Showing posts with label misogyny. Show all posts
Showing posts with label misogyny. Show all posts

Monday, August 10, 2009

The misogyny of denying milk-making moms mental-health medication

OK, I hadn't meant to get so behind in updating this site. I'm not going to do this much longer, so:

Update your feeds and bookmarks! New site at www.RaisingMyBoychick.com!

Really, it's way better.


In honor of World Breastfeeding Week (even if it is almost over), I offer a post about breastfeeding, blame-the-kyriarchy style.

Perhaps you've been lucky enough to have missed this scenario, but I, at the intersection of those with lactating breasts and those with mental illness, have seen it far too often: a woman goes to her psychiatrist, generalist, family doctor, nurse practitioner, or psych nurse, for help with, oh, depression (postpartum or otherwise), or anxiety, or mood disorder, or sleep problem. Being a careful parent and a conscientious patient, she discloses that she is breastfeeding her child, so that she and her health care practitioner can find the healthiest, most appropriate medications for her (should they mutually decide medications are necessary).

This is when, in a sane society, her physician or nurse would nod, draw on hir vast knowledge of and experience with medications appropriate for breastfeeding, and say "No problem, that only rules out a very few classes of drugs, there are lots of things we can try still." Or, barring that, would reach for the copy of Hale's zie keeps handy in hir office, or would call one of the many breastfeeding-knowledgeable pharmacists zie keeps on file as references. The woman and the health care provider she employs would then work together to pick a medication most appropriate for her particular situation.

That is not what usually happens. Too often (ever would be too often), the physician, upon hearing said disclosure, automatically replies "I don't want to give you anything until you wean/terminate breastfeeding/stop doing that."

There is so much wrong with this situation, I hardly know where to start.

Do I start with the ignorance? How so very rarely is weaning actually necessary, in any situation, and even less often to treat most mental health issues? How the ignorance of a basic facet of women's health is inherently misogynistic: how women are not a "special group", lactation is not a "special case", and we shouldn't have to go to "specialists" to find a physician knowledgeable of the basics of care when we are engaged in a normal human biological function? To be ignorant of these things is inexcusable, and reflective of both systemic and individual misogyny, whether recognized or not.

Or do I start with the authoritarianism? With the assumption that the physician knows better -- knows what they're talking about for that matter! --, that what they "want" matters one whit in the face of a client coming to them for treatment of a specific issue, that they have the right to place ultimatums on the conditions under which their clients receive treatment? Paternalistic authoritarianism, whether coming from a man or a woman, dictating or denying the course of a woman's treatment and what she can/'t do with her body, is always misogynistic.

Or do I simply rail against how *&^%ed up, how immoral and wrong-headed it is? How in fact damaging to a woman's mental well-being it is to be denied her normal biological entwinement with her young, to be told she must chose between her own health and the health of her child? Do I describe the panic that ensues, the flight-or-fight reaction as her body is flooded with adrenaline, as she realizes the person across from her is not her ally but her enemy, her judge, the antagonistic gatekeeper blocking her from that which might make her well? Do I justifiably liken it to throwing gasoline on an already smoldering -- or raging -- firestorm of imbalanced brain chemicals?

I do think that we ought be cautious in what we expose our young to, especially when it has the potential to affect brain development, and I am the first in line to question the pervasive use of psychotropics, the first to encourage that other avenues of health and stability and sanity be pursued first, or at least simultaneously. I am the first in line to criticize the culture of "problem? pop a pill!", the first to point out the downsides of many mental health medications -- my own experiences with mood stabilizers and anti-depressants are far from flawless, and what finally made me sane was not the prescription I was handed first.

And I am jumping the line to be the first and loudest to proclaim how so many postpartum and parental mental health problems are the kyriarchy's damn fault in the first place: how the isolation, the lack of tangible support, the dearth of family-friendly work options, the pitiful state of parental leave (in the USA at least), the antagonism toward breastfeeding in public, the burden of parenting placed solely on the "nuclear family" -- and too often primarily if not exclusively on the woman within that unnatural unit --, all combine to create situations in which NOT experiencing postpartum mental health problems is more surprising than having them.

But this? This "I don't want to give you anything until you wean"? That's not a careful critique of the pharmacological industry, that's not an intersectionalist examination of the role kyriarchy plays in the creation of women's mental health issues, and it's not a sober weighing of the balance of "greatest goods" when faced with exposing a child to an ill mother or minute quantities of probably-safe substances. No, that's nothing more than an ignorant, authoritarian, fucked up, misogynistic ultimatum.

Breastfeeding is a feminist issue. This post isn't about telling women what they should/n't do, it isn't about being a "breastfeeding zealot", and it isn't even a defense of medication during lactation (there are benefits and risks, and each woman -- in consultation with knowledgeable health care providers -- must weigh them for herself). It's about saying that the way we talk about breastfeeding, drugs, and mental health needs to change. It's about saying that this kind of comment is downright dangerous, because it discourages women from breastfeeding, it discourages women from getting help for their illnesses, and it supports the kyriarchy through misogyny -- and thus damages all women, lactating or not.

I am lucky that I haven't needed to go on medication during pregnancy, or while the Boychick is nursing. I have done many things, worked very hard, to achieve this, but I also know that I am, at the end, simply lucky. Maybe you were too. Or maybe you were another kind of lucky, and got a health care worker who helped you rather than hindered you. But too many women are slapped with this, too many women are lied too, too many women don't have the knowledge or the spoons to counter this misogyny. And as long as any woman encounters this attitude, we all have a need -- and a duty -- to counter it.

Thursday, July 23, 2009

WFPP Guest Post: Running as Feminist Pursuit

Today's entry to the Womanist/Feminist Parenting Primer comes from a dear friend and occasional reader (if not regular commenter, *ahem*), Courtney Wilder, PhD.

This is a long entry, but well worth it. In it, Courtney first explores the ways that running serves to reify patriarchal gender norms. She then places it in an historically misogynistic context in which women were actively discouraged and often outright barred from and drummed out of athletics and physical pursuits. She ultimately reveals how it is an "ultra-feminist" activity and helps teach her children progressive, feminist values, by showing that women can be strong, by modeling bodily autonomy, and by demonstrating that physical activity is well worth pursuing regardless of whether one meets the patriarchy's sexist standards.

