Thursday, January 29, 2009

Why I'm not blogging

I actually have a draft sitting in the hopper that I typed out at midnight yesterday when I couldn't sleep, which I was really hoping to get up today, but which (because I typed it out at midnight when I really should have been sleeping) really needs a thorough clean up and sprucing before it's ready for your edification and education. I also have notes on three more posts that have been floating around in my head for the past week that desperately want to get out of mine and in to yours.

I am, however, not posting any of that, because of various factors including mold, pervasive bleach smell to clean said mold both resulting in massive headaches, visit to courthouse and handing over of large sums of money to prevent license from being suspended, Random Winter Cold (tm) in all human members of our family, a sort-of-expected visit from Aging Hippie Aunt, and A&P test for which I was completely unprepared (owing mainly to the above factors). And I need sleep. Yes, more even than I need to exercise (or exorcise) my blogging muscles.

But there's no need for pity. It's not been bad, exactly, there's just been... a lot.

So, I hope to get at least one post with actual content up in the next day, but if my luck holds, I will not.

Still, sometime, perhaps just when you need it, perhaps long after you've forgotten me in the fickle environment that is the blogosphere, New Content Will Arrive. I promise.

Monday, January 26, 2009

Closer to understanding the domestic goddess

Those who have been paying attention know that The Man and I are attempting a 1-month no-spend challenge, the largest change for us being not eating out at all (excepting Chipotle once a weekend because hey, it's hungry work shopping for a whole week, and it's Chipotle). In attempting this, I have gone from cooking less than, on average, 15% of our meals (The Man cooked most of the other 85%, at least of dinners), to cooking rather more than 50%, simply because I'm the one home during the day.

In doing so, I believe I have discovered at least part of why the domestic goddess phenomenon is so popular. (Just to reiterate, I'm all in favor of upping the status of the domestic, and I do stay at home during the day, but there's a phenomenon I'm not a part of in which staying home and raising the kids and keeping the house is the entirety of what one [a woman, generally] does and takes pride in. I've long been confused by it, having been raised by a mostly second-wave feminist WOHM, for all that I travel in the same social spheres as many who embrace the title, and have much in common with them.)

The Man and I have long maintained that in an ideal world, we would both be parenting the Boychick 50/50, even if I did all the milk-giving. Given that we do not live in an ideal world, his job 40 hours a week is to go earn money so we as a family can stay fed and housed, and my job during those 40 hours a week is to keep the Boychick and myself alive and (preferably) sane. Anything on top of that is non-obligatory and not expected. Everything else -- the cooking, the cleaning, the house maintenance, the shopping, the getting the fuck out of the house-- is stuff we try to do together, or at least split fairly (and him doing most of the cooking and washing the dishes is SO fair, because... it just is!). This has long worked for us.

But here I am, cooking during the day so we eat at home come evening. Chicken makhani with curried veggies, beef stew with garlic croutons, spaghetti with garlic bread, apple chicken with quinoa, no-knead bread with everything, stuffed squash, beans and rice, roast chicken, and more scones and cookies and muffins and bars than one should have in an entire year, all made at home, from scratch (even the croutons), mostly by me. And you know what? My days are kinda easier. I have, for the love of God/dess, something to do.

And I think that's it. That's why, when women are handed the vast burden of the childrearing by a society that says children and work can't mix and men don't matter in the early years, so many of us turn to being a Good Housewife, or better yet a Domestic Goddess (the good housewife for the new millennium). It gives her something to do other than stare at her (unbelievably beautiful and talented and adorable) child(ren), a purpose -- keeping the hearth, 21st century-style -- and a standard by which she can measure her success in real-time, not just wait around until her kids are 20, 40, 80, and declare, if they turned out right (whatever the hell that means), that she was a Good Mother, and It Was All Worth It.

