me". Gloating is saying "I'm glad I'm not you".

When stuck in traffic, saying "thank you for this opportunity to practice patience" is gratitude. Saying "well at least I have a car, unlike all those poor shmucks starving children in Africa" is gloating.

"I felt sorry for myself that I had no shoes, until I met a man who had no feet" is a statement of gloating masquerading as gratitude.

The difference between gratitude and gloating is whether there has to be someone worse off than you in order for you to feel good about yourself. Those of us with privilege rarely escape the pit of gloating: if we are blind to our privilege still, we don't see what is wrong with our pity; if we have opened our eyes and minds to our privilege, we too often confuse acknowledging that privilege with pitying those "below" us (we are privileged, so they are oppressed, so we must always point out how much worse they have it, right? not so much, no).

Tuesday, March 31, 2009

More on intersectionality

You know how I said we can't always get it right? Well, I was right, because I got some stuff wrong in that last post. I have a tendency to let language run away with me, and go with what sounds good rather than what's right. So in the last post, I conceptually missed one really important piece, and messed up in some of my language.

To whit, the idea of us v them (or even us and them). It doesn't work. When I'm talking about me, I can talk about "those who are not like me". But if I'm talking about "us" -- say, feminists, or fat acceptance advocates -- then I can't talk about a "them" -- women of color, or persons with disabilities -- because they are us. There are feminists of color, and disabled fat activists, and fat Brown trans Deaf feminist bisexual women (ok, I don't know of one, but that doesn't mean she doesn't exist), and for them (tricky word!), separating out one "strand" of privilege/oppression is both impossible and ridiculous. It is only when one has most of the cards stacked in one's favor that one has the privilege of pretending that that one axis of oppression can stand alone, be examined alone and dismantled alone.

We have to think about those who are not like us, yes, but we also must remember that those who may belong to a group we do not might also belong to ours. To say "feminists think this and blacks think that" is to ignore Black feminists. To say "well we invited them, why don't they join us?" is to exclude them (to Other "them"), and to render invisible those who are both "us" and
"them
".

Intersectionalism is vital -- necessary to life! -- because the world is not made up of white people and black people and feminists and trans people. Rather, the world is made up of persons, who might be any combination of white and black and trans and feminist and disabled and fat and neurotypical and and and and...

It is fine and well to have a focus, a specialty (or two or three or however many). It is natural and understandable to have more expertise in the areas where one personally and intimately experiences oppression. But we cannot, we must not, allow that focus to blind us. We must not use our expertise in one area to exculpate our ignorance in another. Intersectionality doesn't mean we are required to study all areas of oppression equally; it calls us rather to open our eyes, to look to our own privilege when telling of our oppression, and it demands that we rid ourselves of the fallacy of "us" and "them".

Selfishly, I need for intersectionality to succeed, for examples of those who work to end one type of oppression interlinking with others to abound, for the skill of looking beyond oneself to find the "us" in "them" to flourish; I need it to succeed, for it is my only hope of teaching my presumably-straight white middle class son how to look at all areas of his privilege, to work against all the ways those-like-and-not-like-him are oppressed, to recognize the existence of kyriarchy and oppose it always. Those of us with even one area of oppression have an opening, as we learn of privilege, to learn intersectionality; those of us with many are forced to adopt it or self-destruct. My child has nearly every privilege in the world heaped on him, in a society that teaches the ugly art of Othering from birth: I fully admit to maternal selfishness when I say I need intersectionality to succeed so I do not lose him to the kyriarchy, which would have him Other everyone I love -- including me -- out of importance in his life.

So, that's not much of a reason for anyone else to adopt intersectionality (I fully recognize that an argument that sounds rather like "think of the white males!" is hardly much of a draw), but it's one reason, among many, I will defend and promote it as much as I can. I have an obligation to others to avoid oppressing and Othering and rendering them invisible, as I myself have been, as I myself am demanding not to be. And also, yes, I have an urgent desire to demonstrate that skill to a child unlikely to ever have call to learn the hard way why it is so very vital.

Intersectionality: the art of opposing the kyriarchy, one word at a time and all ways at once.

Monday, March 30, 2009

On intersectionality

Four months ago, when I was starting this blog, I had never even heard of the word "intersectionality" (wikipedia article, blog post [amazing pictures, but probably NSFW], another blog post, link post). I was aware, in a general way, of race issues, certainly of queer issues, to a lesser extent of trans issues, among others, and I was aware of the language of privilege, of the many ways in which I live with privilege (and the many ways I do not). But "intersectionality" was not a word on my radar, and I didn't really "get" it when I started looking it up -- the arguments "watered down!" "loss of focus!" "not in this movement!" floated through my thinking, though each was, in turn, shot down.

And yet, I think I understood it even then, before I heard it, intuitively; as I named and taglined my blog, while it was primarily about the experience of being a feminist raising a boy, I was clear that he was not just any male, but a white male, a probably-straight male, an American middle class probably-straight white able-bodied male: very nearly the tippy top of the hierarchy, by way of the intersection (!) of all these different aspects of privilege.

The more I've thought about it, and especially after coming upon the word/concept "kyriarchy", the more intersectionality makes sense (kyriarchy is what I was talking about here, though I didn't realize it at the time -- and I was also, unrealizingly, arguing against something of a straw feminism there). Feminism is in opposition to patriarchy, and this is good, but it takes only a moment of thought to realize that this does not and cannot (even at its most inclusive) cover all the ways in which some people are artificially privileged over others. Ultimately, I think it is the very concept of placing persons in a hierarchy (which is to say, it is kyriarchy) which needs to be done away with; and ultimately, it is intersectionalism alone which stands in opposition not just to one strand but, by definition, to all strands of oppression. It is only by working to recognize all forms of oppression/privilege in our work can we oppose all aspects of the kyriarchy; anything less is merely scrabbling for position on that fucked up ladder.

Which is not to say we need to get everything perfectly right all the time; we are human, and therefore both limited and flawed. Furthermore, we are humans raised under kyriarchy, and not one person reading this post can be without at least some privilege (since you've all managed to access the internet in some way or another); we are not going to be able to avoid all slip ups, all language of privilege, all incidents of accidental or oblivious oppression. But we can, and we must, try. Any step is worthy; any mistake is an opportunity to learn; any privilege recognized is a privilege weakened.

This ain't an easy path to walk, and there is no end to it. It would be all too easy to turn aside, to close my eyes, to rest easy on the privilege I do have while screaming for justice for the privilege I don't; but that way lies pain, if not for myself then for others, and if for others, then for all. Intersectionalism isn't diluting our purpose; it isn't putting others ahead of ourselves; it isn't "PC metastized". It is nothing less nor more than refusing to oppress others as we seek to end our own oppression. It is nothing less nor more than basic human compassion. It is nothing less than necessary, and nothing more than possible.