Sunday, June 21, 2009

The Adventures of The Family Lactational, and a Fathers' Day postscript

Okeedoke, I was trying to write an entire actual, y'know, post to go with these comics, but... nah. Later, maybe.

For now, a quick explanation: several years ago, long before the Boychick's conception much less birth or extrauterine life (which is to say, way before I had any first-hand experience with any of this), I came up with the idea for a comic-based handbook for new fathers/non-lactating coparents. It would address the concerns non-lactating parents often express about how to be "involved" when their mamababy is a breastfeeding dyad. I liked the idea so much, I drew up half a dozen examples, starring the superheroes Nursing Mom, Supportive Partner (originally conceived as Super Dad, the rejection of which title and my ambivalence toward SP meriting a post to itself), and Amazing Babe.

They sucked.

But that's OK, because I liked them.

I redrew them, from lined paper (bad for photocopying) to beautiful textured journal paper (er, also bad for photocopying, in hindsight)... and then forgot them.

Well, not exactly forgot: I'd pull them out and look at them and go "hey, this was a neat idea!" every once in a while, and then I'd carefully put the originals back in to the journal with the newer sketches, and put the journal back on the shelf, and not do anything with them.

Consider this a slightly more public, virtual rendition of that tradition.

For your titillation (sorry, I had to), may I present the partial adventures of

The Family Lactational




[Image: Mom in rocker nursing baby, partner bringing plate with drink and apple. Text: Supportive Partner helps keep Nursing Mom hydrated and healthy!]


[Image: Partner wearing baby in sling, on a walk holding hands with mom. Text: Supportive Partner spends lots of time with Nursing Mom and Amazing Babe!]


[Image: Mom nursing babe in sling, partner blocking talking head pointing and "blah blah blah"ing. Text: Supportive Partner guards Nursing Mom from Interfering Ignorami!]


[Image: Partner and Mom in family bed, superhero capes hung up for the night, babe asleep in between them, cat at foot of bed. Text: Supportive Partner spends the night with Nursing Mom and Amazing Babe!]


But what I wanted to say with this, what I really wanted to say and have been having trouble finding the words for, is:

Beloved, when I drew these, I had no idea how far you would blow them out of the water with your fathering, your parenting, your love for our Boychick, your thoughtfulness for me. I had no idea how insulting these caricatures would be to the reality of your deep, rounded, complete parenthood. You had no need for such a guide, and could write your own handbook on how to be a parent (full-stop, not a coparent, not a helping parent, not a mom's-assistant father) as a feminist male in a patriarchal society -- and you should, because the world could and should learn from you: you do nothing miraculous, you never expect accolades for what you do, you expect more from yourself than any one, you just simply, and beautifully, parent our child. It should be nothing out of the ordinary, but it is, and it irritates you that it is, and for that alone, even if I didn't have the hundred thousand other reasons I have, I would love you.

Thank you. Happy Fathers' Day.

Friday, June 19, 2009

An entirely serious conversation, in prose

Gmail Chat, Friday night, 19 June 2009

Feminist X: I want a t-shirt that says Fight the Kyriarchy

me: Yes!
It'd need to have a definition on the back though!

Feminist X: we should have an Etsy store for it
except I can't stencil, lol

me: We'd have to source fair trade tshirts in XXS to 10XL.
Long and short sleeve, dye free no chem.
Mastectomy compatible.
Maternity and nursing.
Am I forgetting anything?
Men and women and unisex, of course.

Feminist X: :-D
I'm telling you...

me: Free alterations for assistant/medical devices as needed
Available embroidered in braille?

Feminist X: LOL

me: Oh, and optional add-ons for assistant animals!
Can't you see a seizure dog decked out in "Fight the Kyriarchy!" gear?
Maybe a flag for scooters and wheelchairs.
Stop me any time...

Feminist X: :-D I'm shaking too hard with laughing to stop you!
you're on a roll...

me: Alas, I think I'm out!

Feminist X: and they say feminists don't have a sense of humor!

Wednesday, June 17, 2009

28 day cycle! And let's talk about sex

(But no, I didn't ovulate on day 14. Interesting factoid: the cycle I did finally conceive the Boychick, I not only ovulated on day 14, but then birthed him at 40w9d, which is the actual average length of gestation for a spontaneous labor in a primipara. He was a by the book baby!)