Because really, am I doing my kid any favors spending half the day trying not to lose my temper with him, not because he's bad or is doing anything wrong, but just because I can't take it any more? I don't know. I believe so, I believe that fostering attachment and providing milk and giving him the freedom to just run and play and cuddle and be free of time pressures and peer pressures and grow-up pressures is good for him, but I don't know. What I do know is that in the last month I've made food that has sustained and been enjoyed by my family, helped us meet our budget, helped us pay off debt so home and working-car ownership is a possibility somewhere just over the horizon. I know I've made something, done something substantial and important, even if it is now nothing more than a memory and a sewage smear somewhere; and it feels pretty darn good.

It's an awfully seductive proposition, turning that sensation in to a vocation, and I think I have more understanding now for why so many do it.

Sunday, January 25, 2009

Are you a good parent? quiz memes, or, the always-good-for-a-chuckle double standards in parenting

I ran across this meme today, which is both funny and incredibly sad and telling about our society (spelling as in original, author unknown):

With all the conflicting parenting advice out there, it’s difficult to know whether you’re a good parent or a bad parent. Take this handy quiz to find out once and for all.
Keep track of your answers on a post-it and total your score at the end. Won’t it be a relief to know whether or not you’re a bad mom?

1. How many hours per week does your child spend in daycare?
A. None. I’m a stay-at-home mom.
B. 40 or more. I work full-time.
C. About 20. I work half-time.

2. Where does your baby sleep
A. In a crib.
B. In my bed.
C. In a co-sleeper.

3. Do you allow your child to watch television?
A. Yes.
B. No.

4. Has your child been vaccinated?
A. Yes.
B. No.

5. How many scheduled activities (storytimes, lessons, classes or playgroups) does your child attend each week?
A. None
B. One or more.




ANSWERS:
1. Day Care.
A: Stay at home mom. You are a bad mom. Your child will be poorly socialized, will lack verbal skills, and will become horribly ill during kindergarten because he or she has never been exposed to germs.
B: Full-time working mom. You are a bad mom. Your child will have an attachment disorder. You are missing the best years of his or her life.
C: Part-time working mom. You are the worst mom. Your child will suffer attachment issues, be poorly socialized, lack verbal skills and will be sick as a dog forever.

2. Sleeping arrangements.
A: Baby sleeps in a crib. You are a bad mom. How could you put your child in a cage to sleep? What’s wrong with you?
B: Baby sleeps in your bed. You are a bad mom. How could you risk rolling onto your child and killing her? What’s wrong with you?
C: Baby sleeps in a co-sleeper. You are a bad mom. How could you waste so much money on that ridiculous co-sleeper? Is it because you read about it in Dr. Sears? You won’t be able to afford to send your child to college.

3. Television
Yes. You are a bad mom. Your child will be violent, mouthy, and unpleasant. He or she will whine for every candy and toy they see the next time you go to the store.
No. You are a bad mom. Your child will lack reading skills and will have nothing to talk with other children about. You are raising a freak.

4. Vaccinations.
A: Yes. You are a bad mom. How could you do that to a helpless baby who cannot consent to being experimented on by the public health system?
B: No. You are a bad mom. How could you do that to a helpless baby whose immune system can’t fight off all those germs?

5. Activities.
A: None. You are a bad mom. Your child will fall behind his or her peers and never catch up if you don’t head over to the children’s theatre production of “Apocalypse Now” this weekend.
B: One or more. You are a bad mom. Your child is overscheduled and will suffer a breakdown due to the stress you’re putting on him or her. You’re probably doing Suzuki, aren’t you?

Brought to you by the folks at Parenting, Mothering, Time, Newsweek, The Today Show, Babycenter.com, Wonder Time, What to Expect When You’re Expecting, Your Pregnancy Week by Week, your pediatrician, your obstetrition, your mother, your mother-in-law, and that awful psycho in the elevator who knows better than you how you should be raising your kids.
(Note that Mothering, the magazine I volunteer for, got a shout out. Note also that when they said "find out if you're a good parent", they meant good mom.)



