Tuesday, March 3, 2009

Why "presumably-straight"?

My friend Lisa asked in a comment on another post:
Why do you say your son is "presumably straight"?
It's a good question, one I realized I haven't explicitly answered anywhere yet. In thinking about it, it seems to come down to three things:
  1. He probably is (going to be) straight. Even with a queer-identified mother (which may or may not affect the odds, and if so, doesn't very much), he has, what, a 90-99% chance of identifying as heterosexual, depending on whose numbers you believe? So, simply, I use "presumably" because it sounds better than "probably", and he probably is.

  2. Although he probably is (going to be) straight, he might not be. Saying he "presumably" is straight is opening up the door to the idea that he might be something other than straight, and hopefully challenges people's assumptions. Which brings us to:

  3. In our heterosexist, heteronormative society, he is presumed by the wider culture (to the point of few even being aware of the presumption) to be straight until proven otherwise. While I do my best to resist this presumption, or to counter it when we encounter it, I cannot entirely do away with it, as much as I might wish. I sometimes feel I can hardly do away with it at all. The vast majority of interactions he has with others are and will continue to be based on the presumption that he is (going to be) straight, and this assumption/presumption colors far more than we are usually aware. Whether or not it turns out to be who in fact he is (he might turn out to not be a "he" at all; I could easily add "presumably" in front of male as well), he will be seen by most in his life as a straight white male (yes, even as a toddler; even at birth!), with all the privilege and roles and stereotypes thereof; and it will affect him, subtly and profoundly; and my only hope of countering the damage those role assignments bring lies in first recognizing them.
Thus presumably-straight.

Monday, March 2, 2009

My new favorite word, and some kick-ass links

My new favorite word? Kyriarchy.
Kyriarchy - a neologism coined by Elisabeth Schussler Fiorenza and derived from the Greek words for “lord” or “master” (kyrios) and “to rule or dominate” (archein) which seeks to redefine the analytic category of patriarchy in terms of multiplicative intersecting structures of domination…Kyriarchy is best theorized as a complex pyramidal system of intersecting multiplicative social structures of superordination and subordination, of ruling and oppression.
That is it, all over. It gets the win. I'm using it as frequently as I can from now on. I blame the kyriarchy. I should rename the blog that (nah). But still: love.

On to things I wish I'd said:

This woman's work
over at Spilt Milk
But the bulk of emotionwork within families remains a burden that women bear. Some of the blame for that needs to lie with women themselves who, in hanging onto whatever small powers they feel able to weild, continue to perpetuate the myth that men are hopeless and oafish when it comes to finer points of running a connected household. Relinquishing this sham is essential to laying down some of the burden. But we can’t discount that traditional gender roles and the structures - especially workplaces - which continue to both support and rely on them are the main reason why women must do most emotionwork[...]
(My reply, minus the giddy jig of joy: "This is what’s so often missing even in households where housework is supposedly shared “equally”. The woman (especially if she’s the mother) is the one to keep track of who needs to do what when, and organizes and cares for the family’s social life/relationship obligations. This more than the dishes or the nappy changes seems to be the last bastion of “women’s work” even among the “enlightened” men I know.")

On squeaky wheels at Shapely Prose:
Kate recently defined privilege as “the luxury of not thinking about it much,” which I think is perfect. One of the consequences of privilege, then, is that if you want people to be inclusive of you, you often have to remind them that you exist. It sucks to have to do this all the time, which is part of why so many people — particularly those struggling to understand their own privilege — confuse privilege with prejudice or ignorance. Even if you’re not actively oppressing those who lack the privileges you have, you are oppressing them by failing to consider them part of the status quo, by requiring them to make explicit requests for basic representation or consideration. We need to be aware of that when it comes to the privileges we have — do you, by default, consider everybody or only the people whose experiences you find familiar?
Which makes me want to delve in to the post on privilege and "in the family" that's been bubbling away in my cranium for a while ("The Boychick and Dykes to Watch Out For!" how can you not love that title?), but as it is I'm on borrowed time here. Which is to say: this is me, putting off one thing (actually, three or a dozen+ things, depending on how we're counting) by coming here to say I'm putting off another thing. Yes, I have achieved multitasking procrastination! Just one of my many talents I get to hone to a fine edge thanks to having the Boychick in tow.