So I started my period today, indicating another cycle we successfully evaded pregnancy, and I'd like to take a moment to wax lyrical about two of the contraceptive methods we use, both of which are generally poohpoohed or dismissed for the very reason I like them: they either require or accept the male partner's full involvement.

Method one: "coitus interruptus", or withdrawal. And no, I don't mean "pull and pray". Withdrawal, when practiced appropriately, is just about on par with condoms in preventing pregnancy (my edition of Contraceptive Technologies places it at 94% efficacy when practiced perfectly, compared to condoms' 95%; the above link places it more at 96% to condoms' 98%). The reasons it's not recommended, as opposed to condoms, are: it does diddly to protect against diseases, it's awfully hard for many to practice perfectly, and it requires the woman to trust and rely on her male partner.

My answer to both the first and the last reasons is: this is why it is not recommended outside of a healthy (emotionally and physically) monogamous relationship, but also why it is a good option inside of one. When almost all other forms of contraception require the woman to do the work (take a pill, get a shot, have a device inserted permanently or temporarily), it's wonderfully refreshing to have a method that requires the man's full buy in and participation, and puts the onus on him for once.

To the middle objection, that it's rarely put into perfect use: well, that's true. Most people don't even know what appropriate use of the withdrawal method calls for, which is:
  • either a lack of ejaculation or ejaculating far away from the vagina (pulling out barely in time only to spooge on the vulva really doesn't do any good)
  • AND a lack of having already ejaculated in the previous 24 hours
The reasoning for the second is that although "precum" (properly called pre-ejaculate) does not contain sperm (really!), it might wash out sperm that has been hanging out in the urethra from a previous ejaculation. But since sperm don't survive long at all outside of a fertile vaginal/uterine environment, even that small chance is over after 24 hours.

So, that's withdrawal: a perfectly acceptable and effective birth control method for those in an emotionally and physically healthy relationship, with a man willing and able to control himself during PIV (penis in vagina) sex, and who can refrain from orgasm in the 24 hours prior to the PIV moment.

The other, as y'all know by now, is the fertility awareness method. This one doesn't require full male participation (although it does require at least some, since it involves either abstaining or using back up methods during fertile times), but can: in our house, The Man's alarm goes off at 6:30am every morning, he gets out the thermometer, turns it on, and wakes me up enough to hand it to me, I stick it in my mouth until it beeps to indicate it's done, he takes it back, and when he gets up he records the temperature. He also records any factors that might influence the temperature, such as illness or time variation, and the date of any PIV sex and the backup contraceptive method used, if any. I (when I, erm, bother to) record my menstruation and cervical fluids (I also used to chart cervical texture and positioning, which was a really strong indicator, but alas that has become unreadable since birthing the Boychick), and do most of the interpreting.

I'm not going to debate or defend FAM much except to say that it is only as effective as the method used during fertile or unidentifiable times: that is, when full abstention is used during all potentially fertile times (about 1/3 of the month for the average woman, closer to 1/2 for me since I have such a short luteal phase), and potentially fertile times are indeed identifiable (they are not for all women) and defined quite conservatively, it can be highly effective. For us, because we use condoms and withdrawal methods during fertile times, it is closer to 94% (possibly even less, because the efficacy numbers for condoms and withdrawal come from using them across the cycle, not just during known fertile times), which we are comfortable with.

There's something fabulously feminist about a birth prevention method in which a male partner can participate so fully. Not only do I gain so much information about my body and its workings through charting (which would be reason enough to chart, even if a man weren't involved at all), but we can on occasion have "deliciously natural sex"* without me imbibing anything that alters or affects my biology, and The Man has to do most of the (minimal) work. What's not to love about that?

I've heard and understand the arguments why women shouldn't rely on men for their pregnancy prevention, and while I understand the need to avoid helpless dependence in most situations, I also think we can go too far into pathological independence. In certain types of relationships, both withdrawal and FAM can be used to encourage male involvement and investment in the birth control method, heighten the relationship between lovers and the quality of lovemaking, and build the best kind of interdependence wherein both parties work together for the benefit of all. And that's as feminist a goal for birth control methods as any I can think of.



*I love this phrase for PIV sex only inasmuch as "natural" is understood to mean "without barriers or other substances", and not implying that only PIV sex is "natural", which of course would be both false and offensive.

Monday, June 15, 2009

Irritations with Blogger, and the beginnings of a comment policy

Obviously, I need a new blog host, one that will actually inform me when I get new comments, instead of only if/when it feels like it/the moon aligns/some random key generator has been met/whatever the hell it is that makes it decide to inform me today and not half the other days.

