4/10 I take my last thyroid pill (no refills on my script), and get my blood drawn to check my levels (yes, cutting it close; no, I shouldn't have waited nearly so long; yes, I've done it before; no, I probably still won't stop from doing it again. procrastination is a powerful habit).
4/16 I go over my results with my doctor, find out my TSH was too high (that is, my body was asking for more thyroid), and I needed more thyroid even before I ran out.
4/17 After a week of occasionally stealing thyroid from the Boychick to get by (don't worry, he didn't go without), I finally get my own, higher, script filled.
4/15-23 I wonder why I've been feeling so tired recently, and so foggy in the brain pan.
4/24 Oh... Right... I (finally!) remember low thyroid = low energy & low brainpower.
Moral of the story? Without thyroid, my brain gets so foggy I can't think of why my brain might be foggy.
(Maybe this is only funny if you are familiar with hypothyroid/chronic illness issues, but it makes me snicker at least. Mine is a dark humor.)
Monday, April 27, 2009
Friday, April 24, 2009
Andrade is guilty, and so am I
I have been half following the Angie Zapata murder case, reading the posts on TransGriot about it, but not reading the links because I am a conscientious objector to the mainstream media (and have been having enough trouble keeping up with my feed reader as it is). I was, well, not pleased exactly (it's hard to be happy about the pitiful "justice" our punitive system offers) to hear that a fully guilty verdict was rendered, including the hate crime charge; I was overjoyed that for once, a "trans panic" defense had so thoroughly failed.
Then I read about Angie's family's reaction, and was struck dumb by the simultaneous realization and the refutation of my own assumptions.
I had thought, here was this little Latina trans girl, murdered by her maybe-boyfriend. I thought I knew her; she'd be kicked out by her transphobic Hispanic family, trying to make it on her own, possibly turning tricks to survive. Good little White Liberal Ally was I, so cynical about her chances for justice, so certain of her alienation.
But then I read her brother's words:
I was wrong. I was guilty of racism, of the most pervasive sort of cisgenderism: the ignore-ance of a trans person's own existence. I committed a hate crime in the whitewashed confines of my own head.
White privilege doesn't go away. Cisgender privilege doesn't go away. We can't do our course in Racism 101 and Transphobia 101 and then wash our hands of the blood of those whiteness has killed, of those cisgender bias has killed.
This doesn't give me much hope for the Boychick. Bashes the rose-colored glasses right off my "raise a post-racist generation" face, in fact. Which is probably a good thing; helps me see how the world actually is, how hard a journey is ahead. Best hope I have is to ground him in a childhood of racism- and cisgenderism-awareness, and show him that it never stops; privilege never goes away, no matter how much we want it to, so our obligation as possessors of privilege to learn, to listen, to humble ourselves, and to root out the prejudices hidden in the darkest corners of our own heads -- which will always be there, more persistent than cockroaches and uglier still -- never goes away.
I am so sorry for what I did to you, how I erased you in my own mind, Angie. Your memory deserves so much more than that. Angie's family: I can only beg forgiveness. Even if you never learn of my assumptions about you, even if you never learn I exist, I have wronged you, and I owe you. I am sorry.
Then I read about Angie's family's reaction, and was struck dumb by the simultaneous realization and the refutation of my own assumptions.
I had thought, here was this little Latina trans girl, murdered by her maybe-boyfriend. I thought I knew her; she'd be kicked out by her transphobic Hispanic family, trying to make it on her own, possibly turning tricks to survive. Good little White Liberal Ally was I, so cynical about her chances for justice, so certain of her alienation.
But then I read her brother's words:
Angie was my sister.And I had to confront my own heart, who thought that by knowing the plight of the plot of too many trans women of color's lives that I knew the circumstances of her life; who thought that since I knew the color of her family's skin that I knew the contents of their hearts. I made so many assumptions about her, not bothering to read further, not even realizing I had made them; as much as I thought about it, which was hardly at all, I thought I knew what I needed to know about her.
She was a member of our family. We loved her very much, and we will miss her every day. Every day and every night our mom has to deal with great pain of ... one of her babies being buried. Every day our siblings and I reach for the phone and realize we’ll never hear her voice. There’s no answer anymore.
A part of our family is missing, stolen from us. Angie was 18, her life was just beginning. She was brave, she had guts, she had courage, and she was beautiful, fun and loving. She was our little sister.
I was wrong. I was guilty of racism, of the most pervasive sort of cisgenderism: the ignore-ance of a trans person's own existence. I committed a hate crime in the whitewashed confines of my own head.
White privilege doesn't go away. Cisgender privilege doesn't go away. We can't do our course in Racism 101 and Transphobia 101 and then wash our hands of the blood of those whiteness has killed, of those cisgender bias has killed.
