I first wrote this four months ago; I'm not really sure why I didn't publish it then. I looked at it again recently, thinking it was much more draft-y and much less coherent than it turned out to be, discovered it wasn't that bad, dusted it off, and here it is.
First, let me say that I've been praying that I can write out these thoughts in a coherent way without tripping up on my privilege and unrecognized prejudices too damned bad. Second, let me say that I know I'm just not gonna get it all right, and I apologize in advance, and request gentle corrections so that I can learn and do better next time.
After my post about why I call the Boychick "presumably-straight", I started thinking, again, about why it is we have transgender and transsexual persons, but not transracial (the questionable case of Michael Jackson, may he finally be at peace, aside). What is it about race and gender that makes being trans one but not trans the other make sense? The most bigoted of "radfems" and the ignorant masses notwithstanding, it is not possible to be rational and be exposed to the stories and lives of trans persons and still claim that they are "really" the gender into which they were assigned at birth. Any rational society would recognize that, would allow for graceful transitions, would legally protect these (and all) persons against discrimination, would provide what medical services they require, would allow appropriate and easy alteration of legal documents, would laugh the "trans-panic defense" out of the court, etc., etc. (And any not-totally-jacked society would get the damn pronouns right!)
And yet, the idea of someone like the Boychick being "transracial", that is, born into one race ("white") and deciding/discovering that he's "really" another race (say, "black") is ridiculous. It's nonsensical. And more than that, it simply doesn't happen. The closest to it is people trying to pass to access the privilege denied to them by racist societies. We are not a rational society when it comes to race, so we cannot claim that it is the fair and equitable way race is dealt with (hah!) that prevents "pressure" from "creating" "transracial" persons; therefore, neither can we say that the real pressures present in a patriarchy are "creating" transgender/transsexual persons -- surely if it were just self-hatred caused by living under a kyriarchy that devalues the body one lives in, we would see far more people of color clamouring for such an identity.
So what makes the difference? Gender is based on sex, which has been a part of our genetics since probably the first multicellular organism. From way, way, way back in our evolutionary history, we instinctively know that there are more or less two types of individuals, and we generally expect to identify as one or the other. Because we are complicated animals, and because of the power of our social memes, gender is an amazingly complex construction, based in genetics and environment and biology and society and psychology and who knows what else -- but there is, inherent in us, some expectation of being gendered, whether that's male or female or something more complex. There is nothing in us that pops us out of the womb wanting pink or blue, nail polish or RC trucks; this is the societal construction of the expression and performance of gender. But if the Boychick lived in a society that gendered yellow teeth female, he might be one of those born with penises who grow up dreaming of dental dye; not because desire for yellow teeth is inborn (which is no more ridiculous an idea than a desire for pink toenails being inborn), but because their internal gender draws them to those things their society genders female, regardless of their external sex.
Race, however, is an entirely social construction, an entirely modern -- in the evolutionary scale -- idea. There is nothing in us that expects to be "race-ed"; genes dictate that the Boychick's skin is less pigmented than others, his eyes have more creases, his nose is more pointed, but there is no gene, or chromosome combination, for defining him as "racially White", or any one else as "Black" or "Asian" or "Aboriginal". What there are, instead, are memes; for this is not to try to argue a colorblind (aka racist, however well intended) ideology: race is entirely real, because we believe it to be so, based only on minute skin tone and facial differences, and we are creatures with amazingly powerful intellects and social memes. (Case in point: there may be no culture that escapes from the ills of racism, but by no means is racial identity universal; what we call "Black" in the US may be "morena or mulata" in Brazil.)
The irony, then, if that is the right word, is that the reason he is only presumably male is because masculinity, male-ness, is something at least partially inborn; the reason he can never be anything but white is because whiteness is entirely socially constructed. The one that is more "real" is the one that an individual may "change"; the one that is more "artificial" is immutable by the individual.
So this is the Boychick I am raising: presumably straight, presumably male, but definitely white.
Showing posts with label cisgender privilege. Show all posts
Showing posts with label cisgender privilege. Show all posts
Monday, July 27, 2009
Friday, April 24, 2009
Andrade is guilty, and so am I
I have been half following the Angie Zapata murder case, reading the posts on TransGriot about it, but not reading the links because I am a conscientious objector to the mainstream media (and have been having enough trouble keeping up with my feed reader as it is). I was, well, not pleased exactly (it's hard to be happy about the pitiful "justice" our punitive system offers) to hear that a fully guilty verdict was rendered, including the hate crime charge; I was overjoyed that for once, a "trans panic" defense had so thoroughly failed.
