(on a blog not-my-own):
"Privilege is so often invisible (silent, but deadly. Like dog flatulence)"
Win!
(Found here)
Friday, May 8, 2009
Tuesday, May 5, 2009
We are not bad moms -- but are we good moms?
Reader sarah replied to my post We are not bad moms* with the following:
To the first:
Furthermore, I believe that babywearing and breastfeeding and elimination communication are good things in their own right; all other things being equal, it is better to breastfeed than to not, better to practice EC than to not. These practices have tangible, intrinsic benefits, to infants, to the parent-child relationship, to parents, to the environment, to society; I do not want to see them placed in opposition to intangible "good parenting", as though it were a trade-off (although I will say I know sometimes it is a trade-off, especially with the limited amount of energy and resources mothers have available to them in the early months and years, but no one can know from the outside the balance of a mother's choices; what costs time and energy for one person might be a simplification and a lifesaver for another). An inherently good thing is good whether or not one is managing to do other good things, and whether or not it protects you from the damage of other not-good things.** And, as they are minority practices, which are often attacked in a very misogynistic way (often supported in a misogynistic way as well, I will grant you), I am loathe as well to contribute to the belittling or dismissing of these parenting choices.
(I also wish to discuss whether or not or in what way(s) attachment parenting practices might indeed protect against "the negative aspects of parenting", but I'll leave that for another post, because it's a complex issue in its own right.)
Jumping to the end of the comment:
That said, I'm not sure I can agree with the "We need to constantly challenge ourselves to look past our more superficial lifestyle choices" preamble. Although that is, at least in part, what I try to do with this blog, I recognize that it is something I am able to do due to privilege: I do not have to worry about where my child's next meal will come from, whether his water is going to make him ill, how to pay for any injury he might incur running around like the toddler he is, or how to protect him from any abusive relations; and so I am able to spend my time thinking about paid family leave, environmentalism, universal health care, and preventing domestic violence, and the role of the kyriarchy in the lack of these things (which is not to say that only those who exist with privilege, like myself, can think big thoughts, or need to "fix" things for "them", just that I have far fewer roadblocks in my way than does someone who is oppressed in more ways -- these roadblocks are one of the many ways the kyriarchy seeks to protect itself). Further, "constantly challeng[ing]" myself does, to an extent, fulfill me and give me energy, but I am not hubristic enough to think that therefore everyone must lead the examined life: for some, letting go of the need to examine and challenge themselves is the healthier path.
Finally, looking at the middle part, where I think the meat is:
The "mommy wars" suck. (A lot.) Possibly the most evil thing about them is the way they make us turn against each other, first by scrambling to place ourselves on a hierarchy of most attached/most crunchy/most Super/most whatever, then by attacking each other with "[not] necessarily... a good mom" when we recognize the fallacy of the hierarchy. Dismantling the kyriarchy without undermining each other, critiquing parenting choices without criticizing fellow parents: these are not easy tasks. It is not an easy dance, and it is so easy to make a misstep -- just as with parenting itself. But it is necessary to try, and it is necessary to forgive ourselves because we will get it wrong sometimes -- just as with parenting itself.
So no, putting the telly on for your toddler doesn't make you a bad mom, and knowing a dozen carries to do with a 5m wrap doesn't make you a good mom. But what might make you a revolutionary is to let go of both the fear of being a bad mom, and the need to be a good mom. Let go of the good mom/bad mom hierarchy altogether. Just be a mom -- a bad-ass mom in your own right -- and tell the hierarchy it can go to hell.
*Which is, by far and without question, my most popular post, which still kind of mystifies me. The reaction to it has been amazing, and humbles me. Thank you to everyone who read, and especially to everyone who commented or passed it on.
**An analogy: recycling is a Good Thing (as is reducing and reusing). I do my best to reduce my consumption of paper and plastic containers, and reuse or recycle what we do bring home. I also drive well over 100 miles a week, when I could take public transit, or avoid travel altogether. Does my typical American use of the car, which has a much greater overall impact on the environment than the waste I produce and how I deal with it, mean that "recycling doesn't make me a good environmentalist"? Does my use of the car somehow negate the Good Thing that recycling is? It's not exactly a rhetorical question, but I have an answer that I can live with for myself, and I hope you do too.