But for now, I'll leave you with a call to head over to Raise the Change to answer a question I posed there on Women's History Month:
I read some really interesting critiques of Black History Month last month (check out Womanist Musings's thoughts on the topic), and was wondering if any of the same applies to Women's History month. Is it a good thing to be spotlighted like this? An unfortunate practice that will be unnecessary after the revolution? A ghettoization that keeps us in our place? What are your thoughts?
Feel free to leave an answer in the comments, though I'd love to see you over there as well. Also note that I hesitated a long time before using the word "ghettoization", and ultimately used it because I could think of none better; caring critiques and alternate suggestions welcome.

Friday, February 27, 2009

What price mental health? part I

I've decided to publish this article in most-likely-three parts, after seeing how long just the preamble was, then how much length the now-lost (thanks, iPhone) second part added to it, and knowing how much I wanted to talk about in the final section. The overall piece is on the literal and figurative costs of bipolar disorder: getting to sanity, staying sane while parenting, and raising a child with a high likelihood of inheriting the tendency. Part one is the preamble, which gives a glimpse of my history and offers some of my perspective on recovering from and living with this disease.

As previously mentioned, I have a diagnosis of Bipolar Disorder Type II, Rapid Cycling, with Mixed States. There are lots of other places that talk about mental health and emotional disorders and bipolar disease, although if you hang around here long enough you'll doubtless get a good picture of what it's been like for me (since it's a different experience for everyone; just in my immediate family, there are three of us with more or less the "same" disease, and three vastly different experiences). But what you really need to know to understand my story is:
  • Psychotropic medicines suck. They are a kind of bandage: sometimes they are a well-placed Ace bandage over a sprained ankle, which is great and effective; sometimes they're a dirty wad of guaze over an arterial hemorrhage, which is not not so great but might be better than nothing; and sometimes they're the Disney (R) Princess (TM) Bandaid (TM) that gets lodged in your throat and on which you choke to death, which is, y'know, bad. For me they were probably dirty guaze: they kept me, barely, from bleeding to death, but gave me a raging infection to struggle with as well (if you will excuse the overextended metaphor).

  • Bipolar disorder sucks worse. Mixed state, which I basically lived in for several years, especially sucks horrifically gawdawfully bad; think of it as high energy self-hatred. You know, the self-loathing of depression but with the energy to actually do something about it. This aspect of this disease is not only not enjoyable, it is highly lethal, with suicide attempts (already ridiculously high in the bipolar population) being even more likely in those with mixed states, and possibly more "successful".

  • Bipolar disorder is a highly complicated disease, with biological and psychological and environmental components (as though the three can ever be separated); it is, however, fundamentally a disease, like diabetes, or fibromyalgia, and deserves no more or less infamy or stigma or survivor-blame than any other disease, which is to say none at all. I think we'd all appreciate it if you understood The Spoon Theory, but we are, basically, just plain persons, just like you. It is not catching; you do not need to avoid us like the plague, or as though we were beset by demons.

  • And yet, I get why people with mental illness used to be (and in some areas still are) considered possessed. I do feel at times like the disease is an It, a thing with a life and a mind of its own, and what it wants more than anything else in the world is for me to be sick, so it can be strong. Feeling inhabited by a dark, inimical Other that would, if its will be done, bring about your destruction is a curse I would not wish on anyone.

  • At the same time, bipolar is part of my identity. It is a part of the indefinable me. I would not choose to not be born, or to be born without it. (I would not be me if I had been born without it.) I obviously did not choose to avoid having children to avoid passing it on, as some psychiatrists have infamously advocated, and the thought of a genetic test with its resultant "therapeutic" abortion for fetuses carrying the genes horrifies me. I don't romanticize the disorder, but nor would I rid humanity of it even if I could; if the problem is in part that we are at risk for premature death, then it is the world that must change so that we can survive, not we who must be made not to exist in the first place.