This doesn't give me much hope for the Boychick. Bashes the rose-colored glasses right off my "raise a post-racist generation" face, in fact. Which is probably a good thing; helps me see how the world actually is, how hard a journey is ahead. Best hope I have is to ground him in a childhood of racism- and cisgenderism-awareness, and show him that it never stops; privilege never goes away, no matter how much we want it to, so our obligation as possessors of privilege to learn, to listen, to humble ourselves, and to root out the prejudices hidden in the darkest corners of our own heads -- which will always be there, more persistent than cockroaches and uglier still -- never goes away.
I am so sorry for what I did to you, how I erased you in my own mind, Angie. Your memory deserves so much more than that. Angie's family: I can only beg forgiveness. Even if you never learn of my assumptions about you, even if you never learn I exist, I have wronged you, and I owe you. I am sorry.
Labels:
cisgender privilege,
parenting,
privilege,
racism,
white privilege
Thursday, April 23, 2009
Blogging Against Disablism Day, May 1st 2009

I'm planning on participating in BADD on May 1st, 2009. Will you join me?
Write a post on the subject of disability discrimination, disablism or ableism and publish it on May 1st - or as close as you are able. Podcasts, videocasts and on-line art are also welcome. You can cover any subject, specific or general, personal, social or political. In the previous three BADD, folks have written about all manner of subjects, from discrimination in education and employment, through health care, parenting, family life and relationships, as well as the interaction of disablism with racism and sexism. Every year I have been asked, so it's worth saying; the discrimination experienced by people with mental ill health is disablism, so naturally such posts are welcome too.
Wednesday, April 22, 2009
How I spent Earth Day
Earth Day. Such a fabulous idea. I'm all about environmentalism, and doing things easier on the earth: breastfeeding, cloth diapering and elimination communication, dressing in hand-me-downs, choosing and growing organic foods, buying local, owning one small car and keeping it up, recycling, crocheting with plarn, washing with baking soda and vinegar (including my hair), making do using up and doing without, et cetera, and so on.
(I can do a feminist defense of environmentalism, too, though for now I'll just offer Having Faith as my evidence.)
So how did I spend Earth Day?
In my car. Driving around aimlessly. For nearly five hours. Probably drove about 100 miles. In circles. (Big circles.) With a feverish toddler zoning out and napping and zoning out and drinking water and napping and zoning out in the backseat.
Yup. That's how I spent Earth Day.
I may not be a bad mom, but I'm not so sure I'm not a bad environmentalist.
Ah well. There's always tomorrow.
(I can do a feminist defense of environmentalism, too, though for now I'll just offer Having Faith as my evidence.)
So how did I spend Earth Day?
In my car. Driving around aimlessly. For nearly five hours. Probably drove about 100 miles. In circles. (Big circles.) With a feverish toddler zoning out and napping and zoning out and drinking water and napping and zoning out in the backseat.
Yup. That's how I spent Earth Day.
I may not be a bad mom, but I'm not so sure I'm not a bad environmentalist.
Ah well. There's always tomorrow.
Monday, April 20, 2009
The difference between gratitude and gloating
I found this when looking through my email drafts folder; I'd typed it up on the iPhone nearly two weeks ago. I'm sure I was interrupted before I could finish, and I really don't remember where I was going with it, so it just kind of ends with no conclusion, but I thought it was an interesting enough snippet it could stand as-is. Feel free (encouraged!) to comment if you can expand on the thought for me.
Gratitude is good, right? It's good for you, it helps you be a better person, everyone should keep a gratitude journal, count their blessings, make every day Thanksgiving, etc, etc... Right?
Maybe. Except when it's not, and that "gratitude" is really gloating, and helps reinforce and blind you to privilege.
Gratitude is saying "I'm glad I'm me". Gloating is saying "I'm glad I'm not you".
When stuck in traffic, saying "thank you for this opportunity to practice patience" is gratitude. Saying "well at least I have a car, unlike all those poorshmucks starving children in Africa" is gloating.
"I felt sorry for myself that I had no shoes, until I met a man who had no feet" is a statement of gloating masquerading as gratitude.
The difference between gratitude and gloating is whether there has to be someone worse off than you in order for you to feel good about yourself. Those of us with privilege rarely escape the pit of gloating: if we are blind to our privilege still, we don't see what is wrong with our pity; if we have opened our eyes and minds to our privilege, we too often confuse acknowledging that privilege with pitying those "below" us (we are privileged, so they are oppressed, so we must always point out how much worse they have it, right? not so much, no).
Gratitude is good, right? It's good for you, it helps you be a better person, everyone should keep a gratitude journal, count their blessings, make every day Thanksgiving, etc, etc... Right?
Maybe. Except when it's not, and that "gratitude" is really gloating, and helps reinforce and blind you to privilege.