There is a corollary to this post that I think should also be said. Babywearing, breastfeeding, EC, etc. don't necessarily make you a good mom. There is a world of hurt you can bring on your child even if you practice those parenting techniques, they don't inure anyone from the negative aspects of parenting.First, sarah, thank you so much for the comment and the post inspiration. I'd like to reply to this -- agreeing and disagreeing and expanding and being inspired by -- in three parts.
I just feel like this needs to be said (and repeated over and over) as I see my friends lulled into a false sense of safety and superiority because they subscribe to a certain set of parenting practices. We need to constantly challenge ourselves to look past our more superficial lifestyle choices to how our personalities, histories, family structures, and communities impact our children in a way that is beyond our control.
To the first:
Babywearing, breastfeeding, EC, etc. don't necessarily make you a good mom. There is a world of hurt you can bring on your child even if you practice those parenting techniques, they don't inure anyone from the negative aspects of parenting.I really hesitate to agree, although I think it is technically true. But as I've mentioned before, everyone and everything in our society jumps at any opportunity to either knock us down and declare us horrid mothers, or place us on Olympian pedestals no one could hope to live up to. I am therefore loathe to take part in any of this game, to spend any of my time lending any credence to the bad-mother meme. I am in fact, in general, loathe to even place mothers on any kind of good/bad spectrum, nor to attempt to define what a "good mother" is, such that someone who breastfeeds and babywears, or who formula feeds and lugs a baby bucket, might or might not be one, because of or in spite of those practices.
Furthermore, I believe that babywearing and breastfeeding and elimination communication are good things in their own right; all other things being equal, it is better to breastfeed than to not, better to practice EC than to not. These practices have tangible, intrinsic benefits, to infants, to the parent-child relationship, to parents, to the environment, to society; I do not want to see them placed in opposition to intangible "good parenting", as though it were a trade-off (although I will say I know sometimes it is a trade-off, especially with the limited amount of energy and resources mothers have available to them in the early months and years, but no one can know from the outside the balance of a mother's choices; what costs time and energy for one person might be a simplification and a lifesaver for another). An inherently good thing is good whether or not one is managing to do other good things, and whether or not it protects you from the damage of other not-good things.** And, as they are minority practices, which are often attacked in a very misogynistic way (often supported in a misogynistic way as well, I will grant you), I am loathe as well to contribute to the belittling or dismissing of these parenting choices.
(I also wish to discuss whether or not or in what way(s) attachment parenting practices might indeed protect against "the negative aspects of parenting", but I'll leave that for another post, because it's a complex issue in its own right.)
Jumping to the end of the comment:
We need to constantly challenge ourselves to look past our more superficial lifestyle choices to how our personalities, histories, family structures, and communities impact our children in a way that is beyond our control.I can give a big ol' Amen! to the bolded part. Certainly when we look at the ways in which the kyriarchy constantly constrains our choices, debating diapering methods can seem like rearranging the deck chairs on the Titanic. Mothers are a persecuted subset of a persecuted gender; mothers who exist without white, straight, able, or class privilege even more so. So much of the damage that is done to our children is out of our control, dictated by the work choices we (don't) have, the community support we (don't) have, the parental benefits we (don't) have, the schooling options we (don't) have, and so on, et cetera, ad nauseum. Even those of us hell-bent on countering the kyriarchy and the dominant culture to the best of our ability recognize that our children will grow up in this society, influenced by its memes and beliefs and ideals and prejudices, fully versed in its gender and racial and sexual norms and mores, and there's not a damn thing we can do about it, except try to at least help them be able to see and recognize those influences in their lives, and thereby, if we are very lucky, reduce their power at least a little.
That said, I'm not sure I can agree with the "We need to constantly challenge ourselves to look past our more superficial lifestyle choices" preamble. Although that is, at least in part, what I try to do with this blog, I recognize that it is something I am able to do due to privilege: I do not have to worry about where my child's next meal will come from, whether his water is going to make him ill, how to pay for any injury he might incur running around like the toddler he is, or how to protect him from any abusive relations; and so I am able to spend my time thinking about paid family leave, environmentalism, universal health care, and preventing domestic violence, and the role of the kyriarchy in the lack of these things (which is not to say that only those who exist with privilege, like myself, can think big thoughts, or need to "fix" things for "them", just that I have far fewer roadblocks in my way than does someone who is oppressed in more ways -- these roadblocks are one of the many ways the kyriarchy seeks to protect itself). Further, "constantly challeng[ing]" myself does, to an extent, fulfill me and give me energy, but I am not hubristic enough to think that therefore everyone must lead the examined life: for some, letting go of the need to examine and challenge themselves is the healthier path.
