Saturday, February 14, 2009

Doctor Who, TV-free, manic depression, and the dangers and gifts of grandiosity

We just finished watching Series 4 of the new Doctor Who. My 23 month old* has now watched more Doctor Who than anything else on screen -- not that he's been watching with us, because he (and we, when he's not napping) is nominally TV-free, but sometimes he wakes up in the middle of an episode that we Just Can't Not Finish (like this afternoon, when we were 20 minutes away from the end of the final episode of the season), and, well, it happens.

In fact, our feelings about Doctor Who pretty well exemplify why we are TV-free: I am a TV addict. Watching one episode of a show I like is pretty much like eating the proverbial one potato chip; it's just not something I can do. I must have more, and more, and more, and then my child is watching lots of things blowing up and the planet being towed by a little blue box and clapping and exclaiming "ball! big ball!" and it occurs to me that perhaps this might not be that wise a decision. If we were not TV free, the TV would be on nearly his (and my) every waking moment -- I know, because I've done it before, years before, lasting for years, losing years. And we're so not doing that with him.

Doctor Who, now... well, there must be exceptions. Doctor Who is one of ours -- probably the greatest, in the large sense of the word. Both The Man and I have been speculative fiction fans for most of our lives; he more the fantasy, I more the scifi. I do not pretend it's a good genre; I could easily do a feminist analysis of the Doctor Who universe, and the outcome would not be favorable (old white man has all the power and a series of usually attractive usually female "companions", running around in his powerful phallic technology, beating the monsters and saving the world? yea, that'd be a big fat feminist fail right there). And, let's face it, it is so pure cheese. Tasty, yes, but in the man-made (hah!), full of words no normal mortal can pronounce, you know it's bad for you, cheese from a can (blue, of course) kind of way.

And I love it. Really, truly love it. I loved Star Trek (TNG, DS9, the movies), and Buffy: The Vampire Slayer, and Battlestar Gallactica (no spoilers, we've only gotten through the first two seasons so far), and honestly can say that Firefly was the best thing ever on TV (although before anyone forwards me a "Help Serenity Fly Again!" petition: it's dead, Jim. let her go. it's over). Cheesy bad speculative fiction with a giant glop of interpersonal drama is right up my alley. I can see how bad it is, and I totally and completely fall for it anyway. Hard. Especially the Doctor.

I was the other day trying to explain why that is to a friend, who doesn't get speculative fiction at all, much less the aliens-and-technology kind of the TARDIS's universe, and I think I stumbled on something:

I am bipolar. Bipolar Type II with Rapid Cycling and Mixed States, specifically. Most of my paternal family falls somewhere on the bipolar spectrum, and my maternal family were mostly alcoholic, which often masks some underlying mental or mood issue. My love of speculative fiction also runs in the family -- as I revealed on Ruth's blog, my whole natal family would play D&D together, and our family bedtime books were along the lines of The Lord of the Rings (and yes, my name is really Arwyn, and yes, I'm named after Aragorn's elvin lover). My father, and this is not an exaggeration, owns every Analog magazine from 1950something onward, and, this might be a tiny exaggeration although if you could see his house you'd know how little, just about every SciFi book ever published. So I come by it honestly.

Back to the point: one of the key features of bipolar disorder is grandiosity; in the "up" part of the experience, this manifests as a feeling of I Can Do Anything, or I Am The Greatest. If I write an essay when I am manic, it is the best essay ever, and will earn me publishing and critical acclaim and fame and wealth. If I so much as pick up a craft, like knitting, my thoughts are filled with invitations to The Daily Show and the Whitehouse, where Very Important People will fawn over my every word on the topic. (This happens in the down part of the cycle, too, where not only am I horrible, but I taint everyone around me, and might very well be the downfall of civilization. This is no more or less crazy, but feels rather worse.)

Which brings us back to Doctor Who. The Doctor and his companions are special -- not in the Stuart Smalley "I'm good enough, I'm smart enough, and gosh darn it people like me!" kind of way, but in the "You are the most important woman in all of creation!!!1!" way. The grandiose way, the way those of us with this mood disorder (and probably the rest of y'all too, although if so you're better at hiding it) secretly believe we are, in a teeny tiny corner of our souls, all evidence to the contrary. It is escapism, to be sure, and fun and enjoyable, yes, but I think these types of shows, where "the fate of the world, nay, the universe, nay, all the universes! is in your hands!!" (and therefore in the hands and minds of those of us pulled in to that cosmos), have a special attraction for those of us prone to this way of thinking to begin with.