Gratitude is saying "I'm glad I'm me". Gloating is saying "I'm glad I'm not you".
When stuck in traffic, saying "thank you for this opportunity to practice patience" is gratitude. Saying "well at least I have a car, unlike all those poor
"I felt sorry for myself that I had no shoes, until I met a man who had no feet" is a statement of gloating masquerading as gratitude.
The difference between gratitude and gloating is whether there has to be someone worse off than you in order for you to feel good about yourself. Those of us with privilege rarely escape the pit of gloating: if we are blind to our privilege still, we don't see what is wrong with our pity; if we have opened our eyes and minds to our privilege, we too often confuse acknowledging that privilege with pitying those "below" us (we are privileged, so they are oppressed, so we must always point out how much worse they have it, right? not so much, no).
Sunday, April 19, 2009
Five minutes of self care
Five minutes of self care, every day.
This is my homework.
Don't laugh; it says so, right there, bottom third of the weekly report page for Massage Lower:
Last week, I turned in my report with that section blank. I wrote at the top: "Totally forgot to do/record this". The week before, I bloviated (which is latin for bullshited -- bullshat?). This week, it's Sunday (class is on Thursday), and I seriously can't think of a single thing to put down. Showered by myself? Well, I managed that once, anyway. Stayed up way too late reading Doctor Who fanfic (again)? That might not actually count as self-care. I made an appointment with my ND to go over my lab results so she'd call me in a new script, and I could stop stealing thyroid from my son; is that self-care?
Yoga would count, if I had anywhere in this cluttered hard-floored tiny (but beloved!) house to do it in. Music would count, if I could have five minutes where the Boychick let me play without rushing over to strum the strings or yelling at me to stop. Reading might count, if it were in time set aside for my own pleasure and rejuvenation, not stolen in moments supposed to be spend with the family, used as a barrier and a hiding place and a retreat in a way, after watching my father build himself a better life in fiction far away from us, that I promised I would never do. Hell, taking time to do my nails or my hair or my makeup would probably count, if I did that crap, which I don't and don't care to. Blogging might count, if I could figure out how to make that work. The teacher is amazingly flexible; our selves are amazingly flexible. Almost anything would count, all it would take is five minutes, consciously and deliberately spent on me, on doing something loving to me, taking care of me.
And I can't think of a thing to put down.
What is it about self-care that is so hard? I swore I wouldn't be a mother who lost herself. I really thought I was doing well; I'm all about benign neglect, I have a life and an identity outside of my child, I've never needed time apart to feel I was standing on my own. I thought things were going fine, that self care would (hah!) take care of itself.
And then I got smacked upside the head with having to actually record said supposed self-care. And I draw a blank.
It's not like I have lost myself: I'm still here, still moderating for Mothering, still reading my own books, still pursuing life as a student, still keeping my own friends, still referring to myself as "me" and not "mommy". But the self that is still here is just existing, just being dragged along by and dragging along the rest of my life; she is not neglected, exactly, but not being nurtured, either. And the point of this assignment in massage school (and why I chose and love this school) is: how can the god in me touch the god in you if the god in me is starving, thirsty, bedraggled, weary, and desperately in need of touch herself?
This must be related to my last post, which was about blogging but at base was really about balance. What does a life in balance look like? What does a life with five minutes of easily recordable self-care a day look like? I know the idea of "having it all" is a myth, that real life is always going to be saying no to some paths so we can say yes to others; life doesn't have to be compromised, uncomfortable, constrained, but it does have to be finite. But surely it must be possible to live this life, and be able to set aside 35 minutes a week, without needing to be the mythical (the misogynistic) Supermom... right?
This is my homework.
Don't laugh; it says so, right there, bottom third of the weekly report page for Massage Lower:
Five minutes of self careThis really shouldn't be hard, should it? Five minutes. Every day. That's all. Five minutes is nothing. It takes the Boychick five minutes just to... wait, he doesn't do anything in five minutes. Which probably explains why it is so hard.
- Sunday:
- Monday:
- Tuesday:
- Wednesday:
- Thursday:
- Friday:
- Saturday:
Last week, I turned in my report with that section blank. I wrote at the top: "Totally forgot to do/record this". The week before, I bloviated (which is latin for bullshited -- bullshat?). This week, it's Sunday (class is on Thursday), and I seriously can't think of a single thing to put down. Showered by myself? Well, I managed that once, anyway. Stayed up way too late reading Doctor Who fanfic (again)? That might not actually count as self-care. I made an appointment with my ND to go over my lab results so she'd call me in a new script, and I could stop stealing thyroid from my son; is that self-care?