  • Being a rapid cycler with mixed states, I don't think (much) in terms of "up" or "down", I think in terms of being stable or not. I never knew stability in my adult life; I went straight from childhood to adolescence and instability, with the instability growing ever stronger even as the wild hormonal ride of adolescence receded. Truly it could be said that I did not know who "I" was. Struggling toward sanity was searching by feel in the darkness for something I had never known and had only the vaguest descriptions of from others. When one has never known normalcy, how does one know whether one has it? When every mood swing has been a potential disaster, a symptom of illness, how does one know what a "normal" or "healthy" range of mood feels like? When each change of mood brings anxiety over what it might foreshadow based on what it's brought in the past, how does one settle into the contentedness of now?

The things it took to bring me from hell to now (not heaven, but the glorious mundanity of earth) were: talk therapy; psychotropic medications; massage therapy; acupuncture; lots and lots of fish oil; and lifestyle and thought pattern and dietary changes too numerous and subtle to list here (arguably the biggest and most important of those: regular and regulated sleep, which is one of the many reasons new parents whether biological or not are at risk for PPD and other postpartum disorders). It took several years, and a hell of a lot of work, and ultimately required moving across the country out of a psychic-black-hole cesspool of a house and to a city where my heart sang "Home!" to get to a real, lasting, joyful stability.

And it cost a lot of money.

cont. in part II...

Say WHAT now?!

In the car, The Man had NPR on to entertain the Boychick whilst waiting for me to bring the pizza (drool) out. We drive off, too busy munching and avoiding downtown traffic to turn off the radio. There's some interview going on about a "lunch lady" (yes, the reporter actually called her a "lunch lady", which should have been my first clue) who took the job just to have something to do while her kids were at work, ended up staying to pay the bills, still here 15 years later, etc, yadda yadda. And then, says the announcer, it's time for the part of her job where she calls up the moms that haven't paid their children's lunch bills*.

The moms.

The moms.

The fucking MOMS.

Excuse me? Excuse fucking me? Is this "lunch lady" living in the district of exclusively single mother (or two mother) households? Do not a one of their students have a father or two hanging around? (Being raised by grandparents or other relatives, perhaps?) No? So what the fuck is with calling the MOMS?

Oh I'm sorry, I seem to have temporarily forgotten that dads' responsibility ends at ejaculation. Wait, no, we need them to pay the bills. Oh this was a bill? Oh right, we just need them to earn the money, but it's up to the mothers to actually make sure the chil'ens are actually fed, because we can't can't expect dads to keep track of little things like the survival of their kids.

Did you perchance notice my ire on this topic? Why, you ask? It's one word. Just one word. What's the big deal?

It's one word that carries with it the world of burden that sexist assumptions about parenting brings. It's one word that says sure there may or may not be men in the picture, but it's certainly not their job to keep track of lunch bills and permission slips and PTA meetings. It's one word that tells women fine, you can get a job if you need to, but heaven forbid you ever share the responsibility of childrearing; no, unto you falls all the hassles of work AND keeping track of everything about your children; only men are allowed off work after 5, you just shift jobs. It's one word that perfectly sums up the double standard of parenting, and it's one word that makes radfem instructions to avoid procreation to avoid perpetuating patriarchy seem to make sense. It's one word that if changed could change the world; it's one word that will probably only be changed when the whole world changes first.

I didn't hear the rest of the piece; my blood was boiling too loudly, and I snapped off the radio in self protection. The story actually had nothing to do with the calls to moms; that was just an aside, a fun little half-second bit to prop up the patriarchy and keep the wimmins in their place. Nothing, really. Just the dimminuization and essentialization of my entire self as woman with child. Just the erasure of my coparent's existence and responsibility. The story moved on, even if I could not, stuck and struck as I was by how much misogyny just one little word could convey.

But hey, the pizza was good.