Healthy? Oh, likely not, and surely not at its extremes. I've watched my father read his life away: he worked, he ate, he slept, he had a family, but mostly, he read. He read scifi, and fantasy, and anything with magic or near-magical technology or psychic pseudocats; anything to escape to a world bigger and better, or bigger and worse, or just somehow bigger -- more grandiose -- than the admittedly mundane one he lived in. His hobbies were D&D and the SCA -- a magic-wielding role playing game (where he was usually god dungeon master) and a sword-wielding medieval recreation group where no one is less than a lady or lord, with all the swagger and finery of the middle ages and none of the dysentery. He spent so little time in this universe, I sometimes think we may be less really real to him than Honor Harrington.

And I've come close to that myself. Hell, I've been there, myself, where Q was more real to me than God, where life was just what I had to do to have more time, in my imagination, as a dragonrider (although not just a dragonrider, of course; no, that wouldn't be grandiose enough, so something always makes me even more special in even the specialest of universes). It's as attractive a prospect to a part of me as it is horrifying to the rest of me.

So why watch at all, then? Why not just shut it out altogether? Because I think I lose something when I starve the part of myself entirely. It can be overdone, to be sure, and I'm glad the Doctor doesn't have new episodes daily or I really would be in trouble, but I think that by feeding that part of myself a little, I keep alive something worthwhile. Some ability to think big, dream big; to play; to immerse myself in an imaginary universe; to be downright daft and silly in public, the mundanes be damned. It serves me well when the Boychick wants to dance in public, wants me to drink tea made of wooden food toys and jingle bells, and will even more, I believe, when he wants me to build forts, slay his monsters, and tell him he can do anything he sets his mind to.

I want him to have that expanse of the imagination. I want him to lead a play-full life. I don't want to lose him to those other worlds, or have this one drained of color for him in comparison, as I've seen happen in my father, and I've seen happen at times in myself; I want him to see the fantasy for what it is, to see the cheese and the sexism and the racism and the cliched writing and the overwrought acting, but oh, let him love it anyway. Let him never lose the ability to dream, and to join in another's dream, to have flights of fant'sy -- just let him land softly, and enjoy the plain world, the simple, complex world in all its mundane glory, as well.

And so we are TV-free, and watch Doctor Who 12 hours a year, and eventually, the Boychick will likely join us for more than just the last 20 minutes we couldn't put off. And that's OK. Let him know the joy of the now, and the joy of the imagination. Let him be sane and stable, and let him be just a teeny bit crazy too. Let there be both in his life, in about those proportions.





*23 months old?? AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!!!!!! *fingers in ears* Lalalallaalala I can't heeeeeeeeeeeeaaaaaaaaar yoooooooooooooouuuuuuuuuu!

Wednesday, February 11, 2009

This is not the post I thought I was going to write

I thought I was going to sit down and write out at least a part of the post that I lost, because there were a lot of things in there I wanted to say, worth trying to say again. I thought I was going to be able to sit down and write, finally, just for a few minutes, at the end of the day, hours (days) after the thoughts popped in to my head demanding my attention.

And then the child came up with a book, and asked me to read, and told me to read, and demanded I read, and wouldn't take no, nor not now, nor in a minute, nor your dad would love to read to you, nor "please come let me read to you!" called from the other room for an answer, only me, only right now, more insistent even than the thoughts. So I read him the book. And then again. And then again. And then again, but this time I am not allowed to touch the book, but I am still supposed to make the puppet move.

Which is when I threw it across the room.

Not a shining parenting moment, that. Not nearly as rare as I would like, either.

I console myself with the thought that there are no perfect parents in the world, that perfection is itself undesirable and therefore paradoxical, impossible. But one could be better. I could be better. I'd say I should be better, but my mother would tell me not to should on myself (does that pun work in other dialects?). But I should be better. I want to be. He deserves me to be. I deserve to be.