Yoga would count, if I had anywhere in this cluttered hard-floored tiny (but beloved!) house to do it in. Music would count, if I could have five minutes where the Boychick let me play without rushing over to strum the strings or yelling at me to stop. Reading might count, if it were in time set aside for my own pleasure and rejuvenation, not stolen in moments supposed to be spend with the family, used as a barrier and a hiding place and a retreat in a way, after watching my father build himself a better life in fiction far away from us, that I promised I would never do. Hell, taking time to do my nails or my hair or my makeup would probably count, if I did that crap, which I don't and don't care to. Blogging might count, if I could figure out how to make that work. The teacher is amazingly flexible; our selves are amazingly flexible. Almost anything would count, all it would take is five minutes, consciously and deliberately spent on me, on doing something loving to me, taking care of me.
And I can't think of a thing to put down.
What is it about self-care that is so hard? I swore I wouldn't be a mother who lost herself. I really thought I was doing well; I'm all about benign neglect, I have a life and an identity outside of my child, I've never needed time apart to feel I was standing on my own. I thought things were going fine, that self care would (hah!) take care of itself.
And then I got smacked upside the head with having to actually record said supposed self-care. And I draw a blank.
It's not like I have lost myself: I'm still here, still moderating for Mothering, still reading my own books, still pursuing life as a student, still keeping my own friends, still referring to myself as "me" and not "mommy". But the self that is still here is just existing, just being dragged along by and dragging along the rest of my life; she is not neglected, exactly, but not being nurtured, either. And the point of this assignment in massage school (and why I chose and love this school) is: how can the god in me touch the god in you if the god in me is starving, thirsty, bedraggled, weary, and desperately in need of touch herself?
This must be related to my last post, which was about blogging but at base was really about balance. What does a life in balance look like? What does a life with five minutes of easily recordable self-care a day look like? I know the idea of "having it all" is a myth, that real life is always going to be saying no to some paths so we can say yes to others; life doesn't have to be compromised, uncomfortable, constrained, but it does have to be finite. But surely it must be possible to live this life, and be able to set aside 35 minutes a week, without needing to be the mythical (the misogynistic) Supermom... right?
This quarter isn't exactly kicking my ass...
But between trying to stay connected with friends (some of whom are going through some interesting stuff, stuff I've been through before and am happy to lend a shoulder of support for, and a tiny horrible part of me is jumping with joy that it's not me! for once! it's not meeeee!), having classes two nights in a row -- each having way more homework than both classes together last quarter --, trying to pull at least a fraction of my weight at my volunteer job, finally waking up to it being spring and finally hacking back the rose bushes about three years overdue for a grooming, having A Conversation with my mother, who finally decided to read my blog and Talk With Me about it (hi mom!), getting lost meandering the blogosphere, catching up on BSG, trying to not eat out or buy Starbucks every damn day, trying to keep the child alive healthy and relatively happy (and not torturing the animals), and attempting to stay at least somewhat connected to my lifemate in some fashion, and, oh, yes, staying sane...
I've been a little busy.
I'd say what I need to post is a laptop of my very own, not The Man's, borrowed when he's home from work, so that I can compose and clean up posts and add links and publish when I'm home alone with the Boychick, rather than having ideas come to me and shelving them so I don't damage my thumbs (again) trying to type them in to the iPhone and end up losing them and kicking myself and rarely actually getting a post up; and that would be part of it, but not the whole of it.
I'd say what I need is more time, time alone and time to think and time to sit down and focus, free of distractions, free of a child climbing on me, free of The Man very patiently not saying anything because he knows how important this is to me, but still being there, waiting, waiting, eventually resenting; and that would be part of it, but not the whole of it.
I'd say what I need is a schedule, some efficiency, some ability to plan my day and manage my time and mark off lists and do all those things Highly Effective People do (whoever they are), rather than stealing my time and wasting my time and sitting down with a plan to write and end up three hours later rousing from a daze of blog reading, five pages of posts I simply must read open in front of me, most on blogs I've never heard of before and with no idea how I got there; and that would be part of it, but not the whole of it.
I'd say what I need is some discipline, to be able to say no, that's too much, I can't read it all, I can't respond to it all, I can't say yes to it all, I can't even read and watch and write all that I want to, all that would be good for me to, I surely can't keep up with your blog and yours and yours and yours and this web forum and that tv show, I have to say no, to limit, to reduce, to simplify; and that would be part of it, but not the whole of it.
I'd say what I need is some confidence, to just post what I write and not sit and tinker and fix and review five thousand times each, making one post take five hours (when it was 95% done in half an hour); and that would be part of it, but not the whole of it.
The whole of it is that this is just life. The whole of it is that I am just me. The whole of it is all of the above, and more: that I am scared of failing, scared of succeeding, scared of drawing attention to myself, scared of no one reading, scared to put myself out there, scared of losing myself if I don't. The whole of it is that, and is simpler than that: I've never done consistency well, I'm a procrastinating perfectionist, I'm busy, I have a toddler, I have a life, and when I juggle, as we all must in life, things get dropped.
