Monday, August 10, 2009
The misogyny of denying milk-making moms mental-health medication
Update your feeds and bookmarks! New site at www.RaisingMyBoychick.com!
Really, it's way better.
In honor of World Breastfeeding Week (even if it is almost over), I offer a post about breastfeeding, blame-the-kyriarchy style.
Perhaps you've been lucky enough to have missed this scenario, but I, at the intersection of those with lactating breasts and those with mental illness, have seen it far too often: a woman goes to her psychiatrist, generalist, family doctor, nurse practitioner, or psych nurse, for help with, oh, depression (postpartum or otherwise), or anxiety, or mood disorder, or sleep problem. Being a careful parent and a conscientious patient, she discloses that she is breastfeeding her child, so that she and her health care practitioner can find the healthiest, most appropriate medications for her (should they mutually decide medications are necessary).
This is when, in a sane society, her physician or nurse would nod, draw on hir vast knowledge of and experience with medications appropriate for breastfeeding, and say "No problem, that only rules out a very few classes of drugs, there are lots of things we can try still." Or, barring that, would reach for the copy of Hale's zie keeps handy in hir office, or would call one of the many breastfeeding-knowledgeable pharmacists zie keeps on file as references. The woman and the health care provider she employs would then work together to pick a medication most appropriate for her particular situation.
That is not what usually happens. Too often (ever would be too often), the physician, upon hearing said disclosure, automatically replies "I don't want to give you anything until you wean/terminate breastfeeding/stop doing that."
There is so much wrong with this situation, I hardly know where to start.
Do I start with the ignorance? How so very rarely is weaning actually necessary, in any situation, and even less often to treat most mental health issues? How the ignorance of a basic facet of women's health is inherently misogynistic: how women are not a "special group", lactation is not a "special case", and we shouldn't have to go to "specialists" to find a physician knowledgeable of the basics of care when we are engaged in a normal human biological function? To be ignorant of these things is inexcusable, and reflective of both systemic and individual misogyny, whether recognized or not.
Or do I start with the authoritarianism? With the assumption that the physician knows better -- knows what they're talking about for that matter! --, that what they "want" matters one whit in the face of a client coming to them for treatment of a specific issue, that they have the right to place ultimatums on the conditions under which their clients receive treatment? Paternalistic authoritarianism, whether coming from a man or a woman, dictating or denying the course of a woman's treatment and what she can/'t do with her body, is always misogynistic.
Or do I simply rail against how *&^%ed up, how immoral and wrong-headed it is? How in fact damaging to a woman's mental well-being it is to be denied her normal biological entwinement with her young, to be told she must chose between her own health and the health of her child? Do I describe the panic that ensues, the flight-or-fight reaction as her body is flooded with adrenaline, as she realizes the person across from her is not her ally but her enemy, her judge, the antagonistic gatekeeper blocking her from that which might make her well? Do I justifiably liken it to throwing gasoline on an already smoldering -- or raging -- firestorm of imbalanced brain chemicals?
I do think that we ought be cautious in what we expose our young to, especially when it has the potential to affect brain development, and I am the first in line to question the pervasive use of psychotropics, the first to encourage that other avenues of health and stability and sanity be pursued first, or at least simultaneously. I am the first in line to criticize the culture of "problem? pop a pill!", the first to point out the downsides of many mental health medications -- my own experiences with mood stabilizers and anti-depressants are far from flawless, and what finally made me sane was not the prescription I was handed first.
And I am jumping the line to be the first and loudest to proclaim how so many postpartum and parental mental health problems are the kyriarchy's damn fault in the first place: how the isolation, the lack of tangible support, the dearth of family-friendly work options, the pitiful state of parental leave (in the USA at least), the antagonism toward breastfeeding in public, the burden of parenting placed solely on the "nuclear family" -- and too often primarily if not exclusively on the woman within that unnatural unit --, all combine to create situations in which NOT experiencing postpartum mental health problems is more surprising than having them.
But this? This "I don't want to give you anything until you wean"? That's not a careful critique of the pharmacological industry, that's not an intersectionalist examination of the role kyriarchy plays in the creation of women's mental health issues, and it's not a sober weighing of the balance of "greatest goods" when faced with exposing a child to an ill mother or minute quantities of probably-safe substances. No, that's nothing more than an ignorant, authoritarian, fucked up, misogynistic ultimatum.
Breastfeeding is a feminist issue. This post isn't about telling women what they should/n't do, it isn't about being a "breastfeeding zealot", and it isn't even a defense of medication during lactation (there are benefits and risks, and each woman -- in consultation with knowledgeable health care providers -- must weigh them for herself). It's about saying that the way we talk about breastfeeding, drugs, and mental health needs to change. It's about saying that this kind of comment is downright dangerous, because it discourages women from breastfeeding, it discourages women from getting help for their illnesses, and it supports the kyriarchy through misogyny -- and thus damages all women, lactating or not.
I am lucky that I haven't needed to go on medication during pregnancy, or while the Boychick is nursing. I have done many things, worked very hard, to achieve this, but I also know that I am, at the end, simply lucky. Maybe you were too. Or maybe you were another kind of lucky, and got a health care worker who helped you rather than hindered you. But too many women are slapped with this, too many women are lied too, too many women don't have the knowledge or the spoons to counter this misogyny. And as long as any woman encounters this attitude, we all have a need -- and a duty -- to counter it.
Friday, July 17, 2009
Have I ever thought of a book?