Obviously I've gotten a few minutes to myself, finally, but at what cost? Have I taught him that I have boundaries and needs too, that mothers work, that thoughts are important? Or have I taught him that he is not good enough for me, that I love him only when I don't have other things to do, that anger expressed physically is an appropriate method of expressing oneself? I don't know. Maybe some of both. Probably mostly the latter.

I grew up in a house with yelling, with anger expressed in punched walls and thrown pillows. The Man grew up in a house with so much yelling he learned to tune it out, so much that family dinners were annual events and guaranteed fights, and now has a conflict avoidance mechanism so profoundly powerful his psyche could probably survive anything, but does so by keeping everything out. I don't want that for the Boychick. We are nowhere near as bad as our families of origin, but I don't want even a shadow of that for him.

There are no "bad" emotions, and we must be free to express ourselves in healthy ways, but this yelling, this anger, can become a habit. The more we rehearse certain neural pathways, the stronger they get, the more readily we fall in to those patterns. If I refrain from yelling when I just cannot take another fucking minute of being ordered about, am I repressing, or reprogramming?

No one deserves to be the focus of anger or verbal abuse, and though often triggered by him, rarely are my outbursts at him, but The Man and I are proof that merely growing up around it, even if rarely directed at us, is enough to leave deep and lasting scars. I want my child to grow up free to express his full range of emotions, but not to have a pattern of flinching like his parents'. I haven't figured out that balance yet, not quite even in theory, and miserably not in practice.

This isn't the post I wanted to write. I am not the parent I wanted to be. But it's good enough for now. And I can do better tomorrow.

Monday, February 9, 2009

Lost post steals thunder

There's nothing quite as disheartening as writing out 90% of a loooong (and interesting, if I do say so myself) post and then losing it to the ether, is there?

I'll try again later. Send me don't-lose-the-post- and don't-lose-heart-vibes, please. I'm fresh out.

In the meanwhile, enjoy this Random Cute Kid Photo from three months ago:

(Because really, what kid doesn't look good in a pink bathing suit and black fedora?)

Saturday, February 7, 2009

Is there an award for this?

I feel like I've passed some kind of threshold. There should be prizes, or possibly medication.

Today, we made sourdough cinnamon rolls. 100% organic, 100% from scratch. Although, to be fair, we didn't grind the flour ourselves. Or the cinnamon. Oh, the corners we cut around here!

I'm not saying they're pretty, and they're not the scary ooey gooey worth every chemical-laden mouthful rolls of Cinnabon lore, but dude, they're homemade cinnamon rolls. Does it get much crazier than that?

I thought about trying to turn this post in to something more profound, possibly (finally!) working in my response to this post over at Shapely Prose, talk about the implications of our food choices, the simultaneous joy and drudgery of cooking from scratch, gender roles in the kitchen (these were a decidedly cooperative endeavor; The Man, sourdough being his current obsession, made the dough, I formed dough into rolls, the Boychick turned the rolls into mess), y'know, something with meaning.

But, nah, I'm in too much of a sugar daze to work that hard. So you can just marvel at my baking and my (in)sanity. Or click away to something more interesting. I won't mind. I have my rolls...

Friday, February 6, 2009

What exactly is the point of a blog reader...

That doesn't actually tell you there are new blog posts to read? Or only tells you for some blogs but not others? Or only tells you a month later there have been a dozen posts in the meantime?

Technology. If I weren't such an addict, I'd abstain entirely, I swear.

Which is all an overly complicated way of saying I JUST found out I got a shout out (and indirectly inspired whole discussions) on Mothers For Women's Lib. I feel like I've arrived, but am acting like I'm the only one in the room still. I just want to grovel and shout "I'm not ignoring you, I'm just ignorant!"

I also appear to have inspired a really kickass rant at Womanist Musings, which would have been more of a compliment if it weren't basically a fuck-you to my own post. Which, to be fair, was a fuck-generic-you rant inspired by a total side comment in yet another post of hers. The whole thing would be funnier or hipper if I didn't get the feeling we were having two different conversations: hers about reclaiming the power of the female genitalia (rock on, I say!), mine about the belittling power of using the vagina (not the whole lovely set including the clit and the labia and all that other fun stuff, just the tube, the hole) as the badge of womanhood. I think we're both right-on, but running right on by each other.