I was then inspired to write a complementary quiz for fathers:

The good dad/bad dad quiz:

1. How much time per week do you spend in the same room with your child(ren)?
A) 0 -- I work 100 hours per week and travel more than 50%
B) 3-5
C) 24/7 -- I am a stay at home dad

2. Where does your baby sleep?
A) In his own room in a crib
B) In bed with the wife
C) In bed with both of us

3. How many diapers have you changed in your child's life?
A) 0-1, but I made sure the little woman always did it within 4 hours of the kid dropping a load
B) 50-100
C) About once a day when I was home

4. If divorced, do you pay child support?
A) Yes, the minimum amount
B) Yes, when I can afford it after the widescreen tv payments
C) No, I got out of it and use the money to pay for my new, blond, wife and our two new children

5. What do you know about your children?
A) Their names, their friends, their friends' parents, the number for their school or daycare, their dietary likes and dislikes, their vaccine schedule (or all the reasons why they are not vaccinated), the date of their next dentist, pediatrician, and music lesson appointments, and what they really want for their birthday
B) Their names, a couple of their friends' names, the type of instrument they play, and what they want for their birthday
C) Their names... usually


Tally up your answers:

Time with kids:
A) None--you are a good dad, because you work so hard to provide for them.
B) 3-5 hrs/week--you are a good dad, because that's more than your father spent with you
C) SAH--you are a Super Dad!

Sleep arrangements
A) In a crib in their own room--you are a good dad for putting your foot down and insisting the little woman separate from the leech
B) In bed with the wife--you are a good dad for sacrificing your own needs to meet your baby's
C) In bed with both of you--you are a Super Dad!

Diaper changing
A) 0-1--you are a good dad for making sure the little woman does it
B) 50-100--you are a good dad for occasionally giving the little woman a hand
C) Once a day--you are a Super Dad!

Child Support
A) Yes--you are a Super Dad!
B) Yes, sometimes--you are a good dad for pitching in when you can
C) No, due to new family--you are a good dad to the new kids for saving your money for them, and a good dad to the old kids for providing them with siblings!

Kid trivia
A) Know it all--you're lying
B) Know some--you're a good dad, because you know the important stuff
C) Know their names--you're a good dad, because at least you stuck around long enough to hear their names

Brought to you by the patriarchy and every exclamatory comment over how fabulous it is when a dad actually does some small thing to parent his kids.

The Man said too much of it was true, and it was all too frustrating, to be funny.

For the record, I answered bad mom, bad mom, bad mom, bad mom, and bad mom. He answered good dad, Super Dad, Super Dad, n/a, and he's lying.

And there you have it. The double standards for parenting neatly summed up in a pair of moderately funny and entirely depressing memes.

Friday, January 23, 2009

The ways I make my child cry

I drive away to class while he's begging for me to take him in my arms and stay with him.

I hold him down while he screams so someone can torture him with medical adhesive or blood drawing syringes.

I place out of his reach really interesting toys like sharp knives and broken glass.

I make him put away the cart after he's run with it around in the store for 10 minutes after I'm done shopping.

I fail to make the water fountain not be turned off for winter.

I tell him he cannot have a third green banana.

I don't make the world soft and bouncy and have rounded corners, and I allow him to get hurt, and sometimes it leaves scars.

I yell at him for no reason other than I am having a hard day.

There is no real point to this post, just a catalogue of some of the ways I fail in my child's eyes. No matter how consensually we try to live, I cannot and will not let him have his way every time. Sometimes he gets hurt, and I can't instantly make it better. Sometimes I am just cruel because I cannot cope any longer. It breaks my heart -- a phrase I did not truly understand until having him -- every time and yet I would not deny him all hurts even if I could. It would deny him the ability to empathize, deny him the ability to sympathize, deny him any chance to grow, deny him the experience of life. I will never willingly inflict pain on him for no purpose other than to suffer, but I cannot entirely regret that he will, sometimes outside of my control and sometimes with my collusion, know suffering.

Wednesday, January 21, 2009

Can we stop saying patriarchy is good for men?

If the patriarchy is good for men, then feminism, which opposes and seeks to dismantle the patriarchy, must be bad for men, and men become feminist's enemies, the pawns and bishop and knights of the patriarchy, if you will. We need to recruit allies, not create enemies which the "us v. them" rhetoric does quite well.

And patriarchy really isn't good for men, except in comparison to how truly horrible it is for women.