* For an excellent piece this reminded the tiny part of my brain that hadn't just imploded at the word "moms" of, see Womanist Musings on If you're poor in New Mexico.

Wednesday, February 25, 2009

A quick plug for a new forum

Friends of mine have recently launched Raise the Change, a website whose purpose I can wholeheartedly get behind:

Raise the Change is committed to respectful and open discussion about political and cultural topics that affect us as women, mothers and global citizens. Our worldview is liberal and progressive.

Although when I first saw just the name, I thought it was one of those "25c a day can send a girl to school for a year!" charities (get it? raising some change?), I quickly figured out it was a take on Ghandi's famous dictum "You must be the change you want to see in the world": as feminist women, we have the chance to raise the change we want to see in the world, which is exactly what I'm trying to do here at Raising My Boychick. They, however, propose to offer just what I lack: the dissemination, discussion, and dissection of the world-issues that create the stage on which we are trying to raise our own individual chicks. Same topics, different angle.

Plus, Bethany and Jessica rock my socks.

So go, check it out, join the forums, post some articles, bring some issues, hash them out. Help get the conversations started.

It's all about the lunches

I have determined that my sanity as a parent and our ability to do the paid-work/care-for-kid split without the usual resulting disconect and resentment is due to lunches. Specifically, that The Man comes home for lunch every day, with rare, difficult exceptions (like today). He also has been known to go in late (er, sometimes really late), take long lunches, and views 5pm as his deadline for leaving the office; staying late means not getting out until 5:15, and happens maybe once a month.

But mostly, it's the lunches. It's the fact that I never have to face 8 or 9 uninterrupted hours by myself with the Boychick. It's the fact that thanks to sleep schedules and naps, the Boychick is usually without his dad around for no more than half his waking day, often less. It's the fact that if dinner needs prep work, we usually do it together at lunch. It's that I do get a lunch break, during which I don't have to deal with another's feces, I can eliminate mine in peace, I can shower with the child on the other side of the door, and I get hugs and adult conversation and a sympathetic ear. It's that sometimes, even, I can have lunch out without having sole responsibility for an always-potentially-cranky toddler. Lunches together make all the difference in the world, which is never so clear as when I find myself alone for lunch with no alternate plans and a roast to start and a loaf to shape and a toddler to save ffrom himself, such as today.

It is part luck that allows us this, and a heap of privilege as well to be sure, but it was also something worked for, chosen, deliberately and determinedly pursued. He guards his lunch jealously, and his evenings rigidly, and refuses travel that by rights his work could demand of him or release him for; and it costs him in networking and advancement and annual review points, but it gains him so much: his family, his lover's sanity, his child's delight. This, far far more than any earning potentially lost, is his responsibility and his right as a father. This is how men can work and sacrifice for the good of their family. Not 80 hour workweeks, but 5 hours of lunches. Just by coming home. Just lunch.

Monday, February 23, 2009

Readers' choice!

So, since it looks like I'm only going to have a chance to do one good-sized post this crazy week, I thought I'd ask you, my loyal readers, which of my several potential topics you'd like me to write about next. There are many fermenting in my brain as we speak, and while I'd love to get to them all today (hah!), school and family and work and health obligations dictate only ONE must be chosen for now! So for your selection and control freak pleasure, which of these would you have me pick:

1) Breastfeeding and choice (a sort of follow up to my prochoice abortion post)
2) What price mental health?
3) Privilege and getting called out on -isms (a sort of response to a recent piece at Womanist Musings)
4) Passing for straight: parenting with a man as a queer-identified woman

So there you go. I guarantee that vote count will be fair and accurate and may have no relevence to the final outcome, and both welcome your alternate suggestions and reserve the right to get caught up in a totally different topic that simply Must Get Covered Now. But odds are good that my next post will be on whatever you, yes YOU, pick for me. So vote now!

Sunday, February 22, 2009

Three hour naps, how I miss you...