Also, I obviously need a comments policy, because this is NOT the place to say X makes anyone a "bad mom/bad parent" if X does not equal abuse and/or murder -- and y'know what, even then said abuse is usually perpetuated due to having previously experienced abuse and misogyny and often occurs in conjunction with untreated or poorly treated mental illness, so let's just skip it altogether, shall we? Again, I'm not denying that "bad moms" exist, I'm just saying that that shit is way too complicated and inevitably exists within a kyriarchal framework, actively antagonistic to women who parent, and I would much rather be focusing on the root causes of abusive parenting than assigning blame (which does absolutely nothing to help) to individual perpetrator/victim women.

And still more lessons from recent debacles, if you refer to your spouse as "wifey" (and not in an ironical reclaiming queer way), and me as "lady" (and not in a hot and/or respectful "I agree completely, my lady!" way), odds are really, really great I'm gonna delete your ass comment.

Further, this is so not the place to play protect the patriarchy through straw arguments, m'kay? It's one thing if you don't understand what I mean by "the patriarchy" or "the kyriarchy" or any other womanist/feminist term, want to learn more, and are asking sincere questions, but another altogether if you come in with your own, erroneous, definition, and call me misguided based on that.

And while I'm at it, let me make abundantly, explicitly clear that to the best of my ability, I will protect this place from comments that are willfully sexist, classist, racist, cissexist, transphobic, homophobic, heterosexist, ableist, sizeist, fatphobic, ageist, or in any other way exhibit fear, prejudice, or discrimination toward any other person based on an immutable or inherent characteristic about themselves -- and yes, that includes bullshit arguments over whether things like fat and queerness are inherent or immutable, 'cause they are. I know I'm gonna slip up and things will slip in, either through Blogger messing up and failing to inform me such a comment has been posted, or through my own ignorance and unexamined privilege and prejudice, and so I respectfully and humbly request y'all's assistance, and promise that when such slip ins/slip ups are pointed out to me, I will thank you, apologize, fix it, and move on.

Spam, obviously, is right out.

Within this comment policy, there is room for disagreement and debate, and ginormous room for discussion and developing our feminist discourse; there is only a dearth of room for discrimination or the defense thereof.

Comments welcome.

Sunday, June 14, 2009

Raising a not-rapist

This post is dedicated to Ruth Moss, who put up two posts both of which prompted and contributed to this one.

In her most recent (because, of course, I never quite managed to finish my response to the older), she poses the question:
...surely in that Glorious Utopian Future gender won’t matter at all anyway? Why would I treat my kid any differently than a girl if he turns out to be making the journey along the “path to manhood“?
And the answer is, of course, that men rape (among other things; in this post I will primarily be focusing on rape, although this argument is equally applicable to the fact that men beat, murder, attack, and abuse).

Not all men, of course, or most men, not even only men; but, in overwhelming majority, rapists are men, and far too large a minority of men prove they are capable of rape.

As Ruth put it so well in the older post, the only way to stop rape is: "Men refusing to rape. That will stop rape."

I have a son. He is a boy, who will grow in to a man.* He will have the potential to rape. The only way to be sure he does not become a rapist is to make sure he learns not to rape.

That is the difference between raising boys and raising girls: we need to raise both of them free of gender stereotypes and arbitrary gender roles, but to ignore their sex and the roles their gender will push them toward in society is as ridiculous a proposition as raising children "colorblind" in regards to race: all it does is reify the dominant paradigm, prop up racism and sexism and the entire kyriarchy, because we cannot fight what we do not acknowledge exists. In this case, that is the truth that some boy children will grow up to be rapists.

This is something a lot of parents don't want to think about -- I know I would really rather not. This is my perfect little baby we're talking about! And he is; he is beautiful, and sweet, and loving, and empathetic, and caring, and absolutely perfect.

Of course, every baby is perfect. And yet, some men are rapists. Somehow, perfect babies grow up in to men who rape. It would be so easy, so reassuring, to hide behind the lie that it couldn't happen to my baby, that I don't have to think about that, that that only happens to those other people and their defective children. But that line of thinking is just another tool of the patriarchy, trying to defend itself; if it can just make us blind enough, we'll do all the defending it needs for it.

No, the only way to make sure that my boy does not become a rapist is to teach him not to rape. And that starts now.