Finally, looking at the middle part, where I think the meat is:
I see my friends lulled into a false sense of safety and superiority because they subscribe to a certain set of parenting practices.Here we have the twofold point: "superiority" speaks to women who attempt to build themselves up by placing themselves ahead of others, because the kyriarchy has ensured that hierarchy is the only organizational principle they know (even in trying to be grateful, we too often make it about being better off than others); "safety" speaks to women who are seeking to protect themselves, because they are under constant attack by the kyriarchy and forces of anti-mother misogyny, threatened always with the spectre of the "bad mom" label if they don't do things "just right". And although I don't think that being "lulled into a false sense of safety and security" (by clinging to breastfeeding or babywearing or what-have-you) is a good thing, I also cannot blame them, or fault the inclination. Because we are under attack, because there is so much out of our control, and if clinging to cloth diapers like they were lifesavers is what helps a mother get through the tsunami of hate, from outside and in, that comes with the early years of parenting... well, she gets through, and that survival is worth celebrating, an intrinsic Good Thing, even if she might have done it "better".
The "mommy wars" suck. (A lot.) Possibly the most evil thing about them is the way they make us turn against each other, first by scrambling to place ourselves on a hierarchy of most attached/most crunchy/most Super/most whatever, then by attacking each other with "[not] necessarily... a good mom" when we recognize the fallacy of the hierarchy. Dismantling the kyriarchy without undermining each other, critiquing parenting choices without criticizing fellow parents: these are not easy tasks. It is not an easy dance, and it is so easy to make a misstep -- just as with parenting itself. But it is necessary to try, and it is necessary to forgive ourselves because we will get it wrong sometimes -- just as with parenting itself.
So no, putting the telly on for your toddler doesn't make you a bad mom, and knowing a dozen carries to do with a 5m wrap doesn't make you a good mom. But what might make you a revolutionary is to let go of both the fear of being a bad mom, and the need to be a good mom. Let go of the good mom/bad mom hierarchy altogether. Just be a mom -- a bad-ass mom in your own right -- and tell the hierarchy it can go to hell.
*Which is, by far and without question, my most popular post, which still kind of mystifies me. The reaction to it has been amazing, and humbles me. Thank you to everyone who read, and especially to everyone who commented or passed it on.
**An analogy: recycling is a Good Thing (as is reducing and reusing). I do my best to reduce my consumption of paper and plastic containers, and reuse or recycle what we do bring home. I also drive well over 100 miles a week, when I could take public transit, or avoid travel altogether. Does my typical American use of the car, which has a much greater overall impact on the environment than the waste I produce and how I deal with it, mean that "recycling doesn't make me a good environmentalist"? Does my use of the car somehow negate the Good Thing that recycling is? It's not exactly a rhetorical question, but I have an answer that I can live with for myself, and I hope you do too.
Saturday, May 2, 2009
Of pink shirts and mary janes
Scene one: It is morning, ninety minutes into our attempts to clothe the child and get ready for the day. We have achieved pants, and just managed to slip a grey shirt over his acquiescing but still squirmy head. And so, of course, he changes his mind, insists he needs to change his shirt. "I need flowers! I need the one with the flowers!" His voice is firm, his breath belabored, each word proclaimed as if inscribed in stone, hard at work as he always is when reaching to make each word just so, make sure he is understood. We ask him if he's sure, verify his request and then again, and he is: there's only one shirt with flowers, bright, dark, shockingly pink, and it's getting too small for him, its sleeves, always abbreviated on his simian arms, now almost right again, falling halfway between his wrists and elbows, their fashion belied by the pooch of belly just sticking out from under the hem. Now he's decided to cooperate, excited he's gotten his flowers, he's dressed in a snap, and runs off to play. I turn to his dad, both of us quirking our lips, and say, "I think we need to get him more shirts with flowers." He nods, agreeing, and heads out after our pink-clad Boychick.