Anyway, those are my forays in to the incestuous intarwebz of the blogosphere. Naively, I thought starting a blog was simple: y'know, write stuff, post it, hope people comment. Then I find out there's this whole WORLD out there that I've been missing, full of amazing, intelligent, thoughtful, ass-kicking women; and I'm still missing out, because of damn stupid technology falling down on the job.

Next up: find a new blog reader for my iPhone, one that doesn't suck. Suggestions? Or, how do you keep up on your favorite blogs?

Thursday, February 5, 2009

Boys and dolls: an exploration of gender, sexuality -- and race

First, it was pretty much a no-brainer that we were getting the Boychick a doll for Solstice. He likes dolls at other people's houses, he plays with his own bunnies and monkeys frequently, asks to wear said toys, nurses them and potties them and walks up and down the hall shushing them (wonder where he got that one...). Boy needed a doll; therefore, boy was going to get a doll.

Neither The Man nor I have any of the objections to or hangups around boys with dolls frequently found in our patriarchal society. So we figured it should be simple, even if we were a little picky: we wanted soft, natural fibers; neutral facial expression; a good size for holding (14 or 16", we figured, based on measuring other toys of his); able to sit; male; anatomically correct preferred but not required. We had a good size budget, access to the whole internet. Easy peasy, right?

Well, no. Maybe if we'd not waited until the last minute, and took the time to custom order a doll, we would have been set. But by the time we were looking, all the custom slots were for, oh, March. And most of them were outside even our generous budget (triple digit prices for a soft fabric doll? maybe when it's not for a not-even-two year old). We did in fact find beautiful dolls made locally that would have been perfect -- except the price. On Etsy we could find reasonable priced custom dolls -- but then there was that wait-list thing.

So, prefab dolls it is. That's fine, lots of choices there. Nova Natural alone sells, what, three, four brands? And this is when we could no longer ignore the astounding gender disparity among dolls. They're made in about a 3-1 ratio of girl to boy just in terms of selection options, and that's not even looking at the numbers of dolls made or sold. We knew we wanted a boy doll, even if we'd given up on the wee penis, because we didn't want the Boychick to think only girls were soft and doll-like, plus we wanted him to identify with the doll, and as far as we know, he's a boy.

Thus our choices were limited in the male-doll department. And thus we came to race...

Do we get him a White doll? Or a doll of color? A Black doll? Or sort of split the difference and get a light-brown-skin doll? We couldn't get a doll that looked just like him (there were White dolls aplenty, but none with his lovely complex grey-green eyes), we weren't about to get the Perfect Aryan Nation blond hair blue eyed doll, 'cause that was just too squicky, but then... what? If we get him a doll that doesn't look like him, why not a doll that really doesn't look like him? Wouldn't diversity in his doll collection be good? Invisibility is the most basic form of discrimination, so wouldn't a black doll be showing that we're trying to Do Things Right? Anyway, his favorite book character is Little Pumpkin from More More More Said the Baby (don't ask us why, he's never told us; because s/he loses hir shoes? because s/he's black? because s/he has a grandma? just because?), so maybe he'd like a doll just like hir? Nothing wrong with a white kid playing with a black doll, right? That's just racist thinking, right?

Except...

We live in the whitest damn city in the US (no wait, now only the fifth whitest damn city). Very, very few of the children the Boychick plays with are children of color. This both makes it very important that he sees the full spectrum of humanity, but it also makes it set off my squickometer when the most frequent interaction with a being of color would be his plaything to do with what he will. Is that body of color, in doll form though it may be, ours to appropriate for our child's play? What is the line between appreciation and appropriation? Between exploration and exploitation? Doesn't it set off anyone else's bells to have a blond-haired presumably-straight white male only play with a body of color as his toy? Does it support the Waldorf-is-for-Whites-only ideology to buy a White Waldorf-style doll? Is this white guilt talking, or an awareness of white privilege? Is this justifying racism, or trying to avoid it?