Ruth also asks:
...I do think we have influence. Or at least, I hope we do. Because I don’t want my kid to grow into One of Those Men. So where to start?
It starts with teaching him that no means no, and that only yes means yes. It means that even though his best friend is almost a year older than he is (just-3, to his over-2), and taller, and larger, and more energetic, and arguably more aggressive -- even though she is all that, he is male, and she is not, and while I don't encourage her to walk all over him either, I do insist that he really listen to her noes, or make sure he gets yeses, when he wants to hug and kiss and touch and play with her.

It starts with teaching him that I have boundaries and limits and needs, too; this is a tough one, because I also believe that the more a child's needs are unconditionally met now, in infancy and toddlerhood and childhood, the better off they are for a lifetime. I encounter this conflict primarily when he needs to nurse (often it is a true need, whether for nutrition or liquid or comfort or sleep) and my body is feeling touched out. I'm not sure where the best balance is between these two needs, but I know we will both be better off for trying to find it together, rather than subsuming myself entirely to his demands.

And yes, as Ruth points out, it also starts with teaching him that his own feelings matter, that his own noes are respected, that those who are bigger and stronger do not get what they want through force and committing violence upon those who are smaller and weaker. Remember, the patriarchy creates rapists by raping them; it creates soldiers who can look at a person and see only a soulless enemy by first dehumanizing them; it creates bullies by bullying them when they are younger. The most revolutionary thing when raising a boy, then, is to protect and respect his humanity; not place his right to personal agency on a pedestal, or place him at the center of the universe, as the patriarchy does, but to ground him in soul-full humanity, help him grow up centered in his own being, capable of saying "namaste" to others because the divine is still in him to honor the divine in others.

In short, and coming back down from my culturally-appropriating neo-Pagan high, raising not-rapists means raising our boys womanist/feminist, protecting them to the best of our power from the damage the patriarchy would do to them.

I'm not saying I know exactly how to do all this. I don't know exactly how to balance his needs for me and my need for me, or wanting to encourage him to be friendly with wanting to ensure he gets permission from others first, or his need to be fully human with recognizing the ways in which male privilege structures only him-as-male as fully a person. And I'm sure there are more aspects of this endeavor that I haven't figured out yet. But I do think these are good places to start.




*Probably. The odds are certainly enough slanted to him being a cissexed male that I must, in this post and in parenting him, take certain actions based on that assumption.

Friday, June 12, 2009

100th post, and a call to de-lurk

So, I don't know if I've mentioned this, but I have this slight streak of perfectionism, combined with a crazy voice mental illness that likes to pick up and run with any slight hesitations or doubts that I might have, thereby leaving me paralyzed and unable to do so much as "any" much less "good enough" because then it wouldn't be "perfect".

Plus, we seem to have a virus, possibly of the porcine variety.

So, I say fuck that shit. Perfection is the enemy of good enough, so I'm going to cough and hack and spit in its general direction until it's soaking the sheets in bed, addled by fever enough that it can't block me from just putting up a damn post already, even if said post sort of sucks.

When I started this blog, well, I didn't start it. I had the fabulous idea that Someone Should write a blog about the experience of being a feminist raising a boy child (little knowing that, um, it ain't exactly a new idea), and came up with a catchy title for it, and went and registered it on Blogger. And did nothing.

Did I mention the perfectionism -> paralysis thing?

It wasn't until a kick-ass writer friend of mine started her own fab (if under-updated) blog that I mentioned my idea to her, and she triple-dog-dared (ordered, actually) me to start posting to it, at which time I, snowed in (in Portland!) and with nothing better to do, put up an introductory post that set the bar so damn low that even I, tied up by perfectionism's tendrils of doubt and self-flagellation, could trip over it.

Then I remembered a post I'd written elsewhere and put that up*, because I thought it was worth saving, and then wrote a fair amount of filler crap, and a couple interesting (if somewhat straw-based) posts, and got caught by the bug. I was going to Blog, give it the good college try (is this the right place to mention I've tried college no less than four times and have yet to graduate?), publish posts daily every two out of three days every other day frequently(ish).

And here we are.

I'm still just starting. I still swear I'm going to prune down my label list, make my own Wordpress theme, buy a domain, and move the blog somewhere prettier and more functional. I still know I have so damn much to learn about my own privilege and prejudices, and needless to say I still have at least 90% left to go in this high-intensity-parenting gig.