Then I read about Angie's family's reaction, and was struck dumb by the simultaneous realization and the refutation of my own assumptions.
I had thought, here was this little Latina trans girl, murdered by her maybe-boyfriend. I thought I knew her; she'd be kicked out by her transphobic Hispanic family, trying to make it on her own, possibly turning tricks to survive. Good little White Liberal Ally was I, so cynical about her chances for justice, so certain of her alienation.
But then I read her brother's words:
I was wrong. I was guilty of racism, of the most pervasive sort of cisgenderism: the ignore-ance of a trans person's own existence. I committed a hate crime in the whitewashed confines of my own head.
White privilege doesn't go away. Cisgender privilege doesn't go away. We can't do our course in Racism 101 and Transphobia 101 and then wash our hands of the blood of those whiteness has killed, of those cisgender bias has killed.
This doesn't give me much hope for the Boychick. Bashes the rose-colored glasses right off my "raise a post-racist generation" face, in fact. Which is probably a good thing; helps me see how the world actually is, how hard a journey is ahead. Best hope I have is to ground him in a childhood of racism- and cisgenderism-awareness, and show him that it never stops; privilege never goes away, no matter how much we want it to, so our obligation as possessors of privilege to learn, to listen, to humble ourselves, and to root out the prejudices hidden in the darkest corners of our own heads -- which will always be there, more persistent than cockroaches and uglier still -- never goes away.
I am so sorry for what I did to you, how I erased you in my own mind, Angie. Your memory deserves so much more than that. Angie's family: I can only beg forgiveness. Even if you never learn of my assumptions about you, even if you never learn I exist, I have wronged you, and I owe you. I am sorry.
Then I read about Angie's family's reaction, and was struck dumb by the simultaneous realization and the refutation of my own assumptions.
I had thought, here was this little Latina trans girl, murdered by her maybe-boyfriend. I thought I knew her; she'd be kicked out by her transphobic Hispanic family, trying to make it on her own, possibly turning tricks to survive. Good little White Liberal Ally was I, so cynical about her chances for justice, so certain of her alienation.
But then I read her brother's words:
Angie was my sister.And I had to confront my own heart, who thought that by knowing the plight of the plot of too many trans women of color's lives that I knew the circumstances of her life; who thought that since I knew the color of her family's skin that I knew the contents of their hearts. I made so many assumptions about her, not bothering to read further, not even realizing I had made them; as much as I thought about it, which was hardly at all, I thought I knew what I needed to know about her.
She was a member of our family. We loved her very much, and we will miss her every day. Every day and every night our mom has to deal with great pain of ... one of her babies being buried. Every day our siblings and I reach for the phone and realize we’ll never hear her voice. There’s no answer anymore.
A part of our family is missing, stolen from us. Angie was 18, her life was just beginning. She was brave, she had guts, she had courage, and she was beautiful, fun and loving. She was our little sister.
I was wrong. I was guilty of racism, of the most pervasive sort of cisgenderism: the ignore-ance of a trans person's own existence. I committed a hate crime in the whitewashed confines of my own head.
White privilege doesn't go away. Cisgender privilege doesn't go away. We can't do our course in Racism 101 and Transphobia 101 and then wash our hands of the blood of those whiteness has killed, of those cisgender bias has killed.
This doesn't give me much hope for the Boychick. Bashes the rose-colored glasses right off my "raise a post-racist generation" face, in fact. Which is probably a good thing; helps me see how the world actually is, how hard a journey is ahead. Best hope I have is to ground him in a childhood of racism- and cisgenderism-awareness, and show him that it never stops; privilege never goes away, no matter how much we want it to, so our obligation as possessors of privilege to learn, to listen, to humble ourselves, and to root out the prejudices hidden in the darkest corners of our own heads -- which will always be there, more persistent than cockroaches and uglier still -- never goes away.
I am so sorry for what I did to you, how I erased you in my own mind, Angie. Your memory deserves so much more than that. Angie's family: I can only beg forgiveness. Even if you never learn of my assumptions about you, even if you never learn I exist, I have wronged you, and I owe you. I am sorry.
Labels:
cisgender privilege,
parenting,
privilege,
racism,
white privilege
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)