Scene two: I'm piled under papers, pen clenched absently between my teeth, flipping through the book balanced on my knee, looking for the piriformis, trying to ignore the near fetish-like way the anatomical illustrator sketches a circumcised penis into every portrayal of palpation around the thighs -- my phone rings, I scramble. It is my love, out for a while, ostensibly to take the child shopping, really just to give me time to play catch up from my procrastination. "So it looks like he's a size nine, and he's really grown out of his current shoes, I can't believe we waited so long. They have a bunch of sandals here, well, these are sort of sandals, but they have straps, and when I got him to put his foot up to see if they would fit, he shucked his shoes and insisted on putting these on. So what should I look for in shoes?" I take a deep breath, trying to drive away my discombobulation, but still thinking about piriformis and penis fetishists and how the hell am I going to get all this done in the next -- calculating -- four hours, and I babble something about looking for really flexible soles, something he can fold in half between finger and thumb, best for foot development, but my eye's glancing back over the scattered papers, trying to sort my scattered mind. "I don't think they have anything like that, but I'll look. The ones he has are pretty flexible, and I'm not sure I can get them off him, to be honest." If they're cheap, I say, and he really wants them... "Alright. I'll see. Either way, we'll be home soon." Then they are, and The Man is carrying his old shoes, and the Boychick is wearing his new, shiny, stiff-soled black ones. "Those are mary janes," I say. "Are they? He really wanted them. He likes the flowers on the inside." "Ah," I nod, as I restack my shuffled papers, clearing my lap for my milk-demanding toddler, and wondering whether any of the flexible-sole shoe companies make shiny black mary janes and if they'd come in his size.
Denouement: I don't much like pink; I'm not sure there is actually anything pink in my wardrobe. I wear plain brown Birkenstocks year-round, though I do own a pair of black slightly-heeled boots, faux-fur lined, remnants from living where there was real winter. I do enjoy flowers, but prefer them outside where they belong, and don't distinguish much between the exotic beauty of an orchid and the everyday beauty of a dandelion. I wonder if I could accept a girlchild loving pink and flowers and patent leather mary janes, whether I am unknowingly pushing my boychild into defying gender norms to fulfill my own anti-patriarchal desires. But then I look at my child, dressed in a shark-covered blue hoodie, jeans with flowers around the waist, grey socks and his new shiny mary janes, tossing his babydoll and nursing his cheetah, and I think no, this is just who he is: for a while, just for now, just until his awareness of the outside world and its strictly-defined gender norms increases, he is simply a child, who likes pink and blue and flowers and fish and bugs and bows; he is simply himself; simply my Boychick.
Scene two: I'm piled under papers, pen clenched absently between my teeth, flipping through the book balanced on my knee, looking for the piriformis, trying to ignore the near fetish-like way the anatomical illustrator sketches a circumcised penis into every portrayal of palpation around the thighs -- my phone rings, I scramble. It is my love, out for a while, ostensibly to take the child shopping, really just to give me time to play catch up from my procrastination. "So it looks like he's a size nine, and he's really grown out of his current shoes, I can't believe we waited so long. They have a bunch of sandals here, well, these are sort of sandals, but they have straps, and when I got him to put his foot up to see if they would fit, he shucked his shoes and insisted on putting these on. So what should I look for in shoes?" I take a deep breath, trying to drive away my discombobulation, but still thinking about piriformis and penis fetishists and how the hell am I going to get all this done in the next -- calculating -- four hours, and I babble something about looking for really flexible soles, something he can fold in half between finger and thumb, best for foot development, but my eye's glancing back over the scattered papers, trying to sort my scattered mind. "I don't think they have anything like that, but I'll look. The ones he has are pretty flexible, and I'm not sure I can get them off him, to be honest." If they're cheap, I say, and he really wants them... "Alright. I'll see. Either way, we'll be home soon." Then they are, and The Man is carrying his old shoes, and the Boychick is wearing his new, shiny, stiff-soled black ones. "Those are mary janes," I say. "Are they? He really wanted them. He likes the flowers on the inside." "Ah," I nod, as I restack my shuffled papers, clearing my lap for my milk-demanding toddler, and wondering whether any of the flexible-sole shoe companies make shiny black mary janes and if they'd come in his size.