I don't know. We didn't know. Nothing we chose felt quite right. We were safe when we were planning on getting him a doll that looked Just Like Him. We even felt safe looking at a doll with dark hair (which he eventually will have; we don't stay blond in either of our families) and dark eyes, or a doll with light brown skin and sandy brown hair with eyes like his. But when the choices came down to blond haired blue eyed, or Black, or White that otherwise had nothing in common with him... it felt like there were no right choices. Every option was fraught with race implications. Every choice could be seen to be wrong.

In the end, we went with the red-haired, brown-eyed White doll. Why? Because the dolls in the size we wanted that we could afford were White. Four girls, two boys, all White, White, White. We weren't touching the so-blond-it-was-white blue-eyed doll, we wanted a doll big enough for him to play with, we couldn't afford the ones that had dolls of many colors, so that's what we bought. Neatly side-stepping the whole thorny race-issue (thank you, white privilege), neatly supporting a company with a racist selection (or non-selection) of dolls.

And the Boychick likes him. We've named him Ira ("what's your dolly's name?" "eye!" "eye?" "eye!" "that's your dolly's name?" "eye!" "um... well, we could go with Ira, I guess..." and it stuck). He spends most of his time tossing him in the air or throwing him on the floor, but that's OK. He's also nursed him, and worn him, and fed him, and undressed and dressed him, and pottied him, and brushed his hair, and done all the things we were hoping he'd get to do with him. As Solstice presents go, it was a success, even if not quite as cool as his play kitchen.

I don't know if we made the right decision. I don't know if there was a right decision. "Raise boy anti-sexist with open, flexible gender roles": check. "Raise White child anti-racist with white privilege awareness and racial sensitivity": ...maybe not so much. I don't know. I just know that my boy has a doll, and I'm stumbling around in the dark -- no, in a light so White it's blinding my way.

Wednesday, February 4, 2009

Overheard conversations, or, why more women aren't feminist

Another quickie from the I'm-still-sick-but-getting-better files:

I went to class last night, as I am wont to do on Tuesdays and Thursdays. Due to my chosen profession (massage therapy, for those new or not paying attention), my classes are, shall we say, somewhat skewed in favor of women. To wit, there is one man in each of my classes of 14 and 6 students total.

Anyway, I was talking at break with two of my (female) classmates, and I don't remember how we got on the topic, but I pulled out an obvious-to-me radfem comment of some sort, which I was pleasantly surprised to have be moderately well accepted. As we were heading back to class, however, the topic continued, and comments were uttered along the lines of "they said we can do it all, but we just can't", and "men managed to run business just fine without us before" -- not exactly shocking for those who listen to the anti- or non-feminists regularly, though I admit to having that moment of "wha??" since I'm not used to it, but on reflection, fairly revealing.

The gist of both comments was, to me, "In The Good Old Days, at least we only had to do/know/be responsible for ONE sphere, and men did their own. Now because we 'can have it all' we have to DO it all." That's surely a sentiment I can sympathize with. And these were both women who had gone to college as a matter of course, one new to the state after being un(der)employed for several years, one switching careers after many years in a male-dominated field. Women who have benefited from feminism, but are still getting the short end from the patriarchy; and they are, not without some justification, feeling abandoned or abused by feminism.

I've posted before that I think we must bring men in to the domestic sphere (and up its status, which is just two sides of the same coin), in order to acheive anything like real equality. While we simply must continue blaming the patriarchy and pointing out its insidious influence on our lives, we also need to shift our message some, because neither "get the hell out of the house and get a job" nor "anything you choose is feminist because it's All About Choice (tm)" is appealing to, nor helpful for, these women. They need to hear that women have always gotten shafted, and that even though we've made some advances we know they're still getting shafted, and here's what we need to do to get men working their fair share and to build a village where no one gets shafted anymore, and won't you come join us? Sure, it's yet more work, but it's work for a really good cause, and by the way, feel free to bring your beau, your brother, your father, your son, 'cause we have a thing or two they need to hear too...

Until they get that message, I have a feeling they're going to remain bitter, when they could be our best allies. And I honestly can't blame them.