Running as Feminist Pursuit

A couple of years ago, I took up running. It did not feel, at the time, like an activity with particular feminist (or un-feminist) overtones; it did not feel subversive, or especially important to my parenting. It felt like a way to get out of the house, like a way to do something other than slowly go nuts writing the last few chapters of my doctoral dissertation, like a way to breathe some fresh air while my kids were in preschool and first grade, respectively. It was cheaper than the gym, more soothing than using an exercise bike in front of the TV, and I got to know the streets of my neighborhood from a perspective that was different from the ones afforded me by car or bicycle transportation.

Of course, nothing – especially nothing involving women and their bodies – can remain neutral for very long. And nothing, I found, that a mother chooses to engage in can fail to impact her children in some way. I started to run more, and I started to read about running, and I entered longer and longer road races (aiming for a marathon this fall!), and slowly I found my perspective shifting. Running is subversive, it can be ultra-feminist, and my running teaches my children a wealth of things about women, and bodies, and how to be healthy, and what so-called limits they might transcend rather easily.

First, the aspects of running that seem to reify sexist gender stereotypes: I have a range of running clothes now, mostly in shades you’d find in a box of Necco Wafers. I have pink and blue and white tech shirts, and lavender and pink and black running bras, and shorts and running skirts that range from black (with a pink waistband) to blue to gray (with a pink stripe). When I run, I look super, super girly. Sweaty, but girly. Despite the skepticism with which seasoned athletes regard running skirts, I wear them almost exclusively – they’re comfy, they often provide more coverage of leg and ass than running shorts, and I like them. Moreover, I finally found an activity where it’s very likely that you can solve your problems with a new pair of shoes, and since this has long been my practice – to soothe my ego or perk myself up or provide a carrot for myself as the reward for some grueling or dull task – I enjoy having a real reason to choose new shoes.

A more serious overlap between running and traditional, repressive, sexist strictures for women involves the size and shape of my body. As I started to run more, I started to weigh less. I went from a perfectly nice size 8 to 10 body (this, after having given birth twice and breastfed continuously for – drum roll please! – more than seven consecutive years) to a size 4. My parents describe me as “lean,” my husband is somewhat taken aback, the most overtly feminine of my female coworkers talk to me frequently in approving tones about my waist and hips. My sister-in-law, a few months post-partum, sized me up when I came to visit and observed simply, “You’re really thin.” I am. I am really thin. But when I look at my daughter, I can see that she’s also lean; I eat well (and frequently, and in good quantities), and I’m inclined to think this is just what my body looks like when I take care of myself. I am really thin, which pings my feminist anxieties in all kinds of ways, but I am also really damned strong. I am in better shape than I ever was as a teenager, or a college student, or a mother of very young children (mine are now eight and five.)

So: while dressing in a cute pink and gray skirt and dashing along the local running trails in my size four body seems very much in keeping with the sexist stereotypes I deplore as a feminist, I’m convinced that running is actually something very different. While some women no doubt run only to govern their bodies into more socially acceptable forms, this practice pales in comparison to those women who fought for the right to engage in physical activity alongside their brothers and male classmates. Although when I began running, I knew vaguely about Title IX, the 1972 law [in the USA] prohibiting discrimination on the basis of sex in educational settings, I had no idea – none – about how hard aspiring female athletes fought for the simple right to compete in organized events. Early female entrants to marathons disguised their gender on their entry forms, were sometimes chased during the race by angry men, were denied official record of their accomplishments. Although in the United States alone, working class women and farm or pioneer women, not to mention enslaved women, engaged in significant physical labor all their lives, somehow twentieth century women who wanted to engage in athletics were seen as too delicate. With the exception of the 1928 Olympics, where there was a women’s 800 meter event, no woman’s footrace was longer than 200 meters until 1960. Women couldn’t officially run the Boston Marathon until 1972. It was a shock to me that women’s bodies were so tightly, so successfully, controlled in this sphere; I had thought of women’s choices regarding their bodies to be largely a matter of reproductive care – access to birth control and abortion. It had never occurred to me that there was public discourse (in the United States, within the last sixty years) about whether women were biologically fit to run distances further than a mile and a half.

Trust me, my children will never take that discussion seriously. My daughter will never, ever have reason to think she can’t be athletic because of her gender; it will, I hope, never even occur to my son to regard girls and women as fragile little things. My kids have grown used to seeing me head out the door in my running clothes, or slog back in, sweaty and disheveled. They’ll happily make conversation at church potlucks about my latest half-marathon; they ask about how my runs go. Occasionally my daughter will come with me on her bike, although she’s a little fast for me. This is the other interesting wrinkle about running for me, and one reason it has such an impact on my kids. Like my grandfather, my dad, and both of my children, I have asthma. While the kids seem to be growing out of it, I have not. So when I run, I run pretty slowly. I can do comfortable 9:30 miles for a long time, but in the running world, that’s slow.

There are a slew of articles – mostly, I’ve noticed, by men – about how disgraceful the current state of things is in the running world, how the marathon is now just open to any fool with shoes, how slow runners should just get some other hobby. I know my kids will encounter this attitude – possibly about their very bodies, possibly about people in general – and I remain hopeful, and confident, that I have provided them with a counter-example to that argument. Because I run, despite the asthma, despite the fraught history of women and their bodies, because I’m confident and strong even in the absence of innate talent or great physical skill – I’m a great feminist role model for my kids. They’ve stopped asking me after races whether I’ve won – the answer will always be no – but they remain proud of my effort. Even in the face of utterly objective measure that tells me I am bad at this, I am slow, I lack talent – I am happily persisting. I hope this is what they learn, my daughter and my son: your body is your body, and you can make it strong, and healthy. No one can tell you what to do with your own body, or that you’re not good enough to do what you enjoy. Your body, however imperfect it might seem by the wildly unattainable standards of our culture, is yours, and it is good.


Courtney Wilder did finish that dissertation, earning a Ph.D. in theology from the University of Chicago, and now teaches in the Religion and Philosophy Department at Midland Lutheran College. She runs and, with her spouse, raises her kids in Omaha, Nebraska.

Sunday, July 12, 2009

The personal and the political

What do I mean when I say “...getting sucked into attacks and defenses of individual "choices" is not only missing the point, it is supporting the patriarchy”?