What the patriarchy does is create a hierarchy with (straight white rich thin ablebodied nuerotypical cisgendered) men at top, and (queer black poor fat disabled neurodivergent trans) women at bottom. It piles every privilege on men; values their work and their bodies as the standard; instills in them surety of their superiority; tells them they are closest to God (made in His image!); and gives them free reign to express their anger and hatred with any violence they please to use, at least as long as it's against a woman.

Sound great? Compared to getting pissed on and shat on and beat on and hated on and enslaved and raped and killed at the bottom of the patriarchal ladder, of course it does. Of course it is. It's a hundred thousand million times better and easier to live at the top as a straight white rich thin ablebodied nuerotypical cisgendered man than at the bottom as a queer poor fat disabled neurodivergent trans woman of color, and any man who tries to play the "you think you've got it hard??" game with a woman deserves, well, any violent expression of anger and hatred she pleases to use.

But simply rearranging that fucked up hierarchy, moving around the pieces so different types get piled on and get to sit on top, isn't what feminism is about. Feminism (and anti-racism and neurodiversity and other power-protesting movements) is about dismantling the whole unholy ladder entirely. It's about saying that the circumstances of your birth -- your gender, your race, your sexuality, your able-ity -- don't give you more value than anyone else. Men don't deserve bowing and scraping and every blessing of capitalism; no one does. Power corrupts, and privilege is ugly, and having power and privilege above others is bad for the soul of anyone.

The thing about the patriarchy is that while it gives men more freedom than anyone else by a factor of a thousand, it is not a perfect freedom. Men are allowed to show anger, but not fear or gentleness or vulnerability. Their work is valued, unless they want to do what is considered feminine. Their bodies are valued, as long as their bodies are manly enough. They are like God, but lose the chance to know Goddess as an equal. They are placed above all, and their humanity and humility corroded thereby.

What feminism offers men is a removal of those restrictions. No longer will men be pampered by the service of women, but rather they will be presented with strong, proud partners they can work with. Men won't be privileged above all others, but all the others will rise up and will join together to the benefit of all. Only the brainwashing of the patriarchy tells us that superiority is better than equality.

In the patriarchy, it is women who get the short end of the stick, to be sure, but I look at my Boychick, as beautiful and vulnerable and perfect as all babies are but "privileged" to be at the top of a stinking ugly inhumane heap of humanity, and I just want to get rid of the damned stick altogether. From here on out, the patriarchy is only going to hurt him, damage him, make him uglier, even as it makes him hurt those below him a million times more. How can that be "good" for him?

Monday, January 19, 2009

A day late and a Boo Yaa short

In frank and open theft of Womanist Musings's idea, I am hereby announcing to the blogger world that I started my period yesterday. I am menstruating, getting a visit from Aunt Flo (oh how I hate that one), riding the red tide, heading to the red tent, and suffering Eve's curse (mmm, more misogyny). I am, indeed, bleeding nigh unto death from my vagina -- or maybe it just feels like it. Either way, I am on the rag; which is actually an accurate colloquialism in this case, since I use cloth pads I made myself.

Why do you want to know this? Ok, you probably don't. But why not? Is our cultural avoidance of discussing menstruation simply out of respect for privacy? Part of our overall avoidance of discussing things involving fluid and the body? (Although apparently the state of one's cervix nine months after one fails to menstruate is fair game for everyone from your brother in law to the grocery clerk.) Or is it part of our misogynistic disgust with the female form, hatred rooted in envy of our power of procreation?

Or maybe no one wants to risk pissing off the already pissy chick with the bleeding pussy?

Regardless, I dislike the silence, the taboo. And so I'm breaking it.

This is my ninth menstruation since the 14 months of lactational amenorrhea the child and chance and round the clock nursing blessed me with. It is the first full cycle we have tried charting for pregnancy avoidance. (I say tried because it doesn't work so well when the child steals the basal body thermometer and loses it inside the house... somewhere... and eventually a new one is purchased, generic because that's all they had under $60 and who the hell spends $60 on a damn thermometer?, that works like absolute shite -- I am not sticking that piece of plastic in my mouth for FIVE MINUTES; if I wanted to do that I'd just buy a freaking glass one -- and the old one finally found, only to have discovered that somewhere in that week of wonky or no charting, you appear to have ovulated. Probably. Which is not the certainty I for one am looking for in my pregnancy avoidance method.) We've been meaning to for, well, all of the postpartum cycles, but just didn't get around to it. Needless to say, this cycle didn't exactly meet all the requirements for successful, safe condom-free nookie.