Monday, February 2, 2009

I am not a vagina

(I promise I'll post thoughtful, substantive, probably curse-free posts that actually mention the Boychick soon -- I have several ideas that are just waiting to get fleshed out -- but while my butt is being kicked and my energy sapped by the Cold of DOOM, you get short, pissed off, off-topic, substance-"lite" rants. Sorry. Only not.)

I don't care if it's a metaphor; I don't care if you're simultaneously getting your radfem on and calling out the colluders (although there seems something misogynistic in dismissing someone one disagrees with with accusations of pandering to the patriarchy, even if supporting hegemony is a result of the acts, but whatever); I don't care if you're using it ironically to point out the obvious sexism in choosing an anti-woman woman candidate to try to capture the woman vote:

Stop calling women vaginas.

Seriously. Just fucking stop. Stop using vagina as the badge of womanhood. Stop calling the token woman the vagina candidate. Stop saying the only difference between (cisgendered!*) men and women are penises and vaginas.

I'm so sick of hearing about women and vaginas. It may have been radical once, but by now, unless you are talking about vaginal birth, The Vagina Monologues, or where to put a tampon or diaphragm, the use of "vagina" is just both overused and underimpressive -- and it is really, really offensive. And yes, misogynistic.

So just. fucking. stop already.



*Seriously, can the use of "vagina=women" get more cissexist? Not only is vagina so not the be all end all of womanhood -- and yes, I don't care if you think you're pointing out the fallacy, or phallusy, of that tired meme, you are supporting and perpetuating it -- it's not even the most accurate if you want to get all scary stupid gender essentialist. How about uterus? That gets more to the "core" of the matter, and (bonus!) manages to exclude and offend even more women, whose uteri have retired, or been removed, or who were both without one for whatever reason. If you're going to be a sexist pig, might as well do it whole hog.

Sunday, February 1, 2009

Public Service Announcement

Do not ever read the comment section on posts about parents or children on a feminist blog that is not explicitly a feminist parenting blog. That shit is scary misogynistic bad. I'm usually good and pulling myself away from the worst of the web (a la goatse et al) but this particular brand of ugliness pulls me in like nothing else.

So, lesson learned: fight for the rights of women, unless they happen to be mothers, unless they are mothers who hate their kids and can afford a live in crew of nannies so they never take them out of the house until and unless they are Perfect Robotic Angels. Right. Glad we got that cleared up.

I need a shower. Is bleach anti-hate? It'll only sting for a little while, and if it erased the contact soul defilement, it might be worth it...

(And no, I'm not giving you a link or telling you where to look. I won't come over to your house when I have the flu, and I'm not tarnishing your soul with a link.)

Saturday, January 31, 2009

I feel like I'm losing my mother

I almost titled this "My mother is considering weight loss surgery", but while the latter is factual, what I have up there gets to the meaning of the post.

I need to preface this by saying that I was raised, to the best of my mother's ability and against my father's wishes, with the basic idea, if not the exact words, of Health At Every Size. I have never deliberately dieted in my life. I have lost significant amounts of weight twice, once in high school because I was accidentally starving myself (if I didn't eat breakfast, I found I only needed a Mt Dew and maybe a pastry at school, had to eat a meal at 5pm when I got home from play rehearsal, then wouldn't be really hungry for dinner at 6:30. I do not recommend this), and again after I got off Depakote, which had royally fucked up my body and my appetite and caused me to gain in the vicinity of 100lbs over two or three years, most of which I lost after getting the hell off it; neither of these times were health-promoting for me. I do not want to hear about your diet. I will bitchslap you (or at least fantasize about it) if you moan about getting fat in my presence, and you weigh less than 150% of what you did two months ago. I do not want to hear about your diet. I have recently fallen hard for Harding et al at Shapely Prose. I do not want to hear about your diet.