It is certainly understandable when faced with the task of changing one's whole culture all in one go to feel overwhelmed, as reader Rachel bemoans: “I think that's what I find daunting about your posts--you address the larger cultural, societal issues that I feel are out of my control. … But my whole culture. That seems impossible.”

And as Jeremy Adam Smith points out over at Daddy Dialectic, there is a trap on the other side, for those who believe “only after the revolution can our piddling interpersonal relationships be lastingly altered” to use this as an excuse to “neglect their family responsibilities, especially the guys.” After all, if equality in individual lives is impossible to achieve, no point trying, right?

Neither of those are what I'm hoping to advocate.

When Rachel says “I can control (as much as anyone I think) what goes on in my family”, she is right. When Jeremy asserts “how vital and immediate it is for heterosexual couples to [establish] a domestic division of labor that makes both parties happy”, he is right. It is only ever in ourselves, for ourselves, that we can choose. It is only ever our own actions and choices over which we have direct, though not complete, control. And it is so vitally important that in our own, personal lives that we work to implement our ideals and values.

That is the personal.

As for the political: we are social creatures. Society is only and simply the gestalt of thousands and millions of individuals. And that makes us – each individual – powerful, for we are society, and each of us has the potential to influence all the dozens and hundreds and thousands of persons in our lives, and through them dozens and hundreds and thousands more.

The personal is political, and the political is personal. Decisions are made by the ones who show up, the ones who speak out, the ones who write letters and raise funds and cast votes and serve dinners and volunteer at clinics; sexism and racism and other facets of the kyriarchy are eliminated by those who demand better, of ourselves and of our kith and kin and coworkers. It is by making connections at the individual level – with your family, your friends, your blog readers, your neighbours, your shops' owners, your company's executives, your government representatives – that we can enact political, societal change.

What does not work, however, and what I speak out against, is the attempt to control those around us, especially through shaming. There may be a fine line between offering influence and attempting control, but it is an important one, and when we are speaking of mothers, who are already a highly persecuted class, already so put-upon and guilt-ridden, maintaining that distinction is even more imperative.

I do not say this because I believe women are fragile, dainty things who cannot take criticism: to the contrary, I am continually amazed by just how much we can take and take on and still do all the work that keeps our families and societies running. But our burdens are already so over-heavy that I decline to add what may be the proverbial straw to any woman's back.

Further, each of us lives in the society we all create, and that society is kyriarchal, actively antagonistic to us living joyful, unconstrained, interdependent, fully human lives. Each of us has our choices constrained if not outright dictated by the circumstances and intersections of our lives – each of which combinations is unique, but all similar for making us less than fully able to live as we would in a saner society.

How, then, can we help change society without hurting our sister sufferers? We can encourage; we must not order. We can offer a shoulder; we must not sit in judgment. We can support; we must not shame. We can influence those around us by example, by sharing our stories, by offering information and support; but they must be open to it. We cannot attempt to control those around us through browbeating or shame or force – or we can, but it is a violation of our values as well as almost inevitably ineffective.

We cannot avoid offending those who are determine to be offended, but we can, and we must, watch our own words and actions to avoid allowing the kyriarchy's voice to speak through our throats: that means, in part, declining to partake in the mommy wars in any of its permutations. That means opposing crying-it-out without attacking those who do it. That means defending breastfeeding without insulting those who weren't able to or chose not to. That means promoting natural family living while acknowledging that all of us have a harmful impact on the planet. That means disagreeing and debating and disputing and refuting each other in a way that respects each side's inherent humanity and dignity, because the only real enemy, the only true evil, is the kyriarchy.

So speak out, yes: live your ideals as best you can, and tell your truth as honestly as possible. I cannot say it any better than it has been said before, so forgive me for ending on what is almost cliched; nevertheless I believe it true: “Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world. Indeed, it is the only thing that ever has.” -- Margaret Mead

Sunday, June 28, 2009

Two things I do believe and several things I don't

I believe "crying it out"* is not good. I believe it should never be the default method of sleep training, and I question whether "sleep training" is even the way we should think about babies and sleep. I believe it can be ever so slightly bad, or pretty bad, or very very bad, depending on a whole load of variables, and while I believe it might sometimes be the least bad of the limited options available (and I blame the kyriarchy and a society that isolates women who mother for those limitations), still I believe it is never a good thing.

Now here are many things I do not believe:
  • I do not believe using CIO makes one a bad person.
  • I do not believe using CIO makes one a bad parent.
  • I do not believe that parents who use CIO do not love their children.
  • I do not believe that parents who do not use CIO love their children more than those who do.
  • I do not believe that all children are measurably and irreparably harmed by CIO.
  • I do not believe that using CIO will definitely make your child hate you, or think you don't love them.
  • I do not believe that CIO should be illegal.
  • I do not believe people who use CIO should be shunned or ostracized.
  • I do not believe I have any right (or desire) to tell any other parent what to do.
  • And I do not believe that saying that I believe CIO is not good says any of the above.

Another thing I do believe is that it is possible to critique a widespread (dare I say dominant) parenting practice without criticizing individual parents -- and I believe it is necessary to try to do so. I believe it is my right, and possibly my responsibility, to explicate the ways that patriarchy both creates and benefits from a society that promotes and routinely uses detachment parenting practices such as CIO -- and I believe that until the society changes such that patriarchy is not limiting and influencing our choices this way, getting sucked into attacks and defenses of individual "choices" is not only missing the point, it is supporting the patriarchy.

Which is not any individual's fault, of course. But we can choose to work to avoid it -- work to avoid both giving and taking offense as we work to change minds and cultures -- and I believe doing so has the power to change the world.



*"Crying it out" or CIO is here defined as any method of sleep training involving leaving a child or infant alone to cry for any length of time with the intent of getting them to go to sleep by themselves. Crying in arms and leaving a child crying alone for a time because one is unable to cope with the crying any longer without risking damage to oneself or the child are not CIO.

Saturday, June 27, 2009

A matter of perspective

Let's consider two scenarios:
  • The first: I was accosted by a rude woman in the deli aisle, who questioned my parenting -- no, accused me of Bad Mothering! -- by interrupting me dishing up a soup sample for the Boychick, with a snotty voice, saying "This stuff is really hot!" How dare she insinuate I was negligently going to burn my child's mouth? She needed to bugger off, mind her own business. Some people!