Denouement: I don't much like pink; I'm not sure there is actually anything pink in my wardrobe. I wear plain brown Birkenstocks year-round, though I do own a pair of black slightly-heeled boots, faux-fur lined, remnants from living where there was real winter. I do enjoy flowers, but prefer them outside where they belong, and don't distinguish much between the exotic beauty of an orchid and the everyday beauty of a dandelion. I wonder if I could accept a girlchild loving pink and flowers and patent leather mary janes, whether I am unknowingly pushing my boychild into defying gender norms to fulfill my own anti-patriarchal desires. But then I look at my child, dressed in a shark-covered blue hoodie, jeans with flowers around the waist, grey socks and his new shiny mary janes, tossing his babydoll and nursing his cheetah, and I think no, this is just who he is: for a while, just for now, just until his awareness of the outside world and its strictly-defined gender norms increases, he is simply a child, who likes pink and blue and flowers and fish and bugs and bows; he is simply himself; simply my Boychick.
Labels:
gender roles,
identity,
parenting,
school,
societal pressures
Friday, May 1, 2009
Blogging Against Disablism Day, 2009

I've struggled with what to write for this post.
I've thought about writing about the shared identity I have as the daughter of a woman with a physical disability: how I learned growing up first to look for seats and benches everywhere, before she got her chair, then later to scan ahead for ramps and wide enough doors and spaces to maneuver; how I felt when I overheard adults who should have known better say she wasn't disabled, she was just fat and lazy; how the Boychick has learned to love electric carts and thinks everyone in one is a grandparent just waiting to take him on a ride.
I've thought about writing more about my struggles with bipolar disorder, maybe finish up part three of the mental health series I've been promising for a while: maybe tell the story of ruining Christmas three years running, anxiety attacks coming out in force with the rising chorus of Christmas carols; maybe the one where I was overwhelmed by the crush of crowds, and had to be lead through IKEA like a woman without sight, because I could see too much, and ended up hiding in an empty slot in the warehouse, exactly like a scared animal because that's all I was, until the crowds and the panic thinned and I could escape; or perhaps tell you about the probably-concussion I suffered when the self-soothing head-on-wall went a little too far, undiagnosed because it was beyond me even to contemplate an explanation when merely existing in my skin was too hard already.
I've thought about getting on my high horse, pulling out my pompous thesaurus, hiding behind a wall of intellectualism, and lecturing about the Evils of Disablism and the Privilege of the Abled -- with just enough self-disclosure and self-flagellation to not lose all your interest, I'd hope.
And I've thought again and again about abandoning the idea of writing about it at all, because it feels like so much hubris, because I'm not ill enough not disabled enough not crazy enough to be worthy of writing about disablism -- and you likely have to be at least as crazy as I am, or love someone who is, to recognize the insanity in that declaration of being too-sane.
That last one is true, in a way; my illness is invisible: my body is not twisted as my mind is, my crutches are hidden as behavioral quirks, not strapped to my arms, and though I walk through life with a devil riding me, my body's back is unbowed. More, too, for I am -- and this is I will admit a relative comparison -- basically sane at the moment, mostly functional in my daily life, able to do normal(ish) things in a normal(ish) way.
Which is all to say, I do not suffer daily disablism the way so many do: insults do not get hurled at me regularly; my basic worth and competence and humanity are not questioned or outright dismissed by those around me. I pass, for sane, for able, for "normal".
But I'm not. I infiltrate. I am quiet, unseen. And so I hear what is said.
I hear bipolar/postpartum depression/post traumatic stress disorder/social anxiety dismissed as a quack diagnosis. I hear fibromyalgia/chronic fatigue syndrome belittled as so much whinging. I hear the jokes about chill pills and happy pills and pill-popping, always implying the joke's subject takes too many or doesn't take enough. I hear the tuts of tongues saying well she's too ill to deserve children, they should take them away and tie her tubes. I hear the perky voices proclaiming it could all be better with positive thinking. I hear the declarations of her as incurable, him soulless. I hear the never-ending refrains of it's not that bad, just stay home, just go out, just be normal, just don't be like that, just don't be you.