Have I ever thought about writing a book? Being bipolar means I have to expend a significant amount of mental energy on not thinking about writing a book, not thinking about a book deal that will make me rich, not thinking about getting published and getting famous, not thinking about my appearance on The Daily Show (the quips we'd trade, the bloggers with less privilege I'd promote, the laughs I'd get, the thoughts I'd provoke, the flats I'd wear to not loom too tall over him), not thinking about getting invited to the White House to discuss the immensely important issues my book would address with depth and nuance (Josh Lyman would be there, of course), not thinking about the revolution that will finally overthrow the kyriarchy for good sparked in no small part by said immensely important and deeply nuanced book. Because if I think of doing a book, I cannot help but thinking of all those things in turn: there are no half measures in this mentally ill mind o'mine.
Reality of course can never live up to such fantasies, and dreaming them both takes away from time I could, and would rather, spend actually writing, and paralyzes me, because the flip side of such grandiosity -- only ever a hair's breadth away -- is being convinced I am and only ever will be a waste of oxygen, hydrogen, carbon, and space. (A friend asked me the other day why, if I didn't think my writing was any good, were people coming to the site in such numbers. My reply was "To point and laugh?" Yes, I might be a wee bit crazy.)
The only way I've found to avoid this type of thinking (what Anne Lamott cleverly and concisely calls "mind fucking") is to not think. If I allowed myself to think about how big my blog could get, what I'd do if it became really popular, the articles I'd be asked to write for Bitch and Salon and Mothering and The New Yorker... I would never actually be able to blog at all. So I don't. I think about this post, the post I have planned for tomorrow, the way I'll respond to the comments I've actually gotten. Better still, I just write, and don't think about it in a meta way at all.
So have I ever thought about a book? Um, yes. But I try not to.
Thursday, July 2, 2009
Blast from the past: I saw my breasts
I'd do things a bit differently if I were writing this now, hopefully better, and I'd have a lot more to say about the multifunctionality of my breasts, but I still love it for what it is. And while I continued (ok, continue) to work with my body issues, the moment described herein really was pivotal for me: the whole trajectory of my thinking changed course, for the better, and I am still so grateful for that.
November 2000
I Saw My Breasts
I have rarely felt good about my body. The best I have ever had to say about it is that it's "acceptable," at least since I started puberty and grew breasts, and had the rest of my body fleshed out.
To put it bluntly, but truthfully, I am fat. Over-tall, over-wide, and flabby almost everywhere. Being manic-depressive, there are times when I could manage to describe myself as "voluptuous." But the rest of the time, I'm just fat.
My breasts, especially, are a problem for me. In a bra, they are a decent, perhaps impressive, size D, and conform nicely to the shape of the bra. When out of a bra, however, they are triangular shaped, long, and flat. I tend to think of them as shy – when I'm standing up straight, my nipples determinedly stare just a few inches in front of my toes. I have long felt like I have old lady breasts – hanging halfway to my hips – while only a teenager. What's more, never, ever, have I seen breasts like mine on anyone else.
Which, to my depressed and self-loathing mind, made me not just a fat geek, but a fat freak.
Of course, intellectually, I know that humans are unique, and no two are quite the same, and those differences should be valued, cherished, and rejoiced. And I do – in other people. I have enjoyed magazines like Hues and Radiance that embrace the variety of cultures, colors, sizes and shapes that humans come in. But for only short periods of time had I been able to carry that certainty within my heart as well as my head.
It was in one of those magazines, shortly after I started to come to terms with my bipolar disorder, that I saw them. My breasts – my breasts – on another woman.
Radiance, having its annual swimsuit issue, was doing a feature on Aviva Jane Carlin, who had written and was performing in a one woman play, as a nude artist's model.
She looked about 50, and she was no supermodel, although she made a super model. And although not as fat as I, she was definitely not "perfect." But her demeanor and confidence, and lack of self-consciousness, made her beautiful.
And she had my breasts.
I'm not sure which of those two thoughts I had first, but the third was amazement at the previous two – she had my breasts and she was beautiful.
And finally, I knew, I had proof that I wasn't the only one. It shouldn't have mattered, perhaps. But it did.
She wore no clothing. Nothing to hide her wide hips, with all their stretch marks. Nothing to cover her arms, that seemed to yearn for the earth, so much did they hang. Nothing to disguise her thighs, that danced at the least excuse. Her stomach was free, free to fall over her waist, to move when she breathed, to smile when she leaned over. Her hair was loose, wild, a dark springy brown liberally streaked with grey. Even her ankles, wide and solid to support her body's movements and poses, were unfettered and exposed.
But most of all, most important to me, were her breasts. Just like mine, they hung low, and looked like thick Doritos. Her areolas were large and barely distinguishable from the rest of her breasts. And her nipples, cross-eyed like mine as she slouched, stared fixedly down. But looking at her gave me a different perspective on our shared glands cum fat deposits.
On me, those breasts have always seemed shy, or sad – depressed even. Their seeming attitude – of depression and defeat – characterized my attitude about my body and my appearance.
But on her… Her breasts characterized her views as well. They stared lovingly at her stomach, surveyed her hips, caressed her legs with their gaze. They were the caring queens of her body, not rising above their subjects, but joining them, looking not outside their domain with embarrassment, but down at it joyfully.
I had seen my breasts on another woman, and they were queens. They added to her beauty, her dignity, her womanliness.
And they were my breasts.