But 100 posts? A sizable chunk of which are actually worth reading? That's pretty cool.

So come celebrate with me. Leave a present: a comment, saying anything, just letting me know you read here, regularly or occasionally. Let me know what you like about the blog, let me know what you want to see in the future, say congrats or good job or keep trying. I know I'm crap at responding to comments, but I read every one, usually about 20 times. So drop a line. It'll be your good deed for the day.

And now if you'll excuse me, I'm going to go down some C and snuggle in bed with perfectionism. We're both pretty miserable.




*Some of these posts contain language and comparisons I wouldn't use now, like putting "bad mother" on par with "the n word" (both because, dude, so not in the same league, and because competing oppressions against each other is always a no-win enterprise). Entering the blogosphere, both in reading other blogs and writing out my own thoughts, has been educational and a growing experience in ways I had never anticipated, and that's a large part of what has kept me going**.

**The rest, of course, being comments from readers, nudge nudge.

Sunday, June 7, 2009

The blogger revealed

I know there haven't been any photos of me on here, nor do I have so much as a profile picture (even though there have been pictures of the Boychick galore, and even of The Man). But it's not some conspiracy, not a deliberate choice for some misplaced reason of delusions of modesty or anonymity/pseudonymity (I'm aware anyone with half a brain and an hour on google could get enough information about me to be really irritating or scary if so inclined).

No, it's just that I don't tend to like photos of myself. And few enough of my close friends or relations are good enough photographers to have produced many photos good enough for me to like (those who are good photographers tend to, rightly!, focus on my beautiful child).

I know it's both cliched and rather patriarchal to dislike being photographed, but here's the thing: I actually like the way I look. I think I'm pretty hot. I even know I'm beautiful. I am not ashamed to show myself, my fat, pale, hairy, un-make-up-ed self, in tank tops and shorts and itty bitty string bikinis. My body image and self confidence are in fact quite spectacularly good, especially considering I am a white American female.

That is, until I see myself in photos. Then, I cringe and feel ugly and start to think I should avoid short sleeves, tight clothing, and revealing my face in public.

I don't know which is the lie and which the truth. I don't know whether I have an inflated ego normally, or know only photographers who mostly fail at capturing my beauty and grace. But if the image of myself in my head is fantastical, then I choose to live in ignorance. I would rather believe myself beautiful and be wrong than to know the truth and defile my soul with self-hatred.

So there aren't a lot of photos of myself around, and fewer still I'm happy to share. But since I don't actually want to be faceless, I've been keeping an eye out for photos to use, and I think I may have had some not-totally-cringe-worthy taken recently at a fair.

Without further ado, I lift teh intarwebz curtain, and reveal the blogger behind the posts:


Wait, not what you had in mind? You wanted my face? Ok, how about this?


Still not good enough? Geez you're picky. Here, I'm looking straight at the camera in this!


*ducks* Ok, ok, I relent: the pictures those were originally based on:



(Is anyone surprised they're nursing pics?)

So what say you, readership? My 100th post is coming up (this is #99!), and I'd rather like to have a profile pic by then. See anything you like? Post a vote in the comments. (Bear in mind, although I am willing to share these photos, they're still not easy for me to look at. And no, I'm not fishing for compliments, just commenting on the state of my crazy. Nice face paint though, huh?)

Thursday, June 4, 2009

Racism in my brain

This is going to be another not-very-fun post for me to write.

First, let me say that I love being reminded of the ways in which humans are at essence primates. We are so very, very similar to our also-primate cousins in so many ways, and it makes me smile to notice the behaviors that are so obviously primate based: the way we touch to communicate and cement relationships, how we use grooming to comfort, the group dynamics that tell us instantly when people in a crowd are part of a family. Maybe I'm weird, but seriously, that makes me happy.

This, however, does not.

Yesterday I was driving along, and glanced over at a car next to me. There was a lovely Asian family driving and having a conversation. The shape of their faces, with the mouth just a little farther (farther from what? from mine, from a more European face, from "normal") out from their faces, reminded me of chimpanzees. Which, not really thinking about it, reminded me that humans are primates, which made me smile.

The smile froze on my face, as I realized holy shit, that is fucking racist.