There is so much I want to write about. Race and privilege; gender and privilege; cisgender and privilege; sexuality and passing; mental health and mental illness; fat parents and a skinny child; babywearing and the lack thereof; breastfeeding and its gradual decrease; and so, so many things about raising this Boychick who is such a bright beautiful light in my life and how I want to raise him up and celebrate him as the perfect being he is and how I almost feel I mustn't because as a probably-straight, definitely white probably-male middle-class American he's going to be heaped and heaped with ugly messages about his superiority for the rest of his life and how the hell do I counteract that; and so much more. There is a superabundance of topics I long to flesh out and share with you.

But we're sick, and this weekend, when The Man and I are sick and I've been disabled by a migraine, the Boychick has decided to say farewell to his prior 2-3 hour naps and substitute them for 30-40 minute "naps" that give him energy for the afternoon and major crankiness for the evening, which we are simply not equipped to deal with, not having any energy ourselves, due to illness and a lack of time in which to relax and reenergize.

So, I had plans to get creative and write an Ode to the Nap, but now I must go tagteam with my coparent; between the two of us, we might be able to fake being 2/3 of a sane and healthy adult, at least long enough to get us all in bed and asleep.

Just don't talk to me about the next week; I'm afraid I'll start whimpering.

Friday, February 20, 2009

Origins of words, and conversations in anatomy class

One of the fun things for me about studying midwifery was learning the origins of many words: midwife, vagina, and cunt, among others. One of the fun things about studying anatomy at massage school is having these come back up.

The cunt came up in a particularly interesting conversation about the bones of the foot. Yes, you have cunts in your foot. Well, cuniforms, anyway: three of the seven tarsal bones in your foot are the medial, intermediate and lateral cuniforms. When the instructor mentioned the cuniforms in class, my head popped up; I had heard that word before. I asked what cuniform meant (dude, it was 9pm, after 2.5 hours of anatomy lecture; I was tired!), she said she didn't know, and BAM, it came to me! I'd heard it before, in the root of cunt! "Cuniform" means "wedge"; "cunt" refers to the wedge of the visible pubic mons. Problem was I'd said "Oh!", and then, of course, she wanted to know... And while I have absolutely no compunctions using "cunt" in a casual setting, or when discussing it academically, I was sitting in a room with a half dozen others I barely know, most of them little old ladies, on the spot, and the damn teacher wasn't taking any hints. I believe the phrase "woman's private parts" crossed my lips, at which point my inner feminist keeled over, disowned me, and burst into flames, all at once. "Oh, cunt!" exclaimed the teacher, who might or might not be gay, but who has a truly impressive tie collection. "Yup", said the mortified I -- I was tripping over cunt? Really? Had my ovaries walked away without giving notification? Was I going to have to hand in my ballsy woman card? Yes, yes, yes, and yes, alas. However, I will never forget the names of at least three of the tarsals in the human foot.

The other fun one came the following week when same teacher was discussing the tendon sheath. "Pretend this pencil is a tendon. And my hand here" making an O "is the sheath. The tendon just goes in there and moves around in the sheath, slides in and out, the sheath providing moisture for easy gliding..." making the appropriate motions, at which point I am burying my head in the table trying not to snigger too loudly. My friend sitting next to me looks at me as though thinking I simply have a dirty mind. On a note (I have learned my lesson about speaking up with these things), I tell her "vagina is latin for sheath". "Really?" she mouths. Oh yes, I nod. And by now we both are sniggering noticeably, and probably pissing off the rest of the q-tip haired ladies.

As a language geek, I vastly prefer the meaning of cunt to the meaning of vagina: the wedge of the visible mons when a woman stands erect and proud, versus the entirely internal sheath for a man's "weapon"; which symbolism do you prefer? And yet which do we use in "polite" company, and which has ended up one of the seven unspeakable words? Coincidence? Perhaps... Due to its history, I cannot quite bring myself to advocate the reclamation of cunt, but nor would I hinder it. I surely would celebrate anything that moves our understanding of female genitalia from male-centric (vagina) to female-centric (the rest of it).

And in the meantime, don't take an anatomy class with me unless you want to alienate the other students. But at least we'll laugh, and remember some things very well.