I am still fat. And my breasts are still overgrown Doritos, hanging halfway to my hips, or at least to my smiling belly button. But my breasts are also queens, and no longer detract from my beauty. I no longer shake my head in bewilderment when my lover comments on their desirability. And I can look at myself in a mirror, and see in it the breasts I share with a proud woman, who is not old before her time, but beautiful because of her years.
Thank you, Ms. Carlin.
Friday, June 12, 2009
100th post, and a call to de-lurk
Plus, we seem to have a virus, possibly of the porcine variety.
So, I say fuck that shit. Perfection is the enemy of good enough, so I'm going to cough and hack and spit in its general direction until it's soaking the sheets in bed, addled by fever enough that it can't block me from just putting up a damn post already, even if said post sort of sucks.
When I started this blog, well, I didn't start it. I had the fabulous idea that Someone Should write a blog about the experience of being a feminist raising a boy child (little knowing that, um, it ain't exactly a new idea), and came up with a catchy title for it, and went and registered it on Blogger. And did nothing.
Did I mention the perfectionism -> paralysis thing?
It wasn't until a kick-ass writer friend of mine started her own fab (if under-updated) blog that I mentioned my idea to her, and she triple-dog-dared (ordered, actually) me to start posting to it, at which time I, snowed in (in Portland!) and with nothing better to do, put up an introductory post that set the bar so damn low that even I, tied up by perfectionism's tendrils of doubt and self-flagellation, could trip over it.
Then I remembered a post I'd written elsewhere and put that up*, because I thought it was worth saving, and then wrote a fair amount of filler crap, and a couple interesting (if somewhat straw-based) posts, and got caught by the bug. I was going to Blog, give it the good college try (is this the right place to mention I've tried college no less than four times and have yet to graduate?), publish posts
And here we are.
I'm still just starting. I still swear I'm going to prune down my label list, make my own Wordpress theme, buy a domain, and move the blog somewhere prettier and more functional. I still know I have so damn much to learn about my own privilege and prejudices, and needless to say I still have at least 90% left to go in this high-intensity-parenting gig.
But 100 posts? A sizable chunk of which are actually worth reading? That's pretty cool.
So come celebrate with me. Leave a present: a comment, saying anything, just letting me know you read here, regularly or occasionally. Let me know what you like about the blog, let me know what you want to see in the future, say congrats or good job or keep trying. I know I'm crap at responding to comments, but I read every one, usually about 20 times. So drop a line. It'll be your good deed for the day.
And now if you'll excuse me, I'm going to go down some C and snuggle in bed with perfectionism. We're both pretty miserable.
*Some of these posts contain language and comparisons I wouldn't use now, like putting "bad mother" on par with "the n word" (both because, dude, so not in the same league, and because competing oppressions against each other is always a no-win enterprise). Entering the blogosphere, both in reading other blogs and writing out my own thoughts, has been educational and a growing experience in ways I had never anticipated, and that's a large part of what has kept me going**.
**The rest, of course, being comments from readers, nudge nudge.
Monday, June 1, 2009
Flash-bulb moment: musings on parking spaces and bipolar disorder
These existing schemes usually have some kind of distance measure, which says something like ‘person’s impairment would be unduly affected by walking 50m/100m.’ When you compare the “harmonisation” proposal with that, something becomes clear: what they’re doing is mandating what kind of impairment you have, rather than assessing the effect of the combination of the impairment and the disabling context of distant or inaccessible parking. We’re moving away from an acknowledgement of the way that parking requirements can be disabling for particular people, whatever their type of impairment, and at reducing that disability by accommodations. We’re moving towards configuring particular people as ‘deserving’ based on an assessment of the type of their impairment or their dependency.
One of the major problems here is that it requires PWD to provide evidence of dependency. You have to prove that if you push yourself too hard, if you work beyond your known limits and ‘act’ like an able-bodied person, not only that you can’t do it but that you will need physical help from another person to walk. It makes dependence, again, the supposed essence of disability, and it attributes this to the individual, rather that seeing it as occurring at the intersection of ‘normal’ parking and impairment.
And my eyes popped wide and my jaw went slack; something clicked for me.
I've long struggled with trying to resolve my identity as a person with mental illness, my current status as basically sane and stable, and the fact that I haven't, don't, won't, and probably just can't hold down a traditional full time office job.
Lots of people with bipolar disorder do manage it, just fine, both with and without medication. My dad's work, the responsibility and need to drag himself out of bed every morning, was at times the only thing that kept him going at all. My brother, with the help of medication, thrives in a high stress, high stakes job in the financial industry. So why can't I? is the refrain the crazy voice uses to castigate me with.
These quotes did two things for me: one, pointed out the fallacy of categorizing people's need for accommodations based on diagnosis, rather than disability. That is, what does it matter that someone else with my diagnosis can work? I can't. Saying "but they do!" isn't going to change my own ability, and it's ridiculous to try to make it.
Two, and the more "aha!" of the points, although you'd think I'd have learned this by now (I know I've brought up the spoon theory here before), is that, just like the person with an invisible physical disability who "could" walk farther, all that trying to pretend that I am "normal", that I am not disabled, does for me is wear me out and make me sick.
Ironic (Alanis Morissettey definition) isn't it, that as long as I acknowledge that I am sick, then I can be well. If I try to pretend I am not, if I park myself too far from my destination, push myself too hard, then I will get sick.