But that's OK, since the Boychick has also decided this month to fall asleep most nights by talking to himself. For an hour. Or two. I really wasn't worried about not getting my period this month, for the same reason a virgin generally isn't.

But still. Isn't it nice to know it's here?

Sunday, January 18, 2009

Something I said in my last post has been bugging me

I said:
This is why it matters when our kids' books have only white, able-bodied, neurotypical, cisgendered, gender-stereotyped characters. This is why it matters that we talk with our toddlers and our preschoolers about diversity and gender and sexuality and race and privilege, to the best of our ability, in ways they can understand. They may not know exactly what they are inside yet, they may not know exactly what race means yet or exactly what sex is yet, so it might seem to "not matter", but so, so soon they will.
I've been thinking a lot recently about race, and racism, and white privilege, and the intersection of feminism and anti-racism (and the intersections of feminism and racism), and I think that was part of why I was trying to do the ultra-liberal thing of conflating all -isms together in one big homogeneous lump and treating them all with "these suck, don't do them" stick.

It doesn't work that way, of course.

The very fact that I can think and say that my child may not know what race is at not-quite-two is because I am white, and my child is white, and The Man is white, and I swim, eat, breathe white privilege. Of course my child doesn't have to "deal with" race yet, or understand that the color of his skin speaks of so much more than how much melanin he produces; not because he is two, but because he is white. We have the option of talking with him about racism, or not. We have the option of talking with him about privilege, or not. That is one small aspect of this giant napsack of white privilege: the option to ignore it exists.

And being white; having this privilege I did not ask for and do not want; having been raised knowing racism was bad but never talking about race; having been taught that to be "color blind" was the goal so if we all (by which of course we mean white people) just squeezed our eyes shut real tight and held on and wished hard, it would go away (it being race and racism and privilege and difficult conversations and horrific pasts and horrific presents)... it's hard to talk about.

I have to anyway. Even if I don't always know what to say. Even if I get it wrong sometimes (which I did, and which I will again). Because I have to, else the Boychick will become just another damn clueless white guy, and I can't let that happen.

This is why it matters

Hellen G commented on my post "there's my rabbit Bob..." that:
many trans people know from a very early age that they have a gender identity issue, even if we don't necessarily have the words to describe it - I was about 5 when I knew that 'something wasn't right' about my body...
Another person I was talking with in the last week said that she knew she was attracted only to other girls by five, as much as a five year old can be (theirs may be an immature sexuality, but it is real nonetheless).

The only reason at age five I didn't know my own sexuality was because I had no word for it, no admittance in my culture that it even existed. By the time I was five, I knew I was attracted to boys and girls (and genderqueers and androgynes and other variations, as much as they showed up in suburban kindergarten land), but it wasn't until a decade later that I had a word for it. I knew most girls liked boys, and some girls liked just girls, but no one liked both. I thought there was something wrong with me, because there were no words for what I was, no bisexuals in my story books, no bi parents, no bi pride marches.

There were straights, and I wasn't that, and there were gays, and I wasn't that either, and there were sluts, of course, but that definitely wasn't me. I didn't even kiss anyone (except for my best friend when she and I were 5, hidden under my parents' waterbed) until The Man. I had no one at all in my culture to connect to, so I wasn't bisexual or pansexual or plain ol' happy queer, I was just a confused mess, wondering why I dreamed both about Wesley Crusher and Xena, Warrior Princess.

And I grew up in a fairly gay-friendly progressive household, and I knew that I wouldn't be kicked out if I came out as queer. I found out years after I came out (with reactions from my friends ranging from "uh huh" to "duh" -- I wasn't exactly good at hiding my queerness in the first place) that my own mother was bisexual, but as a monogamous married woman with kids didn't think it was "worth it" to be out, it "didn't matter".