On abortion

Just to make clear, in case there was any doubt, I am emphatically pro-choice. I do not believe that "life" starts at conception or that aborting an embryo can by a rational omnivorous person be said to be murder (I give more leeway here to vegans, though not if they swat at flies or squish spiders, not even the giant poisonous ones they find crawling up a leg -- only if one can consider squishing a gnat murder will I allow you the moral standing to call abortion murder, though I'll still fight you if you wish to impose your beliefs on others).

I am pro-choice to the point that when I finally got pregnant, after over a year of trying to conceive, I told myself every day for the first trimester that I could have an abortion still. A lot of people look at me askance when I say that, to put it mildly, but it wasn't for lack of love of the potential person growing inside me nor even due to an excess of ambivalence -- of course I had doubts and concerns, but it was an unequivocally wanted pregnancy -- but rather that the reminder of the choice I had reassured me every day that I had options, that I chose this, that I could still make another choice if it was too much. The fact that I chose, actively chose, every day for three months, to keep the pregnancy helped carry me through the long months ahead when bearing the baby was the only path available. It later brought me joy to remember that each day for those early months I chose to welcome this potentiality in to my life. Far from being pathological, contemplating abortion of a tried-for pregnancy was a practice in falling in love with my baby-to-be.

Anyway, all that is to say I am most definitely pro-choice. So when I read Twisty (at I Blame the Patriarchy) say that expressing a desire to reduce the number of abortions is inherently an anti-feminist stance, I do something of a double take (ok, perhaps that's not exactly what she said, but that's how I read "More abortions, fewer abortions — what’s the diff? The numbers are irrelevant.").

I can see how an anti-abortion, pro-choice position could be non-feminist, where abortion is seen as taking a life but is a lesser evil than those which happen when abortion is illegal. Any time the focus is on the embryo or fetus and a comparative analysis of being terminated pre-consciousness v living a life unwanted, the stance is non-feminist (though not necessarily anti-feminist).

But I do believe there is a feminist stance that says fewer abortions are better than more. My reasons for that position, as passionately pro-choice and abortion neutral as I am, are woman-centric:

  • First and simplest and at the root of all the other reasons, if a woman doesn't want to bear a child, she shouldn't have to get pregnant in the first place. Contraception and sex positive education should be universally and freely available. All humans should know about fertility awareness and all women who want to should be helped to chart their cycles. Men who don't want to wear condoms or become a parent should have vasectomies. All adolescents should be taught how to have fabulously enjoyable orgasmic sex without risk of pregnancy, starting with themselves (don't want your daughter to get pregnant? forget the lectures and the condoms, have a beloved aunt take her toy shopping). No one should feel forced to have sex for money or touch or food or safety or grades or housing or any other bullshit reason the patriarchally constrained choices offer her today. And rape, of course, needs to go buhbye, with all women taught assertiveness and self-protection and all men taught to not be sexist raping asses, and with a legal stance of assumed non-consent for women (second half of the post: brilliant idea I wish were mine; now that I know of it, though, I'm bringing it up every chance I get). There are a hundred thousand ways we can make abortion less necessary starting with avoiding unwanted pregnancy, and none of them have to do with moralizing or shaming or "abstinence promotion" and all of them start with the radical idea that women are people.

  • Next up on my list of feminist reasons why fewer abortions would be better: abortion, either chemical or surgical, is not exactly easy on the female body. While assuredly safer than pregnancy and birth, even just a couple weeks of pregnancy followed by termination takes a physical toll and carries real, if minute, risks. While the anti-science anti-abortion Bush-funded propaganda linking abortion to cancer was patently bullshit, that doesn't mean that pregnancy and termination are toll-free either. There's the nausea, exhaustion, and pain of early pregnancy (unmitigated by the joy and excitement of a chosen pregnancy), the blood loss of expulsion, and either the risk of surgical uterine/cervical scars or flooding the body with artificial hormones, both of which get more and more dangerous with repeated use. This is in no way meant to scare women away from abortion (again, it's still easier on your body than a full pregnancy and birth, and I say that as a rabidly pregnancy-positive, birth-positive, crunchy-granola aspiring homebirth midwife, who has a tendency to open up whoopass when people start spouting misogynistic bs about the ickiness and terror of childbearing), but just to point out that once again it is women's bodies bearing the burden of patriarchy's fuckups, women's bodies wracked if not wrecked for men's pleasure.