All so much angst, really. Self-indulgent introspection (a label I'll never do away with, even when I get around to pruning that ungodly mess over there). Excuses. Explanations. Exculpations. Nothing to see here, move along.
Unless you care to share the secret of having it all: life, home, kid, school, work, blog, self...? Please? I promise I won't tell anyone. Trust me: I wouldn't have the time.
I've been a little busy.
I'd say what I need to post is a laptop of my very own, not The Man's, borrowed when he's home from work, so that I can compose and clean up posts and add links and publish when I'm home alone with the Boychick, rather than having ideas come to me and shelving them so I don't damage my thumbs (again) trying to type them in to the iPhone and end up losing them and kicking myself and rarely actually getting a post up; and that would be part of it, but not the whole of it.
I'd say what I need is more time, time alone and time to think and time to sit down and focus, free of distractions, free of a child climbing on me, free of The Man very patiently not saying anything because he knows how important this is to me, but still being there, waiting, waiting, eventually resenting; and that would be part of it, but not the whole of it.
I'd say what I need is a schedule, some efficiency, some ability to plan my day and manage my time and mark off lists and do all those things Highly Effective People do (whoever they are), rather than stealing my time and wasting my time and sitting down with a plan to write and end up three hours later rousing from a daze of blog reading, five pages of posts I simply must read open in front of me, most on blogs I've never heard of before and with no idea how I got there; and that would be part of it, but not the whole of it.
I'd say what I need is some discipline, to be able to say no, that's too much, I can't read it all, I can't respond to it all, I can't say yes to it all, I can't even read and watch and write all that I want to, all that would be good for me to, I surely can't keep up with your blog and yours and yours and yours and this web forum and that tv show, I have to say no, to limit, to reduce, to simplify; and that would be part of it, but not the whole of it.
I'd say what I need is some confidence, to just post what I write and not sit and tinker and fix and review five thousand times each, making one post take five hours (when it was 95% done in half an hour); and that would be part of it, but not the whole of it.
The whole of it is that this is just life. The whole of it is that I am just me. The whole of it is all of the above, and more: that I am scared of failing, scared of succeeding, scared of drawing attention to myself, scared of no one reading, scared to put myself out there, scared of losing myself if I don't. The whole of it is that, and is simpler than that: I've never done consistency well, I'm a procrastinating perfectionist, I'm busy, I have a toddler, I have a life, and when I juggle, as we all must in life, things get dropped.
All so much angst, really. Self-indulgent introspection (a label I'll never do away with, even when I get around to pruning that ungodly mess over there). Excuses. Explanations. Exculpations. Nothing to see here, move along.
Unless you care to share the secret of having it all: life, home, kid, school, work, blog, self...? Please? I promise I won't tell anyone. Trust me: I wouldn't have the time.
Tuesday, April 14, 2009
A red underwear day
This morning I woke up to the expected*, and pulled out my favorite red pad, and pulled on my new red underwear. I hadn't ever had red underwear before (polyester faux-silk for-show pairs notwithstanding), and after just two wearings, I can absolutely recommend it.
There's something wonderfully affirming about wearing red while gushing red. Red is sexy, and powerful; I am sexy, and powerful. It is bloody, and strong; I am bloody, and strong. Red is bold, and beautiful, the color of war and of healers and of birth, and I evoke all those when I bleed between my thighs. Every woman should have red underwear, not for her lover(s), but for herself. No one has to know. It can be our silent scarlet secret.
How much stronger could we be if we wore red when we bled? It's hard to be meek when one is kicking it in hot red true red blood red bold red underwear. Forget pink. Pink is light, and "pretty", and for princesses, and anyway it stains. We are dark, ferocious, queens of war (we bleed for days and still walk on), and we deserve beautiful clothes not even when we bleed, but especially when we bleed, not even on our cunts, but especially on our cunts, and we can leave our mark on this earth elsewhere than our underwear.
It's a red underwear day, and I wouldn't have it any other way.
* Reason number 27 to chart: knowing ahead of time when the flow's gonna show.
There's something wonderfully affirming about wearing red while gushing red. Red is sexy, and powerful; I am sexy, and powerful. It is bloody, and strong; I am bloody, and strong. Red is bold, and beautiful, the color of war and of healers and of birth, and I evoke all those when I bleed between my thighs. Every woman should have red underwear, not for her lover(s), but for herself. No one has to know. It can be our silent scarlet secret.
How much stronger could we be if we wore red when we bled? It's hard to be meek when one is kicking it in hot red true red blood red bold red underwear. Forget pink. Pink is light, and "pretty", and for princesses, and anyway it stains. We are dark, ferocious, queens of war (we bleed for days and still walk on), and we deserve beautiful clothes not even when we bleed, but especially when we bleed, not even on our cunts, but especially on our cunts, and we can leave our mark on this earth elsewhere than our underwear.