This is something I've known for a while (I don't try to work full time, after all, and the Boychick is only a part of that), but I've never entirely been comfortable with it. Reading about others, who have "real", physical, if too oft-maligned, disabilities, struggle with the same issue, if in a different plane, was eye-opening for me. It is only the crazy voice, which does its best to convince me I'm not "really" sick (does that amuse anyone else? the crazy voice saying I'm not crazy?), that would have me disassociate from others with disabilities; but if I acknowledge and accept my shared commonalities with people with physical disabilities, suddenly I feel, and act, much saner.
I don't know the course of my disease, much less my life: I may yet wind up over the edge, hospitalized and incapacitated; I may yet wind up thriving in an office 40 hours a week. But one thing I am certain of: the more I push myself toward the latter, denying myself the accommodations I need and deserve, the more likely I'll find myself in the former.
Further, and worse, as the HAT article points out is happening with physical disabilities in Australia, I am not offered accommodations by the state (or society at large), because as long as I don't try to act sane, I remain sane. I do not meet, as WildlyParenthetical says, the medical/dependency model of "disabled": as long as I do not seek to work in a traditional job, I am able to dress myself, get out of the house, make required phone calls, pay my bills (with money my partner earns for us), and do all those things that the state uses as markers for sanity/ability. I can even manage to do those things when I am unstable from working: I am "unduly affected", and have panic attacks before every call and during every trip to the store, but I still technically could, and thus fail to meet the medical model of disability, so I am denied any work compensation or disability acknowledgments.
And I manage despite this only because I exist with so much privilege: my race, my class, my partnership with a man, my (for now) lack of any other cognitive or physical disabilities. Because of all that, I don't really need the disability benefits I am denied: I have income and health insurance from other sources, access to health care providers, resources to purchase the substances that help keep me sane. Many others like me do not exist with such an abundance of privilege, and are, literally, driven crazy, and only then (and only if they are still lucky and probably privileged) are they "gifted" with acknowledgment of their disability and assistance from society.
I trust I do not need to explain just how horrifying this is, how wrong, and how no (hah!) sane society would allow this state of affairs to continue.
So I'll take that parking spot, thank you, and I'll fight anyone who tries to take away from me or any of my people. Will you join us?
ETA Those of you in Australia can act directly on this particular parking space issue with a letter to government or an open letter to organizations. Thank you!
Wednesday, May 20, 2009
Sanity is situational
I am at the park with my child, having vacated the house so The Man could make phone calls and receive a scheduled phone interview, and the tower I am perched on and the fear of falling are quite physically literal; the Boychick, while perfectly content to make the play structure circuit himself (stairs, tunnel, bridge, ladder, slide, repeat), wants me here, at the pinnacle of the playground, whether for company or assistance I cannot tell and he's not telling.
But here I am, I am here, afraid I will watch him fall, afraid I will fall, afraid I am falling metaphorically, actually, emotionally, and no one will be able to catch me. The Man will never be employed again, we'll not be able to pay rent, not buy food, not pay debt, not pay for meds and blood tests, not keep our pets, not keep my sanity, not keep my life. Am I falling, falling into hell, back into a dark pit I can never forget, have never stopped running away from? I fear I am, and fear the fear is the start of the fall.
Or am I flying? Flying, soaring, so certain that this will be better, amazing, that we've written such a kick-ass resume that he'll get a better job, more pay, less stress, better benefits, less commute, and we'll pay off all debt, and buy a house, and have wealth to share, and I'll be better than sane, and everything will be brilliant. I am flying, flying, and nothing can stop me, so what is this pounding in my heart, and why can't I catch my breath? Why isn't this fun?
Because I know falling and flying are a hair's breadth apart, and I flit between the two, not with reckless abandon, but abandoned by my anchors, a wreck waiting to happen.
Or so I fear; and is the cold, hot, heart-wrenching fear of going crazy a sign of already having gone? Is this mental illness, or all in my mind? Is it a good thing I can still laugh at the absurdity of that question?
All will be well, one way or another. I cling to this as a life preserver (a life preserver for falling/flying; full of hot air?), try to draw a breath, try to just breathe, try to just be. All will be well, and I will be well, and all manner of things will be well.
So mote it be.
Friday, May 1, 2009
Blogging Against Disablism Day, 2009

I've struggled with what to write for this post.
I've thought about writing about the shared identity I have as the daughter of a woman with a physical disability: how I learned growing up first to look for seats and benches everywhere, before she got her chair, then later to scan ahead for ramps and wide enough doors and spaces to maneuver; how I felt when I overheard adults who should have known better say she wasn't disabled, she was just fat and lazy; how the Boychick has learned to love electric carts and thinks everyone in one is a grandparent just waiting to take him on a ride.
I've thought about writing more about my struggles with bipolar disorder, maybe finish up part three of the mental health series I've been promising for a while: maybe tell the story of ruining Christmas three years running, anxiety attacks coming out in force with the rising chorus of Christmas carols; maybe the one where I was overwhelmed by the crush of crowds, and had to be lead through IKEA like a woman without sight, because I could see too much, and ended up hiding in an empty slot in the warehouse, exactly like a scared animal because that's all I was, until the crowds and the panic thinned and I could escape; or perhaps tell you about the probably-concussion I suffered when the self-soothing head-on-wall went a little too far, undiagnosed because it was beyond me even to contemplate an explanation when merely existing in my skin was too hard already.
I've thought about getting on my high horse, pulling out my pompous thesaurus, hiding behind a wall of intellectualism, and lecturing about the Evils of Disablism and the Privilege of the Abled -- with just enough self-disclosure and self-flagellation to not lose all your interest, I'd hope.