Using oneself and one's body as the base model to which all others are compared is normal human (primate, I would argue) thinking, but becomes extremely problematical when the "I" doing the thinking is a member of a race which systematically and horrifically has dominated and oppressed all other races throughout history, so that's a big damn problem right there. And the trope that people of color are more like animals, more animalistic, closer to animals and less evolved (again, using white as "normal" from which other races "deviate") is one of the more pervasive, evil racist constructions, which has been used to justify the enslavement, murder, colonization, and de-humanization of millions of people. And it's in my brain.

When really looked at, it's obvious the construction is such bullshit, too. The very darkness of skin of people of color is, rather than being "animalistic", a sign of more evolution away from our primate cousins: chimpanzees underneath their fur, just like white/European humans, have no need for skin pigmentation, and are therefore pale. The excessive hairiness of limb, torso, and male face of white humans is more similar to our furry relations than is the comparatively lesser hairiness of many other races. So it would be easy and at least as accurate to construct an argument that white people are the more animalistic, the less evolved, the less human; or at least (and most accurately) to see in all humans things that remind us of other animals: face here, hair there, and all of us so obviously primates in body and behavior.

But that's not the way racism works. Whiteness has constructed itself as normal, human, most highly evolved, and all others as deviations and therefore lesser. In this framework, in which we all reside and by which my brain has been thoroughly colonized, whiteness cannot be understood as animal-like because whiteness defines what "human" is; only those who are outside of whiteness can be understood to be different from human and therefore like animals.

And it's in my brain.

I didn't even know about it. I had known about and hated the trope of the "savage, animalistic darkie", scoffed at those who used it, gotten angry at examples of it along with everyone else, and I never realized it was part of my own thinking. How could it be? That's a horrible, evil, racist thought, and I'm not racist, so I couldn't think like that.

But I do.

As a feminist, trying to raise my white male child in a womanist/feminist, anti-racist, anti-kyriarchy manner, to come across such a blatantly racist construction in my own mind is pretty damn horrifying. It's entirely too tempting to shove it aside, to not think about it, to deny it: and that is white privilege. White privilege means not having to think about race or to acknowledge racism when I encounter it, even (especially) in my own thinking. White privilege means I can accept that whiteness=normal, because I am white and it is human nature to think of ourselves as the norm. White privilege means everything in my culture is telling me "you are normal, you are the standard, you are the pinnacle from which all others are deviations"; white privilege means I could choose to not feel bad, to not think too hard, to not talk about it, to not admit it. I would not be directly hurt if I allowed this racism to continue; I would only be going along with the status quo and no one with power would blame me: that is white privilege.

I choose not to accept that privilege (it is white privilege that I have a choice, and I cannot do away with that privilege), and so I expose that thought, talk about it, deconstruct it, and work to do away with it from my own mind.

Now I wonder: how do I stop the thought from colonizing the Boychick's mind? When everything in his culture is telling him whiteness, and therefore he, is the default, when his own normal egocentricism agrees, how do I combat it? I can point out the ways in which all humans look and act like the animals we are; I can talk about how his father is hairy just like other primates, and how he will eventually be as well; I can avoid the "colorblind" ideology that prohibits mention of race at all, thereby reinforcing the white-as-standard meme: but I don't know if that will be enough.

The only thing I am certain of is that it is only possible to counter and defend against something when we know it's there, and so I am grateful to that racist thought, in debt to that family: for without the realization that came after, I would still be coasting along, smug in my superiority, unaware I carried that ugly construct within myself.

Wednesday, June 3, 2009

Tiny hiatus

My parents are in town from out of state (yaaaaay!), so blogging will likely be slow for the next week while they're here.

Tiny updates for the tiny post on the tiny hiatus:
  • The Man had an in-person interview yesterday that went well, but we won't hear back for another week. Cross your fingers for us.
  • I passed my Kinesiology Lower practical final with 98/100, and the comprehensive written final with 99/100 (without having a chance to study). W00t!
  • Massage Lower practical final is tomorrow, and you have no idea how much I'm looking forward to being on the receiving end. Want. Massage!
  • Twitter is weird.
Told you they were tiny updates. Back to full time blogging next week.

Monday, June 1, 2009

Flash-bulb moment: musings on parking spaces and bipolar disorder

I was reading about the Australian disability parking scheme bruhaha at Hoyden About Town, when I read this quote (long, but worth it):

These existing schemes usually have some kind of distance measure, which says something like ‘person’s impairment would be unduly affected by walking 50m/100m.’ When you compare the “harmonisation” proposal with that, something becomes clear: what they’re doing is mandating what kind of impairment you have, rather than assessing the effect of the combination of the impairment and the disabling context of distant or inaccessible parking. We’re moving away from an acknowledgement of the way that parking requirements can be disabling for particular people, whatever their type of impairment, and at reducing that disability by accommodations. We’re moving towards configuring particular people as ‘deserving’ based on an assessment of the type of their impairment or their dependency.