It's a red underwear day, and I wouldn't have it any other way.
* Reason number 27 to chart: knowing ahead of time when the flow's gonna show.
Monday, April 13, 2009
We are not bad moms
(Inspired by an off-hand comment from a friend of mine, but applicable to pretty much every mom I've ever met. Very, very few of the dads, though. And no, that is not a coincidence.)
Allowing, or even encouraging, your toddler to watch TV does not make you a bad mom (or mum).
Using disposable diapers/nappies, whether regularly or occasionally, does not make you a bad mom.
Pushing your child around in a stroller does not make you a bad mom.
Using bribes or coercion or even lying to your child does not make you a bad mom.
Sending your child to daycare or public school, whether so you can work or just because you need the break -- all together now! -- does not make you a bad mom.
I am a TV-free advocate. I am an Elimination Communication (with cloth diaper back up) enthusiast. I adore and enjoy teaching babywearing, and prove daily that a stroller is not an essential baby-accessory (we don't own one at all). I firmly believe in unconditional parenting (and unconditionality), and strive for consensual living. I believe in attachment theory (about the same way I believe in the theory of gravity), and advocate for attachment parenting, and think the public school system, in the US at least, is fundamentally flawed.
But parenting -- life -- is not a checklist. It is not a competition. And you are not a bad mom.
This is not to say that anything goes, or that having ideals and standards and beliefs and goals is wrong, or mistaken, or pointless. Far from it; I am, as the above list shows, a fan of ideals and standards and beliefs and goals. This is not to say there are not right and wrong choices in parenting (feeding your kids is right, beating them is wrong); it is not to say there are not things better and worse for kids (exclusive breastfeeding for the first half-year is better, yelling at them for developmentally appropriate behavior is worse). Rather, it is to plea with all those reading to recognize that even making a "bad" choice does not make you a bad mom. Even if we agree that a particular choice or action is less than ideal (today I have yelled at my child, threatened him, bribed him, ignored his cries, and generally made some less than stellar parenting choices), making that choice, or doing that action, or failing to meet that standard, does not make you a bad mom.
The whole world is filled with people who are eager to tell us what a bad job we are doing, that we are ruining our children, that we as women are inferior, that we are incompetent, that we are hated, that we can never be good enough, that mothers are worthless, that we are worthless mothers, that mother love is instinctual, that mothers must be perfect, that if we achieve perfection it is no big deal, that if we fall from perfection we are broken, that we are bad moms.
These are lies. These are misogynistic lies, put forth by the patriarchy. And we swallow them whole, and we spit them back out, at each other, at ourselves.
Don't do the patriarchy's work for it. Reject the lies. If you let your toddler watch TV, even if you don't like that s/he watches, that's OK. If you don't feel guilty letting your toddler watch TV, that's OK too. (If you try to argue with me that there's nothing wrong on a large scale with infant TV watching, I'll argue back, but no way am I going to tell you what to do in your own life.) You are not a bad mom. You do not have to call yourself a bad mom when you admit it, as though it were some kind of protective amulet (mothers are hardly the only ones who do this: it's just shades of "yes massa" "I'm just a silly blonde" "you know how we Jews are"); you may get a pat on the back from the patriarchy, but all it does is perpetuate the hate. And you are still being oppressed.
What we do is not who we are. What we do in the early years of parenting our children really is not who we are. Our choices matter, yes; activism and advocacy matter; and there really are bad moms out there.
But really? We don't need to prefix or suffix our "failures" with self-flaggelation. If parking your kid in front of the TV so you can get a break (or cook dinner, or take a shower, or just because they enjoy it) is the worst you do on a regular basis, I can say with all confidence you are not a bad mom.
Thumb your nose at the patriarchy: next time the words "bad mom" start to fall from your lips, change it to bad-ass mom. Because you are.
Allowing, or even encouraging, your toddler to watch TV does not make you a bad mom (or mum).
Using disposable diapers/nappies, whether regularly or occasionally, does not make you a bad mom.
Pushing your child around in a stroller does not make you a bad mom.
Using bribes or coercion or even lying to your child does not make you a bad mom.
Sending your child to daycare or public school, whether so you can work or just because you need the break -- all together now! -- does not make you a bad mom.
I am a TV-free advocate. I am an Elimination Communication (with cloth diaper back up) enthusiast. I adore and enjoy teaching babywearing, and prove daily that a stroller is not an essential baby-accessory (we don't own one at all). I firmly believe in unconditional parenting (and unconditionality), and strive for consensual living. I believe in attachment theory (about the same way I believe in the theory of gravity), and advocate for attachment parenting, and think the public school system, in the US at least, is fundamentally flawed.