  • The second: I met a nice woman today, while I was getting a soup sample for the Boychick. She wanted to help keep him safe, so she, having just gotten scorched by the soup herself, let me know "This stuff is really hot!" I knew that already, but I was touched that she would take the time to get involved and offer a helpful word to a stranger. It really takes a village!
Sometimes there are absolute truths, and sometimes people are absolutely being douchebags. But so often, it's a matter of perspective, and it's at least as much up to us to avoid taking offense as it is to others to avoid giving it.

It's so hard as mothers: we get on the defensive, because we are so often being attacked by society, by misogynists and child haters and moralists who use us as a battle ground for their causes. And sometimes, doing the oft-draining work of parenting in an oft-unhelpful society, we don't have the reserves to open ourselves up to others, for fear of such an attack. But sometimes, oftener than we think, the stranger we meet with the maybe-helpful, maybe-not advice is well intentioned, a potential ally, a village aunty, another struggling mother -- and if we could just open up, shift our own interpretations, we could be renewed and sustained by such contact, whether we needed that help or not.

An unpleasant incident that leaves us feeling attacked; a kind moment that leaves us smiling: sometimes, we get to choose. Sometimes, it's all a matter of perspective.

Tuesday, May 5, 2009

We are not bad moms -- but are we good moms?

Reader sarah replied to my post We are not bad moms* with the following:
There is a corollary to this post that I think should also be said. Babywearing, breastfeeding, EC, etc. don't necessarily make you a good mom. There is a world of hurt you can bring on your child even if you practice those parenting techniques, they don't inure anyone from the negative aspects of parenting.

I just feel like this needs to be said (and repeated over and over) as I see my friends lulled into a false sense of safety and superiority because they subscribe to a certain set of parenting practices. We need to constantly challenge ourselves to look past our more superficial lifestyle choices to how our personalities, histories, family structures, and communities impact our children in a way that is beyond our control.
First, sarah, thank you so much for the comment and the post inspiration. I'd like to reply to this -- agreeing and disagreeing and expanding and being inspired by -- in three parts.

To the first:
Babywearing, breastfeeding, EC, etc. don't necessarily make you a good mom. There is a world of hurt you can bring on your child even if you practice those parenting techniques, they don't inure anyone from the negative aspects of parenting.
I really hesitate to agree, although I think it is technically true. But as I've mentioned before, everyone and everything in our society jumps at any opportunity to either knock us down and declare us horrid mothers, or place us on Olympian pedestals no one could hope to live up to. I am therefore loathe to take part in any of this game, to spend any of my time lending any credence to the bad-mother meme. I am in fact, in general, loathe to even place mothers on any kind of good/bad spectrum, nor to attempt to define what a "good mother" is, such that someone who breastfeeds and babywears, or who formula feeds and lugs a baby bucket, might or might not be one, because of or in spite of those practices.

Furthermore, I believe that babywearing and breastfeeding and elimination communication are good things in their own right; all other things being equal, it is better to breastfeed than to not, better to practice EC than to not. These practices have tangible, intrinsic benefits, to infants, to the parent-child relationship, to parents, to the environment, to society; I do not want to see them placed in opposition to intangible "good parenting", as though it were a trade-off (although I will say I know sometimes it is a trade-off, especially with the limited amount of energy and resources mothers have available to them in the early months and years, but no one can know from the outside the balance of a mother's choices; what costs time and energy for one person might be a simplification and a lifesaver for another). An inherently good thing is good whether or not one is managing to do other good things, and whether or not it protects you from the damage of other not-good things.** And, as they are minority practices, which are often attacked in a very misogynistic way (often supported in a misogynistic way as well, I will grant you), I am loathe as well to contribute to the belittling or dismissing of these parenting choices.

(I also wish to discuss whether or not or in what way(s) attachment parenting practices might indeed protect against "the negative aspects of parenting", but I'll leave that for another post, because it's a complex issue in its own right.)

Jumping to the end of the comment:
We need to constantly challenge ourselves to look past our more superficial lifestyle choices to how our personalities, histories, family structures, and communities impact our children in a way that is beyond our control.
I can give a big ol' Amen! to the bolded part. Certainly when we look at the ways in which the kyriarchy constantly constrains our choices, debating diapering methods can seem like rearranging the deck chairs on the Titanic. Mothers are a persecuted subset of a persecuted gender; mothers who exist without white, straight, able, or class privilege even more so. So much of the damage that is done to our children is out of our control, dictated by the work choices we (don't) have, the community support we (don't) have, the parental benefits we (don't) have, the schooling options we (don't) have, and so on, et cetera, ad nauseum. Even those of us hell-bent on countering the kyriarchy and the dominant culture to the best of our ability recognize that our children will grow up in this society, influenced by its memes and beliefs and ideals and prejudices, fully versed in its gender and racial and sexual norms and mores, and there's not a damn thing we can do about it, except try to at least help them be able to see and recognize those influences in their lives, and thereby, if we are very lucky, reduce their power at least a little.

That said, I'm not sure I can agree with the "We need to constantly challenge ourselves to look past our more superficial lifestyle choices" preamble. Although that is, at least in part, what I try to do with this blog, I recognize that it is something I am able to do due to privilege: I do not have to worry about where my child's next meal will come from, whether his water is going to make him ill, how to pay for any injury he might incur running around like the toddler he is, or how to protect him from any abusive relations; and so I am able to spend my time thinking about paid family leave, environmentalism, universal health care, and preventing domestic violence, and the role of the kyriarchy in the lack of these things (which is not to say that only those who exist with privilege, like myself, can think big thoughts, or need to "fix" things for "them", just that I have far fewer roadblocks in my way than does someone who is oppressed in more ways -- these roadblocks are one of the many ways the kyriarchy seeks to protect itself). Further, "constantly challeng[ing]" myself does, to an extent, fulfill me and give me energy, but I am not hubristic enough to think that therefore everyone must lead the examined life: for some, letting go of the need to examine and challenge themselves is the healthier path.