  • Then there's the financial issue. While as feminists we should be working on universal health care for all with abortion 100% covered and 100% available, in the meantime abortion (if you can get it) ain't cheap, at $350-1000+ a pop, unless one is privileged to have insurance that covers it (compare this please to the cost of a one-time vasectomy at $500-1000+, which could prevent untold numbers of abortions, carries none of the stigma of abortion, is a vastly simpler procedure, and is more likely to be covered by insurance). Even if women earned as much as men, as long as the burden paying for terminating an unwanted pregnancy falls to women, we're going to be at a disadvantage. Paying for an abortion can mean the difference between paying the rent and having to find someone to stay with; it can mean the difference between being able to afford this semester of college or not, between applying to grad schools this year or not; it can mean the difference between getting the hell out of dodge or having to stay in a town with the dickwad who spewed his wad and fucked you over in the first place. Of course we need to give away abortions free, but until we get to utopia, damn right I'm going to say there need to be fewer abortions; not more babies, but fewer pregnancies to start with, because one way or another it is women who are literally paying the price of our PIV-sex obsessed culture.

  • Last and probably most controversially in feminist culture, there need to be fewer abortions because having an abortion usually sucks -- not in a "post-abortion-syndrome" way, but just in a that-shit-ain't-easy way. I have not yet been there myself (though if I had gotten pregnant when the Boychick was less than a year, I would have been at my local clinic that very day, and I'm not sure what I would do if that happened now; termination would certainly be on the table for consideration), but having watched others go through it, having miscarried an unwanted, unknown pregnancy myself, having listened to feminist women discuss the destiny of their frozen fertilized embryos, my conclusion is that it sucks; not for everyone, not every time, not horribly, but I do not believe that it is only "pro-life" propaganda that makes it, for some, an emotionally difficult experience. I do believe that the guilt around the choice to terminate is a cultural patriarchal construct, as most woman-guilt is, and to be sure an abortion can also be simply an entirely joyful decision, but it's such a complex one that there is no one way women will ever feel about it. There is no wrong way to feel and no right way to feel, and anyone attempting to invade women's minds to dictate to them what they "should" feel during or after the event needs to be bitchslapped as hard as anyone attempting to invade her body, whether that's the religionists telling her it's murder she must carry the guilt for or radfems telling her it's simply nothing and any effect it has on her is merely her weakness to patriarchal bullcrap. Some women feel joy at an abortion; some women mourn their potential baby; some women feel easy relief; many women feel all of the above and more. But as long as any woman is drained by the experience; as long as any woman dislikes it; as long as any woman would make another choice under less patriarchally insane circumstances; as long as any woman would rather have not had to face this choice: I am going to say we should work to need fewer abortions.


I am pro-choice. I believe feminists need to work toward a world with assumed non-consent, where health care, day care, family-friendly employment, contraception, sex-positive education, and abortion are universally available and accessible, where every family doctor, general practitioner, gynecologist, nurse practitioner, and nurse midwife is trained in and offers safe abortions; and I believe that to the extent this or any step toward this reduces the number of abortions without increasing the number of unwanted, unchosen babies, this is to be celebrated. There will always be abortions, because there will always be contraceptive failures, changes of situation, and changes of mind. But we don't need to be anti-feminist "babyists" to believe fewer abortions is a good thing to work toward.



Note: This is not the place to debate abortion. One does not have to agree with me, nor even be pro-choice, in order to comment, but posts that are exclusively moralizing, actively anti-choice, or exist only to register one's disagreement with a pro-choice stance will be deleted. All other comments are welcome and invited.