I hear it all, and it hurts me all. Sometimes I speak up, and sometimes I don't; sometimes I let the pain show, and sometimes I don't; sometimes I out myself and sometimes I don't. Sometimes I have the strength, the energy, the reserves, the coping ability, the buffer. Sometimes I don't.
I've been called names, dismissed to my face, asked to do too much, told I'm not doing enough. But it is in my invisibility, my passing, that I am most affected by (dis)ablism; it is the side comments, the snide comments, the jokes and the jabs about "them" that are really about me and mine, that I suffer from most frequently.
You may not see me when we are out in the world together, may not see my diagnosis, see my illness, see my allegiance to the tribe of the disabled -- but I see you. And I hear you. And I remember.
This just in: Great Britain's new Poet Laureate
Blogging from my car, because I just heard on the radio: GB's new Poet Laureate is the first woman to be offered the post in the 400 years of its existance. And she's feminist. And a mother. And bisexual. Someone pinch me and tell mr I'm dreaming, or the radio was garbled -- or better yet, post a link of confirmation!
I might go in to my thoughts on why the US's appointments of women PLs and the UK's lack thereof (before now!) are both reflective of the patriarchy at some other time, but since I owe you a BADD post already today, and must go stop the child from learning how to drive before he learns to tie his shoes, I'll just leave this post at begging for someone to post a link.
I might go in to my thoughts on why the US's appointments of women PLs and the UK's lack thereof (before now!) are both reflective of the patriarchy at some other time, but since I owe you a BADD post already today, and must go stop the child from learning how to drive before he learns to tie his shoes, I'll just leave this post at begging for someone to post a link.
Monday, April 27, 2009
From the "oh... right..." files
4/10 I take my last thyroid pill (no refills on my script), and get my blood drawn to check my levels (yes, cutting it close; no, I shouldn't have waited nearly so long; yes, I've done it before; no, I probably still won't stop from doing it again. procrastination is a powerful habit).
4/16 I go over my results with my doctor, find out my TSH was too high (that is, my body was asking for more thyroid), and I needed more thyroid even before I ran out.
4/17 After a week of occasionally stealing thyroid from the Boychick to get by (don't worry, he didn't go without), I finally get my own, higher, script filled.
4/15-23 I wonder why I've been feeling so tired recently, and so foggy in the brain pan.
4/24 Oh... Right... I (finally!) remember low thyroid = low energy & low brainpower.
Moral of the story? Without thyroid, my brain gets so foggy I can't think of why my brain might be foggy.
(Maybe this is only funny if you are familiar with hypothyroid/chronic illness issues, but it makes me snicker at least. Mine is a dark humor.)
4/16 I go over my results with my doctor, find out my TSH was too high (that is, my body was asking for more thyroid), and I needed more thyroid even before I ran out.
4/17 After a week of occasionally stealing thyroid from the Boychick to get by (don't worry, he didn't go without), I finally get my own, higher, script filled.
4/15-23 I wonder why I've been feeling so tired recently, and so foggy in the brain pan.
4/24 Oh... Right... I (finally!) remember low thyroid = low energy & low brainpower.
Moral of the story? Without thyroid, my brain gets so foggy I can't think of why my brain might be foggy.
(Maybe this is only funny if you are familiar with hypothyroid/chronic illness issues, but it makes me snicker at least. Mine is a dark humor.)
Friday, April 24, 2009
Andrade is guilty, and so am I
I have been half following the Angie Zapata murder case, reading the posts on TransGriot about it, but not reading the links because I am a conscientious objector to the mainstream media (and have been having enough trouble keeping up with my feed reader as it is). I was, well, not pleased exactly (it's hard to be happy about the pitiful "justice" our punitive system offers) to hear that a fully guilty verdict was rendered, including the hate crime charge; I was overjoyed that for once, a "trans panic" defense had so thoroughly failed.
Then I read about Angie's family's reaction, and was struck dumb by the simultaneous realization and the refutation of my own assumptions.
I had thought, here was this little Latina trans girl, murdered by her maybe-boyfriend. I thought I knew her; she'd be kicked out by her transphobic Hispanic family, trying to make it on her own, possibly turning tricks to survive. Good little White Liberal Ally was I, so cynical about her chances for justice, so certain of her alienation.