Finally, looking at the middle part, where I think the meat is:
I see my friends lulled into a false sense of safety and superiority because they subscribe to a certain set of parenting practices.
Here we have the twofold point: "superiority" speaks to women who attempt to build themselves up by placing themselves ahead of others, because the kyriarchy has ensured that hierarchy is the only organizational principle they know (even in trying to be grateful, we too often make it about being better off than others); "safety" speaks to women who are seeking to protect themselves, because they are under constant attack by the kyriarchy and forces of anti-mother misogyny, threatened always with the spectre of the "bad mom" label if they don't do things "just right". And although I don't think that being "lulled into a false sense of safety and security" (by clinging to breastfeeding or babywearing or what-have-you) is a good thing, I also cannot blame them, or fault the inclination. Because we are under attack, because there is so much out of our control, and if clinging to cloth diapers like they were lifesavers is what helps a mother get through the tsunami of hate, from outside and in, that comes with the early years of parenting... well, she gets through, and that survival is worth celebrating, an intrinsic Good Thing, even if she might have done it "better".

The "mommy wars" suck. (A lot.) Possibly the most evil thing about them is the way they make us turn against each other, first by scrambling to place ourselves on a hierarchy of most attached/most crunchy/most Super/most whatever, then by attacking each other with "[not] necessarily... a good mom" when we recognize the fallacy of the hierarchy. Dismantling the kyriarchy without undermining each other, critiquing parenting choices without criticizing fellow parents: these are not easy tasks. It is not an easy dance, and it is so easy to make a misstep -- just as with parenting itself. But it is necessary to try, and it is necessary to forgive ourselves because we will get it wrong sometimes -- just as with parenting itself.

So no, putting the telly on for your toddler doesn't make you a bad mom, and knowing a dozen carries to do with a 5m wrap doesn't make you a good mom. But what might make you a revolutionary is to let go of both the fear of being a bad mom, and the need to be a good mom. Let go of the good mom/bad mom hierarchy altogether. Just be a mom -- a bad-ass mom in your own right -- and tell the hierarchy it can go to hell.



*Which is, by far and without question, my most popular post, which still kind of mystifies me. The reaction to it has been amazing, and humbles me. Thank you to everyone who read, and especially to everyone who commented or passed it on.

**An analogy: recycling is a Good Thing (as is reducing and reusing). I do my best to reduce my consumption of paper and plastic containers, and reuse or recycle what we do bring home. I also drive well over 100 miles a week, when I could take public transit, or avoid travel altogether. Does my typical American use of the car, which has a much greater overall impact on the environment than the waste I produce and how I deal with it, mean that "recycling doesn't make me a good environmentalist"? Does my use of the car somehow negate the Good Thing that recycling is? It's not exactly a rhetorical question, but I have an answer that I can live with for myself, and I hope you do too.

Monday, April 13, 2009

We are not bad moms

(Inspired by an off-hand comment from a friend of mine, but applicable to pretty much every mom I've ever met. Very, very few of the dads, though. And no, that is not a coincidence.)

Allowing, or even encouraging, your toddler to watch TV does not make you a bad mom (or mum).

Using disposable diapers/nappies, whether regularly or occasionally, does not make you a bad mom.

Pushing your child around in a stroller does not make you a bad mom.

Using bribes or coercion or even lying to your child does not make you a bad mom.

Sending your child to daycare or public school, whether so you can work or just because you need the break -- all together now! -- does not make you a bad mom.

I am a TV-free advocate. I am an Elimination Communication (with cloth diaper back up) enthusiast. I adore and enjoy teaching babywearing, and prove daily that a stroller is not an essential baby-accessory (we don't own one at all). I firmly believe in unconditional parenting (and unconditionality), and strive for consensual living. I believe in attachment theory (about the same way I believe in the theory of gravity), and advocate for attachment parenting, and think the public school system, in the US at least, is fundamentally flawed.

But parenting -- life -- is not a checklist. It is not a competition. And you are not a bad mom.

This is not to say that anything goes, or that having ideals and standards and beliefs and goals is wrong, or mistaken, or pointless. Far from it; I am, as the above list shows, a fan of ideals and standards and beliefs and goals. This is not to say there are not right and wrong choices in parenting (feeding your kids is right, beating them is wrong); it is not to say there are not things better and worse for kids (exclusive breastfeeding for the first half-year is better, yelling at them for developmentally appropriate behavior is worse). Rather, it is to plea with all those reading to recognize that even making a "bad" choice does not make you a bad mom. Even if we agree that a particular choice or action is less than ideal (today I have yelled at my child, threatened him, bribed him, ignored his cries, and generally made some less than stellar parenting choices), making that choice, or doing that action, or failing to meet that standard, does not make you a bad mom.

The whole world is filled with people who are eager to tell us what a bad job we are doing, that we are ruining our children, that we as women are inferior, that we are incompetent, that we are hated, that we can never be good enough, that mothers are worthless, that we are worthless mothers, that mother love is instinctual, that mothers must be perfect, that if we achieve perfection it is no big deal, that if we fall from perfection we are broken, that we are bad moms.

These are lies. These are misogynistic lies, put forth by the patriarchy. And we swallow them whole, and we spit them back out, at each other, at ourselves.

Don't do the patriarchy's work for it. Reject the lies. If you let your toddler watch TV, even if you don't like that s/he watches, that's OK. If you don't feel guilty letting your toddler watch TV, that's OK too. (If you try to argue with me that there's nothing wrong on a large scale with infant TV watching, I'll argue back, but no way am I going to tell you what to do in your own life.) You are not a bad mom. You do not have to call yourself a bad mom when you admit it, as though it were some kind of protective amulet (mothers are hardly the only ones who do this: it's just shades of "yes massa" "I'm just a silly blonde" "you know how we Jews are"); you may get a pat on the back from the patriarchy, but all it does is perpetuate the hate. And you are still being oppressed.

What we do is not who we are. What we do in the early years of parenting our children really is not who we are. Our choices matter, yes; activism and advocacy matter; and there really are bad moms out there.

But really? We don't need to prefix or suffix our "failures" with self-flaggelation. If parking your kid in front of the TV so you can get a break (or cook dinner, or take a shower, or just because they enjoy it) is the worst you do on a regular basis, I can say with all confidence you are not a bad mom.

Thumb your nose at the patriarchy: next time the words "bad mom" start to fall from your lips, change it to bad-ass mom. Because you are.

Sunday, March 22, 2009

Independence, attachment parenting, and societal misogyny

I was in one of those sort of surreal conversations the other day, where someone was telling me that, now that he's two, the Boychick really should spend some time away from The Man and me, so he can "develop independence".

I tried to stutter a defense about how he has a lot of independence already, just within the context of our family unit (see? I can't even articulate the thought well in retrospect), which earned me a patronizing head shake.