I still sometimes feel like screaming at her "of course it fucking mattered! I could have saved myself a decade of pain and confusion if you were out!" I needed someone, anyone, to say to me "these people exist. this sexuality, this gender, these intrinsic inclinations are normal." And I was ready to hear that by age five. Helen was ready to hear that by age five.

This is why it matters when our kids' books have only white, able-bodied, neurotypical, cisgendered, gender-stereotyped characters. This is why it matters that we talk with our toddlers and our preschoolers about diversity and gender and sexuality and race and privilege, to the best of our ability, in ways they can understand. They may not know exactly what they are inside yet, they may not know exactly what race means yet or exactly what sex is yet, so it might seem to "not matter", but so, so soon they will. And their friends will. And we need to give them the words to explain it, and the room to celebrate it.

Friday, January 16, 2009

Toddler friendships (or, bath and cheese-eating pictures!)

I have a very dear friend, who happens to have a child about 10 months older than the Boychick. To our relief (for we would get together regularly for our own sanity anyway), they are as close as toddlers can get to Best Friends. They light up when they see each other (if it is almost always followed by screams of possessiveness), they push each other in carts, they walk around holding hands, they play at crawling together, they feed each other food they "cook" in their kitchens, they even on occasion hug, or kiss each other's boo-boos better. They sometimes bathe together, pouring water over each other and splashing and laughing hysterically. It melts our hearts.

They also, of course, yell at and hit each other, and scream whenever the other gets something the first doesn't, and snatch things from each other, and insist on always doing what the other is even if only one can at a time, and generally give us a big ol' headache. But hey, they're toddlers.

The only "unusual" part of all this is that the Best Friend is (as far as one can tell before puberty) of the female persuasion.

You would not believe (or perhaps that should be "I in my optimism can hardly believe") the amount of labeling this gets them from the generally-sexist general population. If they are not siblings ("sisters", usually, because the Boychick does not wear clothing with trucks and "Mommy's little monster" plastered all over it, and therefore must be female), then they are "boyfriend and girlfriend": they "flirt"; they "smooch"; he is "a little ladykiller" (can there be a more misogynistic phrase?), she "quite the catch". Because, of course, a boy and a girl, no matter how young, cannot be pals, or buddies, or just plain friends. Theirs must be a romantic relationship, if not a sibling one, for there cannot be any other roles for a male and a female of the same age.

This attitude, of course, makes my head explode. They don't know what romance is. They barely yet know what "boy" and "girl" are (he less than she, it seems so far). All they know is they like each other, like to spend time together, like to play with each other -- and occasionally despise the other with an agony representable only by supersonic screams of rage (if you've ever had a toddler, you know of what I speak).

But even if they knew. Even if they were teens, and had the potential to be romantically interesting in anything, and definitely were aware of the physical differences between the sexes, so what? Must every non-gay male and female be a romantic possibility? Can there be no relating to a person without evaluation of their sexual potential? Must every one of the Boychick's future female acquaintances be labeled by idiotic onlookers as a "maybe girlfriend"? My blood pressure skyrockets at the vision.

Before you accuse me of getting worked up over nothing, this is not just innocent fun that adults have with the relationship between their children, with no harm to the little ones. The assigning of toddler friendships with the "romantic" or "boyfriend/girlfriend" label is nothing more or less than a part of the ploy of the patriarchy to make women sexual objects and men sexual predators. If one is programmed to look at someone of the "opposite" gender and think "sex", even if in just some small part of one's mind, regardless of whether one is actually attracted to the other, then one cannot relate to the other as a person. And the patriarchy would surely fall apart if we all did that.

Wednesday, January 14, 2009

"...there's my rabbit, Bob, and his bunny wife Bob"

There was a time I naively assumed that I wouldn't have to worry about sexism in my child's books until at least story books, maybe not even until chapter books. Surely board books, written to start reading to infants so young they only understand the rhythm and rhyme of the words, would be immune!

That naivete lasted until maybe five minutes after the Boychick got his first book.