But then I read her brother's words:
I was wrong. I was guilty of racism, of the most pervasive sort of cisgenderism: the ignore-ance of a trans person's own existence. I committed a hate crime in the whitewashed confines of my own head.
White privilege doesn't go away. Cisgender privilege doesn't go away. We can't do our course in Racism 101 and Transphobia 101 and then wash our hands of the blood of those whiteness has killed, of those cisgender bias has killed.
This doesn't give me much hope for the Boychick. Bashes the rose-colored glasses right off my "raise a post-racist generation" face, in fact. Which is probably a good thing; helps me see how the world actually is, how hard a journey is ahead. Best hope I have is to ground him in a childhood of racism- and cisgenderism-awareness, and show him that it never stops; privilege never goes away, no matter how much we want it to, so our obligation as possessors of privilege to learn, to listen, to humble ourselves, and to root out the prejudices hidden in the darkest corners of our own heads -- which will always be there, more persistent than cockroaches and uglier still -- never goes away.
I am so sorry for what I did to you, how I erased you in my own mind, Angie. Your memory deserves so much more than that. Angie's family: I can only beg forgiveness. Even if you never learn of my assumptions about you, even if you never learn I exist, I have wronged you, and I owe you. I am sorry.
Then I read about Angie's family's reaction, and was struck dumb by the simultaneous realization and the refutation of my own assumptions.
I had thought, here was this little Latina trans girl, murdered by her maybe-boyfriend. I thought I knew her; she'd be kicked out by her transphobic Hispanic family, trying to make it on her own, possibly turning tricks to survive. Good little White Liberal Ally was I, so cynical about her chances for justice, so certain of her alienation.
But then I read her brother's words:
Angie was my sister.And I had to confront my own heart, who thought that by knowing the plight of the plot of too many trans women of color's lives that I knew the circumstances of her life; who thought that since I knew the color of her family's skin that I knew the contents of their hearts. I made so many assumptions about her, not bothering to read further, not even realizing I had made them; as much as I thought about it, which was hardly at all, I thought I knew what I needed to know about her.
She was a member of our family. We loved her very much, and we will miss her every day. Every day and every night our mom has to deal with great pain of ... one of her babies being buried. Every day our siblings and I reach for the phone and realize we’ll never hear her voice. There’s no answer anymore.
A part of our family is missing, stolen from us. Angie was 18, her life was just beginning. She was brave, she had guts, she had courage, and she was beautiful, fun and loving. She was our little sister.
I was wrong. I was guilty of racism, of the most pervasive sort of cisgenderism: the ignore-ance of a trans person's own existence. I committed a hate crime in the whitewashed confines of my own head.
White privilege doesn't go away. Cisgender privilege doesn't go away. We can't do our course in Racism 101 and Transphobia 101 and then wash our hands of the blood of those whiteness has killed, of those cisgender bias has killed.
This doesn't give me much hope for the Boychick. Bashes the rose-colored glasses right off my "raise a post-racist generation" face, in fact. Which is probably a good thing; helps me see how the world actually is, how hard a journey is ahead. Best hope I have is to ground him in a childhood of racism- and cisgenderism-awareness, and show him that it never stops; privilege never goes away, no matter how much we want it to, so our obligation as possessors of privilege to learn, to listen, to humble ourselves, and to root out the prejudices hidden in the darkest corners of our own heads -- which will always be there, more persistent than cockroaches and uglier still -- never goes away.
I am so sorry for what I did to you, how I erased you in my own mind, Angie. Your memory deserves so much more than that. Angie's family: I can only beg forgiveness. Even if you never learn of my assumptions about you, even if you never learn I exist, I have wronged you, and I owe you. I am sorry.
Labels:
cisgender privilege,
parenting,
privilege,
racism,
white privilege
Thursday, April 23, 2009
Blogging Against Disablism Day, May 1st 2009

I'm planning on participating in BADD on May 1st, 2009. Will you join me?
Write a post on the subject of disability discrimination, disablism or ableism and publish it on May 1st - or as close as you are able. Podcasts, videocasts and on-line art are also welcome. You can cover any subject, specific or general, personal, social or political. In the previous three BADD, folks have written about all manner of subjects, from discrimination in education and employment, through health care, parenting, family life and relationships, as well as the interaction of disablism with racism and sexism. Every year I have been asked, so it's worth saying; the discrimination experienced by people with mental ill health is disablism, so naturally such posts are welcome too.