But it got me thinking: what IS independence? And why is it seen as so damned important?

Here's the thing: the Boychick has never been away from The Man or me. One or the other of us has been with him, been the one primarily responsible for overseeing his well-being, at all times. We've never had a "date night" where we left him with someone else. We're not, at this age, absolutely opposed to the idea, but we have no particular desire for it, either. We've had lots of dates, and lots of adult conversations, with the Boychick around, and all three of us like it that way just fine. (This is in no way meant to condemn those who do desire -- even need -- breaks from their children, dates with their partners, or to work in child-free environments part or full time. Although I am overtly and entirely in favor of attachment parenting, I have no desire to police what that looks like in other families, nor even whether they choose it or not.)

In the popular conception, at least in America, this makes the Boychick horribly smothered, denied the opportunity to be "independent", tied to us (literally, at times) in ways sure to stunt him in the long run.

And yet, no one would ever accuse us of being helicopter parents:

  • At the park, I plop myself down on a bench with a book or my schoolwork or my iPhone, and gently encourage the Boychick to run and play -- and eventually, when he's ready to, he does, and wanders far and wide, though usually within my sight.


  • At home, he plays on his own while I do my work, and has done since he was a few months old -- a few minutes at a time at first, in my lap or on the floor right next to me, now for hours a day (with numerous swings back to show me this or that), and often in other rooms.


  • We are entirely in favor of free range parenting, and I, as a former latch-key kid who started biking home by myself at age 8, was recently horrified to discover that Oregon law strongly discourages children under 10 years old being left home alone for even "short" periods of time. (I also discovered I could be prosecuted for leaving my sleeping toddler in the car in our own driveway to run inside, pee, and get the bed ready for transferring him. But noooo, surely society is not at all oppressive of women-who-caretake!)


  • We love the book Whistle for Willie, published in 1964, in part because of its portrayal of a perhaps 5-8 year old boy playing on his own in his neighbourhood, even getting sent on an errand to the corner store by himself -- of course, he's not actually alone, because there are several other kids also outside playing (without an adult in sight).

Modern American culture is horrified by almost all these things. We raise the spectre of Stranger Danger, of the Pedophile Lurking in the Bushes, of the omnipresent and omni-oppressive What If? at every turn, restricting and limiting and oppressing -- and yes, smothering -- our children, even as we push them away.

It seems to me, then, that The Man's and my sin in the eyes of "mainstream" culture is not failing to foster independence, but our refusal to force detachment -- what I sometimes call "pathological independence". It is our willingness and commitment to provide a safe base from which the Boychick may explore, and to which he always may return, that earns us ire and shaming clucks of the tongue.

Independence, no matter what popular culture says, cannot be created by forcing the chick out of the nest; that is only detachment, which teaches children they cannot trust those around them, and cuts off their rightful sense of interdependence. Real independence, which is entirely capable of coexistence with interdependence and thus dependence as well, is grown in to, at one's own pace, under one's own power, and comes from knowing that one is free to roam, free to leap, and yes, free to fall -- which children are so much more likely to risk when they know they have a soft space to land.

We spend so much time demanding "independence" in our offspring's infancy (demanding they sleep alone, forgo our embrace, learn to "self-soothe"), then refusing to let them taste anything approaching real independence (freedom to explore and exist unobserved and unoppressed, along with responsibilities to others who depend on them) when they are at the age they most need it. How much more backwards can we get?

To take this, once again, from the personal to the political: I suggest there is something inherently anti-feminist -- misogynist -- in this backwards stance.

First, we replace mother's own (ideal, biological default) milk with man-made artificial infant food; a parent's arms with artificial rockers, swings, play pens, etc; a parent's bed and a mother's breast with barred cribs and artificial white-noise and silicone "nipples"; we tell parents to ignore their instincts, and allow their babies to cry themselves to sleep. Not to put too much biology-is-destiny spin on it, but all of this serves to separate and detach the motherbaby -- which biologically ought still be thought of as one unit even after birth, only gradually and mutually separating over time (with "mother" here being substitutable with any number of close allomothers; the point being that infants and to a lesser extent toddlers biologically expect the constant presence of a known, loving, familiar adult or near-adult) -- damaging a mother's belief in her own abilities and conceptualizing her as broken, incomplete, inconsequential.

Then, when both primary caregiver and child ought to be naturally starting to get ready for the child to explore ever further afield, we demand constant vigilance: children must NEVER be left alone or unobserved for even a moment, "because something might happen, dun dun DUUUUUUUUUUUN!"; this serves to tie the primary caregiver, usually a woman (either the primary mother or a usually-female allomother in the form of daycare workers, school teachers, playground monitors, etc), to the child, never allowed to pursue her own goals and career, required always to have her attention focused completely and near-exclusively on the child(ren), or risk being cited negligent, labeled a Bad Mother -- even risk having her child(ren) taken away by a system that declares alone time under some arbitrary and ridiculously high age actually illegal.

This is classic patriarchy modus operandi: declare women broken, insufficient, lesser-than, dangerous even; then demand our complete sacrifice and subsumation of self under some pretext (which also inevitably serves its end goals), usually exactly counter to the previous demands (thereby, if we are to follow, requiring suspension of rational, logical thought); make it almost impossible to deviate from the demands (lack of allomothers, break up of neighbourhoods, laws and a Big Brother culture quick to dial 911 to enforce the norms); and punish us completely out of proportion to the "offense" if we dare to deviate.

So no, we're not going to leave the Boychick with a sitter or take him to daycare just so he can taste "independence"; nor will we refrain from leaving him in our yard to play, or home alone when he is ready, just so he can be "safe": I may not be totally (hah!) independent from the patriarchy, but neither will I bow down and allow it to define "independence" for my child.

Thursday, March 12, 2009

More thoughts on the mommy wars

A thought I didn't quite articulate but alluded to in my last post:

There is a moderately sizable movement that purports to be "anti mommy wars", of which Dawn's post (and especially the comment thread, last I checked) is a very good example. This side takes the position that since the mommy wars are supposed to be WOHM v SAHM, breast v bottle, cosleep v cry it out, then they can sidestep the misogyny by saying none of it matters, just do whatever works for you.

It is not a position without merit. Certainly it is admirable in that it is attempting to get away from the us v them impotent infighting of the traditional mommy wars. It's very post-modern in its relativism, and all the more appealing therefore to a certain type of privileged intellectual (in which group I usually include myself; certainly relativism is my default stance on many topics).