But parenting -- life -- is not a checklist. It is not a competition. And you are not a bad mom.
This is not to say that anything goes, or that having ideals and standards and beliefs and goals is wrong, or mistaken, or pointless. Far from it; I am, as the above list shows, a fan of ideals and standards and beliefs and goals. This is not to say there are not right and wrong choices in parenting (feeding your kids is right, beating them is wrong); it is not to say there are not things better and worse for kids (exclusive breastfeeding for the first half-year is better, yelling at them for developmentally appropriate behavior is worse). Rather, it is to plea with all those reading to recognize that even making a "bad" choice does not make you a bad mom. Even if we agree that a particular choice or action is less than ideal (today I have yelled at my child, threatened him, bribed him, ignored his cries, and generally made some less than stellar parenting choices), making that choice, or doing that action, or failing to meet that standard, does not make you a bad mom.
The whole world is filled with people who are eager to tell us what a bad job we are doing, that we are ruining our children, that we as women are inferior, that we are incompetent, that we are hated, that we can never be good enough, that mothers are worthless, that we are worthless mothers, that mother love is instinctual, that mothers must be perfect, that if we achieve perfection it is no big deal, that if we fall from perfection we are broken, that we are bad moms.
These are lies. These are misogynistic lies, put forth by the patriarchy. And we swallow them whole, and we spit them back out, at each other, at ourselves.
Don't do the patriarchy's work for it. Reject the lies. If you let your toddler watch TV, even if you don't like that s/he watches, that's OK. If you don't feel guilty letting your toddler watch TV, that's OK too. (If you try to argue with me that there's nothing wrong on a large scale with infant TV watching, I'll argue back, but no way am I going to tell you what to do in your own life.) You are not a bad mom. You do not have to call yourself a bad mom when you admit it, as though it were some kind of protective amulet (mothers are hardly the only ones who do this: it's just shades of "yes massa" "I'm just a silly blonde" "you know how we Jews are"); you may get a pat on the back from the patriarchy, but all it does is perpetuate the hate. And you are still being oppressed.
What we do is not who we are. What we do in the early years of parenting our children really is not who we are. Our choices matter, yes; activism and advocacy matter; and there really are bad moms out there.
But really? We don't need to prefix or suffix our "failures" with self-flaggelation. If parking your kid in front of the TV so you can get a break (or cook dinner, or take a shower, or just because they enjoy it) is the worst you do on a regular basis, I can say with all confidence you are not a bad mom.
Thumb your nose at the patriarchy: next time the words "bad mom" start to fall from your lips, change it to bad-ass mom. Because you are.
Sunday, April 12, 2009
On fat
This has been sitting in my draft queue for over a week. I don't know why I didn't just publish it then; I think I forgot about it, or thought it needed more clean up than it did (I only tweaked a couple tiny things; no, it's not perfect, but I'm posting it anyway, so there). Ah well, better late than never. Also, fair warning: it's very rant-y and personal. Read elsewhere if your "fuck" quotient has been met for the day.
Did I mention I'm a fat acceptance advocate? 'Cause, yea, I am. My own mother raised me so, God/dess bless her a thousand times.
So I'm reading with interest this post, and I find it really interesting, and then I read the comments, which are interesting in another way, and then comes this:
Because it's so. fucking. wrong.
You know why my mom is fat? And I'm talking really fat, lose one or two hundred pounds and still be morbidly obese fat. You really wanna know why?
Because she dieted.
Because she was told that her 170 lb, 5'5" body, her healthy, strong body, her beautiful, perfect body, was "too fat".
So she dieted, and lost 20 pounds. And then gained 25.
And dieted again, and lost 20 pounds. And then gained 30.
And dieted and lost 20 and gained 40, and lost 30 and gained 40, and had one kid (while finishing medical school back when women were so small a minority there were "doctor" lockers for the men and "nurses" lockers for the women) and gained 40, and lost 40 and gained 80, and, and, and... Until her body, still beautiful, still perfect, still strong, was actually fat, and not quite as healthy, and in rather more pain.
And no, she doesn't have the healthiest of eating habits. You wanna know why?
Because she dieted.
Because her entire life people have told her to clean her plate, to not eat so much, that these foods were "bad", that these foods were "good", that she could have cake if she were good, that she had to eat her veggies or she'd be bad, that she should just avoid fat, that she should just avoid carbs, that she should just use a sugar substitute, that she should eat small meals, that she should eat once a day, that she should swallow sponges, that she should count points, that she should chew 50 times, that she should drink more water, that she should stop drinking anything, that she should, she should, she should, she should, she should. Golly gee fucking wiz, you think maybe she lost touch with her hunger and her fullness and her inner guidance there just a little bit?