And I've thought again and again about abandoning the idea of writing about it at all, because it feels like so much hubris, because I'm not ill enough not disabled enough not crazy enough to be worthy of writing about disablism -- and you likely have to be at least as crazy as I am, or love someone who is, to recognize the insanity in that declaration of being too-sane.
That last one is true, in a way; my illness is invisible: my body is not twisted as my mind is, my crutches are hidden as behavioral quirks, not strapped to my arms, and though I walk through life with a devil riding me, my body's back is unbowed. More, too, for I am -- and this is I will admit a relative comparison -- basically sane at the moment, mostly functional in my daily life, able to do normal(ish) things in a normal(ish) way.
Which is all to say, I do not suffer daily disablism the way so many do: insults do not get hurled at me regularly; my basic worth and competence and humanity are not questioned or outright dismissed by those around me. I pass, for sane, for able, for "normal".
But I'm not. I infiltrate. I am quiet, unseen. And so I hear what is said.
I hear bipolar/postpartum depression/post traumatic stress disorder/social anxiety dismissed as a quack diagnosis. I hear fibromyalgia/chronic fatigue syndrome belittled as so much whinging. I hear the jokes about chill pills and happy pills and pill-popping, always implying the joke's subject takes too many or doesn't take enough. I hear the tuts of tongues saying well she's too ill to deserve children, they should take them away and tie her tubes. I hear the perky voices proclaiming it could all be better with positive thinking. I hear the declarations of her as incurable, him soulless. I hear the never-ending refrains of it's not that bad, just stay home, just go out, just be normal, just don't be like that, just don't be you.
I hear it all, and it hurts me all. Sometimes I speak up, and sometimes I don't; sometimes I let the pain show, and sometimes I don't; sometimes I out myself and sometimes I don't. Sometimes I have the strength, the energy, the reserves, the coping ability, the buffer. Sometimes I don't.
I've been called names, dismissed to my face, asked to do too much, told I'm not doing enough. But it is in my invisibility, my passing, that I am most affected by (dis)ablism; it is the side comments, the snide comments, the jokes and the jabs about "them" that are really about me and mine, that I suffer from most frequently.
You may not see me when we are out in the world together, may not see my diagnosis, see my illness, see my allegiance to the tribe of the disabled -- but I see you. And I hear you. And I remember.
Thursday, April 23, 2009
Blogging Against Disablism Day, May 1st 2009

I'm planning on participating in BADD on May 1st, 2009. Will you join me?
Write a post on the subject of disability discrimination, disablism or ableism and publish it on May 1st - or as close as you are able. Podcasts, videocasts and on-line art are also welcome. You can cover any subject, specific or general, personal, social or political. In the previous three BADD, folks have written about all manner of subjects, from discrimination in education and employment, through health care, parenting, family life and relationships, as well as the interaction of disablism with racism and sexism. Every year I have been asked, so it's worth saying; the discrimination experienced by people with mental ill health is disablism, so naturally such posts are welcome too.
Saturday, March 7, 2009
What price mental health? part II
The things it took to bring me from hell to now (not heaven, but the glorious mundanity of earth) were: talk therapy; psychotropic medications; massage therapy; acupuncture; lots and lots of fish oil; and lifestyle and thought pattern and dietary changes too numerous and subtle to list here (arguably the biggest and most important of those: regular and regulated sleep, which is one of the many reasons new parents whether biological or not are at risk for PPD and other postpartum disorders). It took several years, and a hell of a lot of work, and ultimately required moving across the country out of a psychic-black-hole cesspool of a house and to a city where my heart sang "Home!" to get to a real, lasting, joyful stability.
And it cost a lot of money.
How much money exactly? First, I should point out that because of where we were and how I was doing, my parents financed all of this. There is simply no way I could have done any of this without them; I could probably not afford to do it all even now. The privilege in having parents who were able and willing to do this for me is breathtaking and humbling. I was blessed to be the late-born daughter of doctorate-holding, career-stable, mortgage-paying, middle-class, married white American parents who are mental-health knowledgeable and alternative-therapy-tolerant. If not for them and for their multiple states of privilege, I simply would not have been able to spend those years pursuing health and stability in the way I did, and would likely not be sane today. It is privilege, pure and simple, that allowed me to, via my parents, afford these things. It is criminal that so many do not have the financial or social access to resources that my privilege granted me. I take none of this for granted. (Conversely, at least a significant portion of these costs could have been avoided with even a rudimentary Universal Health Care system in place. If that be socialism, than socialist I be.)
And now, in the honor of American tax time, an itemized list, primarily covering the years 2002-2005 (unlike the IRS, I do not expect an audit; numbers are rounded and approximated for ease of calculation):
First, there was the health insurance, which you will see did not do much to pay for the things that got me to wellness, but was viewed as necessary by those around me; to be sure, we would all have been grateful for it should a hospitalization ever have proven necessary. The first year or so I was still, barely, able to be on my parents' employer subsidized insurance, at probably $75/month (did I mention they had good jobs?). The next two years they paid for COBRA coverage for me, at approximately $400/month, after which I had no insurance. Total cost: $10,500
There was the psychotropic medication, a "premium" formulation new enough it was not on my insurance's preferred formulary, but considered worth it because I only had to take it once a day, and had more flexibility in timing its ingestion without incurring negative effects. I was on it for approximately the same three years I had health insurance, at $80 every three months. Sub total: $640. There were also numerous blood draws and psychiatric visits for medication management, not all of which were covered for one reason or another (my medication cessation management was overseen by a DO, after I lost insurance, with whom each visit was over $100), and a brief (comparatively) stint on an additional antidepressant medication and the attendant psych visits. So, let's call the total an even $1000.