The problem is, in trying to avoid the mommy wars by "rising above", it fails, and indeed perpetuates just another variation of it. When I read a comment thread like that, what I hear is "aren't we all so much better than those small little women who have Positions on those issues and try to advocate for them". It ends up being another case of the "nonjudg(e)mental" sounding at least as judgmental and superior as those they're complaining about.

Again, this isn't to pick on this article as an example, nor even to shame that idea's adherents as a whole; that would be both hypocritical and counterproductive. Instead, I'm hoping to point out how, once again, the patriarchy has managed to frame the conversation in such a way as to always advantage and privilege and perpetuate itself, by making sure some women somewhere in the conversation are getting hated on and put down; and worst of all, it's making us do it to ourselves, by people who are trying to do better.

So, taking a position in the mommy wars, playing in to the us v them, "if you're not doing it like me you're doing it wrong and you're a bad mom and shame on you" = hating on women and supporting the patriarchy.

And, not taking sides, saying "it's all the same, none of it matters in the long run, it's all about individual choice, shame on you for caring what anyone else does" = hating on women and supporting the patriarchy.

So what's left? It would appear to be a double bind, and certainly societal forces are going to use all their resources of shame and misrepresentation to try to stuff us in to one of those boxes, no matter how hard we try to escape them, but I do believe there is an alternate path, that can have a righteous moral position and avoid misogynistic mother shaming. And surprise surprise: it starts with blaming the patriarchy.

It starts with accepting and understanding the idea that women are people, with full moral agency and ability to make choices that are right for them; and that the we live in a patriarchy that severely and overtly and subtly oppresses women and constrains what options and resources we have available.

It starts with saying that if we are pro-choice, we damn well ought to be working to make sure that women have REAL choice, and the ability to choose, not just to fantasize about what we might do under other, better circumstances.

It starts with recognizing that the language of choice is privileged to start with, that the idea of bickering over whether staying home or having a career is laughable to a woman without class privilege, white privilege, hetero privilege, cisgender privilege, able privilege, neurotypical privilege, age privilege, who may be fighting just to keep her children fed, keep them uninjured, keep them unhated, keep them alive, or just keep them when society would declare her "unfit".

It starts with saying that the system is fucked, and that under the system we are fucked, and that patriarchy is our enemy, and women -- all women, women like us and women dissimilar, women who agree with us and women we vehemently disagree with -- are the ones we are fighting for, not fighting with, even if on some small skirmish they are on "the other side".

It starts with saying that while not all mothers are good mothers, most are, and that being a good mother has NOTHING to do with some stupid checklist, and everything to do with loving one's children and doing one's good enough to be good enough (not even necessarily one's best to be good enough), and that one's worth as a mother is not measurable by how one's child "turns out", and furthermore one's worth as a woman is not dependent on one's worth as a mother.

In short, it starts with recognizing and rejecting every lie the patriarchy tries to feed us about mothers and motherhood.

Got all that? Ok. Given that -- but try not to take it as a given, for I know I for one am prone to slipping up and forgetting parts or all on a regular basis -- we can direct our attacks at the systemic ways the patriarchy influences and constrains choices, and promotes choices that promote its own ends: how a culture of detachment which promotes a pathological level of "independence" encourages aggression and devalues women and their work; how birth practices and the birth culture shames and vilifies women's bodies, protects institutionalized violence against women, and removes women's confidence and trust in our own power; how the belittlization of breastfeeding and especially the attacks on nursing in public shames and vilifies women's bodies, and promotes a false dichotomy between a woman's freedom and her child's health.

I could go on, but that's sufficient to exemplify how a conversation could and must be framed to attack systems and institutions that devalue -- dehumanize -- women, without attacking women or their choices at all.

In such a conversation, we must remember that it is not -- cannot -- be the goal to have all women choose the "right" action, even as we recognize and believe that as the systems are rectified the proportions will shift. There will always be disagreement and variation and that must be not only accepted but celebrated. We must also remember that as we champion our causes, we must take issue with the ideology, never take issue with individuals. We can debate how various practices affect women's status, and value parenting practices for how they avoid or conform to patriarchal goals, without valuing individual women for how they "measure up" to some imposed ideal.

There will always be those who take offense, who take criticism of ideology as personal attack; there will be times when we slip up under the weight of patriarchal pressures and violate the above starting points; there will be those who simply deny or reject some or all of those precepts entirely; but as much as we are able within the patriarchal, misogynistic societies we live in, this can point our way toward avoiding the so-called "mommy wars" while still fighting for feminist paths in parenting.

And the patriarchy is gonna hate it.

Wednesday, March 11, 2009

The patriarchy loves the mommy wars

Dawn at this woman's work has an interesting post up about should-ing on an already overwhelmed mother. She framed it as those self-righteous LLLers (these, I should say, as she was one of them) versus a woman who just needed to hear that CIO (the act of leaving a baby alone to "cry it out" as a method of sleep training) was just fine in her situation.

I take objection to this, yes in part because I am a "self-righteous LLL-type" who believes that CIO is harmful (to infants, to their parents, and to the adults they grow into), but mostly because I think the situation thus framed misses the point.

The point? US society hates women, and alternatingly exalts (without offering any actual support), hates, and ignores mothers. Anytime an issue like this is framed as an individual choice issue, while neglecting to point out the ways in which the patriarchy has forced women in to this bind in the first place, we're supporting the patriarchy and its lies about women and mothers and parenting.

The point here should not be to tsk the LLL women for failing to encourage a harmful practice, nor to applaud the woman for taking care of her own needs so she doesn't endanger her children; the point should be that in a sane society, no way would a woman with three children under five be expected to care for them essentially on her own, with a "partner" in the picture only enough to pay the bills. Of course she's exhausted, and of course she shouldn't be shamed or blamed for doing something -- the only thing available to her -- to get enough sleep to stay sane and able to function during the day. But it's criminal that she was put in that position in the first place; there should be parental leave and daycare subsidies and mother's helpers and community resources available to make sure she and her infant got the sleep and the care they needed and deserved.