Wednesday, April 22, 2009
How I spent Earth Day
Earth Day. Such a fabulous idea. I'm all about environmentalism, and doing things easier on the earth: breastfeeding, cloth diapering and elimination communication, dressing in hand-me-downs, choosing and growing organic foods, buying local, owning one small car and keeping it up, recycling, crocheting with plarn, washing with baking soda and vinegar (including my hair), making do using up and doing without, et cetera, and so on.
(I can do a feminist defense of environmentalism, too, though for now I'll just offer Having Faith as my evidence.)
So how did I spend Earth Day?
In my car. Driving around aimlessly. For nearly five hours. Probably drove about 100 miles. In circles. (Big circles.) With a feverish toddler zoning out and napping and zoning out and drinking water and napping and zoning out in the backseat.
Yup. That's how I spent Earth Day.
I may not be a bad mom, but I'm not so sure I'm not a bad environmentalist.
Ah well. There's always tomorrow.
(I can do a feminist defense of environmentalism, too, though for now I'll just offer Having Faith as my evidence.)
So how did I spend Earth Day?
In my car. Driving around aimlessly. For nearly five hours. Probably drove about 100 miles. In circles. (Big circles.) With a feverish toddler zoning out and napping and zoning out and drinking water and napping and zoning out in the backseat.
Yup. That's how I spent Earth Day.
I may not be a bad mom, but I'm not so sure I'm not a bad environmentalist.
Ah well. There's always tomorrow.
Monday, April 20, 2009
The difference between gratitude and gloating
I found this when looking through my email drafts folder; I'd typed it up on the iPhone nearly two weeks ago. I'm sure I was interrupted before I could finish, and I really don't remember where I was going with it, so it just kind of ends with no conclusion, but I thought it was an interesting enough snippet it could stand as-is. Feel free (encouraged!) to comment if you can expand on the thought for me.
Gratitude is good, right? It's good for you, it helps you be a better person, everyone should keep a gratitude journal, count their blessings, make every day Thanksgiving, etc, etc... Right?
Maybe. Except when it's not, and that "gratitude" is really gloating, and helps reinforce and blind you to privilege.
Gratitude is saying "I'm glad I'm me". Gloating is saying "I'm glad I'm not you".
When stuck in traffic, saying "thank you for this opportunity to practice patience" is gratitude. Saying "well at least I have a car, unlike all those poorshmucks starving children in Africa" is gloating.
"I felt sorry for myself that I had no shoes, until I met a man who had no feet" is a statement of gloating masquerading as gratitude.
The difference between gratitude and gloating is whether there has to be someone worse off than you in order for you to feel good about yourself. Those of us with privilege rarely escape the pit of gloating: if we are blind to our privilege still, we don't see what is wrong with our pity; if we have opened our eyes and minds to our privilege, we too often confuse acknowledging that privilege with pitying those "below" us (we are privileged, so they are oppressed, so we must always point out how much worse they have it, right? not so much, no).
Gratitude is good, right? It's good for you, it helps you be a better person, everyone should keep a gratitude journal, count their blessings, make every day Thanksgiving, etc, etc... Right?
Maybe. Except when it's not, and that "gratitude" is really gloating, and helps reinforce and blind you to privilege.
Gratitude is saying "I'm glad I'm me". Gloating is saying "I'm glad I'm not you".
When stuck in traffic, saying "thank you for this opportunity to practice patience" is gratitude. Saying "well at least I have a car, unlike all those poor
"I felt sorry for myself that I had no shoes, until I met a man who had no feet" is a statement of gloating masquerading as gratitude.
The difference between gratitude and gloating is whether there has to be someone worse off than you in order for you to feel good about yourself. Those of us with privilege rarely escape the pit of gloating: if we are blind to our privilege still, we don't see what is wrong with our pity; if we have opened our eyes and minds to our privilege, we too often confuse acknowledging that privilege with pitying those "below" us (we are privileged, so they are oppressed, so we must always point out how much worse they have it, right? not so much, no).
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)