When medication alone proved not to be sufficient, I was recommended by a college adviser to see a psychologist known for his quirky humor and Buddhist-influenced woo-ish talk therapy, with particular experience with bipolar spectrum disorders. We were, indeed, a good fit, and I saw him nearly every week for those four years; the attempt to switch to every two weeks proved problematical, as did the attempt to switch therapists. He charged $100 per 50 minute session (he actually raised it $5 every calendar year I saw him, and was due to hit $115 when we moved back across the continent; conveniently averaging $100 for the four years I saw him). And my insurance did cover him, with only a $15 copay... for the first 22 visits a year. Copay subtotal: $1000. Out of pocket total: $14,400.
Counterpoint to talk therapy was massage therapy; massage grounded me, tethered me to reality and the body and the now at times when I felt like flying right out of my skin. It also helped me learn to accept and love my body again, after side effects of the medication made me feel it had betrayed me. I was blessed to have first one and then another excellent massage therapist, each of whom was willing to offer me amazing deals that amounted to $100/month for biweekly or semimonthly massage. Times three years (2003-2005), that totals: $3600
Acupuncture I started a year after massage therapy, on alternate biweeks from the massage; with offering me a student discount, even though I was primarily studying myself at that point in my life, sessions were $40 each, a bargain when his sessions were 1.5-2 hours, and we have yet to find another acupuncturist who holds a candle to how caring, involved, respectful, informative, and effective he was. Total cost: $1900
What finally clicked for me (although it could not have worked without all the rest of it) was high omega 3 (specifically EPA 50% by weight) fish oil. I had heard bits about it in terms of mental health before, but was convinced to start trying it based on a metastudy published in a peer-reviewed psychiatric journal that showed high EPA was as or more effective than standard psychiatric medications for mild to moderate cases of bipolar disorder, depression, bipolar depression, and even schitzophrenia. I started taking it a year or so before getting off the psychotropic mood stabilizer, and finally felt what I imagine the prescription was supposed to feel like: real mood stability and uplift. This is hardest to calculate, because my dose has fluctuated so much over the years, from as little as 2 caps to as many as 8 a day. My most common dose, though, was 2g twice a day; thus, at $15 for a 90-capsule bottle (purchased online at 50% discount off the $30 retail price), over two years, totals $500.
There were many other pieces to bridge to sanity I built, but though not without cost, they are harder to put a price tag on: getting regular and regulated sleep (8-10 hours, every night, no exceptions, which at times meant turning down concerts with friends, trips to big cities, and all of my night-writing, which is previously when I'd gotten the bulk of my inspirations); learning to listen to and trust my body, and eating foods that truly nourished me; avoiding anything that encouraged the mind-fuck mentality, which is pretty much all American media (and most Americans); avoiding artificial additives as much as possible; and avoiding subjecting myself to unnecessary stressors in all forms, from full time regular employment to countless well-practiced thought patterns. Did I mention it took a lot of work? But that was largely of the emotion-work category, which we are oh so good at avoiding in our calculations of Gross Domestic Product, so we'll leave those out of these numbers (how does one count the cost of taking an hour to go outside and connect with the dirt for a while? it was on a doctor's orders, but somehow I don't think I could bill my insurance for it).
Grand total of the pieces easy to quantify: $31,900.
$31,900
For my international readers, that's 25213 Euro, 22569 GBP, 41080 CAD, or 49754 AUD, in today's currency at least (converter found here). That's more than The Man's mother grossed in an entire year, even right before retirement, after 20 years at the same job as a nurse's aide. Then again, it's only one base-price luxury compact SUV. It's half of what the mortgage on the hell-hole house was, two-thirds of what we sold it for.
It's a lot of money.
Some of these numbers have been very hard for me to type. $14,400 to sit in a room and talk to a guy for an hour once a week (total talk time: 200 hours)? Seriously? And yet, it was invaluable in terms of my mental health. Many weeks I walked out wondering what the point of it was; but each week, little by little, with leaps forward and setbacks suffered, life got better. Weeks I decided I didn't need it, it wasn't "doing anything", and didn't go in, were the hardest weeks to get through.
Maybe I could have, should have, gotten that therapy free from a 12 step program (which one, though? I had avoided most of the addictions commonly used to self-treat bipolar disorder, such as alcohol, drugs, sex, and shopping. where in that small town was the 12 step program for the woman who had everything and could do nothing? for moody artistic introspective types who didn't plan or attempt suicide, nor cut open her flesh, but found getting a nice rhythm going with her head on the wall quite soothing? there may be a hundred AA-inspired groups out there, but some niches are yet to be covered), but this was what was available, this was what worked for me.
To own those numbers without hesitation or reservation, I have to be able to say, at some level, I am worth it. And I am. But even 200 hours of therapy hasn't made that easy for me to proclaim, when everything in my culture tells me different.
How hard is it to admit to this much privilege? Very. (About $31,900 hard?) I could not have afforded this on my own. The Man's mother, even if she were alive and still working at that time, couldn't have afforded it. My own parents, after a long illness and a stock market crash, couldn't afford it now. The privilege of being supported, not having to work for my food or shelter, taking four years to work exclusively on my self and my health... it is profound.
Will we be able to afford this for the Boychick? Will he need it? I pray he won't, and we will even so, but the thought terrifies me.