And this is how my good mama raised me. She was fucked over by the patriarchy and fatphobia and an asshole dad who thought "not starving" = "fat" (and yet insisted that no food be wasted at the table and all plates must be cleaned), and my asshole dad who thought fat = bad and ugly, and a diet industry that told her swallowing sponges = good. She promised to do better with me, her showing-every-sign-of-being-fat daughter, and though I wish she'd gotten a clue in time to save my seven-years-older brother (who once got in a yelling match with my dad about how fat I was WHEN I WAS FUCKING FIVE), I am beyond grateful that she did it more or less right with me. She wasn't perfect (who is?), and I do not have a perfect relationship with food (who does?), but once I was talking with her (at her, really, with her nose buried in a magazine, she occasionally emitting an appropriate-sounding "uh huh") and casually said "Mom, would it be OK if I dye it?" talking about my hair, and her head snapped up with the exclamation "you certainly may not diet!" Bless her a thousand times for that one, and for the subscription to Radiance, and then to Hues (both now defunct, unfortunately but unsurprisingly), and for putting herself between my dad's fatphobic vitriol and me, and for the thousand other things she did to try to avoid fucking me up as badly as she had been.

Bless her also, while I'm on the topic, for plonking $1000 at a trip at boutique clothing stores that sold clothes at which I was a size 1 as soon as I hit adolescence (the $1000 was only once, and bought abundant [pun intended] clothes for both of us; but the general gist of go shopping, spend lots, make shopkeepers grin and stay open late for us continued). Bless her for giving me a wardrobe that looked fucking fabulous on me, whatever size I was at the time, for making shopping a joy and a treat and a way to surround myself with older women who also Got It, and told me how amazing I looked (because I did!) and offered to pay me to model for them. Bless her.

Thus, difficulties that many fat acceptance converts struggle with, I largely avoided. I grew up knowing dieting was stupid and unhealthy and didn't work (knowing indeed that dieting was responsible for turning my 160lb mom into my 400ishlb mom), even if I did also watch her try PhenFen and every other "it's medicine and scientific so it must be healthy" prescription diet drug that came out. I did not usually know my weight or consider it an important indicator of health, even as she had discussions with her doctors about hers. Bless her for that as well.

And now... weight loss surgery. Stomach stapling. Bariatric bypass.

Maybe.

If I still had all the old Radiance issues I could pull out all the articles that talk about what a Dumb, Self-Hating Idea it is, but she'd dismiss them because "the surgeries are really different now, and I know a lot of women for whom it really was good". And she may be right. The surgeries are safer now (it would have been hard for them to get less safe!), and there are women for whom it was a godsend. And with her other health issues (notably her mobility issues, which are aggravated though not caused by her weight), maybe it would be good for her, too. We've had several discussions on the topic, each trying to listen to the other, each trying to be heard. I am open to the possibility that it might be the right decision for her.

But I still feel like I'm losing her. Not because, if she went through with it, her beautiful body would melt away (seriously, my mother is the most beautiful person in the world to me, with the only sometimes exception of my child, and it's not that she has "such a pretty face", though she does, nor in spite of her size, nor even really because of it, but simply because she is so. damn. beautiful, just as she is). Nor because she'd be making a choice I disagreed with (she's an allopathic drug dealing MD, I'm a crunchy woowoo acupuncture-loving fish-oil-swilling neo-hippie; we're used to disagreeing and still loving and respecting each other). Not even because, no matter how safe it is, the surgery still might kill her.

No, it's because I find an article like this one that I so want to email to her because she'd Get It... and I don't. It's because I used to always talk to her about my own weight and health and body acceptance issues... and now I feel I can't.

I'm losing her. My rock -- no, my squishy safe bed with the softest pillows and the monster-repelling covers -- my loving mother, my protectress, my goddess, the one person who would stand up for me and my right to love my body just the way it is thank you all very fucking much... isn't anymore. I can't send her those articles because she'd think I was trying to make a point with her and whether to do the surgery, when I just want to share my joy. I can't talk to her about my stuff, because it'll sound like it's about hers. It sometimes makes me miss my mother so much I start to cry.

Which is so much self-indulgent angst and a slap in the face to everyone who actually has lost a mother in the real dead-and-gone sense (my own beloved lifemate included), but they're my feelings, and I'm sticking to them... the way my mama taught me.



(Any comments in favor of her doing the surgery because weight loss always = good, saying I don't want her to because then I'll be the fattest, supporting the dangerous myth that fat = unhealthy, promoting your own diet, talking about the weight you "need" to lose, or in any other way displaying willful fatphobia or thin privilege will be deleted. Consider that fair warning.)