The truth is even board books, even modern board books, are rife with sexism, heterosexism, racism, and of course, what's a good word, cisgenderism? (One can't even call it transphobia, for it's more the complete lack of acknowledgment that gender isn't always obvious, simple, and binary. Transphobia might be a step up.)

The title for this post came from the usually innocuous Sandra Boynton, in her book titled Fifteen Animals, a recent gift from beloved relatives and fellow Boynton fans. That line alone would be enough to make my head explode (the male bob is referred to as a rabbit, the female with the diminutive bunny; she is of course a "wife", not an independent woman rabbit nor even an interdependent but nonsexist "spouse"; and he possesses her as his wife), but it's only one of the offensive examples on the Boychick's library -- which itself has been chosen largely by us to be as nonsexist as possible.

A recent disappointment was Papa, Papa. I had heard good things about Mama, Mama from the AP community (mentions of nursing and cosleeping, also things lacking in children's books in general) -- and apart from one weird and one schmaltzy page it isn't too bad -- and since I try never to buy a mother-centric book without getting a corresponding father-centric book, we ordered Papa, Papa as well, with moderately high hopes.

Papa Papa, it turns out, is basically one long exploration of fathering stereotypes. Father as home builder, wise and worshiped, leader, teacher of howling (in a patriarchal context, this can stand for teacher of how to be outspoken, assertive, and possessive; how to trumpet aggression), and promoter of (and proud of) independence are some of the highlights. The "best" pages are the first and last, where Papa teaches little ones to sing, and where the narrator feels "warm and safe" with Papa (in the context of playing "peekaboo"), but nowhere is there an image of father-as-nurturer, or father-as-caretaker (as in Mama, Mama, which features Mama cleaning and feeding the narrator). The Man's take on it is the Mama, Mama book is about the mother/child as a unit, with mother as safe base, and exploring the world around WITH each other, whereas in Papa, Papa, there is separation between the father and child, with the father teaching and giving TO the narrator.

Another example is Sam Loves Kisses (bought for the Boychick by well-meaning friends because of the lovely last page featuring a snuggly family bed), in which the "mommy" gets "a sweet kiss" and is depicted (in a dress, though devoid of feminine curves) as busy in the kitchen, and the "daddy" (bepantsed, of course) gets "an airplane kiss", and plays with Sam to distract him so the mother can cook -- because, of course, the man couldn't take a turn cooking, nor could he distract the child with nurturing or cuddles. We'll not even get in to the cars covering Sam's bedspread.

I could go on: there's City Babies, in which there are mother animals but no fathers (I will allow that the non-human animal kingdom is factually sex-biased in parenting, but the authors could have used examples from the avian world -- there were three bird pages in there already); in Daddy Cuddles, an otherwise excellent book, the human father "cuddles" his baby on his back, demonstrating once again that men can be playful (piggy back) but not nurturing (in arms); of the several books that depict one parent and a child, only one has a father instead of a mother (the hippopotamus of Sandra Boynton's The Bellybutton Book).

So we are confronted with what to do. We have already chosen "the best of the bunch", at least of what we can find in stores around here, and if we wanted more books with fewer -isms and more diversity, we'd have to special order all of them (I actually tried to order And Tango Makes Three for the Boychick for Yule, but was informed it was unavailable in board book at this time), and I wouldn't even know where to look. We don't wish to censor books, but neither do we want to immerse him at so young an age (or ever!) in a sexist, heterosexist mindset, when his opinion on the world is just being formed.

For many of our books, we have settled on alternate readings that offend us less (we switch who gets which type of kisses and who is in the kitchen in Sam Loves Kisses, and say "...there's my rabbit, Bob, and her bunny partner Bob"). But when others come to read to him, they read it the "straight" (pun intended, of course) way. Will he look at others funny (or correct them!) when they read it "wrong? ...and would that be "bad"? If we don't read exactly what is on the page, will we damage or delay his reading, if he's still using these books in a few years when he's at that stage? If we cross out the irritating bits and write in our versions, are we teaching him censorship and book defacement are OK? Or would we be merely recording and commemorating our family's unique stories? How do we navigate these waters?

How do you?