Scarier thought still: will I need it again? Will he be raised by a mother, not blessed with sanity paid for with privilege, but wracked with instability and unable to sufficiently treat it?
cont. in part III
Friday, February 27, 2009
What price mental health? part I
As previously mentioned, I have a diagnosis of Bipolar Disorder Type II, Rapid Cycling, with Mixed States. There are lots of other places that talk about mental health and emotional disorders and bipolar disease, although if you hang around here long enough you'll doubtless get a good picture of what it's been like for me (since it's a different experience for everyone; just in my immediate family, there are three of us with more or less the "same" disease, and three vastly different experiences). But what you really need to know to understand my story is:
- Psychotropic medicines suck. They are a kind of bandage: sometimes they are a well-placed Ace bandage over a sprained ankle, which is great and effective; sometimes they're a dirty wad of guaze over an arterial hemorrhage, which is not not so great but might be better than nothing; and sometimes they're the Disney (R) Princess (TM) Bandaid (TM) that gets lodged in your throat and on which you choke to death, which is, y'know, bad. For me they were probably dirty guaze: they kept me, barely, from bleeding to death, but gave me a raging infection to struggle with as well (if you will excuse the overextended metaphor).
- Bipolar disorder sucks worse. Mixed state, which I basically lived in for several years, especially sucks horrifically gawdawfully bad; think of it as high energy self-hatred. You know, the self-loathing of depression but with the energy to actually do something about it. This aspect of this disease is not only not enjoyable, it is highly lethal, with suicide attempts (already ridiculously high in the bipolar population) being even more likely in those with mixed states, and possibly more "successful".
- Bipolar disorder is a highly complicated disease, with biological and psychological and environmental components (as though the three can ever be separated); it is, however, fundamentally a disease, like diabetes, or fibromyalgia, and deserves no more or less infamy or stigma or survivor-blame than any other disease, which is to say none at all. I think we'd all appreciate it if you understood The Spoon Theory, but we are, basically, just plain persons, just like you. It is not catching; you do not need to avoid us like the plague, or as though we were beset by demons.
- And yet, I get why people with mental illness used to be (and in some areas still are) considered possessed. I do feel at times like the disease is an It, a thing with a life and a mind of its own, and what it wants more than anything else in the world is for me to be sick, so it can be strong. Feeling inhabited by a dark, inimical Other that would, if its will be done, bring about your destruction is a curse I would not wish on anyone.
- At the same time, bipolar is part of my identity. It is a part of the indefinable me. I would not choose to not be born, or to be born without it. (I would not be me if I had been born without it.) I obviously did not choose to avoid having children to avoid passing it on, as some psychiatrists have infamously advocated, and the thought of a genetic test with its resultant "therapeutic" abortion for fetuses carrying the genes horrifies me. I don't romanticize the disorder, but nor would I rid humanity of it even if I could; if the problem is in part that we are at risk for premature death, then it is the world that must change so that we can survive, not we who must be made not to exist in the first place.
- Being a rapid cycler with mixed states, I don't think (much) in terms of "up" or "down", I think in terms of being stable or not. I never knew stability in my adult life; I went straight from childhood to adolescence and instability, with the instability growing ever stronger even as the wild hormonal ride of adolescence receded. Truly it could be said that I did not know who "I" was. Struggling toward sanity was searching by feel in the darkness for something I had never known and had only the vaguest descriptions of from others. When one has never known normalcy, how does one know whether one has it? When every mood swing has been a potential disaster, a symptom of illness, how does one know what a "normal" or "healthy" range of mood feels like? When each change of mood brings anxiety over what it might foreshadow based on what it's brought in the past, how does one settle into the contentedness of now?
The things it took to bring me from hell to now (not heaven, but the glorious mundanity of earth) were: talk therapy; psychotropic medications; massage therapy; acupuncture; lots and lots of fish oil; and lifestyle and thought pattern and dietary changes too numerous and subtle to list here (arguably the biggest and most important of those: regular and regulated sleep, which is one of the many reasons new parents whether biological or not are at risk for PPD and other postpartum disorders). It took several years, and a hell of a lot of work, and ultimately required moving across the country out of a psychic-black-hole cesspool of a house and to a city where my heart sang "Home!" to get to a real, lasting, joyful stability.
And it cost a lot of money.
cont. in part II...
Saturday, February 14, 2009
Doctor Who, TV-free, manic depression, and the dangers and gifts of grandiosity
In fact, our feelings about Doctor Who pretty well exemplify why we are TV-free: I am a TV addict. Watching one episode of a show I like is pretty much like eating the proverbial one potato chip; it's just not something I can do. I must have more, and more, and more, and then my child is watching lots of things blowing up and the planet being towed by a little blue box and clapping and exclaiming "ball! big ball!" and it occurs to me that perhaps this might not be that wise a decision. If we were not TV free, the TV would be on nearly his (and my) every waking moment -- I know, because I've done it before, years before, lasting for years, losing years. And we're so not doing that with him.
Doctor Who, now... well, there must be exceptions. Doctor Who is one of ours -- probably the greatest, in the large sense of the word. Both The Man and I have been speculative fiction fans for most of our lives; he more the fantasy, I more the scifi. I do not pretend it's a good genre; I could easily do a feminist analysis of the Doctor Who universe, and the outcome would not be favorable (old white man has all the power and a series of usually attractive usually female "companions", running around in his powerful phallic technology, beating the monsters and saving the world? yea, that'd be a big fat feminist fail right there). And, let's face it, it is so pure cheese. Tasty, yes, but in the man-made (hah!), full of words no normal mortal can pronounce, you know it's bad for you, cheese from a can (blue, of course) kind of way.