One of the major problems here is that it requires PWD to provide evidence of dependency. You have to prove that if you push yourself too hard, if you work beyond your known limits and ‘act’ like an able-bodied person, not only that you can’t do it but that you will need physical help from another person to walk. It makes dependence, again, the supposed essence of disability, and it attributes this to the individual, rather that seeing it as occurring at the intersection of ‘normal’ parking and impairment.


And my eyes popped wide and my jaw went slack; something clicked for me.

I've long struggled with trying to resolve my identity as a person with mental illness, my current status as basically sane and stable, and the fact that I haven't, don't, won't, and probably just can't hold down a traditional full time office job.

Lots of people with bipolar disorder do manage it, just fine, both with and without medication. My dad's work, the responsibility and need to drag himself out of bed every morning, was at times the only thing that kept him going at all. My brother, with the help of medication, thrives in a high stress, high stakes job in the financial industry. So why can't I? is the refrain the crazy voice uses to castigate me with.

These quotes did two things for me: one, pointed out the fallacy of categorizing people's need for accommodations based on diagnosis, rather than disability. That is, what does it matter that someone else with my diagnosis can work? I can't. Saying "but they do!" isn't going to change my own ability, and it's ridiculous to try to make it.

Two, and the more "aha!" of the points, although you'd think I'd have learned this by now (I know I've brought up the spoon theory here before), is that, just like the person with an invisible physical disability who "could" walk farther, all that trying to pretend that I am "normal", that I am not disabled, does for me is wear me out and make me sick.

Ironic (Alanis Morissettey definition) isn't it, that as long as I acknowledge that I am sick, then I can be well. If I try to pretend I am not, if I park myself too far from my destination, push myself too hard, then I will get sick.

This is something I've known for a while (I don't try to work full time, after all, and the Boychick is only a part of that), but I've never entirely been comfortable with it. Reading about others, who have "real", physical, if too oft-maligned, disabilities, struggle with the same issue, if in a different plane, was eye-opening for me. It is only the crazy voice, which does its best to convince me I'm not "really" sick (does that amuse anyone else? the crazy voice saying I'm not crazy?), that would have me disassociate from others with disabilities; but if I acknowledge and accept my shared commonalities with people with physical disabilities, suddenly I feel, and act, much saner.

I don't know the course of my disease, much less my life: I may yet wind up over the edge, hospitalized and incapacitated; I may yet wind up thriving in an office 40 hours a week. But one thing I am certain of: the more I push myself toward the latter, denying myself the accommodations I need and deserve, the more likely I'll find myself in the former.

Further, and worse, as the HAT article points out is happening with physical disabilities in Australia, I am not offered accommodations by the state (or society at large), because as long as I don't try to act sane, I remain sane. I do not meet, as WildlyParenthetical says, the medical/dependency model of "disabled": as long as I do not seek to work in a traditional job, I am able to dress myself, get out of the house, make required phone calls, pay my bills (with money my partner earns for us), and do all those things that the state uses as markers for sanity/ability. I can even manage to do those things when I am unstable from working: I am "unduly affected", and have panic attacks before every call and during every trip to the store, but I still technically could, and thus fail to meet the medical model of disability, so I am denied any work compensation or disability acknowledgments.

And I manage despite this only because I exist with so much privilege: my race, my class, my partnership with a man, my (for now) lack of any other cognitive or physical disabilities. Because of all that, I don't really need the disability benefits I am denied: I have income and health insurance from other sources, access to health care providers, resources to purchase the substances that help keep me sane. Many others like me do not exist with such an abundance of privilege, and are, literally, driven crazy, and only then (and only if they are still lucky and probably privileged) are they "gifted" with acknowledgment of their disability and assistance from society.

I trust I do not need to explain just how horrifying this is, how wrong, and how no (hah!) sane society would allow this state of affairs to continue.

So I'll take that parking spot, thank you, and I'll fight anyone who tries to take away from me or any of my people. Will you join us?



ETA Those of you in Australia can act directly on this particular parking space issue with a letter to government or an open letter to organizations. Thank you!