And I know I just railed against placing individual blame, but now let me encourage individual responsibility by saying that "community" can and must (for the patriarchy surely isn't going to step up to the plate) start with us. Rather than condemning or encouraging an individual "choosing" CIO, why don't concerned community members pitch in to make it unnecessary? In this situation, the LLL members could have offered to take her other children for a few afternoons so she could sleep when the baby napped. They could have pitched together to bring her dinners for her family and cleaned her house while her partner was out of town to take some of her burdens off. The truly radical could have offered to take the baby overnight to nurse for her so she could have a night of blissful, restorative, uninterrupted sleep. And regardless of what this woman did, they could spend a couple hours every month sending letters and calling their representatives -- or the HR departments of local businesses! -- to make sure their money went where their mouths are to support real family friendly policies.

The point of this isn't to turn around and shame the LLL ladies, who were only trying to do their best, as was the mom of three, but to attempt to reframe the conversation. All too often we see this as a mommy war issue -- sanctimonious APers v pragmatic CIOers -- on which we are supposed to take "sides", without anyone taking issue with the whole mommy war idea to start with. I will never stop saying CIO is harmful, but there's a whole universe of ways to support women without compromising on that issue; we just have to start taking a broader, and dare I say more political, view first. Stop blaming individuals, either way: start blaming the patriarchy.

Friday, February 27, 2009

Say WHAT now?!

In the car, The Man had NPR on to entertain the Boychick whilst waiting for me to bring the pizza (drool) out. We drive off, too busy munching and avoiding downtown traffic to turn off the radio. There's some interview going on about a "lunch lady" (yes, the reporter actually called her a "lunch lady", which should have been my first clue) who took the job just to have something to do while her kids were at work, ended up staying to pay the bills, still here 15 years later, etc, yadda yadda. And then, says the announcer, it's time for the part of her job where she calls up the moms that haven't paid their children's lunch bills*.

The moms.

The moms.

The fucking MOMS.

Excuse me? Excuse fucking me? Is this "lunch lady" living in the district of exclusively single mother (or two mother) households? Do not a one of their students have a father or two hanging around? (Being raised by grandparents or other relatives, perhaps?) No? So what the fuck is with calling the MOMS?

Oh I'm sorry, I seem to have temporarily forgotten that dads' responsibility ends at ejaculation. Wait, no, we need them to pay the bills. Oh this was a bill? Oh right, we just need them to earn the money, but it's up to the mothers to actually make sure the chil'ens are actually fed, because we can't can't expect dads to keep track of little things like the survival of their kids.

Did you perchance notice my ire on this topic? Why, you ask? It's one word. Just one word. What's the big deal?

It's one word that carries with it the world of burden that sexist assumptions about parenting brings. It's one word that says sure there may or may not be men in the picture, but it's certainly not their job to keep track of lunch bills and permission slips and PTA meetings. It's one word that tells women fine, you can get a job if you need to, but heaven forbid you ever share the responsibility of childrearing; no, unto you falls all the hassles of work AND keeping track of everything about your children; only men are allowed off work after 5, you just shift jobs. It's one word that perfectly sums up the double standard of parenting, and it's one word that makes radfem instructions to avoid procreation to avoid perpetuating patriarchy seem to make sense. It's one word that if changed could change the world; it's one word that will probably only be changed when the whole world changes first.

I didn't hear the rest of the piece; my blood was boiling too loudly, and I snapped off the radio in self protection. The story actually had nothing to do with the calls to moms; that was just an aside, a fun little half-second bit to prop up the patriarchy and keep the wimmins in their place. Nothing, really. Just the dimminuization and essentialization of my entire self as woman with child. Just the erasure of my coparent's existence and responsibility. The story moved on, even if I could not, stuck and struck as I was by how much misogyny just one little word could convey.

But hey, the pizza was good.


* For an excellent piece this reminded the tiny part of my brain that hadn't just imploded at the word "moms" of, see Womanist Musings on If you're poor in New Mexico.

Monday, February 2, 2009

I am not a vagina

(I promise I'll post thoughtful, substantive, probably curse-free posts that actually mention the Boychick soon -- I have several ideas that are just waiting to get fleshed out -- but while my butt is being kicked and my energy sapped by the Cold of DOOM, you get short, pissed off, off-topic, substance-"lite" rants. Sorry. Only not.)

I don't care if it's a metaphor; I don't care if you're simultaneously getting your radfem on and calling out the colluders (although there seems something misogynistic in dismissing someone one disagrees with with accusations of pandering to the patriarchy, even if supporting hegemony is a result of the acts, but whatever); I don't care if you're using it ironically to point out the obvious sexism in choosing an anti-woman woman candidate to try to capture the woman vote:

Stop calling women vaginas.

Seriously. Just fucking stop. Stop using vagina as the badge of womanhood. Stop calling the token woman the vagina candidate. Stop saying the only difference between (cisgendered!*) men and women are penises and vaginas.

I'm so sick of hearing about women and vaginas. It may have been radical once, but by now, unless you are talking about vaginal birth, The Vagina Monologues, or where to put a tampon or diaphragm, the use of "vagina" is just both overused and underimpressive -- and it is really, really offensive. And yes, misogynistic.

So just. fucking. stop already.



*Seriously, can the use of "vagina=women" get more cissexist? Not only is vagina so not the be all end all of womanhood -- and yes, I don't care if you think you're pointing out the fallacy, or phallusy, of that tired meme, you are supporting and perpetuating it -- it's not even the most accurate if you want to get all scary stupid gender essentialist. How about uterus? That gets more to the "core" of the matter, and (bonus!) manages to exclude and offend even more women, whose uteri have retired, or been removed, or who were both without one for whatever reason. If you're going to be a sexist pig, might as well do it whole hog.

Sunday, February 1, 2009

Public Service Announcement

Do not ever read the comment section on posts about parents or children on a feminist blog that is not explicitly a feminist parenting blog. That shit is scary misogynistic bad. I'm usually good and pulling myself away from the worst of the web (a la goatse et al) but this particular brand of ugliness pulls me in like nothing else.

So, lesson learned: fight for the rights of women, unless they happen to be mothers, unless they are mothers who hate their kids and can afford a live in crew of nannies so they never take them out of the house until and unless they are Perfect Robotic Angels. Right. Glad we got that cleared up.

I need a shower. Is bleach anti-hate? It'll only sting for a little while, and if it erased the contact soul defilement, it might be worth it...

(And no, I'm not giving you a link or telling you where to look. I won't come over to your house when I have the flu, and I'm not tarnishing your soul with a link.)