And I love it. Really, truly love it. I loved Star Trek (TNG, DS9, the movies), and Buffy: The Vampire Slayer, and Battlestar Gallactica (no spoilers, we've only gotten through the first two seasons so far), and honestly can say that Firefly was the best thing ever on TV (although before anyone forwards me a "Help Serenity Fly Again!" petition: it's dead, Jim. let her go. it's over). Cheesy bad speculative fiction with a giant glop of interpersonal drama is right up my alley. I can see how bad it is, and I totally and completely fall for it anyway. Hard. Especially the Doctor.
I was the other day trying to explain why that is to a friend, who doesn't get speculative fiction at all, much less the aliens-and-technology kind of the TARDIS's universe, and I think I stumbled on something:
I am bipolar. Bipolar Type II with Rapid Cycling and Mixed States, specifically. Most of my paternal family falls somewhere on the bipolar spectrum, and my maternal family were mostly alcoholic, which often masks some underlying mental or mood issue. My love of speculative fiction also runs in the family -- as I revealed on Ruth's blog, my whole natal family would play D&D together, and our family bedtime books were along the lines of The Lord of the Rings (and yes, my name is really Arwyn, and yes, I'm named after Aragorn's elvin lover). My father, and this is not an exaggeration, owns every Analog magazine from 1950something onward, and, this might be a tiny exaggeration although if you could see his house you'd know how little, just about every SciFi book ever published. So I come by it honestly.
Back to the point: one of the key features of bipolar disorder is grandiosity; in the "up" part of the experience, this manifests as a feeling of I Can Do Anything, or I Am The Greatest. If I write an essay when I am manic, it is the best essay ever, and will earn me publishing and critical acclaim and fame and wealth. If I so much as pick up a craft, like knitting, my thoughts are filled with invitations to The Daily Show and the Whitehouse, where Very Important People will fawn over my every word on the topic. (This happens in the down part of the cycle, too, where not only am I horrible, but I taint everyone around me, and might very well be the downfall of civilization. This is no more or less crazy, but feels rather worse.)
Which brings us back to Doctor Who. The Doctor and his companions are special -- not in the Stuart Smalley "I'm good enough, I'm smart enough, and gosh darn it people like me!" kind of way, but in the "You are the most important woman in all of creation!!!1!" way. The grandiose way, the way those of us with this mood disorder (and probably the rest of y'all too, although if so you're better at hiding it) secretly believe we are, in a teeny tiny corner of our souls, all evidence to the contrary. It is escapism, to be sure, and fun and enjoyable, yes, but I think these types of shows, where "the fate of the world, nay, the universe, nay, all the universes! is in your hands!!" (and therefore in the hands and minds of those of us pulled in to that cosmos), have a special attraction for those of us prone to this way of thinking to begin with.
Healthy? Oh, likely not, and surely not at its extremes. I've watched my father read his life away: he worked, he ate, he slept, he had a family, but mostly, he read. He read scifi, and fantasy, and anything with magic or near-magical technology or psychic pseudocats; anything to escape to a world bigger and better, or bigger and worse, or just somehow bigger -- more grandiose -- than the admittedly mundane one he lived in. His hobbies were D&D and the SCA -- a magic-wielding role playing game (where he was usually
And I've come close to that myself. Hell, I've been there, myself, where Q was more real to me than God, where life was just what I had to do to have more time, in my imagination, as a dragonrider (although not just a dragonrider, of course; no, that wouldn't be grandiose enough, so something always makes me even more special in even the specialest of universes). It's as attractive a prospect to a part of me as it is horrifying to the rest of me.
So why watch at all, then? Why not just shut it out altogether? Because I think I lose something when I starve the part of myself entirely. It can be overdone, to be sure, and I'm glad the Doctor doesn't have new episodes daily or I really would be in trouble, but I think that by feeding that part of myself a little, I keep alive something worthwhile. Some ability to think big, dream big; to play; to immerse myself in an imaginary universe; to be downright daft and silly in public, the mundanes be damned. It serves me well when the Boychick wants to dance in public, wants me to drink tea made of wooden food toys and jingle bells, and will even more, I believe, when he wants me to build forts, slay his monsters, and tell him he can do anything he sets his mind to.
I want him to have that expanse of the imagination. I want him to lead a play-full life. I don't want to lose him to those other worlds, or have this one drained of color for him in comparison, as I've seen happen in my father, and I've seen happen at times in myself; I want him to see the fantasy for what it is, to see the cheese and the sexism and the racism and the cliched writing and the overwrought acting, but oh, let him love it anyway. Let him never lose the ability to dream, and to join in another's dream, to have flights of fant'sy -- just let him land softly, and enjoy the plain world, the simple, complex world in all its mundane glory, as well.
And so we are TV-free, and watch Doctor Who 12 hours a year, and eventually, the Boychick will likely join us for more than just the last 20 minutes we couldn't put off. And that's OK. Let him know the joy of the now, and the joy of the imagination. Let him be sane and stable, and let him be just a teeny bit crazy too. Let there be both in his life, in about those proportions.
*23 months old?? AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!!!!!! *fingers in ears* Lalalallaalala I can't heeeeeeeeeeeeaaaaaaaaar yoooooooooooooouuuuuuuuuu!