So no, she doesn't make "perfect" eating choices. And you know what else? Neither do a fuck load of skinny people. In fact, she eats a lot less than a lot of not-fat people I know, and a lot "healthier", and she's moving around a whole lot more weight (pssst, weight bearing is good for your bones -- her osteoporosis scans give her the bone density of a woman 20 years younger than she is), which, let me think, burns more calories.
So, perfect diet? No, even if there were such a thing. "Worst possible food choices"? FUCK YOU. What the hell does that mean, anyway?
Me? I'm just fat. Morbidly obese? Meh. I don't keep track. I certainly was, at one point. Why, you ask? It's called necessary medication, and it made me gain somewhere over 100 pounds (I was fat to start with, and fucking hot, thank you very much), without me doing a thing. When I got off it, I lost 75 pounds, without doing a thing. You know why? Because I'm just fat. Because my body has a weight it likes being at. Because I'm a sedentary American. Because both my parents are fat. Because half of my aunts and uncles are fat. Because I don't have 40 hours a week to spend in a gym, nor the money to pay someone to oversee my continual starvation. Without starvation and a full time job exercising, I will never be thin. If I moved more, I would be healthier, and have more muscle mass, and maybe lose a little bit of weight, but I wouldn't be thin. Why? Because I'm just fat. And I am beautiful. And I have a pretty healthy relationship with food. And I am strong. And I am smart.
"Worst possible food choices"? FUCK... well, you know.
Did I mention I'm a fat acceptance advocate? 'Cause, yea, I am. My own mother raised me so, God/dess bless her a thousand times.
So I'm reading with interest this post, and I find it really interesting, and then I read the comments, which are interesting in another way, and then comes this:
And I just stop and want to scream at my computer FUCK YOU!!!“Does there always need to be an ‘underlying cause’ though? ”
When you hit morbid obesity, yes, I think there has to be something that drove the individual to make the worst possible food choices (and continue making them, even if they have WLS).
Because it's so. fucking. wrong.
You know why my mom is fat? And I'm talking really fat, lose one or two hundred pounds and still be morbidly obese fat. You really wanna know why?
Because she dieted.
Because she was told that her 170 lb, 5'5" body, her healthy, strong body, her beautiful, perfect body, was "too fat".
So she dieted, and lost 20 pounds. And then gained 25.
And dieted again, and lost 20 pounds. And then gained 30.
And dieted and lost 20 and gained 40, and lost 30 and gained 40, and had one kid (while finishing medical school back when women were so small a minority there were "doctor" lockers for the men and "nurses" lockers for the women) and gained 40, and lost 40 and gained 80, and, and, and... Until her body, still beautiful, still perfect, still strong, was actually fat, and not quite as healthy, and in rather more pain.
And no, she doesn't have the healthiest of eating habits. You wanna know why?
Because she dieted.
Because her entire life people have told her to clean her plate, to not eat so much, that these foods were "bad", that these foods were "good", that she could have cake if she were good, that she had to eat her veggies or she'd be bad, that she should just avoid fat, that she should just avoid carbs, that she should just use a sugar substitute, that she should eat small meals, that she should eat once a day, that she should swallow sponges, that she should count points, that she should chew 50 times, that she should drink more water, that she should stop drinking anything, that she should, she should, she should, she should, she should. Golly gee fucking wiz, you think maybe she lost touch with her hunger and her fullness and her inner guidance there just a little bit?
So no, she doesn't make "perfect" eating choices. And you know what else? Neither do a fuck load of skinny people. In fact, she eats a lot less than a lot of not-fat people I know, and a lot "healthier", and she's moving around a whole lot more weight (pssst, weight bearing is good for your bones -- her osteoporosis scans give her the bone density of a woman 20 years younger than she is), which, let me think, burns more calories.
So, perfect diet? No, even if there were such a thing. "Worst possible food choices"? FUCK YOU. What the hell does that mean, anyway?
Me? I'm just fat. Morbidly obese? Meh. I don't keep track. I certainly was, at one point. Why, you ask? It's called necessary medication, and it made me gain somewhere over 100 pounds (I was fat to start with, and fucking hot, thank you very much), without me doing a thing. When I got off it, I lost 75 pounds, without doing a thing. You know why? Because I'm just fat. Because my body has a weight it likes being at. Because I'm a sedentary American. Because both my parents are fat. Because half of my aunts and uncles are fat. Because I don't have 40 hours a week to spend in a gym, nor the money to pay someone to oversee my continual starvation. Without starvation and a full time job exercising, I will never be thin. If I moved more, I would be healthier, and have more muscle mass, and maybe lose a little bit of weight, but I wouldn't be thin. Why? Because I'm just fat. And I am beautiful. And I have a pretty healthy relationship with food. And I am strong. And I am smart.
"Worst possible food choices"? FUCK... well, you know.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)